r/AskUS • • Apr 09 '25

Does Trump needs to be stopped?

27 Upvotes

Does Trump need to be stopped before he starts ww3? The man has turned the whole world against the US. As an outsider i fear he will invade some innocent country triggering a world War. Or maybe a major terrorist attack on a distracted and devided US.


r/AskUS • • Mar 29 '25

Why do Americans tolerate Nazis and other hate groups that threaten violence against ordinary citizens?

15 Upvotes

Follow the General Strike US if you wish to make a difference

Reach out to local unions

Organize before they take that freedom away from you

Oh and NO MORE TOLERATING THE INTOLERANT


r/AskUS • • Apr 13 '25

Do MAGA supporters actually realize the lies?

0 Upvotes

I really struggle to believe that they ACTUALLY believe certain things.

Like their whole rhetoric of the economy needs to be bad to get better

or how they were in denial about Musk's "Roman Salute"

How DOGE is actually a good thing

And much more. I have to ask, Do they actually know this is all a false and just go along with it or do they actually think this is all true?

If the former why keep it up when their guy is already in office?

If the latter why do they think the more insane things like Haitian migrants eating pets?

Do MAGA supporters actually realize the lies?

I really struggle to believe that they ACTUALLY believe certain things.

Like their whole rhetoric of the economy needs to be bad to get better

or how they were in denial about Musk's "Roman Salute"

How DOGE is actually a good thing

And much more. I have to ask, Do they actually know this is all a false and just go along with it or do they actually think this is all true?

If the former why keep it up when their guy is already in office?

If the latter why do they think the more insane things like Haitian migrants eating pets?


r/AskUS • • Mar 26 '25

Will you admit Trump is trying to become a dictator? This question got me banned from askTrumpsupporters awhile ago because they are an echo chamber, can any conservatives here answer it?

134 Upvotes

“He who saves his Country does not violate any Law.”

This was tweeted out by Trump. My question to supporters is when will you admit he is in fact trying to become a dictator. He now very clearly thinks no law should apply to him so when will it be? When he starts disappearing his political enemies into foreign prisons as he has recently made a deal to? Will it be when he starts arresting reporters for unfavorable coverage? What will the line be exactly? Or will you keep denying it no matter what happens?


r/AskUS • • Mar 12 '25

Do Americans have an education system?

0 Upvotes

Hi guys! Just your friendly authentic European here asking a totally not loaded question that shows my inherent pompousness. Actually it’s hard to see what I’m typing because my nose is stuck so high up in the air.

Anyway, jajaja (that’s laughing, but in Spanish, or as we say, “español” … but I’m actually French and I know this because I’m trilingual) - here’s my question:

Do you guys go to school when you’re younger? Is there an education system in the US?

I’m just genuinely wondering from the bottom of my heart, because I’ve observed from my 1000 year old village that otherwise wouldn’t survive in a global economy without tourism, that American tourists:

  • only speak English

  • think Europe is a country (LOL)

  • don’t put the bar down at ski resorts

  • only live in cities < 200 years old

  • are fat

  • shoot each other over arguments

  • are happy with what Trump is doing

Ok that last one is an assumption, and I’m not really sure so I’m going make another post here asking how people feel about Trump. Again my nose is stuck so high up in the air that I’m unable to read the 100 other posts created every day asking that same question.

Anyway thanks and totally genuinely looking forward to your answers regarding if America has an education system because I’m European and really just have no idea, genuinely.

Edit: I can’t believe I have to clarify that this post is satire, poking fun at European condescension towards Americans on this SubReddit. We see the same tired generalizations and feigned curiosity where questions are delivered more as assumptions and insults rather than asking in good faith.


r/AskUS • • Mar 06 '25

How Did Russia Buy the USA?

6 Upvotes

Russia just won the cold war. You fell asleep at the wheel, how do you feel about it?


r/AskUS • • Mar 18 '25

How is it that every student learns about the horrors of Hitler and WWII in school, but despite that, the US is currently dealing with the rise of fascism?

0 Upvotes

EDIT: So, a couple of things. First of all, out of the myriad of accounts posting something along the lines of "fascism isn't happening here", I'm not going to say all of them, but the LARGE majority of them are just a few weeks old, or years old with negative karma, or accounts whose history shows a smattering of posts on unrelated topics, then a number of months of silence, then magically they're posting every day on political topics with far-right rhetoric. So to the non-zero amount of accounts that legitimately believe this, you all might want to clean house and introspect on why the bots and trolls are mirroring what you think.

