r/AskSocialScience • • 7h ago

Debate Koshnood - Ohran

0 Upvotes

Hey, I recently started to (more or less peacefully) debate with a friend of mine regarding the relation between crime rates and cultural background.

None of us in the field, but I am a scientist in STEM and therefore like to talk about data rather than perceptions, so we often end up commenting on scientific articles coming from the psychology/social sciences field, which are sometimes difficult (for us) to evaluate in terms of comprehensiveness of data or bias-driven results.

The last discussion we had was on the following articles:

  1. https://doi.org/10.1177/08862605241311611: Immigrant Background and Rape Conviction: A 21-Year Follow-Up Study in Sweden, stating that conviction data actually show that "The odds of being convicted of rape were higher for individuals with an immigrant background across all models. After adjusting for potential confounders (socioeconomic status, substance use disorders, psychiatric disorders, and criminal behavior), these odds decreased but remained significant, especially for those born outside Sweden and arriving at age 15 or older"

  2. https://doi.org/10.1177/08862605261493524: Conviction Is Not Commission: A Methodological, Conceptual, and Ethical Critique of Khoshnood et al., arguing that Koshnood et al have overstretched in their conclusions, giving too little space to other confounding factors and erroneously focusing on conviction rather than commission.

I am curious to have other (more informed?) opinions on this matter, particularly concerning the following:

a) the quality of the study by koshnood et al

b) whether there are more comprehensive and higher-quality studies concerning the issues and

c) If not, do you have a reason why?

Please don't use this post to release your frustration against migration and/or racist people, I am genuinely curious about these topics and recognize my low-education around this.


r/AskSocialScience • • 1d ago

Does capitalism encourage too much consumption at the expense of human well-being?

18 Upvotes

I've been thinking about how much of our economy is built around getting people to consume more and more. Entire industries worth hundreds of billions of dollars, like advertising, marketing, and sales, exist largely to convince people to buy things.

But is all this additional consumption actually making people happier their lives more worth living?

Every product we make requires real and limited resources such energy, raw materials, and human labor. Then there are all the secondary costs like shipping, packaging, administration, legal work, advertising, etc. All of this consumes even more resources and, more importantly, people's time.

Obviously, a lot of consumption genuinely improves people's lives in low GDP countries. But in wealthy societies, I wonder how much of what we produce and consume actually adds much to human well-being.

As productivity improves, we could theoretically work less and enjoy more free time. Instead, we seem to keep finding new things to produce, market, and consume.

Is there a point where further "economic growth" becomes increasingly disconnected from improvements in people's lives?


r/AskSocialScience • • 2d ago

Reducing individuals to variables

3 Upvotes

I’m asking this in good faith as someone with an interest and appreciation for social science. I’m aware that my framework for understanding these concepts might be very skewed so any feedback is welcome. This might be the wrong sub to post this in so if you have suggestions for a better place to post this please let me know!

Is it an acknowledged phenomenon that in the fields of sociology, critical theory, etc. that in studying and researching humans and their interactions that a person’s subjectivity gets flattened to just a few variables? My background is in environmental science so to me this seems like a necessity, you couldn’t study any large population and take every variable into account (let alone even know what all the relevant variables would be). Regardless, I have to imagine that in the required process of turning a subjective human into an object, a set of variables, we lose valuable information. To use an environmental idiom, you cant see the forest for the trees, but the inverse 😅.

I understand and accept that you can still obtain meaningful data with an incomplete or even flawed model, but im just wondering if this is something regularly taken into account and if it has a name.

Im fascinated by objectivity vs subjectivity in humans, specifically how our political and academic views might reduce how subjectively we view others.


r/AskSocialScience • • 2d ago

Did colonialism contribute to formalizing racism? If so, how?

3 Upvotes

what did the old version look like, just a random concoction of ever changing notions or just simply stereotypes that held little weight in belief or actions towards someone.


r/AskSocialScience • • 4d ago

Did colonialism contribute to spread of fascism?

0 Upvotes

Fascism is the idea we are superior as a race, so I guess that would have been impossible without occupation of other peoples.

How do scholars view this idea? What ingredients go into the concoction of fascism?


r/AskSocialScience • • 4d ago

Is Constant Social Comparison Unique to Chinese Culture?

6 Upvotes

Is it only in Chinese culture that people tend to make constant comparisons — like the famous “other people’s kids” trope — which makes people feel they are never good enough and hand over the right to judge themselves to outsiders?


r/AskSocialScience • • 4d ago

Answered Can someone define white privileged for me?

