r/AskLawyers • • Dec 05 '24

[CA] My neighbor that tried to kill my whole family has been released from prison and still lives next to us.

2.8k Upvotes

When I was younger, my neighbor kicked our door opened and tried to kill us ( 7 family members) using two knives.(before this incident happened, he was stalking us for months, he knew everything about us) He has now been reléased from prison and lives next to us. We talked to his parole officer but she says there's nothing we can do about it, and we just have to deal it with it or move, but we can't move because it's so expensive here in SoCal. This has really impacted our mental health, my sisters can't sleep at night because they are afraid that he will come in again and I have had extreme paranoia since the day he tried to kill us. I really would like to know if there's something we can do about this, please and thank you


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 03 '24

Does my HR manager have the right to ask about what's in my truck?

2.4k Upvotes

I carry a Smith and Wesson .357 for personal protection. The other day, the HR and my coworker had a brief meeting in the coworkers office. HR manager is not from this state.

We asked her how she was liking it compared to her previous state, and she replied with "I like it here except for all the gun nuts and such." Neither myself nor my coworker responded. "Wait, do you guys carry guns?"

I'm not trying to kick the hornets nest about guns on reddit because that never goes well, but she can't ask if I keep a pistol in my truck, can she?


r/AskLawyers • • Feb 01 '25

[VA] Judge banned me from a federal building for doing my job

2.1k Upvotes

On one of my security shifts in a federal courthouse I heard a Gunshot outside (which happens all the time downtown). I went and checked all of the outside windows and doors and found nothing. Then I went and checked all the cameras and even the recording system to see if I could find anything. I sadly couldn't find the incident since I don't know the camera system that well. This is also recorded on the CCTV system.

I made notes of times and my actions in my daily report. Later during my shift I was checking the higher floors and came across a broken window with a bullet hole in it. I called my direct supervisor to inform him of the situation and that I was going to call our dispatch for a case number.

My supervisor said no and that it was a maintenance issue and not to call dispatch. My supervisor then told me to take pictures and email them to him. Later in the morning I called dispatch and filed and active report to cover my ass.

So the cheif judge got upset with me because I didn't call dispatch when I heard the gun shot. It was explained to her it happens all the time. She got upset and verbally banned me and my supervisor from returning to the Federal courthouse. I have no received anything saying I have been officially trespassed. Is this right? Can she legally do this?

UPDATE! FPS and US Marshals have sided with me against the judge. I'll be going to FLETC to become a federal law enforcement officer. With the recommendation of the FPS regional commander and of course hard work im Just waiting on some on boarding paperwork.


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 11 '24

Put in an anonymous grievance at work, was forced to admit it was me, then was fired

2.0k Upvotes

tl;dr is the title, and the fact I spoke up about my coworker’s sexist activities. Need advice on how to approach this.

Edit for clarification: I worked security, not healthcare. It was the healthcare staff abusing the elderly. It was the men in my department (I was the only woman of 14) that were being sexist.

At this job I witnessed a lot of elder neglect and tried to speak to management about it several different times. After they didn’t address it, I anonymously submitted a grievance I typed up. I did it anonymously specifically because I was afraid of retaliation.

A few days later my director sat down with me and genuinely forced me to admit it was me that submitted the grievance. I tried to tell him multiple times it looked like it was anonymous, but he wouldn’t let up. Once I caved, he told me I should have talked to management (which, again, I tried) because the grievance I put in is required to go to DHEC. (Side note: I followed up with DHEC and it was never sent in.) After this happened, I could feel that there was a some tension between my director and I.

I got fired last week and I, in my personal but quite reasonable belief, think it’s to cover this up, and that I always spoke up when my coworkers were being sexist (I was the only woman in my department of 14 people).

Three questions:

  1. was my director allowed to force me to admit it was me in the first place?

  2. who do I contact regarding the fact I strongly believe it played a part in my termination? Is this considered civil or criminal?

  3. Is this included in the definition of “wrongful termination”? I’m in SC so I know they didn’t have to give me a reason, but they did, and the “reason” they gave me is indisputably not true.


r/AskLawyers • • Jan 29 '25

[DC] How is Trump able to just unilaterally freeze funding on federal programs without an Act of Congress?