Second of all, to all the accounts posting something along the lines of "learn the definition of fascism, herp derp", gardenfella posted 14 criteria for it in one of the top comments here so, you know, you all can go read the list. Get back to me with the things that you think this administration ISN'T doing on that list.

Third of all, this topic has, at the time of this edit, 819 comments. The upvote/downvote ratio is exactly 50%. I KNOW there are more comments here supporting the premise that the US is dealing with a rise of fascism, so I can only assume trolls and bots are astroturfing this topic with downvotes, as if that will somehow quell a discussion that is - again - currently sitting at 819 comments and counting. Good try I guess, but that's not gonna do it.

Lastly, a shoutout to all the educators out there who have chimed in. I appreciate you and what you do every day.


r/AskUS • • Mar 31 '25

Why do Americans not seem to care about school shootings?

5 Upvotes

I noticed that there have already been 4 this year, which is a pretty shocking and disgusting number. In Canada (where I'm from) we've had 9 school shootings in our 150+ year history. 4 in 3 months would have us call for a national emergency.

So what gives?

I understand that American citizens are very attached to their guns, but 1 in 3 Canadians have guns. We just need to get a license and register our weapons and have them locked up/secured (no conceal and carry). Why do Americans buck any sort of gun registry or control at all when these things clearly work?

Edit Holy man this sparked quite the debate. To respond to the mass amount of statistical downplay answers, I'm simply going to point out the fact that there was legislation passed regarding trans athletes in school sports even though this is an iota of participants in sports (10 at the NCAA level), but for some reason because kids are killed in other places, it's ok to accept over 200 of them dying at school every year? That seems really really illogical and like a lack of value for human life.


r/AskUS • • Mar 29 '25

Trump is using Hitler playbook… tell me I’m wrong

169 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking a lot about historical parallels, and the similarities between Trump’s approach and Hitler’s rise are unsettling. I’m not saying they’re identical, but the patterns are hard to ignore.

Mass rallies & speeches – Trump’s rallies aren’t just campaign events; they’re loyalty tests, propaganda machines, and ways to keep his base engaged. Hitler mastered this tactic too.

Propaganda & media control – With platforms like Truth Social and allies on X, Trump has built his own media ecosystem that dismisses mainstream journalism as “fake news” and pushes a cult-like narrative.

Extreme nationalism & isolationism – “America First” echoes the kind of nationalism that fuels division and global hostility, much like Germany’s pre-WWII stance.

Empire-building rhetoric – He’s floated ideas of taking Greenland, suggested the US should control Canadian resources, and even made bizarre comments about Gaza. There’s a clear interest in expanding US power.

•Creating a common enemy – Whether it’s immigrants, the media, Democrats, or “the deep state,” Trump thrives on scapegoating, just as fascist movements always have.

•Testing legal limits – He’s continuously pushed the boundaries of the legal system, questioning its legitimacy and seeing how much he can get away with.

Private loyalist forces – While not a full-blown SS or Brownshirts, his reliance on figures like Bannon’s networks, Proud Boys, and other extremist groups suggests he’s willing to use non-official forces to exert influence.

January 6th & the Munich Putsch – Both were failed coup attempts, used to rally supporters and delegitimize the sitting government. And just like Hitler’s followers, Trump’s rioters are being reframed as martyrs.

I know the contexts are different—Germany was in economic collapse, the US is (was?) a stable democracy—but these patterns are eerily familiar. And Trump’s story isn’t over. If he gets back into power, history suggests he won’t stop at just being president.

Am I overthinking this, or do others see the same trends?


r/AskUS • • Apr 11 '25

To people who are against transgender people, why?

25 Upvotes

I'M ASKING A GENUINE QUESTION HERE. I swear to god if I see this comment section flooded with supportive people (love y'all, but sit this one out) just making fun of and mindlessly downvoting the other side, I'm gonna lose it.

So I ask, as a transgender person myself, what have we done to bring this ire upon us?

I would absolutely love to have a civil discussion about this, and hopefully foster understanding between us.

Edit: This blew up a lot faster than I can type out actual, thought out debates. I've only seriously replied to 1 person and I'm at over 400 comments.