0 Upvotes

As a Caucasian man I have been declined jobs because of the color of my skin. Declined enlistment in armed service. Told I would need a college degree because I didn’t graduate high school. In my experience I have been discriminated against because I’m white.


r/AskSocialScience • • 7d ago

What Research Has Been Done on Preobrazhensky's Primitive Socialist Accumulation Outside Economics?

5 Upvotes

Preobrazhensky (The New Economics, 1926) proposed (as part of his framework of “primitive socialist accumulation,” which was debated during the Soviet industrialization debate) that the state could raise capital accumulation by turning the terms of trade against the peasants (economists call this “Preobrazhensky’s first proposition”), without lowering industrial workers’ welfare (his “second proposition”). The economists Sah and Stiglitz (1984) formalized these and concluded that the first proposition holds (the “Sah–Stiglitz accumulation theorem”) but the second does not (the “Sah–Stiglitz welfare theorem”). Other economists later extended or challenged Sah and Stiglitz’s analysis. I’m looking for work by non-economists (e.g., historians, sociologists, etc.) that engages with these propositions or with related ideas. Any references appreciated.


r/AskSocialScience • • 12d ago

Is there a relationship between population control and social conservatism?

18 Upvotes

I've heard Marxists say that capitalism needs the traditional patriarchal family in order to maintain birth rates, so there can be enough workers and consumers, but the relationship between social attitudes towards women and population control always seemed rather nebulous to me.

Recently, however, I heard about the Great Retreat, which undid social progress for women in the USSR in the 1930s in order to boost the population as part of the war effort.

And I also heard about a Traditional Education of Girls Course founded in Russia supposedly as part of a push for conservative values in order to combat the country's population decline.

Previously I thought the current wave of traditionalism was just people reaching for women/a crisis of gender roles as a historically "common sense" scapegoat for their economic troubles, but could it be more than that?

I'm struggling to even formulate precise questions, to be honest. As I said, this whole matter seems nebulous to me, but is there any light you could shed on it? Thank you.


r/AskSocialScience • • 16d ago

Why do politically polarized people assign different characterizations to the same groups of less polarized people?

0 Upvotes

I understand that doing so is in part a rhetorical technique that serves respective agendas, but why isn’t the middle perceived as the end result/product of a dialectic, a compromise that satisfies the most people possible? Why instead is the middle viewed as unprincipled, wishy-washy, etc? I see ultra-leftists say liberals are right-wing, but I also see the far right say liberals constitute the radical left. Why is there such divisive debate instead of the logical conclusion being that liberals and centrists will generate positive appeal, of any degree, to the largest group of people? Forgive me if any of this is fallacious in construction — I’m looking for those blind spots and breakpoints to be exposed.

Context about my positionality and possible relevant biases: I am a south indian-american woman of Outcaste heritage + white-collar immigrant parents from poverty and lower-middle class backgrounds, was raised in middle-class and upper-middle-class suburbs in the midwest and mid-atlantic, both in predominantly white and asian areas, went to private, public, and charter grade schools, went to a public state university in a middle-class college town as well as private university and college in a big city, was raised catholic but now a secular christian, spending adulthood between two big cities known for diversity and gentrification. I consider myself moderately liberal and value pragmatics over ideology


r/AskSocialScience • • 17d ago

Why has America traditionally been more OK with on-screen violence than on-screen sex?

63 Upvotes

It's probably still true today that you can show somewhat bloody gunshot or stab wounds and still get a PG13 rating, but if those nipples make an appearance, you're pretty much guaranteed an R, especially if it's in a sexual context.

And it's been like that since film began. Actually, the social more probably pre-dates film, but I'm mostly interested in film.

On screen nudity (in narrative films) became more-or-less legal in the late 50s when a court ruled that "nudity per se is not obscene." It still wasn't OK to show nudity in sexual contexts though. We didn't get legal hardcore until the early 70s (Warhol's Blue was in 1969 and then it was off to the races). BUT, all throughout the 60s there were violent, sexy films called roughies where it was ok to stab a naked woman with a knife, but still very much illegal to put an erect penis anywhere near her.

Why is this? Why was this? Are there any studies or article that explore this?


r/AskSocialScience • • 17d ago

Why Are So Many People Adamant About The Idea That Black People Can’t Be Racist?

