r/AskProfessors • • Feb 22 '24

Professional Relationships AITA for calling out my Professor for infantilizing the whole class?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a second semester student in a two year master's program. We have a professor who everyone complains about being impossible to work with, but I chalked it up to students constantly complaining about professors and ignored them.

I think this may be the only Professor I have come across that doesn't understand how to lead a classroom in a lab setting.

We had a lab class tonight where we were supposed to test the LD50 of cadmium on oligochaetes. Fine and dandy, right?

The professor spent an hour explaining to the slowest students in the class something that they should have understood from undergrad, then realized that an hour had passed and panicked, and I mean he panicked. He rushed everyone to the lab, gave us haphazard instructions- which he told us to stop doing five minutes later to instruct us to do something else. We ask him if we can do anything, but the answer was always not yet.

We ended up doing nothing but weighing some sediment and picking up worms in pipettes, while the professor did the other 70% of the lab that we were supposed to do and didn't let us do because 'it was getting late.'

I ended up getting angry and said I thought this was a graduate level lab class, not a high school level one when he refused to let us do anything yet again. He got upset and told me 'welcome to biology.'

Was I being a jerk by saying that?

Edit: I will send an apology email to my professor regardless for my disrespectful comment, regardless of how I personally feel about the situation.


r/AskProfessors • • Apr 16 '24

Grading Query Why Don't You Let Students Use Notes On The Exam?

1 Upvotes

Hello Professors! I want to start this off by saying I appreciate all you do. I am just curious and love to better understand the method behind teaching. Why don't you let your students use notes on their exam when in the real world they would have access to every resource publicly available? Wouldn't it be better to allow students to have their notes but have them apply what they know somehow on the exam? I want to state again that this is not a critique of what you do, I am just purely curious why some professors choose to do this.


r/AskProfessors • • Mar 05 '26

Plagiarism/Academic Misconduct Falsely accused of cheating?

1 Upvotes

what should i do?

hi guys. i took an exam today and the professor told us to take off smart watches (like apple watches, where you can access notes and safari and stuff). i have a lowly health tracker (amazfit band5) that tracks my heart rate, footsteps, and calories. i could technically receive texts, but i cant actually do anything on it or answer anything or access the internet nor AI.

so i kept it on and just used it to keep track of time. but a girl next to me went and reported me to the professor saying i was cheating. professor told me to take it off, i say okay and keep taking the test. however, i go to turn it in at the end. professor accuses me of cheating, saying that it is a SERIOUS AND BIG problem that i didnt take off the watch when she told us to take off devices.

i explain to her that i didnt think this counted as a smart watch because i cannot access any internet, google, AI, or anything. i use it to track my steps and can’t even answer texts or calls when i get them. however, she kept trying to get me to admit that i was cheating, saying “are you sure there’s nothing else you want to tell me about that watch?” i am confident i did not cheat and did not hack down. but professor just did NOT believe me.

i kept saying no. that i was just looking at the time. she took down my name and the name of the TA, told me if she wanted to talk to me she would. then i left.

what should i do? will she report this to the university and will i have to contest or defend myself? im a bit annoyed because i know i didn’t do anything wrong, but she is making me feel like i did.


r/AskProfessors • • Dec 17 '23

Academic Life If you had a student with a 69.48, would you round them up to a 70?

2 Upvotes

Just wondering


r/AskProfessors • • Apr 28 '24

Career Advice My lecturer is putting it off dangerously

2 Upvotes

A month ago I asked him for a reference for grad school and he agreed. He told me I'm in the 90th percentile of our class so he's happy to give me a strong reference.

But now it's literally a few days until the deadline and he hasn't submitted it. I'm freaking out. I reminded him on Thursday, he said thanks for the reminder and he'll aim to submit it on the day, but he hasn't. I was hoping he'd do it over the weekend but he hasn't. He'll probs be busier over his day job when Monday hits.

I dont want to be an annoying parrot but it's literally days until deadline. What shld I do now


r/AskProfessors • • Nov 04 '25

General Advice Is Missing Exams Due To Mental Illness Reasonable?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m bipolar and really struggling. It’s difficult to sleep, eat, and preform basic everyday things because my nervous system is so dysregulated.

