r/AtheneLive • u/lingonga • Oct 06 '19
Chris interview viewed by a vaguely informed fairly neutral spectator
Hi, I asked my GF who has not so much insight on what Athene has been up to lately to watch the interview that both Reese and Athene suggest in order to better understand this cancel culture situation.
She brought some very interesting points that I then explored even further but before we delve in let me be clear by saying that I have no problem with what Athene is doing there, these comments and questions come from someone who is trying to help and that I'm occasionally being devil's advocate.
No previous context was given to my GF. She did not know who the interviewer was nor what he did prior to the interview. I think this is important to stress because if this pops up in any place other than Athene's fans/haters circles no one will have context and this is the evidence that Athene points to.
She did know that Athene has fundraised for charity, that he is the public face of a group of people in Germany aiming to do good in the world and very little about his twitch/youtube persona.
Let's start.
"Putting the email quotes on the stream was not fair"
There were two quotes from an email Katarina received and a tweet from Katarina that were placed on the stream. These quotes being here are first addressed by Chris wanting to give some context about them, and there's the first problem. It was a trap, or it kinda looks like one. See, by addressing the quotes he broke Katarina's brother petition to not quote him yet Katarina's email quotes, in Chris' argument, are a direct result from the brother's interview. So how can he defend sending that email if it was first sent because of an interview now not allowed to disclose? And Athene and Reese know this and use (and I don't mean they planned it, it just happened) this to criticize him for quoting Katarina's brother.
He acknowledges that the interview is something that may not be taken into account anymore, so why keep showing those emails?
Again, I am not saying I agree, he could have maybe not mentioned it, but it is interesting. Also, I am not ignoring what the email actually says, that is just not the point of this argument.
"The quotes from streams Chris brings up don't sound like a laughing matter"
Here I'm talking about when Chris started to investigate Athene's opinion on women. I know Athene, I can find what he does on his stream funny and obviously not serious but when presented with the out of context quotes he does not respond in a professional manner: he mocks the interviewer and starts taunting him. For someone that knows little to nothing about Athene's twitch stream humor, it is not funny to respond like this to these comments (and it is maybe worse if the one watching is a woman).
I understand that all twitch chat was laughing along with Athene but if this is the evidence one that knows little to nothing is pointed to, it does not inspire respect nor confidence. She did eventually agree with Athene but she had to filter out his mockery.
"If you have an audience, your words will have an impact"
This is referring to Athene saying that women are controlling persuasive machines (or sth along those lines).
She really disliked this comment and pointed out that him rephrasing it now does not remove the impact done.
I don't know how to expand this more but I still wanted to mention it. It is impossible to know how everybody will take what you say but we have seen bigger internet influencers adjust what they do and say because of the impact their words and actions make.
Final thoughts
2hs in on the VoD she got bored and stopped. At the end of the day she stands with Athene but wishes he was less of a douchebag when confronted with an interview and could totally see people not giving credit to him just because of this.
I understand both Athene and Reese were under lots of stress and anxiety but if this is the evidence you point to for the uninformed then maybe be more professional about it?
Either way, I believe it was something worth sharing. Let me know what you think.
Thanks