0 Upvotes

I figured this would be a good place to start to hopefully have some good faith discussion about this topic, as well as get some insight from real sociologists (hopefully) on this topic, and understand the motivation and thought process behind this belief and whether or not you all consistently subscribe to this idea. So here goes…

To me, it seems like the argument hinges on certain arguments like “white people created race/racism”and that “black people lack the systemic power to be racist”. I agree that generally - when talking about the US and many other countries as a whole - black people DO lack the systemic power to impose racism. But why does that somehow mean they can’t be racist in other aspects?

Here are the inconsistencies I feel I’m noticing in these arguments, and rebuttals I give in response to a few assertions the other side makes. I truly would like an explanation because maybe I’m missing something as far as my logic goes. Feel free to give your own response to one or all of these:

  1. **“They lack systemic power”**

What do we define as a system? If we only define it as an entire country and not cities or schools etc. why? Systems can be pretty small and within those systems a person can be marginalized regardless of what broader system the smaller one exists under. Plenty of ideologies held by people aren’t backed by a system as big as a country, or state, or city, but if they act in accordance to their own beliefs - no matter how minute those actions are - we would likely label them as someone a part of that ideology

2. **“White people were the ones to create it”**

** **Since when has an ideology that doesn’t possess root words that restrict its use in certain contexts (unlike misogyny, ableism, etc) LIMIT who can adopt that ideology and who can be affected by it? Theres nothing linguistically limiting the word/ideology of racism to just white people

3. (In response to the dictionary definition(s))
**“The dictionary only describes things, it doesn’t explain their function”**

How can you claim a word applies to a function without being able to describe the word itself? And what authority do you look to when relying on whether or not a function applies to a word or not? I can concede that the current overarching function of SYSTEMIC racism in our world is best described through a sociological lens, but to me thats only describing whats happening broadly and systemically, not necessarily limiting the other potential functions that could be attributed to a racist ideology of anyone or any given group. The function of someone’s racist ideology can look different in many different ways depending on their own goals in they set based on their belief in a racial hierarchy, and their own ability act on those goals effectively.

Obviously theres a ton of nuance involving this topic and I feel like there is a big philosophical aspect to this discussion to consider. I genuinely would like to hear any thoughts you all have regarding my views. Any flaws to point out, rebuttals, or correction in my way of thinking would be great to hear

Thank You!


r/AskSocialScience • • 17d ago

Subreddits for recruitment advice

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am a PhD student seeking advice on subreddits which accept recruitment posts for qualitative research in the field of psychology and social media please. Any advice for would greatly appreciated. Does anyone have any recommendations?


r/AskSocialScience • • 19d ago

Is there any evidence that having the 10 Commandments in classrooms changes beliefs or behavior?

12 Upvotes

Texas, among other states, has recently required that all schools display the 10 Commandments in the classroom.

Is there any social science evidence that doing so changes anyone's mind -- or their behavior?


r/AskSocialScience • • 19d ago

How influential were interviews with serial killers to the development of modern criminal profiling?

7 Upvotes

I've been researching the development of criminal profiling, particularly the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit and its work interviewing convicted serial killers during the 1970s and 1980s.

Researchers such as John Douglas, Robert Ressler and Ann Burgess studied offenders including Edmund Kemper and David Berkowitz to better understand patterns of criminal behaviour.

I'm interested in understanding how much these interviews actually contributed to the development of modern criminal profiling.

Were the findings from these interviews instrumental in developing investigative techniques, or were similar approaches already emerging through other areas of criminology, forensic psychology and criminal investigation?

I'm also curious about the methodological limitations of this research. Given that some offenders were manipulative or potentially unreliable narrators, how did researchers evaluate the accuracy of their accounts?


r/AskSocialScience • • 24d ago

Why is hostility toward China so normalized in American online discourse?

31 Upvotes

Im not American and I don't live in the US. I've repeatedly noticed on Reddit something that I find difficult to understand - the normality of hostility toward China and, sometimes, to Chinese people.

What strikes me isn't that people disagree with Chinese government, but its how readily negative attitudes toward China seem to be taken for granted, even in discussions that have nothing to do with any specific Chinese action.

China is so distant from US that I suspect that most ordinary americans have relatively limited knowledge of its political system and society beyond what they encounter in media. Yet, the hostility seems to me remarkably strong and almost self-evident, like as disliking China requires no particular explanation.

Im interested in how this developed and became so socially widespread?

