UPDATE: Thanks everyone for the feedback and encouragement! This was … nice, very therapeutic.
I think for now I’m going to take some of the advice here and just focus on living my life and on meeting people in real life. At least there I have a better than zero batting average.
I do suspect that my pictures (and the subject in them) is not doing me any favors. Maybe in a few months and re-take them and I’ll work up the courage and post my profile for review (although damn y'all can be mean haha)
…And get cat, I really feel that not having a cat is hurting my chances.
Thanks everyone.
[ORIGINAL POST]
TLDR: I've been having abysmal results on dating apps and am seriously considering giving up and just focusing on real life. But before I do, I wanted a quick sanity check: Is this a normal experience for a guy in Seattle, or am I tripping and doing something completely wrong?
A couple of things upfront: This isn't meant to be another rant about dating apps (there are plenty of those already), nor am I specifically looking for profile advice. I'm more interested in getting some perspective, primarily from a men's POV (I recognize women have a very different experience, with their own set of challenges).
I'd like to hear what kind of success, if any, other guys are having. How are you using the apps? Do you send likes with comments or just likes? How much effort do you put into it? And roughly how many likes are you sending?
Quick about me:
I'm 44, 6ft, ~170 lbs, divorced two years ago, and have kids. Stable job, etc.
I spent the first 1.5 years working on myself and regularly go out to social events and interest groups. So I'm not relying exclusively on apps, but meeting people in real life is slow and hit-or-miss.
Looks wise, I honestly don't know anymore. I used to think I looked alright (at least my mom tells me), but this experience has me questioning that. I do get compliments on my style ("you always look/smell so nice")
I'm not jacked, but if you squint really hard under the right lighting, there's some definition. So at least I look like I try.
Socially, I'm comfortable striking up conversations with strangers, and women generally seem comfortable around me. I don't think I give off creepy vibes.
My experience with the apps (Hinge only, so far):
A few months ago, I decided to give Hinge an honest try.
I put some effort into my profile:
A mix of photos: no bathroom selfies, at least one full-body shot, a social/vacation photo, and an interest-related photo. Face, smile, teeth, and hair visible in most. No AI pictures.
Prompts written in a conversational, slightly humorous style. I share something I'm interested in and follow it with a question to make it easy for someone to engage.
Filled out all the profile details, including politics (liberal). Haven't tried video or audio prompts.
The results (or lack thereof):
Sending roughly 20–30 likes with comments per week.
Reading profiles and avoiding obvious incompatibilities (e.g., wanting kids vs. not wanting kids).
Trying to make comments thoughtful, funny, or engaging (man like I was actually proud in a few them)
After roughly 70 likes, I've had 5 matches. Only one actually responded. Zero dates.
Where I'm at now:
Honestly, this feels like a disproportionate amount of effort for very little return. Writing thoughtful comments takes a surprising amount of time, and I don't particularly like how much mental space the whole process is taking up.
I can think of a few ways to improve my profile, but they'd require a fairly significant investment (professional photographer, buying new clothes specifically for pictures, etc.). I'm just not convinced the payoff would justify it.
So, am I having a pretty typical experience, or am I doing something wrong? How are other guys navigating this?