Edit 2: I don't want to say I'm grateful for these responses. It shows something that I thought was the case: most people don't hate trans people themselves, they're just concerned for the people who could actually be negatively impacted by transgender people (cisgender women and children, for the most part), which is completely understandable.

While I can't speak for all trans folks, I can say that I myself do feel guilty about invading women's spaces, and we do think about how we impact them. I personally long for a world where I don't have to worry about disenfranchising cisgender women or making them feel uncomfortable/unsafe.

Edit 3: I'm deleting this alt account after being told by several people in my DMs to off myself. To those of you who I had actual discussions with, and to those who wrote responses that showed you put some thought and care into it (I tried to read most of the responses, even if I didn't reply), I thank you.

Good day to everyone except people who tell others to kill themselves.


r/AskUS • • Mar 24 '25

Are Americans going to be silent on what trump and republicans are doing?

4 Upvotes

r/AskUS • • Apr 09 '25

Liberals: Why do you use this sub to ask questions that aren't actually questions?

39 Upvotes

I get it. There's a mentally deficient orange rapist in the white house. Shit's weird right now. But most of the "questions" I've seen on this sub are low-effort gotchas like "Republicans: why do you refuse to admit you made a mistake?" and such. Like anyone it's addressed to is going to answer that or even treat it as a real question? It assumes a position right from the start, and even on Reddit, it's an obvious time-waster. So why? Is it to make you feel good? Is it karma farming from the inevitable 2k+ comments of bashing anyone on the other side from you? Do you even think there's actual Republicans left on this site? I really want to know.


r/AskUS • • Apr 04 '25

If Trump is impeached

0 Upvotes

If we have a successful impeachment, that makes J.D. Vance president? Then if we successfully impeach him we get Mike Johnson? Then we get Pete Hegseth? Is there a constitutional process that purges the entire administration?


r/AskUS • • Mar 11 '25

I'm Canadian

14 Upvotes

Hello American friends, is this what you want? Do you guys want to hurt me, my family and my people? Our two countries since and before the Canadian Confederation have been partners (besides 1812). Both of our peoples have died side by side in your wars and this is what your president is doing to us now. He has threatened my people with annexation, made life more expensive for the both of us and is undermining my people's national identity. When is enough enough for your president? My question to all of you is what is the attitude of the normal American citizen? Do you guys want this? What are you guys doing about it?


r/AskUS • • Mar 15 '25

Why So Many Red States Hate Democrats?

4 Upvotes

Just curious even if you look at the economic stats of blue states to red. The blue seem to do better.

Now I know this post is with all respect. But why do so many people in red states totally hate democrats. Yet many of the people in the red states do benefit from services that can be deemed a left sided made service eg social security etc.

Why do so many go against their own interests ? just curious


r/AskUS • • Apr 13 '25

Why did Americans pass up the opportunity to have an absolute MILF as president in 2024?

0 Upvotes

r/AskUS • • Apr 09 '25

Are democrats selfless and republicans selfish

0 Upvotes

I think this is just a vague idea of course, but it seems overall to be my take. If you break it down that way that’s why GOP sees Dems as weak and Dems see GOP as jagoffs.

Edit- everyone assuming being selfless is a good thing is taking this question at face value without critically thinking it through. Selflessness knows no boundaries and are easily manipulated. The way you use a term is not always the true meaning or factual definition of the word.

This is not a “loaded” question - but one meant to hopefully make some think deeper about the divide.


r/AskUS • • May 01 '25

Is this sub more than an echo chamber?

7 Upvotes

It says AskUS but it seems more like a sub for leftists to ask MAGA people (who are usually banned from most subs) rhetorical questions to make themselves feel smarter than they are.

EDIT: Since most people are assuming how I voted, I should clarify I didn't vote in the last election since neither candidate represented me well enough. But the fact so many people think I'm only critical of them because I'm obsessed with "bad orange man" is telling


r/AskUS • • Mar 29 '25

Facism in the US.

2 Upvotes

Isn't it crazy how fascism in the US is a real possibility before we could establish universal Healthcare, education, etc?


r/AskUS • • Mar 18 '25

Why aren't Republicans more concerned about the failing economy?

51 Upvotes

So under Trump with his economic policies. We are on track to see a negative GDP over the next two years coupled with higher rates of inflation.

We've also seen a decrease in demand and investments as the uncertainty in the markets raise, and with his tariffs incurring global economic boycotting of American business and goods we are going to see an increase in unemployment.

