r/AskTheologists • u/Bjarki56 • Dec 14 '20
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • Feb 07 '21
How do Protestants defend Sola Scriptura given the question of Biblical canon?
The doctrine of Sola Scriptura states that Scriptures (NT and OT) are the sole infallible sources of divine authority (as opposed to an institution, such as the Catholic Church). I believe most Protestants believe in this doctrine.
The problem I see with Sola Scriptura, however, is the question of how Protestants establish the proper canon of the Bible - specifically the New Testament. If the Bible is the sole source of divine authority - how do we know specifically what books comprise it? There is nothing in the New Testament that specifies the criteria for books to be considered canonical. The Book of Revelation, for example, took a long time to be considered canonical, and some Eastern Christian churches do not consider it canonical to this day. The authorship of Matthew is also still a matter of some debate.
So, it seems to me that, in order to properly establish a New Testament canon (Or OT, for that matter), one must appeal to some authority outside of the Bible in order to determine the proper canon, such as tradition or church history. As such, the doctrine of Sola Scriptura cannot hold, because it implicitly assumes a equivalent authority to the Bible that can determine what books properly belong in the Bible.
The only objection I've heard to this view is that the New Testament canon is somehow "self-authenticating". In other words, we can tell what books belong in the Bible because their inspired nature is readily apparent. I don't see this as sufficient, because one individual may view books as inspired that others do not.
So, in summary, the concept of Sola Scriptura appears to collapse in on itself due to the question of canon. Are their any arguments in favor of the doctrine that would contradict my points?
Thanks and God Bless.
r/AskTheologists • u/PlasticGuarantee5856 • Jul 29 '24
My faith in Christ was dealt a devastating blow due to critical Bible scholarship
Greetings everyone. I am an Eastern Orthodox Christian from Serbia struggling with faith. Until recently, I was sure that there was no real issue with my faith and the academic Bible scholarship; unfortunately, at least in my opinion, I was wrong. Now I’m not going to claim that academic Bible scholarship intends to disprove Christianity, but its views certainly influence me, at least, my view of the Bible.
It all started with me reading about the existence of Jesus as a historical person. Since 99% of scholars agree that he existed, was baptised, and got killed by crucifixion, I was really happy. My happiness, it seems, wasn’t meant to last that long.
At first, I learned that the overwhelming majority of scholars consider the Gospels to be anonymous and not written by Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John. Alright. Then I discovered that Paul most likely isn’t the author of the Pastoral epistles. Okay, that is not insurmountable I guess. And then, the final blow came yesterday: I discovered the book Helping Jesus Fulfill Prophecy by Robert J. Miller.
The author claims the book is a product of first-class scholarship and the reviews (here and here) don’t seem to disagree. Miller argues (note, these aren’t my words, I’m trying to sum up his arguments) that Christians blatantly manipulated the Old Testament to make it fit with their narrative about this supposed messiah that Jews rightly dismissed. Here is a quote from it to consider:
[Both Muslim and Christian] interpreters quote selectively and out of context; both ignore relevant biblical material that would wreck their interpretations; both show no interest in what the passages meant in their ancient settings; both impute dubious and arbitrary meanings to the texts; both read their biblical passages within the framework of religious assumptions that emerged centuries after those passages were written … Christian interpreters (including NT authors) sometimes create customized passages by combining pieces from different scriptures, and they sometimes rewrite prophecies. (p. 378)
This is, I’m not going to lie, very scary for me. The notion that the NT authors straight up manipulated the OT scriptures just to project their view on Jesus seems devastating. And look at the implications of that. I would appreciate any advice for getting back to God, because I feel very far away from him now, and I do not really like that.
EDIT: Can someone please contact me so I can understand why I can’t see any comment on this post?
r/AskTheologists • u/Megs020 • Jan 03 '21
How long do we wait for?
I really hope these questions make sense.
If the bible was finished being written nearly 2000 years ago, let's say.
Why is it taking so long for the end to come?
Why didnt they keep writing the bible if there was going to be such an expanse of time between the bible being finished and 'the end'?
Obviously they didnt know exactly when 'the end' would come, so why did they stop when they did? Yet we're still waiting and could be still waiting for another 2000 years.
r/AskTheologists • u/Same_Ad_6641 • Sep 11 '23
Does bible scholarship make you feel depressed?