I’ve tried so many things from medication to therapy and can’t seem to find stability which sucks, because I really enjoy my course work and want to do a PhD

I have 2 midterms this week and i’m considering asking to take a makeup exam due to the severity of my symptoms — I had to call in last midterm for one class because of the same issue. There’s just nothing I can do when my symptoms flare

I feel really ashamed for this and like I should just be able to push through and figure it out like other students.

What do you think as profs — is this a valid reason to miss exams or not? Do I just need to pull myself up by my bootstraps so to speak and push through?


r/AskProfessors • • Jul 26 '24

Plagiarism/Academic Misconduct I have a second Offence of Collusion - advice needed

0 Upvotes

I need some advice on what will happen to me. I have a second offence of collusion this year which means expulsion is highly likely from my university. I'm a 2nd year undergraduate student at a UK Russel Group University. When I did the misconduct I was going through a hard time with my mother who's seriously mentally ill. She's bedridden, needs help all the time and I often went back home multiple times during the week to help care for her plus my disabled dad when my aunt was busy. My caring responsibilities consisted of bathing them, cooking, feeding, changing them. My dad used to be looked after by my mum but ever since she got ill she couldn’t care for him anymore. I was struggling with mental health aswell because of the stress of home and university but I didn't seek any help at the time. So when my coursemate who lives with me at my university flat knocked on my door and wanted to do the online multiple choice exam with me I didn't say no. She did ask me to do it the day before but I did say no at that time even though she was being persistent. I didn't say no on the day of the exam as I felt like because of our prior conversation she wouldn’t listen. I don't know what's going to happen to me. My university’s default penalty for second offences is expulsion with no award. Only in the event of substantial mitigation they’ll consider a lesser penalty. Do you think I’ll get expelled? I’ve been taking steps to improve myself. I’m considering not living with her next year and have taken lots of online courses on academic integrity. I’ve also saught mental health help for my mum and me, and also asked help from social services to provide care for both my parents so I won’t be stressed out anymore.


r/AskProfessors • • Dec 22 '25

Plagiarism/Academic Misconduct I know she cheated, but can’t access the proof.

1 Upvotes

A woman I know (CJ) who has in no small way negatively impacted mine and others lives because of her selfishness cheated to get her Associates and later used that to get her Bachelor’s for Lab Technician. How do I know this? Because the people who took her tests and did her work admitted they did it. They were her family by a previous marriage, and they believed they were just helping her get a better life for her kids.

Once she got a somewhat wealthy man and moved away, she denied all access to the kids. No Grandma can’t see them. No, Dad can’t visit. After the betrayal, the Grandma and Aunt told me what they had done in a rant about how CJ used them. I asked for proof. The Grandmother gave me the login info, the class, and specific assignment that CJ wrote down for her to do. The Aunt said she did things online while she was in Illinois, a state CJ has never even been to.

I informed and provided info to the school I believe she attended and waited. When I hadn’t heard anything, I called and was told that because this woman had already graduated, they weren’t going to do anything about it.

I have several degrees, all of which I worked hard and honestly to get. This lack of pursuit of academic honesty feels like a slight to me, morally and ethically. Can anyone provide me advice on how to get the school to investigate the assignments and exams that were taken out of another state? I feel that alone is proof enough that she didn’t do the work, but the Aunt no longer has access to computer she used.

Thanks.


r/AskProfessors • • Jun 18 '24

Plagiarism/Academic Misconduct Failed thesis twice , please tell us what should we do?

0 Upvotes

My boyfriend studies in Prague, his thesis work was failed TWICE, saying that he used AI. However, it was never proven… The university keeps taking money for the semesters and the exams. What should he do? Btw, he didn’t use AI, and they never showed any proof of him using AI. His friend failed for the same reason, and when we checked their works through GPTZero, AI use wasn’t as high as the university said it was.
Also, he has a good GPA and his mentor ignored him while he was writing both of his papers, on the second thesis my boyfriend reported him to the university and his mentor replied on the day of his deadline🤡 I saw the “document” which they sent to my bf where they describe the “act” and the possibility of getting expelled, and the document looks very informal and unprofessional… His friend’s mentor said that to prove that he didn’t use GPT, he has to write a new paper with a screen recording))) Also, the day before his thesis presentation, the university texted my bf that they want to use his thesis where he’s gonna be a CO- author for his own work in a magazine🤡🤡🤡 Does anyone have any advice on what should we do, we are thinking that he should go to court, and return all the money because we also found out that students pay veryyyyy different tuition prices, however going to court also is a waste of money… Any advice? (P.S. Sorry for my English😂, not my first language)


r/AskProfessors • • Jan 14 '25

Career Advice Hi, I want to be a college professor, I'm a history major. What steps do I need to take?

