r/AskPhysics • • 44m ago

High school research project: Expert perspectives on the evolution of the Black Hole Information Paradox (1974–2025)

1 Upvotes

Texto del post:

Hello everyone!

I am a 1st-semester high school student working on a research methodology project about the historical evolution and mathematical shifts of the Black Hole Information Paradox—from Hawking’s 1974 semiclassical calculation to recent holographic approaches (2020–2025) like Quantum Extremal Surfaces, Entanglement Islands, and Replica Wormholes.

As part of my methodology, I am collecting perspectives from physics students, researchers, and enthusiasts to contrast the historical literature with the current consensus in the field.

If you have a background in theoretical physics, quantum gravity, or quantum information, I would greatly appreciate it if you could answer my short 9-question survey (it takes under 5 minutes):

🔗 Survey Link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScQpY2T8IOROPXjPMDtb4Bb1EiJooZZWeQ8BuFnWRQK6FAp6w/viewform?usp=dialog

Thank you so much for supporting young students interested in theoretical physics! Any feedback or paper recommendations in the comments are also very welcome


r/AskPhysics • • 2h ago

Light ?? I know nothing abt physics but I have a question

1 Upvotes

Do flashlights and other things that are supposed to light stuff up, actually shine or create light?

I have a very superficial understanding of physics and I was never interested in that stuff, but I was shining my flashlight at night and noticed that when I shine it in a direction with no objects obstructing its light path there was no light. I thought the flashlight was broken at first but when I shined it at something and there was light. This made me wonder if light actually exist, but I think that’s not inappropriate way to phrase it. I’m wondering if light isn’t created by the flashlight and stuff like that light is just something that we perceive from the reflection of whatever the flashlight’s doing to my understanding light is what’s being reflected that’s what we can see but whatever the flashlight’s doing, you don’t see it if it’s not reflecting off anything. Reminder, I’m somewhat incompetent in this field so everything I just said is based off my guess of how things work and some high school physics that i didnt pay attention to.
I now realize this isn’t an actual question but any responses that could explain my experience or dive deeper into the concept are appreciated and the reason I chose Reddit is I don’t feel like researching through a bunch of sources or talking to ChatGPT and receiving invalid info.


r/AskPhysics • • 3h ago

ap physics 1

2 Upvotes

hi everyone! i’m currently taking ap physics 1 and i have a two-day test (one day mcq and the other is frq) coming up this week. it’s on unit 2.

im not great on the tests, and my teacher doesn’t teach well. she just compensates with crazy curves, but i actually want to get a good raw score.

do you guys have any good textbook recommendations to learn? or is a textbook not even good for learning ap physics 1? i watch videos and do ap classroom practice questions but there were questions where i didnt know how to do in every single assessment that i’ve done no matter how much i studied.

thanks!!


r/AskPhysics • • 4h ago

Theory of Relativity question

0 Upvotes

Why does time move slower for someone moving near the speed of light compared to a stationary guy? So this would mean someone elses present is another guys future. Therefore, would that mean, if we go far enough away from our galaxy and looked back, we could see the totality of humanity depending on ur distance? So... since past, future and present exist as one, does that mean the end of the universe has already happened and technically were all dead 😭

So, the universe decided our whole fate in this one pre-written movie but why is it we can only see the past and not the future??

Edit - I'm reading everyones replies but because i'm not very smart myself, its taking a while to understand.


r/AskPhysics • • 5h ago

What would happen if you somehow quantum tunneled your entire body into a wall or other solid object?

0 Upvotes

I understand the odds of it ever happening with large objects is so incredibly low that for all intents and purposes it’s impossible and will never happen.

What I’m curious about is, if it did, what even happens next?


r/AskPhysics • • 6h ago

Gravity or time. Does either come first?

3 Upvotes

Another way to ask might be to say which initiates the other? When I think about it I keep going back and forth about whether one could exist without the other.


