r/AskReligion • • Apr 21 '20

General What makes your religion correct?

47 Upvotes

So everyone has a different viewpoint on religion, everyone belives something slightly different right? So I’m just wondering, why is any one persons religion more correct than another’s, like if your a Christian, why is Christianity correct, whereas atheism or islam or Buddhism not correct?


r/AskReligion • • Jul 30 '25

Consistent with the Christian faith, is masturbation a sin?

26 Upvotes

I am a (former?) agnostic, but I'm currently going down my spiritual journey. Albeit slowly, I'm trying to find my way to Christ and one of the many things I struggle with is..well, self-pleasure. I'm young, and not very well read in God's word. I was hoping someone who has found Christ and who is more versed than me can help me understand this battle against my own flesh.

The hardest part is, I don't even know if I'm supposed to be denying myself release. I'm mostly just doing it out of fear "in case" it might be wrong. Any guidance on this would be appreciated.


r/AskReligion • • Feb 23 '20

Why does God get some of the credit if I save someone's life but gets less credit if I kill someone?

23 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Apr 08 '20

Meta Can the mods please bring an end to childish questions like "a peRsoN fRoM thiS rElIGioN SAiD thaT KiLling iNnOCeNt CHilDReN iS A GoOD tHInG, IS ThIs TrUe?" And "GoD cAn'T EXisT bC I'M hAVinG a mIDliFE CriSIs"?

20 Upvotes

I want to learn about Shintoism, not some redditor's moral conundrum about God not Existing because He can't Eat a freaking pineapple or how xyz religion is suspicious bc some nobody said something ludicrous that no sane human being would say outside of a carefully monitored environment like a debate* or academic/philosophical lecture.

Let's see some questions like "why are some religions centralized like the Khilafah and Papacy, while others are 'do your own thing'?" Or like "how did you learn to integrate your religion into the city you live in?" Even though I have accepted Islam as the Absolute Truth, I still want to learn about your experiences. I know that sounds contradictory, but think of it as that line from Captain America: Civil War where Tony Stark tells Peter Parker not to do anything he would do, and definitely not to do anything he wouldn't do, and how there's a fine line in there where he (Peter) comes into play. Basically, use your head and don't overcomplicate it. /endrant

Edit: *I hate debates bc they don't usually result in any real growth. I rarely ever see either side give a genuine interest in learning about the other side. It's like how Prophet Muhammad (Peace and Blessings upon him) said to avoid excessive argumentation bc it can kill the heart. If you take this to start a debate, then you should automatically be banned. We need to have some standards on this sub.


r/AskReligion • • Apr 23 '15

[MODS] Can we get a Sikh flair? It's the fifth largest religion in the world and there isn't any flair on this sub

20 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Apr 19 '20

Meta is the stock market the god of our modern world? We make human sacrifices to the market, we do everything to please the market, nobody really can see it or understand it and a happy market most of the time doesn't translate into benefits for the people but just for the priests of the market.

17 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Apr 28 '19

Why are some biblical people have regular names like Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Paul, Mary, Sarah. But some are archaic and foreign like Hezekiah, Zebedee, Ezekiel?

13 Upvotes

Were these people really called Matt back in the history days? And I once asked a Spanish speaking coworker what they were called in Spanish and he mentioned Paul was called Raul, Luke was Lucas. Are these names really language based? Are Ezekiel and Obadiah and Haggai name swapped in other languages?

And why are some of the names used so much, how many John's are there? Yet I mention Methuselah and you know I can only be talking about one person in the entire history of people.


r/AskReligion • • Apr 17 '20

Christianity Is there a limit to how much water a priest can bless?

11 Upvotes

Like, could he bless an aquaduct, and therefore an entire town or city is drinking "blessed" water? Or has anyone ever thought about blessing the ocean?


r/AskReligion • • Oct 10 '25

Judaism The Hebrew god is really Satan?

10 Upvotes

Without attacking me because im genuinely just curious. I have been seeing a lot of post claiming that the Hebrew god is actually lucifer, and the the jews are really Satan's chosen people. Apparently this is in their bible? Now with that said im pretty ignorant to Judaism and the Hebrew bible, but it seems like they are using something in the Hebrew bible to make this claim. Could someone please elaborate further on this? Im personally atheist but am intrigued by the ideas of all the religions and how they vary and the hold they have on people.


r/AskReligion • • Aug 02 '25

Christianity If God is merciful, why would He create someone He knows is going to hell?