0 Upvotes

I'm currently attending college and I always wanted to teach history. I really like the deep dives and the more advanced stuff so I wanted to do the collegiate level. I'm a senior right now, and I've taken most everything needed for a history major, and some stuff for secondary education, but I've yet to start my masters. So what steps do I need to take from here? Thank you!


r/AskProfessors • • May 12 '24

Professional Relationships There’s a public website rating professors

15 Upvotes

So there’s a website rating professors, and while I have not care about students criticisms, a bad review calling me the worst professor and even saying my personality does not help was published.

It’s infuriating to me that students are entitled to make such comments and even make them public.

This profession has brought me so much stress, and it’s making me feel like I’m in a place we’re in not using my strengths. This is just a job for me, I don’t feel like being the super professor, but c’mon, I’m trying my best.

I just repeat myself that a st*pid teenager’s comment does not have the power over me, but reality is it kind of hurts.


r/AskProfessors • • 22d ago

META Do you guys look at your rate my professors?

0 Upvotes

Not a teacher just curious.


r/AskProfessors • • Jun 22 '24

Grading Query Is this grade justified?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I just finsihed my summer semester and was waiting for my final grade for a hypothetical BIP Assigmnet, which is just a fake intervention plan i would make for a kid in my classroom who is dealing with behaviors. I did hand write my description box as my computer did not have an option to type directly onto the pdf. The sadness i felt when i saw a 0 on my submission. The professor only left a comment saying 'Myname, this is completely illegible" despite having my mentor at my learning center being able to read it and revising it. I have contacted the professor and have not received anything back. Is a zero justifiable despite me completing the assignment


r/AskProfessors • • Nov 22 '25

Career Advice Is it worth applying to positions requiring a PhD with only a Master’s?

1 Upvotes

I meet all the other requirements. My girl friend keeps telling me “you never know, there might not be better candidates” but I’m assuming the PhD requirement affects accreditation as well.


r/AskProfessors • • Feb 26 '24

General Advice Is it a good idea for professors to give quizzes right before class ends to check the knowledge learned and attendance?

0 Upvotes

Hi all. This was one of my favorite profs. But he only did 1 thing I disliked. Basically, he would always give ~10 min quizzes before the end of class and after the entire 2h+ lecture.

I feel like it was a very good idea for him to easily check attendance and also get some grades, but it would just stress me the fuck out. While I am a smart person that got A's on almost all of them, I always found them to be too stressful. I feel like I need more time to fully understand the material. I assume other students are also like that. It would have been great if the quiz deadline was until midnight or next day, but I understand that he also wanted to check attendance. Not sure what other profs think.


r/AskProfessors • • Oct 29 '24

General Advice I feel betrayed by my Professor but I am also not sure what to do and would appreciate other peoples thoughts on this matter.

0 Upvotes

I have recently graduated and am blessed to find a company to work for, although just an internship, but there is a good chance for official employment. I had a role of assisting my manager with university relations and I had recommended my professor who I worked with and have done favors for. Fast forward 1 year from the start of our collaboration, we receive an email from said professor about wanting to cancel the collaboration with the company due to 3 reasons. 2 of them were about me and 1 was something regarding the company, but I will just talk about the 2 related to me the other one about the company was something out of our control and should have been explained.

1st reason: I had not addressed my professor in 2 emails among the many emails we had with each other as "Dear name_of_professor". He is not happy and said is disappointed because he wants to be called "Dear Dr. name".