I also find it interesting in comparison with Japan and South Korea. They are also Asian countries but the tone of discussion about them is different. This makes me wonder whether racial prejudice plays role in hostility to China, while also suggesting that race alone may not explain the difference.

I am aware that reddit is not representative of American public opinion, and Im not claiming that all americans share this attitude.

So my question is: What does social science can tell about how such strong negative attitudes toward a foreign country become normalized among people who may have limited direct knowledge of that country? In particular: what explains anti-China sentiment in US, and how can the effects of geopolitical rivalry, media and political framing, social conformity, and racial prejudice be distinguished?


r/AskSocialScience • • 25d ago

why do people feel more comfortable sharing personal struggles online than in real life?

14 Upvotes

It seems like people openly talk about mental health, relationships, and personal issues online, but still hesitate to have those same conversations face-to-face. Is this due to anonymity, lack of immediate judgement, or something deeper in how we process social risk?


r/AskSocialScience • • 27d ago

So if there currently is a literacy crisis, when was the peak of literacy in the U.S.?

54 Upvotes

There’s been much said about the literacy crisis, how 21% of adults are functionally illiterate and how children are also reading below basic levels.

Throughout a lot of history, IIRC, literacy rates were pretty low until we started getting into the early 20th century.

So if the literacy rates are now declining. When was the peak of adult literacy in America?


r/AskSocialScience • • 29d ago

How similar are the social effects of the 1920 Spanish Flu to the 2020 COVID Pandemic? Did the survivors of the Spanish Flu heal a social scar like the one caused by COVID?

21 Upvotes

r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 16 '26

Why do richer countries have higher suicide rates than that of poorer countries?

60 Upvotes

I know the data isn't 100% accurate but a trend I notice is that people in places like North America, Europe, and Japan talk about how miserable their life is while living in such a developed, rich, and safe nation


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 16 '26

Is there any correlation between proximity to 'Silicon Valley capitalism'-style environments and 'AGI might exterminate humanity in the next decade'-style fearmongering?

14 Upvotes

So, I recently realised that a theory I learned of a while back should be capable of producing testable predictions.

It had to do with psychological projection and the belief of some Silicon Valley technologists that 'there is 10% chance AGI will exterminate humanity in the next decade'*.

A certain Ted Chiang had speculated that such sentiments could be caused by tech sector people reflecting the behaviour and attitudes of Silicon Valley startups into their products:

This summer, Elon Musk spoke to the National Governors Association and told them that “AI is a fundamental risk to the existence of human civilization.” Doomsayers have been issuing similar warnings for some time, but never before have they commanded so much visibility. Musk isn’t necessarily worried about the rise of a malicious computer like Skynet from The Terminator. Speaking to Maureen Dowd for a Vanity Fair article published in April, Musk gave an example of an artificial intelligence that’s given the task of picking strawberries. It seems harmless enough, but as the AI redesigns itself to be more effective, it might decide that the best way to maximize its output would be to destroy civilization and convert the entire surface of the Earth into strawberry fields. Thus, in its pursuit of a seemingly innocuous goal, an AI could bring about the extinction of humanity purely as an unintended side effect.

This scenario sounds absurd to most people, yet there are a surprising number of technologists who think it illustrates a real danger. Why? Perhaps it’s because they’re already accustomed to entities that operate this way: Silicon Valley tech companies.

Consider: Who pursues their goals with monomaniacal focus, oblivious to the possibility of negative consequences? Who adopts a scorched-earth approach to increasing market share? This hypothetical strawberry-picking AI does what every tech startup wishes it could do — grows at an exponential rate and destroys its competitors until it achieved an absolute monopoly. The idea of superintelligence is such a poorly defined notion that one could envision it taking almost any form with equal justification: a benevolent genie that solves all the world’s problems, or a mathematician that spends all its time proving theorems so abstract that humans can’t even understand them. But when Silicon Valley tries to imagine superintelligence, what it comes up with is no-holds-barred capitalism.

From: Silicon Valley Is Turning Into Its Own Worst Fear

I am not very convinced but it does appear more plausible to me than the 'they have watched too much Terminator'-theory.

Recently I realised that this theory implies testable predictions.

Such as, people working on AI in environments very unlike to 'libertarian' Silicon Valley techno-capitalism where those hypothesised psychological factors are absent should be much less inclined to think in that way. I know such groups exists, for example, the LLM Apertus is the product of a collaboration of Swiss public universities and the Swiss National Supercomputing Centre. Though, I don't have any knowledge of whether such '10% chance AGI will exterminate humanity in the next decade'-sentiment is less prevalent amongst public and/or university AI developers.