I spend a lot of time lately reading on the r/academicbiblical and r/askbiblescholars because they seem to be more objective and knowledgeable than apologists. But I have been kind of saddened and depressed lately because to put it bluntly they do a good job at ripping any reliability of scripture to pieces. Some of the things I have learned are
Virgin birth likely didn't happen and was a narrative taken from elsewhere
Other things in the gospel that are much more likely literary devices than historical (herod's slaughter of infants and Jospeh and mary fleeing to Egypt, census by quirinus)
Many of the epistles are likely forgeries (not written by who they are credited to)
Gospel authors are likely different than who they are credited to
Jesus doesn't fill the messianic prophecies supposedly nor does he claim to be God
lots of the Old Testament is historically inaccurate
Gospel of John is extremely contradictory and historically inaccurate
What's your view on discrepancies such as this? I still have faith but I am going through a lot of doubt at the moment
r/AskTheologists • u/LilDruck • Jun 16 '21
How is heaven perfect if loved ones are in hell?
I’m kinda struggling with the idea of spending eternity knowing people are suffering while you live “perfectly”, just wanted to know what you guys think.
r/AskTheologists • u/Wazowskiwithonei • Mar 25 '21
Birth control
Hi all. I know Catholicism tends to shy away from the use of birth control, and I've been told by some of my former seminary professors that the arguments can be rather compelling. I honestly hadn't spent much time in reflection on this particular topic (I'm from a Protestant denomination and it wasn't high on the priority list), but recent events have made me consider this to a greater extent.
Brief background: our daughter was born with a genetic condition. Wouldn't it figure, I passed along my own genetic condition to her. Awesome. We spent a solid month in the NICU with an entire team of doctors trying to get her healthy enough to leave the hospital. Watching our infant go through all she endured was absolutely the most difficult time of our lives. We just got the phone call today from the geneticist confirming that our odds of having children with this same condition are 50/50. What a roll of the dice, huh?
So on to our question at hand: what are your theological views on birth control, and what reasoning do you use? To what extent are we preventing God from doing what He wants to do by using birth control? Obviously I'm here today as one of those genetic abnormalities who would never have seen the light of day if my parents had access to the kinds of technology that's available today with things like in vitro fertilization. Lord knows I'm glad to be here. At the same time, I had a very rough start. Our daughter has had a similarly rough start. To what extent are we robbing God of His ability to work, and to what extent are we practicing mercy by keeping someone else from having to experience all that's necessary in the healing of this condition?
I don't expect that these will be easily answered questions, but I would love to get some open and honest feedback from others to help us carefully weigh the decisions we must make for the future. Thanks in advance to each of you for taking the time to read and/or respond.
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • Nov 09 '21
How does God show himself in current days?
Sorry if this is not the right sub. I'm a Christian and I've suddenly found myself in a faith crisis. I can't stop thinking why doesn't God talk directly to us. I understand, and logically agree to some apologetics as "God does not make talk directly to us so that we have a true choice", or "God already tried this and it didn't go well", but I can't feel them in my heart, and this is right at the time in which I got married and can't stop thinking, how am I supposed to lead a family if I myself am unsure of my faith.
I see so many people saying, "this was God's doing" but I'm finding it hard to differentiate between things planned/done by God or things following their natural flow.
Again, sorry if this is the wrong audience, but I'm afraid of coming out in person and it came to me of asking this here, but how does God show himself in the current days?
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • Dec 17 '20
Historicity, Reality and Faith: How does it affect you?
(Cross-posted from r/academicbiblical).
For many of us brought up in Christian households, the accounts in the Old Testament are treated as accurate history - even if Genesis is seen as more allegorical, from Abraham onwards things tend to be taken literally.
This has quite a profound knock-on effect on faith - when New Testament authors refer to these events, they're treating them as the truth. Christ even meets Moses at the Transfiguration.
For those of you who have a Christian faith (and here I'm somewhat more interested in those who accept Christ's supernatural elements like resurrection and ascribed miracles), how do you feel when the historical and archaeological research doesn't support the Old Testament narratives?
How does this change the way you see God, or Christ? It certainly gives me pause, at least.
r/AskTheologists • u/Kermits_MiddleFinger • Nov 07 '22
Why is pre marital sex considered a sin?
r/AskTheologists • u/pennylanebarbershop • Mar 14 '22
Why do demons appear suddenly in the gospels but not in the Old Testament?
If demons exist, wouldn't Moses, Abraham, Elijah, and others have been casting them out of people?
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • May 31 '21
Does the Bible teach that we have an immaterial soul that leaves the body when we die or is that Greek influence on Christianity?
I read somewhere that dualism - that we are body and soul - is not Scriptural. NT Wright wrote a short blog about this that got me thinking.
What's the scholarly consensus? Do we have souls?
