TL;DR: Every food we enjoy today is the result of someone experimenting and getting it right. How many failed combinations did it take to discover the good ones? Are most ingredients actually compatible, or are good flavor combinations surprisingly rare?
---
Random thought I can't shake: Every dish we eat today is basically a survivor. Someone had to be the first person to put cheese on bread, ferment cabbage, or figure out that cassava is poisonous unless you process it first. And for every successful discovery, there were probably tons of failed experiments that nobody bothered to write down.
So what's the ratio? 10 bad recipes for every good one? 100? 1,000?
I think it's interesting because it says something about how much culinary territory we've actually explored.
If the ratio is low, maybe most ingredients go together better than we think, and we've barely scratched the surface of possible combinations. If it's high, maybe genuinely good flavor combinations are pretty rare, and we've already discovered most of them.
A few things make me lean toward the low-ratio side. Chocolate and chili, melon and prosciutto, miso and caramel all sound weird on paper but somehow work. And most dishes that turn out badly seem to fail because of salt, texture, or proportions, not because the ingredients are fundamentally incompatible.
Curious what cooks, food scientists, and historians think. Has anyone actually researched this? Is there anything out there on flavor compatibility or the history of food combinations?
Also, what's the worst ingredient pairing you've personally tried? I'm talking about something that was so wrong, chemically or otherwise, that absolutely nothing could save it.