r/AskLegal • • Apr 21 '25

Abrego Garcia 2019 Ruling?

0 Upvotes

Can anyone, and I repeat ANYONE provide me with the 2019 ruling where an immigration judge granted him a temporary order to not deport?

Why has this not circulated? People continue to claim he was given “due process” but can’t manifest those court documents either. I’m sure they’re referring to his 2019 hearing where I have seen what appears to be an ICE intake form that alleges his bulls hat and money sweatshirt make him part of a gang. But hilariously also fails to indicate he has gang tattoos as the administration claims now. This is such a legal nightmare led by a petulant child.


r/AskLegal • • Apr 18 '25

Regarding the Kilmar deportation fiasco

43 Upvotes

Much of the controversy around this man's deportation to El Salvador seems to focus on his qualities as a person. However a few facts remain:

  • He was "accidentally" (and illegally) sent to El Salvador as a result of an administrative error, and this was done without due process. The POTUS admits this.

  • He has never officially been convicted of a crime

  • The current administration has been ordered by the court to retrieve him, and are more or less ignoring the courts.

I think I understand all of this. However hasn't it been confirmed that he was undocumented and living in the US as an illegal alien? How can you "wrongfully" deport someone if they're not even supposed to be in the country to begin with? Is the issue that even undocumented/"illegal" people need a full court case before being deported?

Edit: I'm just trying to figure out what's going on. Looks like I really kicked a hornets nest here.


r/AskLegal • • Jul 07 '26

Just got a ticket as a minor

3 Upvotes

Just received my first ever ticket as a 16 year old the day before I turn 17, I live in Texas and the cop was unclear of wether or not I have to attend court or if I can just pay online, I was going 44 in a 40(still don’t understand why I didn’t get a warning since this is also my first offense but it’s whatever). I know this is only a minor speeding incident and am really hoping I don’t have to actually attend court


r/AskLegal • • Feb 01 '25

What are legal strategies we common folk can we do to save our country

0 Upvotes

The constant barrage of what I see is horrifying. I love this country and what great it has been able to create to the world. It feels like our Congress is doing nothing. A lot of laws and protections come from lawsuits right? Like landmark Supreme Court cases? So is there a way we the people can file some type of lawsuit to do something? Anything? What are legal strategies the common person can do to protect our country? I know lawyers can get expensive but idk is there maybe a common people fund someone can muster to do something? The people we relied on are deep in the pockets of these tech billionaires and aren’t doing their congressional power to do anything. So what can we the common folk do?


r/AskLegal • • Apr 21 '26

Can a landlord really decide one of two ESA pets doesn't count and charge fees for it?

0 Upvotes

When a letter mentions both animals and the landlord still comes back saying one doesn't count and is subject to pet fees and the regular pet policy... that's a gutting thing to deal with, especially when those animals have been a real support system. The FHA doesn't cap the number of animals in a household, so what legal ground is the landlord actually standing on here? Has anyone navigated this and found a way through it ?


r/AskLegal • • Apr 27 '25

Should my wife be worried about deportation?

0 Upvotes

How close are we to seeing recent naturalizations under Biden revoked? My wife got naturalized right before Trump's inauguration. She's a citizen of the UK but was born in an asian country and has that on her UK passport. She's had trouble getting her updated drivers license because every DMV so far doesn't "do that type of license here". It seems like naturalization puts you in an "other" citizenship category. I'm curious if there is any way for the current administration to revoke citizenship under this category.


r/AskLegal • • Jul 08 '25

Shouldn't the new Medicaid work requirements under the "One Big Beautiful Bill" be considered unconstitutional, because, they force states to make their residents work for benefits?

0 Upvotes

Regarding one's personal opinion towards the work requirements, I'm just asking whether or not the Trump/Vance administration has the legal authority to force states to make their residents work, volunteer, or, attend school. I'm already exempt from the work requirements due to proliferative diabetic retinopathy with macular edema (a complication from diabetes) and severe OCD, but, I just think work requirements for Medicaid is (or at-least should be) unconstitutional.

In 2012 when SCOTUS struck down the ACA's mandatory Medicaid expansion, because, the ACA wanted to force states to expand their Medicaid program, wouldn't the new Medicaid work requirements violate that same law, but, just on the opposite side of the coin?

Legally, they probably would have had more success allowing or even incentivizing states to put work requirements instead of forcing them to.

In 2019, the work requirements in AK and NH got struck down and that was when Trump was still in office.


r/AskLegal • • Nov 11 '25

[US] Why are monetary penalties that can deprive a defendant of the ability to feed, clothe, shelter, and obtain life saving healthcare for themselves (just as important to one’s life and liberty as not being imprisoned), allowed as the result of civil trials instead of only criminal trials?

0 Upvotes

Is there a theoretical way that this could be changed to only being allowed as the result of criminal trials?

Regardless of how unlikely it would be to succeed, what could this process look like?


r/AskLegal • • Oct 15 '26

Want dad out of our life.

