r/AskPhysics • u/Zestyclose-Town-4876 • 1d ago
1% INCREASE or DECREASE in friction - which would be worse for humanity short-term and long-term?
Hypothetical, magical 1% change in friction - what happens immediately and what's the long-term outlook?
8
u/Mortal4789 1d ago
im not sure where friction starts and stops, if its not relevant to DNA its defiantly relevant to organelles upwards. blood flow in particular might have some issues as friction is the main thing your heart beats against. so you might find your getting 1% less / more oxygen in every breath etc.
so i think both bad, they disrupt and equilibrium your biochemistry is highly tuned towards, resulting in fairly rapid death
6
u/cman674 Chemistry 1d ago
I’m just a humble chemist (not a biochemist) but I think this could be a major issue on the molecular scale. Fundamentally friction is based on electronic interactions so an increase (or decrease) in friction would likely mean something like the charge of fundamental particles or a change of the coloumb constant. Not sure if that would be a big issue or not for biological processes.
2
1
u/GreenFBI2EB 23h ago
Depends, do you want natural disasters to be worse, or human disasters to be worse?
Hurricanes/Tropical cyclones' wind speeds will slow down a tad when they interact with land due to friction. So, a landfalling hurricane would actually decrease in intensity somewhat slower. This also means that it would be easier to destroy a house by said hurricane.
On the opposite end, the breaks on your car work using friction. So, a decrease in friction means it would be harder to break. Likewise, an increase in friction would be just as bad, as others pointed out, you'd have to deal with things like more lubrication on machinery because friction would mean you'd need more energy to move a turbine.
1
u/PotentialDeep5165 1d ago
Between what?
1
u/imokay4747 1d ago
Everything
-2
u/PotentialDeep5165 1d ago
So you're adjusting the electrostatic forces of the outer most electrons in everything.. allowing electrons to be stripped "more easily" such that bonding by touching is reduced.
You need to take your macroscopic considerations to the microscopic levels to think about further ramifications and then look at the larger picture.
3
u/HasFiveVowels 1d ago
There’s one guy in every thread that just doesn’t get the assignment
-3
u/PotentialDeep5165 1d ago
Meh. It's too simplistic of a question without thinking thru consequences on the OP. Provide some specifics of the physics and we can look at the math.
4
u/HasFiveVowels 1d ago
Yes. It was a simplistic question. What you should’ve done is just interpreted their question as "reduce mu by 1% in classical physics… what happens?" not "attempt to modify the standard model in such a way that creates such a change". Responding with "you can’t" is the least interesting way you could’ve possibly responded. Doing so is not "the height of intellectual rigor"; it’s just pedantic and boring.
1
u/PotentialDeep5165 1d ago
I didn't say you can't. Mu is a macroscopic averaging -- my point was for op to consider deeper into what goes into mu --friction is not a fundamental force; think deeper about what the real question is asking with regard to fundamentals.
If you don't understand fundamentals then you don't have much of a chance at recognizing impact of macroscopic factors.
Consider if this were optics and dielectric response. Sure, simplistic variance is one thing (Snells law) but you miss out on understanding dispersion and other phenomena. There are relation and equations for understanding at a deeper level. Friction with mu is not.
Keep on striving for solid understanding. It's worth it.
1
u/HasFiveVowels 1d ago
Again, even after having it spelled out, you’re missing the point. But hey, at least you’re technically correct.
-1
u/PotentialDeep5165 1d ago
Hahaha.
Keep matriculating.
And may your social skills improve with time.
2
u/HasFiveVowels 1d ago
I graduated quite some time ago. I’ll try to follow in your footsteps, though. I’m going to go watch an action movie and loudly say "that would never happen!!" at everything that isn’t perfectly coherent with particle physics. Give me a break.
→ More replies (0)1
1
-2
u/damarian_ent 1d ago
Decrease. A decrease in friction would mean atoms are less likely to hold together to form our current reality. Bonds would fail
5
u/Mcgibbleduck Education and outreach 1d ago
In FRICTION?
Bonding isnt explicable due to friction, is it? Am I crazy?
Friction is a macroscopic effect, is it not?
4
u/joeyneilsen Astrophysics 1d ago
No, friction is at least partly the force required to break bonds that form between molecular bumps on surfaces pressed together.
1
u/Mcgibbleduck Education and outreach 21h ago
That makes more sense, I get that. Atomic bonding has naught to do with it since it’s the strong interaction.
But friction as a phenomenon is emergent.
0
u/Thick_Wasabi448 1d ago
Tbf, they specified atoms and not molecules.
2
1
2
u/imokay4747 1d ago
I don't think a 1% decrease in static friction would affect most if not all molecular bonds unless it's already a very unstable material. Otherwise introducing non static friction would crumble the material as it already stands today. So we'd see avalanches and rock slides because those are carefully balanced already but the static friction that holds things together would largely be unnoticeable
1
u/FuzzyAttitude_ 1d ago
1%?? Is it really so fatal?
0
u/damarian_ent 1d ago
1% would affect our casual classical view of things less, but at the smallest levels, that 1% affects smaller things substantially more.
1
u/mikk0384 Physics enthusiast 1d ago edited 1d ago
Friction has basically nothing to do with chemical bonds in that way.
3
u/Traveller9536 1d ago •
![]()
Both are due to electronic effects, so a change in one would probably change the other
0
1d ago
[deleted]
3
u/llllxeallll 1d ago
A change in either direction would lead to DNA replication being unpredictably altered. Most living things would have, at minimum, an adjustment period.
1
31
u/gathmoon 1d ago
Increase is way worse imo. Energy costs go up movement is harder. Things break down faster.