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

Undergraduate project: measuring laser beam waists using the knife-edge method

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'd like to share a small project I worked on during my undergraduate studies.

We built an automated setup to measure laser beam waists using the knife-edge method, combining a Thorlabs translation stage, an ESP32, an optical power meter, and custom electronics.

We tested two lasers and obtained the following beam waist measurements:

  • Diode laser: 9.8 µm

  • HeNe laser: 30.8 µm

I also developed Python scripts for data acquisition and analysis. I've uploaded the code, experimental data, PCB designs, and project report to GitHub:

https://github.com/turtushig22-blip/thorlabs-esp32-laser-beam-profiler

It was a learning experience, and I'm sure there are things we could improve. I thought I'd share it in case anyone finds it useful or has suggestions.

I'd appreciate any feedback!

Thanks for reading!


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

What's the legitimacy of the reference with respect to which quantum correlations are catagorized and measured?

2 Upvotes

For anti-correlated entangled particles and correlated entangled particles over long distances when measured the correlations are reported as its already established in quantum physics but how would the relative orientation of two externally chosen axis be valid for the measurement unless we have a proper common reference frame.

How can we confidently classify the outcomes as matching or opposite if the physical equivalence of the reference orientations at the two locations has not itself been established?

What provides the physical foundation for this comparison?


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

How might alternative analogues to light be perceived by humans?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Dear smart people, please give me your wisdom.


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

The Sun’s Gravitational Pull

4 Upvotes

If we had a single grain of sand statically placed the same distance from the Sun as the center of Earth… Removing all other factors from the Solar System, Galaxy, Universe… It’s just an unmoving Sun and a single grain of sand with no speed/velocity of its own… How long would it take for that grain of sand to “fall” into the sun due to gravity alone?


r/AskPhysics • • 8h ago

If electrons are negatively charged and atomic nuclei are positively charged, why don't electrons fall into the nucleus?

152 Upvotes

We know that opposite electric charges attract each other. So why doesn't the electron simply collapse into the positively charged nucleus?

What keeps atoms stable? Is it quantum mechanics, the uncertainty principle, or something else?

I've always found this fascinating and would love to hear different explanations!


r/AskPhysics • • 8h ago

Im really frustrated and restless that we are unable to figure out and know the origins or back story or meaning behind such a vast universes existence - Will I never be able to get any closure on this in my lifetime?

0 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • 8h ago

Double major in Physics and Marhematics vs. Double major in Physics and Chemistry

4 Upvotes

Which option will give me a deeper, more thorough understanding of “reality“, life and the universe?


r/AskPhysics • • 9h ago

Ferrari fire in cornfield

0 Upvotes

Hey, so i just saw a video online where a dude drove ferrari on a cornfield and stopped and it caught fire?

Could it have been prevented if he just slowed down and drove off the field? https://www.reddit.com/r/thatsdamninteresting/s/gouHTscE35


r/AskPhysics • • 10h ago

On some incredibly small level, is all matter teleporting?

1 Upvotes

Zeno’s paradox states for an object to move any distance, it first has to go half that distance and then another half, but suddenly half that distance became the goal so another half(1/8th of the original goal) and half and half again, which means an object should never be able to travel anywhere, but obviously we can move and stuff so that has to mean we’d be teleporting right? Even in some astronomically small scale

But that’d be traveling a distance(X) over a 0 second time gap and x/0 is infinity so collisions would end the world or something, but that’s not the case so I don’t get it


r/AskPhysics • • 10h ago

At the micro-level, why does increasing the moment arm length lead to increased torque, all else being equal?

0 Upvotes

Please do not give a macro-level response (e.g., derivation of conservation laws for a large system). I am very well aware of the conservation laws and have derived them a million different ways in college starting from first principles.

What I am looking for is that visceral understanding at the atomic or quantum level for why length directly correlates with increased torque. I have just accepted the fact as a good physics soldier, but I have never truly understood why the torque equation works at a fundamental level. It seems like black magic.