4 Upvotes

My dad (70M) currently lives with my sibling. Dad is mostly wheelchair bound and relies on me for transport to/from medical appts (every few weeks, over 100 miles round trip + hours of my time).

Dad was supposed to be paying rent to Sibling for living there, but contributes literally nothing - no bills, no cleaning, no groceries, nothing but a leech. He has said repeatedly he is working on moving out but has made no efforts at all to. I know because I have Power of Attorney and have access to most all of his finances, and pay for his phone.

He has received over a quarter million over the years from his dad (grandpa) and likely never paid taxes on them. He often sends money to randoms he meets on the internet / his girlfriends over the years (this has been an ongoing thing since like 2009). Completely financially inept and just a burden on all of us - never takes accountability for anything.

I honestly just want him out of our life. What are my options? Make him a ward of the state? Get full legal guardianship over him? Report him to the IRS? Kick him out of the house and let him figure it out on his own? I think the eviction process may be super stressful for everyone and not worth it if we're just forced to take him back.


r/AskLegal • • Feb 26 '25

Can US tax payers file a class action suit against Musk?

0 Upvotes

He's basically taking our money by first creating chaos at the FAA, then turning around and forcing them to use his Starlink system. He can afford to pay a modest one thousand dollars to every person in the US and still technically be a billionaire (Musk worth $379B, US population 340M, I know it's all theoretical and not piles of cash though.)


r/AskLegal • • Feb 08 '26

Do I have the right to refuse service as a regular clerk?

0 Upvotes

So I’m at my first job right now, and yesterday, something happened that really threw me off. I just serve ice cream. That’s about it. But yesterday, a guy came in with a sweater that had the Totenkopf skull embroidered. The skull in question had sunglasses on with the SS design on them. He had Nazi tattoos all over his neck and arms. I’m so serious when I say that it took everything in me not to spit in his food. I could have just left it at that, but then, his kids followed him in. I couldn’t stand the idea that someone like that was allowed to have children. I asked my manager what to do in that situation, because I could not in good conscience serve a person like that again. She said that I should just get her if anything like that happened again, but I’m a shift lead, so often times it’s just me there. There has also been increased Gaiter Gestapo presence (ICE) in my town recently, and if they ever show up to my counter, I *can not* serve them. What can I, as a run of the mill shift lead, legally do in that situation? Am I allowed, especially if I fear for my safety, to just kick them out?

edit: are you guys seriously getting your panties in a twist because some stranger minimum wage ice cream scooper on the internet who you will never eat had the *nerve* to not want to give I’ve cream to Nazis? Like not to sound like a draft-dodging troglodyte, but do you hear yourselves? You act like it’s some personal transgression that I don’t want to serve actual Nazis. What would you do? Would you just go “here’s your change! All hail ze great führer!” Would you tell your kids years down the line that you gladly gave business to the worst kind of people at a job that paid you 12 dollars an hour? Really? Go get a life, or at least be sweaty somewhere else. Don’t you have better things to do? Or is your only contribution to society being maidenless on the internet berating minimum wage teenagers for having a shred of a moral compass? all I did was ask a question. what do you think you’re accomplishing here? did you expect to change my mind? cuz I’m guessing you didn’t. you are saying these things with the knowledge that the only thing that will come from that is more bitching. that is the only thing you’re accomplishing, and you knew that. that’s how you’re choosing to spend your free time. Not doing something for the benefit of your fellow humans; just causing problems on purpose with no reward other than making yourself angrier. Do you like it? Do you like making your life miserable on purpose? Or do you feel like you’ve accomplished something? I can’t tell what’s sadder; a cave-dwelling incel spending their life making a little petty comment on every small thing that catches their attention, or a wage slave who wastes what little free time they have on Reddit making absolutely no difference to a question they never intended in answering/knew the answer to.


r/AskLegal • • Oct 16 '25

Did Mike Johnson just ADMIT to being an Antifa Terrorist?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

[Speaker Cites Antifascist Ideals and Acts by Republican Party]


r/AskLegal • • Jan 25 '25

What kind of legal issues is Anthony Fauci potentially facing?

47 Upvotes

Delete if not allowed

With the recent Presidential Pardon, what are the potential legal battles Dr. Anthony Fauci could face? Not looking for a political debate; just legal opinions.


r/AskLegal • • 6d ago

Is this legit, or is our apartment manager making a threat?

Post image
0 Upvotes

For reference, we have a small compartment under our mailboxes. We occasionally leave lost items here for other people in the building, but usually it's empty. When this sign went up there was a single piece of junk mail there.

I would also like to mention i got my mail today at 3pm and this was not there. We went to walk the dogs at 7pm and it was there.

The apartment manager does send us notices constantly about small things, almost feeling vindictive at times. Telling us to clean off our patio when there's anything other than a chair outside, telling us where we are and aren't allowed to walk our dogs. She put a tow notice on my neighbors car earlier this week for "impoper parking" after they got into it about walking her dog near the office.