I know some people on the right believe in his message of short term pain for long term gain but how long is the short term? We don't have the current infrastructure in place to replace the partner's we'll be losing at this scale and it'll take 10 - 20 years to build even part of that out

This sets the stage for stagflation.

The markets are in freefall as uncertainty grows with these on again off again tariffs...

I can keep going...

So my question is why aren't Republicans worried about this?

(Let me know if you want any of my sources)

Edit thanks for all the responses

Going to mute this post now because I'm getting too many notifications. Feel free to DM me if you want to discuss


r/AskUS • • Mar 15 '25

America the Great has lost over $3Tn USD for the stock market in 3 months. How are you all feeling about that?

12 Upvotes

Meanwhile your government spending has increased $36 billion over the same timeframe as your leader's face gets yellower and yellower. Is he a dragon that takes the money from fired Federal workers and absorbs it into his skin or is he just full of jaundice?


r/AskUS • • Apr 06 '25

Why are Americans voting against their own interests?

40 Upvotes

-Crashing the economy, stock markets

-Tariffs which contradict his efforts to curtail inflation

-Due process which protects individuals safety

-Dismantling of the education system

-Women’s rights: reproductive, voting

-Cuts to universally used services like Medicare

-Hiring incompetence: Defending his national defence team on instead of calling for their resignation when they are clearly jeopardizing active military safety

-Starting international relations wars with the world and loosing any soft power they may have had

-Favouring tax cuts on the rich to the detriment to the majority of his voters (even if they aren’t singularly powerful the way one billionaire would be)

How do you justify voting for changes that will impact you negatively?

—— I feel like this is worth some precision:

To those who feel the post is condescending, the interests that are being referred to are what is typically agreed on by the majority (ex. Most people agree that inflation is bad). Sorry if it ruffled some feathers.

Re: Due process: The Fourteenth Amendment prohibits states from depriving “any person” of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. The Supreme Court has held that this protection extends to all natural persons (i.e., human beings), regardless of race, color, or citizenship

Re: stock markets. Some people may be able to endure short term pain, but there is a lack of either empathy or abstraction for those who are already living paycheck to paycheck.

Re: Abortion, the recommendations in Project 2025 curtails resources and it does deny access to abortions in emergency situations.

https://www.guttmacher.org/fact-sheet/how-project-2025-seeks-obliterate-srhr

Re: Voting concerns. Look into the SAVE act.


r/AskUS • • Apr 23 '25

Why don't people on this sub let conservatives speak for themselves?

2 Upvotes

This echo chamber is so loud that no question sounds like an honest inquiry. If you're not asking a question to understand, you're not asking—you're just grandstanding with a question mark.

Time and again, I see questions that already assume the worst about conservatives, phrased in such a way that any attempt to answer is already a concession of guilt. These aren't invitations to conversation—they're rhetorical traps.

"Why do conservatives want poor people to die if they can’t afford healthcare?" "Because compassion gets in the way of profit, obviously."

"How do conservatives sleep at night knowing they hate minorities, the poor, and public education?" "On a bed of money and denial, just like always."

"Why do Republicans worship a Jesus that looks nothing like the one in the Bible?" "Because their Jesus carries an AR-15 and votes straight ticket."

"When did conservatives stop being capable of empathy?" "Sometime between Reagan and now."

"Why do conservatives only care about 'freedom' when it means they get to harm others?" "Because selfishness is their entire ideology."

These are loaded questions, not genuine inquiries. They're built on faulty premises and demand the accused defend a claim they never made. It’s the same tactic as asking, “Why do you beat your spouse?”—you’re guilty before you speak.

If someone tried asking, “Why do liberals love criminals and want to abolish all police?”—this subreddit would rightfully see it for what it is: an unfair straw man. But swap the ideology, and suddenly it’s karma, clapbacks, and Reddit gold.

You don’t have to agree with conservatives. But if you’re not letting them speak without framing them as villains first, are you even asking a question—or are you just writing a smug monologue?


r/AskUS • • Jan 23 '26 Regret

When did “detained” start meaning “kidnapping” when it comes to ICE? Why do people claim there’s no due process when immigration court already issued a deportation order?

2 Upvotes

My understanding is that a removal order means an immigration judge has already reviewed the case and completed due process, ordering the person to leave the U.S. Under that scenario, why is being “detained” described as “kidnapped”?

EDIT: thx for the award!