Our vet wants our cat on a prescription diet for life, with no clear medical justification. We're trying to figure out if this is reasonable.
Quark (female, spayed, 8 years old) had a struvite crystal episode at the start of this year. She stopped urinating entirely and became very avoidant. She was put on Hill's Prescription Diet s/d to dissolve the crystals. She had no stomach problems with it, and a follow-up urinalysis confirmed the crystals were fully gone. At the time of the crystals she did drink less, but that's back to normal now.
At that point the vet switched her to Hill's c/d Multicare Stress as a maintenance diet. She vomited it out immediately. So she was switched to Royal Canin Veterinary Urinary S/O + Hypoallergenic, which she tolerates fine. She has been drinking normally since and is back to her old self.
The vet now says she needs to stay on the Royal Canin for life. When we asked why, the answer was "this is standard practice in our practice." No further urinalysis or bloodwork has been done since the switch. The packaging itself says the recommended duration is 5-12 weeks for dissolving crystals, up to 6 months for preventing recurrence, and up to 1 year if intolerance signs disappear. Lifelong use isn't mentioned anywhere.
Her brother Yoghurt (neutered, same age) is also eating this food because they share a feeder. The vet said this was fine, that it shouldn't cause any problems. He is healthy and has no issues.
Before the crystal episode, both cats ate a regular multi-protein dry kibble for years without trouble. Quark started occasionally vomiting from it in the last few years, with the kibble still being chunky and not dissolved yet. She has always drunk a lot, and still does. We have multiple water fountains around the house, and she also drinks from the faucet. The acute reaction to Hill's c/d looked like a stronger version of the same thing. She had no issues with Hill's s/d. She doesn't care for any human food, except for banana, khaki fruit and avocado. She never liked wet food before, but she did like the prescription wet food she got when she had the crystals. We didn't continue with that because it was prescription food and Yoghurt couldn't have it either.
Every spring Quark has sneezing fits that gradually disappear once summer arrives. She also seems to vomit more during these periods.
Background on the cats: they're indoor cats, both chill, extremely social, at a healthy weight, with very soft and shiny fur. Neither shows any physical discomfort. Two years ago a third cat joined the household. That transition went well and all three tolerate each other. They have three litterboxes between three cats. The food, water and litterboxes are all spaced quite far apart from each other. One litterbox is used by all three, one by Quark and Yoghurt, and one by Yoghurt and the third cat. We're based in Europe, so food availability may differ from US recommendations.
We're looking for opinions on:
Whether lifelong use of this specific food is actually justified, or whether a maintenance diet would be more appropriate now
Whether Yoghurt should be eating this at all. We've read conflicting information online that this food can cause calcium oxalate problems in healthy cats. Our vet doesn't want to address this, does anyone have any info or knowledge from their vets? We're not sure what to make of this
Any experiences from others who've navigated something similar
What questions we should ask the vet, and how we should approach that conversation
We want to address this with our vet first and would like some input to take into that conversation. We're open to getting a second opinion if needed, but want to have a proper conversation with our current vet first.
Species: Cat
Age: 8 years old
Sex/Neuter status: Female, spayed
Breed: Domestic shorthair (tuxedo)
Body weight: ~4 kg (last weighed)
History: Struvite crystal episode at the start of 2026 with complete urinary blockage. Treated with Hill's Prescription Diet s/d for dissolution. Follow-up urinalysis confirmed crystals fully resolved. Transitioned to Hill's c/d Multicare Stress as maintenance diet, immediate vomiting. Switched to Royal Canin Veterinary Urinary S/O + Hypoallergenic, which she tolerates. No further urinalysis or bloodwork since the switch. History of occasional vomiting from previous multi-protein dry kibble over the last few years. Seasonal sneezing fits every spring that resolve in summer.
Clinical signs: Currently asymptomatic. Drinking normally, urinating normally, behaving normally. Back to her baseline.
Duration: Crystal episode occurred at the start of 2026 (around 4-5 months ago). Current diet has been ongoing since shortly after.
Your general location: Netherlands (Europe)
Links to test results, X-rays, vet reports etc: None available