r/AskProgrammers • • 15h ago

Does using ai to write code in climate models unprofessional?? Or is it important to learn how to code ??

I can solve basic errors but I’m not able to write complete codes yet 😭🙏. Still in college (physics major)

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/Electronic-Yam-69 15h ago

As long as you can verify it's working the way you want it work.

7

u/sububi71 15h ago

It works until it doesn't. Whether you ever hit that point in a specific project is impossible to say, but if you do, you're kind of screwed.

0

u/Previous_Lemon2169 15h ago

Well most of the scientists I worked with used ai to code .. they all had premium models and don’t hit token limits like I do soo..

2

u/sozesghost 15h ago

They are not you.

1

u/laxika 15h ago

They are either better at avoiding context pollution or just have a bigger plan.

2

u/Small_Dog_8699 14h ago

Eventually total incompetence will set in.

2

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 13h ago

Programming is nothing but a form of expression of your ideas. How can you verify that your concepts, your theories, your axioms are being expressed just the way you intended it to be expressed? Sorry there’s a lot of expression here but you get the point right?

How can you validate that the program is doing exactly the way you have set your parameters?

1

u/Living_Fig_6386 14h ago

I don't think that using AI to generate code is considered unprofessional.

As with any code, it's up to you to test and validate the results that it is generating, so, in the case of climate modeling, your procedure would be to validate the code by using previous data to which the model has been applied and then verifying that the results are the same as previous.

You really need to show that you can validate the code.

1

u/RatherNott 14h ago

 Just a quick heads up about AI:

AI data centers are being constructed at an alarming rate, and there are already 8 billion prompts per day, with billions more planned and on the way.

The effect this has on the climate when we are already so close to irreversible tipping points is often unknown by AI users.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5p426fSlYH4

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2026/oct/22/finland-google-felling-trees-datacentre

Using it also contributes to a dystopic surveilence state.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5lYsO4k7OIY 

1

u/Upstairs_Jelly_1082 13h ago

does it involve formulas? and do you understand them?

1

u/RetroGrid_io 11h ago

In my experience about 30% of AI output is wrong, if not outright hallucination. If you can review to the degree that you can catch and throw out this third, then great. Otherwise, you have 100% chance of ending up stuck in a tree someplace rather than where you want to be.

0

u/laxika 15h ago

You can get very far just by using models (if you have common sense & logic). Learning to code is only needed if you need to do something complex and serve it to tens of thousands of people.

Using AI is NOT unprofessional. It is the future. I do work as a Staff SW Engineer and have not written any code since the start of this year.