Kind of related, too. I used to work with the brain injured and it's hard for me to think they had "souls" because they're personalities and memories changed drastically after their accidents. How can that be?
Any answers are appreciated. Would prefer to hear from fellow believers who are also scholars!
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • Dec 29 '22
The inevitable decline of churches that adopt a liberal theology
The above is the kind of claim often espoused by my father, a PCA pastor. This Christmas was no exception.
He launched into a long diatribe aimed at progressive Christianity, and concluded with the statement that, historically, churches that adopt a liberal theology eventually die out. This is presumably because liberal theology is an affront to the gospel and/or just plain wrong.
I’m less concerned about labeling a theology wrong or right and more curious about whether or not his statement has some weight to it. It seems to me like he is right—the more progressive denominations seem to be bleeding members compared to their more evangelical counterparts. Is this due to factors beyond simply a more liberal theology?
If this is the wrong sub for this question please point me elsewhere. Thank you!
r/AskTheologists • u/toonzman92 • Jul 20 '22
How do you feel comfortable with the origins of the Bible?
As a christian I struggle with the origins of the Bible. As a teenager, it was hard enough having faith that God inspired the writers of each book with "his perfect word". As I have grown, though, I've struggled more in my realization/understanding that the path of the scripture is even more rocky than that. I struggle with having faith that God's word was perfectly recorded by the writers, without being marred by their own opinions and cultural understandings, that these stories and lessons were then perfectly preserved and passed down verbally and copied perfectly, then that we found the complete stories even though there are books referenced that we don't have or choose not to read. Then we trust a group of people without much thought (for most people) on which books deserve to be in the Bible.
And all of that is even before you get into the text and differences of opinion/translation and possible contradictions.
I know that different people believe different things on what the Bible consists of, the completeness of the Bible as we know it, and how literally to take it.
On a whole, though, how do other christians accept these facts?
For me, it's come down to the fact that I just have decided it is worth believing in. Choosing that I want to believe this way because it seems right, but it seems like such a shaky way to go about it. I don't feel sure in my faith, although I'd say I am determined in my faith. If I was born to a family with a different religion, I wonder if I would not decide the same for that religion, if that makes sense. Please give me your opinions.
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • Nov 26 '23
How do you reconcile faith and belief that the Bible is not inerrant?
I’ve been a longtime lurker on r/askbiblescholars and r/academicBiblical I have seen excellent discussions and articles from both subreddits.
That and studying ancient history at university put the nail in the coffin for me when it came to believing the Chicago statement and biblical inerrancy.
Ever since I was a child I was taught that the Bible is the infallible word of God and God “speaks” to us through this perfect text we believe in X and Y because the Bible tells us so. Those of you who don’t believe in biblical inerrancy what does your faith look like? I’m afraid I will never be able to join a Bible study/teach or become a meaningful member of any American non denominational church.
r/AskTheologists • u/Dry_Bones_Rattle • Oct 23 '22
I die and go to Heaven. What happens if I sin and fall from there?
Hypothetical time.
So, I live and accept Jesus. I die because the wage of sin is death. I am called up to Heaven and given a new body, hopefully in better shape than my current one. I become like the angels (Matthew 22:30) so I get fitted for my new white robe, checkout my learner's harp from the music shop, and get fitted with a set of pre-used training wings (now with more eyeballs!).
*cliche record scratches to halt noise*
And yet, I just realized that angels have free will (same as us) and can rebel and fall.
What will keep me from possibly rebelling and falling?
I can't imagine our free will would be stripped away upon entering Heaven, because that defeats the purpose of us choosing to worship Him.
And seeing Christ for who He truly is (1 John 3:2) didn't stop some of the angels from rebelling against Him, so that's not enough to always stay in good terms up there.
And while Christ's blood makes me live forever (like the angels) does it keep me pure even on the other side? If that is the case, why did it not work for the angels who rebelled? Why were they instantly condemned to Tartarus with no chance to repent? If Satan himself accepted Christ as his Lord and Savior, could he waltz back into the Divine Council like nothing happened? I guess that's probably a question for another day....
Is there anything in cannon or even in any popular non-inspired writings (Enoch, Midrash, Gnostic Gospels, etc) that lead to any answers to this predicament we may find ourselves in of making it to Heaven, but slipping on a cloud and falling?
I'd like to think I would be content with singing 'Holy, holy, holy'...but after a few thousand years...well, I'd hate to see an attractive person here on earth, make a quick flight down for some relaxation, and wake up the next morning in Tartarus for my actions.
tl:dr - What happens if after entering Heaven, I pull a Lucy and try to usurp? Please cite sources.