Does anybody here knows anything of how much truth there would be to any statement that such fears are less common the greater the socio-cultural distance from Silicon Valley is?

* Weirdly enough, in none of the, admittedly few, examples of such fearmongering I encountered was provided a plausible mechanism for 'AI to exterminate humanity in the next decade'. An LLM hacking the US' nuclear arsenal and Terminator factories might work in Hollywood movies, but I doubt it would work in real life. And I don't think we in this decade would see enough androids for a robot revolution to make more sense than LLMs going Skynet on us.

Lastly, to avoid being misunderstood, I am not saying there is nothing to worry about when it comes to the development of 'AI'; I am worried about various current developments for diverse reasons and think not enough is done to make those opaque Black Boxes which display all kinds of unforeseen and unintended behaviour transparent and ensure they behave. However, those worries are, I think, a bit more grounded than such '10% chance AGI will exterminate humanity in the next decade'-sentiment.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 15 '26

Is Wealth Inequality Actually a Major Predictor of Relative Increases in Crime?

20 Upvotes

I've heard the claim (with the occasional supporting graph) that a major indicator of crime is wealth inequality (as opposed to absolute poverty).

I was having another conversation with someone recently about how overall crime has gradually decreased over time in the US (not withstanding that major crime spike in the 90s, and then that smaller one during COVID). That idea crossed streams with the title thought, and with the present trueism that wealth inequality in the US is growing rapidly, does the idea that "wealth inequality is reasonably predictive of crime" hold much water?


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 14 '26

Are academic economists really that dismissive of other perspectives, or is online discourse just that unrepresentative of the field?

80 Upvotes

I'm not from the social sciences, so apologies if this is a naive question.

I've been looking on r economics and r AskEconomics for critiques of Ha-Joon Chang's work, since I quite enjoyed his books and wanted to get to know some opposing arguments. Some answers do engage with his claims, but many start with something like "he's a cherry-picking political hack" or "nobody takes him seriously", point to citation counts, or brush off follow-up questions with "I'll leave that as an exercise to the reader". I saw similar responses about other heterodox economists like Richard Wolff.

What i found the most surprising is the level of certainty. Answers often state "this is wrong" with a single data counterexample, even when someone points out that a different measure might support the original claim.

I've read that research like Fourcade, Ollion & Algan's "The Superiority of Economists" (2015) describes economics as a bit more self-assured and closed off than other social sciences. So I'm wondering whether that's what academia is really like, or whether this is mostly an online phenomenon?


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 14 '26

Psychiatrization

12 Upvotes

Do you have any ideas/examples/theories of non formal practices happening in early socialisation stages that could contribute to psychiatrist/psychological/pathological thinking patterns later on in life? As implicit knowledge incorporated in the habitus. Like for example in economical thinking: the practice of getting grades in school as socialisation towards social comparison/competiton thinking patterns.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 12 '26

How do social scientists distinguish cultural appropriation from cultural exchange or appreciation?

21 Upvotes

I’m only vaguely familiar with the term “cultural appropriation,” and I’d like to understand how it is defined and studied in the social sciences.

Are there widely accepted criteria for distinguishing cultural appropriation from cultural exchange or appreciation? Or do definitions differ substantially across disciplines and researchers?

Some everyday examples that prompted my question are:

- Restaurant chains such as Taco Bell or Olive Garden serving food associated with cultures other than that of their founders.

- Someone attending a Greek festival, buying a T-shirt featuring the Greek flag, and wearing it despite not being Greek.

- Someone cooking another culture’s traditional food or opening a restaurant serving it.

- Someone buying traditional clothing or jewelry directly from members of that culture and wearing it.

- Someone performing another culture’s music or getting a tattoo featuring one of its symbols.

I’m interested in the framework used to evaluate examples like these. How do factors such as power differences, historical context, religious significance, commercialization, attribution, and the involvement of members of the originating culture affect the analysis?

Also, does the scholarly use of “appropriation” necessarily imply harm or wrongdoing, or do researchers distinguish between appropriation as a process and particular instances considered harmful?

I’d appreciate research-based explanations or recommended readings, especially anything that explains how these distinctions are applied in practice and how disagreement within the originating culture is addressed.