2nd reason: I had not appropriately mentioned his name on a twitter post about an event that happened 2 months ago. Issue is that I couldn't add his name specifically as it would mean I have to add the names of all professors who were apart of this company's celebration and this would make the post too lengthy even though I had already expressed my deepest gratitude to the all the attendees.

As such, he explicitly said he won't receive calls or face to face meetings until I write an email with the company email to apologize for not addressing him as Dr. and also revise my post with his name, his research center's name and students name.

This is the first time to experience something like this and I feel betrayed especially with everything we have done together throughout my college years and how he helped me immensely though my thesis studies.

I own up to the fact that I mistakenly didn't address him as Dr. in 2 emails but I thought we were already fine with that and if he was not ok with it he could have privately talked to me about it. Also I don't understand why he brings up twitter post when this is a private matter and has nothing to do with the company.

I just wanted to ask other's opinions on this matter and what is the normal reaction that professors would have to this situation. I have this thing where mistakes I make will always stick in my mind and eat me away but thankfully I have good support from my family that prevents it from getting worse.


r/AskProfessors • • May 13 '26

General Advice how do i tell my professor im uncomfortable with a fellow classmate?

1 Upvotes

for context, i had a falling out with a friend for a very serious reason and had recently cut him off. im very certain he will not be a serious danger to me, but he's obviously someone i dont want to be around. the issue is we share a class together.

obviously, i am going to keep my distance. but in the event that something may happen, i just want to inform my professor about the situation so that he's aware of it. is this a good idea? how should i go about reaching out to him about something like this??

EDIT: thank u guys for all the comments and advice!!!! i heavily appreciate you guys keeping it real with me, i really wanted straightforward, no BS answers. i kept the reasoning super vague in this post for privacy reasons, but i've decided that the events that happened between me and this student are serious enough that it should be dealt with higher ups. please wish me luck :,)


r/AskProfessors • • 4d ago

Academic Advice Prof denying retake even after handing in two different doctor notes. What do I do?

1 Upvotes

I woke up on the exam morning with loss of vision, my sight had spots of blindness for some reason. Also, had dizziness, nausea, and a pretty bad headache. I immediately emailed the professor and mad an appointment with my ophthalmologist and my regular doctor. The regular doctor had easiest availability the next day so, I emailed both notes the following day. She didn't respond until a week later.

Her response:
"Hello ------

Please check your syllabus for that.

Than you."

The syllabus states "No make-up exams or rescheduling are permitted." but also states "There is NO make-up of exams, assignments, or quizzes. If the instructor is notified in advance, and only under extenuating, verifiable circumstances as determined by the instructor, whose decision is final, alternative credit for exams may be offered. Documentation of extenuating circumstances is required."

I believe I met all her requirements, she has not responded a day later. The exam I missed is with 25% of my grade and I'm currently sitting at an 88%, I'm doing pretty well in a very hard course. I'm pretty frustrated and need help on what I should do?


r/AskProfessors • • Sep 16 '24

General Advice Do I need to go to college to become smart?

2 Upvotes

I’m in my senior year of high school and for my whole life I have had a deep passion for knowledge and learning. I really want to acquire knowledge on a wide variety of subjects such as psychology, philosophy, politics, economics, world religions, history and science in order to enhance my life and be self aware. I want to have strong critical thinking skills and be highly literate so that I can understand and interpret information (to avoid misinformation). I want to be a life long learner and I can see myself still reading and studying textbooks 20 years from now. I want to be a strong public speaker and be able to write in an intelligent and cohesive manner.

My question is, if it is possible to become very smart and knowledgeable without going to college. If I have the drive to sit down and study subjects and write essays and research papers on my own and really make learning apart of my life, will that be enough to have the same skills someone who has gone to college has (or even more)? I understand that I wouldn’t have access to a professor or peers and learning would be up to me to do myself, but is there really that much of a difference from going to college and having the drive to self learn?

I’m not referring to how people who go to college often make more money or how I would need a college degree to go into a specific field or job. I’m purely just interested in if I can achieve my dreams of becoming an intelligent scholar, on my own, through self study. I’m just interested in too many things to imagine choosing one thing to major in (other than a future job, though it probably wouldn’t be something I’m passionate about). Plus In my mind, if I went to college to get a bachelors, I would want to go further and get a phd (though that’s not something I can reasonably do financially).