10 Upvotes

I’ve been reading Romans 8 where it talks about God foreknowing and predestining people, and it’s been bothering me deeply. If God is omniscient and already knows who will be saved and who will be eternally damned, why would He still create people He knows will end up in hell?

How is it merciful or loving to create someone for an eternity of suffering? Why not just… not create that person? The usual answer is “free will,” but if God already knows what that person will freely choose, is it really merciful to bring them into existence anyway? Wouldn’t it be more merciful to not create them at all?


r/AskReligion • • Apr 19 '20

If a person commits suicide, are they to spend the rest of eternity in purgatory?

10 Upvotes

Not planning on committing suicide, we were just having a conversation. I was always under the impression that everyone is give a chance to repent their sins, regardless.


r/AskReligion • • Apr 19 '20

Are there any relgions belief sustems that believe in "God" (or somethink akin go God) but do not a believe in an afterlife?

10 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Apr 13 '20

Christianity Does the Bible condemn homosexuality?

10 Upvotes

Hi guys! My first post on this subreddit! I am a Christian and I have heard people say that being gay is alright according to the Bible, despite the many verses that condemn it. I am accepting to any answers to this question!


r/AskReligion • • Jan 04 '20

Christianity Is it possible for a saint to be "de-canonized"? If so, did it ever happen in history?

10 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Jun 12 '19

How do religious people believe in a God when there is no evidence?

10 Upvotes

"The Bible says he exists" is an answer I hear a lot. How do you know if The Bible is actually telling the truth? For all we know, The Bible can just be a made up book written 2,000 years ago by a Random guy.

Not trying to start a fight, would just like an honest answer


r/AskReligion • • Feb 03 '26

What did Epstein mean by goyim?

9 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Jan 26 '25

Christianity Why should I suffer for not believing in God?

9 Upvotes

I am sure there are a lot of posts like this. And I have asked this question many times but noone has given me an anwer that would make sense.

I dont get why I should suffer for eternity just for coming to the conclusion that I dont have a reason to not believe in God (btw Im agnostic so this is hypothetical situacion). And the argument that Jesus already sacrificed himself for us doesnt make sense cuz we still go to hell acording to the Bible and the argument that if you dont want God in your life you will logically not spend eternity with him doesnt make sense on more than one level. And yes I have not read the Bible but I dont consider "the answer is in the Bible" as an explanation.


r/AskReligion • • Apr 19 '20

When christians think that yoga makes you hindu...

9 Upvotes

...how is that supposed to work?

Like, if I stretch, on my hands and feet and breathing slow, it magically changes my religion? Or is it only if I call it a "downward facing dog"? Only if I call it by its proper sanskrit name? Only if I do it in a series of asanas? Only if it's meditation? Only if I'm already more or less a hindu?

How do they explain that many avid practitioners of yoga still don't believe in shiva?

Seriously, I would like to know how people who say stuff like that, actually imagine it to work.

EDIT: For clarification, I know that not all christians think that (likely, only a tiny minority), I'm wondering specifically about those who do.

EDIT#2: I know that this is fringe. Even if it were 1:100.000 christians, I would still love to hear their reasoning.

EDIT#3: The most baffling part of this, to me, is that there is a reverse position where nationalist hindus think that christians' love for yoga is a covert attempt to convert them. And/or that hinduism/yoga/india are inseparable and thus chrsitians shouldn't do yoga.


r/AskReligion • • Feb 13 '12

Tell me about fasting in your religion and in your experience.

9 Upvotes

Does your religion encourage periodic fasting or abstaining from other items/activities? Do you recall a time when the practice benefitted you?

(I'm Catholic, so I'm not debating the value of fasting. Just curious about how it is practiced by others.)


r/AskReligion • • 9d ago

U go to hell if you dont follow a certain god

8 Upvotes

Am i the only one who thinks this is absolute bs? Like wdym you don't get to heaven simply because you followed the "wrong" god. What makes even less sense is that the ppl who say this say that god is a loving god. I myself believe in god but im not religious, even i can tell that if one goes to hell cuz god is example allah and u thought it was jesus quite literally makes god not loving. Like u cant tell me one can be absolutely evil but end up in heaven cuz they followed the "right god".


r/AskReligion • • Jul 27 '26

How does one move from the God of the philosophers to the God of religion?