.
r/AskTheologists • u/RyeItOnBreadStreet • Jun 16 '21
What is the biblical basis of the idea that you need a "personal relationship with Jesus"?
The concept of needing a personal relationship with Jesus is at the center of many, if most most, evangelical and charismatic belief systems. However, as someone who grew up in those environments, I cannot for the life of me conjure up any passages that use such language, outside of the bride-bridegroom imagery in the Gospels and Revelation. Are there any such verses? If not, where did this concept grow out of?
r/AskTheologists • u/SaltSpring3 • Jan 04 '21
What's up with the Second Coming and Jesus's Eschatology?
I've recently been reading literature by scholars such as Dale Allison and N.T Wright on Jesus's own eschatology. After being honest to the available text, the most obvious and plain reading shows us that Jesus and the apostles viewed the second coming along with the coming kingdom of God to be within the generation of the disciples. I understand there are partial preterist views out there that argue that Christ was talking about the destruction of Jerusalem, but this argument seems to argue from a conclusion than looking at the evidence.
My question is presupposing that Christ was an apocalyptical preacher, how are Christians supposed to reconcile this idea that Christ didn't actually come back within the lifetime of the apostles? Does this mean that Jesus was wrong? and if he was wrong what does this say about the hope Christians have in the first place?
Thanks in advance
r/AskTheologists • u/Soggy_Loops • Sep 17 '21
How did God-believing non-Israelites in the Old Testament know what to believe about God?
We hear about prophets and other people believing in God, such as Balaam and the Edomites, but what did they follow? Were they not bound by the Mosaic law? What was their salvation contingent on?
Many have answered this question to me as “they worshipped idols that were false representations of God”, but are we suppose to believe that the only descendants of Abraham to still believe in God was the line of Isaac?
r/AskTheologists • u/LeanAhtan92 • Jun 15 '21
Why are so many Christians (mostly on the right) so opposed to pacifism when Jesus seems to specifically teach it in the Sermon on the Mount?
I'm not talking about complete pacifism. I'm talking about nonviolent response to the violence of others or the overwhelming support of the military and war. In my opinion that doesn't seem biblical and seems quite worldly.
r/AskTheologists • u/EverydayDiscipline • Oct 12 '21
Is Matthew 24:34 a failed prophecy since all hearing it died without the world ending?
r/AskTheologists • u/Over9000Bunnies • Jun 17 '21
The Gospel Of John
I am very naive in terms of genre, which seems to be very important when reading the Bible. And John has caught my attention.
The other 3 gospels seems to portray Jesus's sermons as vague and force people to think on their own "give to Ceasars what is Ceasars, and give to God what is god" and "if your right eye offends you, pluck it out".
Statements like these are vague and forces the listeners to think. What is Ceasars that is not God's? How can your right eye offend you? It seems it is on the listener to decide.
This changes with John, in which Jesus's short mysterious statements term to long speeches that are less obscure. "No one can come through the father except through me" and the story where Jesus shows the disciples the holes in his wrists, after his resurrection.
I have heard some say that John is actually an interpretation, not literally what Jesus did and said.
I have heard others say that Matthew, Mark, and luke were Jesus's exoteric teaching to crowds. But John was Jesus's internal specific teaching to the disciples.
My question: how am I to read and understand and interpret the gospel of John? Which seems to stand out among the gospels.
r/AskTheologists • u/trans-trot • Oct 17 '25
What did king Saul do with the 200 philistine foreskins
Like did he keep them or throw them away or burn them
r/AskTheologists • u/[deleted] • Oct 04 '23
Was Jesus born in 1 AD or 1 BC?
Before you answer, yes i do know that he was most likely born between 6 BC and 4 BC, but im asking from the traditional dating of Jesus's birth, was he born in 1 BC and then the new year after that was 1 AD or was he born in 1 AD as in it was 1 AD even before he was born.
r/AskTheologists • u/riskofgone • Nov 05 '22
How do christians deal with the idea that Jesus taught the apocalypse would be soon?
From what I am reading, most biblical scholars believe that Jesus had preached that Jesus was an apocalyptic scholar. All 4 gospels besides maybe Luke say that some of them will not die before the coming of the kingdom. Paul also believed that Jesus taught this. There were also lot of smaller hints that preach the same, basically that things will end soon so treat it as such. Sorry I dont have sources.
One explanation I heard that I heard is that Jesus didn't have knowledge of when it would happen. We know this from the bible. And that he just doesn't know everything because he was a man. But it raises another question, what does he know? He can prophesize the apocalypse but he has no idea when? Can someone please help me understand?