TL;DR: Can I become smart, intelligent and well written and read from self study or is that something I need to go to college for?


r/AskProfessors • • Sep 20 '24

Plagiarism/Academic Misconduct "Friend" copied my homework without my knowledge. Professor issued a violation even after acknowledging in the academic integrity meeting that I had no intent or knowledge of it. How to proceed? How aggressive should I be in my appeal?

2 Upvotes

A friend I've known for years copied my work without my knowledge and turned it in. We've previously shared work with each other and used it to bounce ideas and get a better understanding of the teachings, and they've never copied my work before. The professor has said on multiple occasions that he wants us to work together and share ideas so that we get a better understanding of his class, I understand this is not a free ticket to copy and I trusted my friend not to go behind my back and use my work in a way that would cause issues, because in the 3 years I've known him there's never been any hint of dishonesty. Were both a bit socially...challenged...so we've always just texted it to each other and then texted back and forth about any points of interest or disagreements between our understandings of the problems. In my mind this is the same as if we were to swap printed copies to look over for a few minutes, I wouldn't send my HW to just a random peer in class, this was a trusted friend.

I was emailed with a form about academic integrity and had to set up a meeting with a facilitator and the professor. I was confident that I wasn't going to be in any trouble because I had strictly pure intentions and reading stories of other people with the same problem it was sorted out and they did not receive violations. In the meeting I was open, honest, and as uncomfortable as it was, I threw my friend under the bus like he deserved. I still received a violation on my permanent record because the professor was "following the policy" that I quote in my appeal letter below, and specifically said that I should only "guide" my peers through any issues they have.

I am hoping to get some feedback on my appeal letter, and what other actions i can take to make sure my appeal is taken seriously. Am i being too aggressive? Or even am I completely out of line with my interpretation of the policies. I've redacted the professors name and my university name. The letter:

""

The statement that -Professor- used to justify giving me this violation reads as follows:

“Working on an assignment with others when the instructor asked for individual work. Turning in work that is identical or very similar to others' work. Excessively relying upon and using the ideas and work of others in a group effort.” -Citation to Universities academic integrity policy-

-Professor- specifically pointed to “Turning in work that is identical or very similar to others’ work.” as the reasoning for issuing this violation. I understand -Professor-'s reasoning for giving me the violation, but I do not agree with his interpretation of the policy that is the basis for his reasoning.

My homework was original, as acknowledged by -Professor- himself in the academic integrity meeting. I did not turn in work that is identical or very similar to others’ work. In this context, my work is the “others’ work.” I also submitted the assignment before ever attempting to help my peer, so at the time of submission there was no copy of my work, and I could not have turned in work that is identical. Therefore, the literal interpretation of this section of the academic integrity policy does not agree with the decision to issue me a violation.

-Professor- said in class and again in the academic integrity meeting that he encourages students to discuss and compare their understandings. I was happy to hear this as I enjoy discussing new information and concepts with my peers. The peer that stole my work was one of my closest friends that I’ve known for years, and I never had any reason to suspect that my work was going to be stolen. I would never jeopardize my education and career so that another student could get a free ride on my back, especially for an assignment with such a minimal impact on the overall course. I had no intention to facilitate the copying of my work and had no knowledge that my peer was going to copy my work. Therefore, I believe the decision to issue me a violation does not align with the spiritual interpretation of this section.

If this decision is allowed to stand, I will unfortunately be compelled to no longer attempt to help any of my peers. I believe this reaction to a violation in these circumstances is entirely reasonable, as there is no way for me to know whether a peer will use my work, solution, or partial solution, regardless of the medium I use or the way I try to help, and I will not risk receiving even an admonition, as a second strike would jeopardize my entire education and career.  This is not what the academic integrity policies of -University Name- strive to do. They are intended to uphold the integrity of the university. Issuing a violation against a student who has been betrayed by a trusted friend and was put into such an uncomfortable position, is not upholding the integrity of the university. I believe punishing a student, who had the sole intention of helping their peers understand the teachings, for the careless actions of their peers diminishes the integrity of the university.

""


r/AskProfessors • • May 04 '26

Grading Query Forgot to submit my final assignment....am I cooked?