8 Upvotes

The real difficulty is not believing in God, but believing in the God of religion

The God of the philosophers is comparatively easy to take seriously: Aristotle’s self-thinking thought, Plotinus’ One, Spinoza’s infinite substance, Leibniz’s necessary being, or Hegel’s Absolute Spirit. These are very different conceptions, and some, especially Leibniz and Hegel, stand much closer to revealed religion than others. But they are all intelligible attempts to think ultimate reality through reason

Such a God is not usually imagined as one being among others, subject to arbitrary passions or episodic changes of mind. In Aristotle, the divine eternally contemplates itself. In Plotinus, all reality proceeds from the One. In Spinoza, God is the immanent infinite reality of which all things are modes. We participate in the divine through knowledge and contemplation. As Spinoza puts it, our intellectual love of God is part of God’s eternal love of himself

The God of religion asks for something... much more difficult

One must believe not only in an ultimate divine reality, but that this reality disclosed itself through particular historical persons and events: that this particular Arab received revelations through an angel; that this particular carpenter in Palestine was the Son of God and rose bodily from the dead; or that this charioteer revealed himself as the supreme divine reality on the battlefield of Kurukshetra

These are claims that God entered history at a particular time, in a particular place, through particular people. And not only that, but that the account of this happening should be received with trust, love, and faith rather than with the ordinary skepticism we apply to extraordinary historical claims

In effect, one is asked to suspend doubt for one decisive exception

Fine, perhaps. But which exception?

Why believe this revelation rather than another one? Why accept the resurrection but reject Joseph Smith’s visions, or accept Muhammad’s encounter with Gabriel while rejecting the miracles attributed to Apollonius of Tyana? Why not believe all of them?

But if we believe all of them, they seem to make incompatible claims. And if we use reason to decide which revelation is more credible, why not use reason all the way down? Why not apply the same standards of textual criticism, historical probability, manuscript analysis, contradiction, development, and uncertainty that we apply everywhere else?

At that point, it becomes difficult to see how one could ever establish that a particular revelation was not merely sincere, profound, spiritually transformative, or symbolically true, but literally the unique intervention of God into history

A common philosophical solution is to say that religions express through narrative, symbol, and image the same ultimate reality that philosophers approach conceptually. Religious representation and philosophical thought would then be different forms of the same truth. This seems to have been the view of Hegel, for instance

But this solution risks dissolving the God of religion. If resurrection, revelation, incarnation, and miracle become symbolic expressions of a more general metaphysical truth, religion survives in some way, yes, but its distinctive historical claims lose their force

Christ becomes a symbol of divine self-emptying. Krishna becomes a symbol of the Absolute revealing itself in finite form. Revelation becomes the historical imagination of a people trying to express what philosophy later articulates more clearly

Perhaps that is true. But it is no longer quite what the religions themselves claim, and I believe it leads to the slow dissolution of religion

So the real question for me is not simply:

“Should we believe in God?”

It is:

How could a reflective person come to believe that the ultimate reality described by philosophers is also the particular, historical, and personal God proclaimed by one religion?


r/AskReligion • • Nov 03 '25

Judaism My family had a Jewish branch that did not survive WW2, what can I do as an atheist to respect that part of my lineage?

8 Upvotes

Heya hey, heavy title I know but it basically sums it up. I'm Dutch and I recently discovered through overhearing my grandparents and asking about it afterwards that my maternal side, which comes from Amsterdam, had a Jewish offshoot (I E not direct maternal lineage as far as I know) that were killed by the Nazis during the war.

I have since specifically dedicated my moments of silence each year during the yearly ww2 "remembrance of the dead" to that Jewish offshoot, but I still feel like I'm not doing enough. I thought about maybe passively observing some Jewish holidays as a way to pay my respect, but I am unsure if that would be considered offensive. Advice appreciated.

(Note: I am not planning to convert, outside of the difficulties I heard regarding that, I also am pretty strongly atheistic in my personal beliefs, I am instead specifically looking for ways I can respectfully honour these roots without conversion)


r/AskReligion • • Apr 04 '20

Are there any religions that don’t recognize or worship a God or deity? I’m asking because I’m wondering how Scientology gets a 501c tax exempt status...

8 Upvotes

r/AskReligion • • Jan 01 '20

Abrahamic faiths: Do believers of the 3 different religions go to the same heaven?

8 Upvotes

As far as I know the 3 different abrahamic faiths (Christianity, Islam, Judaism) all believe in the same god, correct me if I'm wrong. Of course their beliefs differ on other points. So by my title question I'm curious firstly on a theoretical level and secondly on general concensus even if not backed by sources from religious/sacred text. Thanks.


r/AskReligion • • Dec 15 '19

We’re Mary and Joseph married at the time of conception? If so, why hadn’t they consummated their marriage?

8 Upvotes