r/AskScienceFiction • • May 03 '14

[meta] If your tag is [real life] [earth] [real world] [reality] or any permutation of that do not ask your question.

0 Upvotes

We do not deal with the real world here. if you would like to ask questions about the real world try /r/askscience because we do not do that here. If your question uses the [general] tag consider weather it can be answered using only information from within established work, if the answer is no ask the question elsewhere. Thank you.


r/AskScienceFiction • • Dec 29 '25

[Star Wars IV onwards] Is the three body problem solved in this universe? Luke stares at a binary star sunset.

3 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • Feb 15 '26

[Warhammer 40k] How differently does the Warhammer timeline play out if the Emperor of Mankind was born the opposite gender?

0 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • Jan 14 '23

[Marvel / MCU ] why didn’t they just nuke Thanos army in endgame?

0 Upvotes

It seems a quick solution would be to send a few tactical nukes and then the USMC to clean up any survivors. We know most of the army is relatively weak, being able to be killed/take damage from punches from normal un-augmented humans, so no reason a tactical nuke wouldn’t vaporize everyone except Thanos. (And Thanos also reacts to punches from Captain America, who’s only a few times stronger than a normal human, so a nuke will probably kill him as well).


r/AskScienceFiction • • Oct 12 '26

[Harry Potter] How important is it to say the spell a wizard uses?

0 Upvotes

We see Ron struggle with Levios-uhhhh because he’s enunciating it wrong, but that also has to do with the fact that he’s only in his first year and has had little practice with magic up until then.

Elite wizards like Snape and McGonagall or Dumbledore and Grindelwald, however, are able to have a fight without uttering a single incantation. This isn’t entirely black and white, though, as we see Voldemort give the incantation for the Killing Curse multiple times, Snape gives a very dramatic “Exxxxxpelliarmus!” During his ‘duel’ with Gilderoy, etc.

So, is it more to do with the individual wizards’ practice with the individual spell?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Nov 21 '19

[Star Wars] How did Rey become more powerful in a week than Jedi who had spent months or years training?

0 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • 5d ago

[Harry Potter] How do Muggle born students get their supplies and get to the Hogwarts Express without wizarding parents?

20 Upvotes

A Muggl -born kid gets a letter and suddenly needs a wand, robes, cauldron, and books from Diagon Alley. Their parents can't see the Leaky Cauldron and have no idea how to get Galleons. Do wizards send someone to explain all this, or do they just trust that a family with no wizarding knowledge will somehow figure out how to find a hidden street in London? The Weasleys seem to help some families but that can't cover everyone.


r/AskScienceFiction • • Feb 21 '24

[The Last of Us 2] Why did Ellie spare Abby?

0 Upvotes

She hated her completely for killing Joel, and what she did was unforgivable. She went though so much trouble to get revenge on the psychopath who took away the only father she ever had. It didn’t even quite make sense for her to just let her go, especially as she was drowning her she saw that vision of him which had to hurt more due to how she would never see him again because of Abby.


r/AskScienceFiction • • Mar 24 '25

[Marvel/DC] Let's say Bruce Wayne/aka the Batman is transposed into the marvel universe in much the same way Miles was. How far does he get in this new world where the supers don't have easily exploitable signature weaknesses?

0 Upvotes

Like say he has a misunderstood run in with some X-Men or X kids , or he tries to take on Sabertooth or Magneto or goes after Green goblin. Could he really do as much as he does back in the DC universe?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Apr 29 '25

[Fallout] why no closed order infantry?

0 Upvotes

For most of history, armies would march and fight in tight formations, basically because there was no good reason not to, and it was the best way to magnify and control the amount of force you have access to. It even stuck around for a while post-gun, up until about WW1. A confluence of factors lead do its end, including machine guns and accurate artillery, telecommunications and the abundance of rifles.

So, in the post apocalypse, wouldn’t most of this have gone away? Sure you’ll have some rifles, no different from skirmishing units during the Napoleonic wars, but you can’t really make them right? And if you can, not at incredible scale. So arming your entire army with them is always going to be infeasible, no? The boomers have like 2 functional howitzers and that alone is enough to make them a regional player despite everything else about their civilization being laughably backwards, so we know that isn’t common either. The NCR uses radios, but again I cannot imagine that those are so common or that they’re replicable to the point where you can just rely on them for every unit

So it makes me wonder, why isn’t anyone (and particularly why isn’t the Legion) organizing their troops into big closed order blocks? Battlefield command and control instantly becomes anywhere between “way easier” and “possible at all”, it would massively increase the effectiveness of their melee units, it would make sending out units equipped with new non-rifled firearms possible, it just seems like an upgrade in every way possible to “open order infantry but with 10% of the technology that made open order make sense to begin with”. And it’s not like they couldn’t still have elite units equipped with the best stuff who still fight in open order, as that was common place in every war between industrialized powers in the 19th century


r/AskScienceFiction • • Mar 17 '24

[Avatar: The Last Airbender] Why does the level of technology vary so widely and inconsistently?