Im just trying to figure out if this is another one of her threats, or if it is actually usps? And how can we keep our mailboxes being delivered if the compartment is nearly always clear?


r/AskLegal • • Apr 27 '25

Should my wife stay in the country?

0 Upvotes

My wife from Ukraine always meets her family during the summer always in another country since the war. She came here the correct way, she has a green card that expired but has a letter extension for 2 years also has a us drivers license and a us passport. I tell her not to go this year.


r/AskLegal • • Sep 17 '25

May the federal government encourage firings for speech?

0 Upvotes

May the United States federal government, under the First Amendment, encourage, incentivize, or coerce an employer to fire an employee that the federal government didn’t enjoy?

I understand that it is well-established law that if your employer doesn’t enjoy your speech, even political speech, they may fire you for it, if they want to. And that is not the question I am asking.

I’m not sure if there is any established law about how deeply the federal government may or may not participate in that process.

There was a similar era in history that may have spawned some case law about this. But I’m not a legal scholar (my college was in history and journalism; legal-adjacent). In the early 1950s, during the time of McCarthysim, the federal government encouraged employers to fire and “blacklist” people accused of being communists, particularly in the filmmaking industry. Perhaps some case law rose out of that?

I would be interested to know the cases that are most relevant here.


r/AskLegal • • Jan 13 '26

Impeding ICE arrests

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen people legally observing/recording ICE arrests where the agents: don’t identify themselves, have their faces covered, and are in “uniforms” that could easily be put together by anyone in proximity to a military surplus store. The recordings aren’t useless, but they’re not stopping people from getting snatched off the street.

The advice I see given is to not interfere with the arrest, to just record it. The thing is, if they don’t identify themselves as law enforcement, how would witnesses be able to tell they weren’t just a group of masked men kidnapping someone off the street? And would it not be reasonable for citizens to intervene, physically if necessary, to stop such an act?

If someone were to try to prevent a kidnapping by a group of masked men, guys with no badges or warrants, and they got arrested for impeding an arrest, would most courts just drop the case?


r/AskLegal • • Dec 21 '25

Would this constitute a crime? Is it illegal for the bird to steal, or are only humans held accountable? And if it isn't a crime for the bird to take the sandwich, is it a crime for the person who opens the door to let it out with it? What would a charge be if you're not aiding in a crime?

0 Upvotes

r/AskLegal • • Feb 14 '26

Is there a reason for the Epstein files to have names redacted?

0 Upvotes

I’m not a lawyer so this is a legitimate question:

Is there a reason that they could not release the names of the people named in the emails? For example, because it would cause an impartial jury and therefore be unable to guarantee a fair trial? It seems like nobody is naming names and this is the only reason I feel like anyone could be not doxxing these horrific people is to prevent interfering with an eventual trial.


r/AskLegal • • May 03 '26

[US] Can I sue the government if AI mistakenly determines I'm too drunk to drive, and I can't escape an emergency situation?

0 Upvotes

Drunk driving AIs are 98% accurate. At 242 million drivers in the US, that's 5 million false positives per day. 5 million people who cannot start their cars to go shopping, get to work, seek emergency medical attention (which will likely have a higher false positive rate), go check on their friends and families, etc.

Being able to operate your car will essentially be a lottery system. Unless you've got something that is 99.99999% accurate, you're going to end up killing someone trying to flee an emergency.

Do they, or their families, have a case in court against the government, or the car manufacturer? Because, people in the government are college educated. They should know that 99% of anything is statistically low. Yet they pass legislation requiring the tech.


r/AskLegal • • Jun 10 '25

How to attend strictly peaceful protest and not get caught up if things get violent?

4 Upvotes

I don't want to clash with police or cause any trouble. Just march peacefully with signs. What do I do to not get get caught up in the violence or arrested?


r/AskLegal • • Oct 25 '25

Is there a point where "assault by sound" becomes illegal?

11 Upvotes

I'm seeing these "interview protestors" type videos and often protesters will blow whistles, ring bells and blast megaphones at the interviewer to disrupt them.

Hearing damage is a real thing so is there a point where blasting someone with sounds crosses a threshold of dangerousness to become assault? Is it a decibel level? What's the cut off?


r/AskLegal • • Jul 20 '25

Can Obama sue Trump

0 Upvotes

Why doesn't Obama or Biden for that matter ever sue Trump for making false claims about them? Trump sues everyone under the sun who says anything bad about him. I just don't understand it.


r/AskLegal • • Jun 02 '25

Identification of federal law enforcement

3 Upvotes

My question is being motivated by this recent incident in a town not far from me. Video posted on CNN's youtube page: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/LwTcoc5INlM

Is it true that federal law enforcement officials, like these men, are not required to produce any identification that proves they are, in fact, who they say they are?

Seems like one could reasonably assume your friend was being kidnapped by an armed gang dressed as law enforcement. If one of the people filming decided to get their gun and demand that this gang release their friend, and the law enforcement officers shot and killed that person, then the government's argument would be what? Everyone on site should've just assumed we are who we say we are?