Update:
Thank you to u/ipokethemonfast. The paper below is exactly what I was looking for.

https://scholarship.haverford.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1494&context=physics_facpubs


r/AskPhysics • • 13h ago

Gamma-ray detection: FWHM issue

1 Upvotes

Hello,

Me and my lab partner have been looking through countless sources trying to figure out how a sodium iodide scintillator (and the photomultiplier) works. We have been doing a Compton Scattering lab and one of the main concepts that we must know is how the detector works.

One of the main issues we've been having is regarding the FWHM. Some sources say that the FWHM must decrease; others say the opposite. This has made us even more confused than before. Can someone help explain what's going on here?

(From our data, the FWHM is larger for higher energy photons than lower energy photons. Our lab demonstrator said that the opposite must be the case due to the number of photons created in the scintillator being Poisson distributed).

Thank you! :)


r/AskPhysics • • 13h ago

How can the CERN (and all parcticle accelerators) follow the law of conservation?

1 Upvotes

Like how can the elemental parcticles inside the atoms not get decomposed in always the same parcticles? Or am I undestanding it wrong?


r/AskPhysics • • 13h ago

Compression of atoms

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • 13h ago

Compression of atoms

2 Upvotes

So we all know that you can compress gases and liquids to an extent, but I was thinking about repelling atomic forces and how two objects never actually touch and it dawned on me that if atoms between 2 physical bodies never touch and if I drop a bowling ball from a skyscrapper the hole in the ground is due to an impact, at the point of impact between to solids to the internals of an atom compress?


r/AskPhysics • • 14h ago

Would rearranging my bed's angle stop it from moving in the direction of the mechanical humping waves produced by my housemate in his room? NSFW

211 Upvotes

My housemate in the room in front of mine humps girls aggressively, and it shakes my bed back and forth along the longitudinal axis.

Here's the bird's eye view(the brackets are the beds and their orientations):

His room, his bed: [ ], humping ⬆️⬇️

Hallway

My room, my bed: [ ], I am moving ⬆️⬇️ as I'm lying on my bed

Would rearranging my bed with an angle stop it from moving in the direction of the humps? If so, what is the optimal angle to not feel like it's happening on my own bed?

For example:

[ ]

/ /

Or

[ ]

🛏


r/AskPhysics • • 16h ago

What do you understand by exact numerical methods in Open quantum dynamics?

2 Upvotes

I will start a project in this area but the "exact numerical methods" confesses me.
Does it means exact diagonalization? or just a methods with controllable error?
What does it mean exact numerical methods
Also, could you comment me which ones are the most use in open quantum dynamics?


r/AskPhysics • • 17h ago

if Earth was 12X bigger would we see farther objects?

0 Upvotes

as far as i know since the earth is a big ball (or a geode) far objects disappear bc they like go on the other side of the ball or smth like that (the surface appear flat aslong as its big enough)
so does that mean a bigger ball gives more sight?
and also does our eyes have sight limit?


r/AskPhysics • • 18h ago

I have a question about the universe that i cant figure out

0 Upvotes

So with the universe, it technically cant be infininite, becuase there has to be an end at some point, orelse it would eventuall collapse on itself, whereas if it did have an ending, it physically couldnt just stop, there would have to be something past the stoppign point, there cant just be nothingness, and if it were soemthing tha just repeats against itself, that would make it some sort of loop, but there would have to be skmething bast the loop, like if you draw an oval, you would go round and round, seein everything repeat, but if you stepped up while i curved down, you would leave the oval, and theoretically it was a forth dimensional peice of matter, it would require some sort of 4th or 5th dimensional being to elscape he universe, but then past tha if it were something else similar to out universe but in a dimension up, wouldnt hat just make it an infinite loop of realitys, always stepping up a dimension, making it infinite, with an infinite amou of dimensions, wich would mav most likely collapsed by now... im genuinely confused out of my mind and couldnt find an answer tha had no undeniability whatsoever, i need some help here