0 Upvotes

My final project for a class was due at 11:59pm on Friday. I uploaded it to Brightspace on Friday afternoon well in advance of the deadline, and it showed 'upload successful', I relaxed for the rest of the weekend believing that my work was submitted. Just a few minutes ago when checking back to look at grades, I made the horrifying discovery that I had forgotten to hit the 'submit' button after uploading the file....so it was never formally submitted. I immediately submitted it for real and sent my professor an apologetic email explaining the situation, but she's very busy this week so I probably won't see the final results until Friday.

I'm freaking out because the course syllabus stated that no late work would be accepted, and the rubric for the final project stated that "If you received a 0% on the final project, you will receive an F for the class." I've had an A in the class up until now, so failing the class over this mistake would be absolutely brutal. I'm told that professors can see a log of uploads in Brightspace even if they weren't submitted, so she should be able to log at the log and see that I did indeed upload it before deadline and just didn't hit 'submit'.

Would you show a student mercy in this situation if the documentation is there?


r/AskProfessors • • Mar 31 '24

Academic Advice Why do professors not give out LoRs?

0 Upvotes

Why is it so hard to get letters of recommendations from professors? I don't mean to brag but I always sat in the front row, I always participate and engage with the professor, I was a straight A student and I never asked any professor for any favors. I emailed a bunch of my professors, that knew me by name and I chatted with them a bit after class, for LoRs. Only 2 professors responded, 1 agreed and the other one said that you should ask a professor who teaches that subject (I applied to a major that I didn't study but is similar but I had not taken any courses for that major for my Undergrad). I used my school email but I emailed them in start of Feb while I graduated last Fall. All the professors I asked were from my last semester and only two from the spring 23 semester. I did get into the program but it was really frustrating and disheartening to know that professors that I thought I had good rapport with, didn't even acknowledge my email.


r/AskProfessors • • Dec 15 '23

General Advice Last semester, one of my college classmates confessed to constantly cheating in another class. How should I have reported him to his professor? What would have likely happened to that cheating student?

4 Upvotes

Hi all. Basically, there seems to be a very difficult required course to graduate for my undergrad degree. In another and unrelated class, our group would constantly be talking about that class. Everyone had the same prof and same class except me because I already took a graduate class that satisfied that course requirement. I would listen to them all complain.

But the strange part is when 1 kid randomly and casually confessed to constantly cheating in the class. He said he couldn't do the assignments anymore. He just started paying some person in another country to do all his assignments for his class. When we heard that, everyone thought it was awesome and funny. Except me.

I was thinking about reporting him to that prof, but I never did because I did not want to get involved with my name and everything to a prof that doesn't even know who I am. I already am constantly stressed out. He has no effect on my life. I thought that if I report him to the prof, the prof would require me to make a statement or something. Would that have likely happened? I thought that student would have likely gotten a F for that course and would have needed to graduate late. Honestly, wouldn't he have gotten expelled for this constant cheating?


r/AskProfessors • • Mar 04 '21

Professional Relationships Is it rude to ask a professor why they won't upload an answer sheet for a test we've already turned in?

0 Upvotes

Title says it all. This test is done and over with, and I'm wanting to compare my missed questions with the correct answers, but after asking the prof. to upload an answer sheet I got a fat no. They did however offer to meet up with me and go over the answers/answer any questions I may have.


r/AskProfessors • • Dec 08 '25

Grading Query Are professors annoyed if asked for a grade bump over a technicality?

0 Upvotes

I just received the grade for my first assignment for my MSc course (62% - UK), and it was heartbreaking. The feedback was not detailed, just a few points, specifically one point about the structure not working. However, before this summative assignment, I received feedback from the formative one, stating that it had a good structure from a different professor, which is why I continued.

I talked to the professor who graded my assignment, and he said, 'feel free to contact the other professor and ask for a grade bump, but not by much; the max it can get is 65'. I felt confident and insecure at the same time about this assignment. According to the final feedback, I violated 2 out of 10 marking criteria, and I got a 38% deduction, which seems unfair and made me feel the need to appeal in general. But at the same time, that will annoy my professors so much, and I want to be on good terms with them. What should I do?