1 Upvotes

I've watched both the original cartoon and also the new live-action series, and in both instances I've found myself scratching my head regarding the level of technology that exists in the world.

The uniforms and weapons suggest a medieval era setting, yet there are also what appear to be metallic steamships. Even more asinine is the massive technological jump between the original and the Legend of Korra series, where they suddenly have aircraft and automobiles, despite the latter taking place barely a generation after the first (Aang's son is still alive!).

Are there logical in-universe reasons or did the writers just not care?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Mar 21 '24

[Barbie Film] What is the status of Trans men in the Barbie World (or trans Barbie-to-Kens)?

0 Upvotes

After seeing the Barbie film, and hearing about some anti-woke complaining about a trans actor in the background, I thought about this for a while, seeing with the Barbie world being reverse with roles between men and women. For those who are Ftm, are they just treated like Kens, trade places with trans women with the big news both good and bad, are like Allen in the background, etc.?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Aug 13 '14

[asoiaf] Suddenly, an entrepreneur from Colorado is transported into Westeros. The only things that have made the journey with him? About 50 seeds of the dankest medical grade kush. How does this affect westerosi society?

3 Upvotes

Add a whole new meaning to highgarden. Eh? Anyone?

I'm sorry, I'll let myself out.


r/AskScienceFiction • • Aug 02 '24

[Star Wars] Does Darth Vader still have a penis?

0 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • Feb 15 '15

[Batman] Bruce Wayne's parents kill each other in front of Bruce, what's next?

0 Upvotes

Young Bruce Wayne wakes up to hear arguing(about money, land etc.) downstair; he peers into the dining room only to see Thomas and Martha pointing pistols at each other. They fire killing each other instantly.

What does Bruce become?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Jan 13 '24

[Game of Thrones] Does the duel that Jorah Mormont fought in the pits of Meereen prove that in a duel with equally skilled warriors rapier is inherently superior weapon to one-handed sword?

3 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • Dec 19 '25

[DC] Could Beast Boy become impregnated if he changes into a animal where males can get pregnant NSFW

16 Upvotes

Could Beast Boy become impregnated if he changes into a animal where males can get pregnant?

Furthermore, if he were to transform while pregnant into a human, would he then be a pregnant male beast boy?

This is not a weird mpreg thing, this conversation came up naturally between me and a friend and we were stuck on if he could or couldn't. I personally believe he could since he can manipulate his DNA and when he does turn into an animal, it's a 100% replica except for the green colours


r/AskScienceFiction • • Jun 09 '26

[Warhammer 40k] Ok, seriously, what the H-E-Double Hockey Sticks are the Fenris Wolves? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I've always been under the assumption that these things are mutated/genetically modified humans from the DAoT. But after looking again at their lore and some old discussions, I noticed my assumption was seemingly never actually fully confirmed anywhere and the people theorizing this never even agreed if the Fenris wolves were transformed humams, tranaford space marines, or both.

Furthermore, I also saw a lot of speculation that Magus saying; "There are no wolves on Fenris" implied these creatures were secretly wolf-shaped Warp Spawn. And yet another argument saying the Fenris Wolves were just semi-sapient xenos the natives & Space Wolves found too cool/useful to exterminate.

So which is it? Or do we still not know the exact origin and nature of these beasts even after all this time?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Aug 02 '15

[Batman] Who is Batman?

0 Upvotes

He's gotta be pretty rich, I hear he has loads of gadgets and some type of bat car(?)

He probably lives in Gotham too since he seems to be seen there the most.


[M]

Rule #1. Discuss all fiction based on data about the fictional universe presented and not meta data about that universe.

Answer this question as if you were a person living in the DC Universe.


r/AskScienceFiction • • Apr 29 '18

[Friends] Why does Ross, the largest friend, not simply eat the other five?

5 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • Apr 19 '25

[Iliad] Why was Achilles' heel extra vulnerable?

1 Upvotes

Sure, it was the only part of him not covered by invulnerable god-armour, but how can taking an arrow to the heel be fatal?


r/AskScienceFiction • • Jun 04 '14

[harry potter] The Wizard Sex Post (NSFW) NSFW

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/AskScienceFiction • • Apr 23 '18

[Mario] Who is that Green Mario dude?

0 Upvotes

At first I thought Mario just sometimes dressed in green like when he dress in white and red or whatever but I've seen him karting with a taller green mario.

Is he a fan or something? why would Mario be friend with a guy cosplaying as him? that's kinda weird.


r/AskScienceFiction • • Aug 23 '24

[MCU] Did Cap simply gain ability to wield Mjolnir or did he actually get full Thor power set?

0 Upvotes

I never really got that. Was Cap simply found worthy of wielding Mjolnir but without full Thor powers or did he actually get the whole set, which we weren’t able to see?