1.7k Upvotes

I thought the power of the purse rested with Congress and Congress alone. So how can the President just unilterally freeze the funding that is already approved by Congress in the annual budgets?


r/AskLawyers • • Feb 09 '25

[WI] My employer told me I needed a Doctors note from the emergency room. Not the Urgent care. I'm a little confused.

1.6k Upvotes

Today, my managers told me I was written up for absences that I had a doctors note for. I went to urgent care. Yet they said I needed it from the emergency room. I work at a goodwill.

Update I learned it's a discrimination thing. Because no one else here has been asked to provide a doctor's note from the emergency room. So yeah. I'm quitting this is bullshit and I feel uncomfortable already working here.

Second Update

I went through my policy handbook to see it specifically needed an emergency room doctors note. DOCTOR'S RELEASE Under most circumstances, absences for two (2) or more working days in a row are considered casual absences, and no documentation is required unless Family Medical & Leave Act leave is requested. Absences lasting more than two working days in a row require a doctor's release to return to work. Employees must also submit a request for a ”Personal Leave of Absence” or FMLA for any time off amounting to more than 2 days. Refer to Section 6, pages 7 and 8 If GWINWOH management has reason to believe that the absence due to illness or any other personal reasons are not legitimate, it reserves the right to require a doctor’s release

Third Update

Well. They told me to go home. Due to me crying because I was stressed out. I do not plan to come back. I told them they could terminate me. I'm not comfortable working there at all. One of my managers was always rude to me. I'm done.


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 23 '24

[DE] Is this a HIPPA violation

1.4k Upvotes

My boyfriend recently took his own life. I found him, called 911 and immediately started performing CPR. My neighbors volunteer with the fire dept and one is also an EMS so they heard the call when it went out and came over to ‘assist’. They got there right around the time the medical personnel arrived so they took me into my house while the crew took over CPR. The crew working on him got his pulses back but unfortunately he had an anoxic brain injury. Since he was an organ donor he went on to save 4 other people with his gift of life. I later found out that neighbor (who I haven’t liked since me and my narcissistic ex husband split up) called my ex husband the same night all of this happened and told him what my boyfriend had done and how he did it. I know this wasn’t a hospital setting but is this some form of HIPAA violation? They heard the call and came over so even if they weren’t technically working since they responded to the call can they still be held responsible for divulging this information? My ex husband then went on to tell our kids (ages 9,12, and 14) what my boyfriend had done and how he did it and I never would have given the kids details since he did it in our home and they live with us 5 nights out of 7. I was only going to tell them that he had taken his own life but I wouldn’t have told them how until they were older. Is there anything I can do legally for them doing this? Thank you for the help!

Edit: thank you to everyone who offered advice and provided links, I appreciate you. Some things I would like to clarify:

  1. I have my kids in therapy and got them in immediately after this happened and thankfully they all seem to be doing well with it.

  2. I also started therapy, however the therapist I was seeing specializes in kids and didn’t offer me any helpful insights that my friends hadn’t already given me. Money is tight so I’m not going to keep giving it to her. I asked to stop seeing her and I’m on a waiting list for a therapist that specializes in PTSD because that is what I need. I need help getting the visuals out of my head. I absolutely want help.

  3. For all of the trolls saying my ex deserved to hear this information and that I subjected my kids to this, you truly have awful evil hearts and I feel sorry for you. The man I ‘subjected’ my kids to gave me the kind of love I only ever dreamed about. He was the kindest, most loving, funniest, smart, handy, just incredible all around, he was literally the whole package. Stepped up and acted as a father to my kids, much more so than their actual father did. He was the one that would help with homework and help get them up for school and be there for anything they needed, helped around the house and literally put me on a pedestal. I went from walking on eggshells with a man that would scream at the top of his lungs with spit flying from his mouth at his kids every single day of the week, didn’t matter if it was their birthday or Christmas, he screamed every day to a man that treated us with respect and love. This was completely out of character and no one expected it, not me or his family.

  4. I work in healthcare as a respiratory therapist, (that’s why it was so embarrassing I spelled hipaa wrong and I don’t know what the hell i was thinking, and as a healthcare worker familiar with hipaa I feel it’s a violation but I wanted other opinions) I worked through Covid, I’ve dedicated my life to helping others, literally everyone who knows me will tell you I’m one of the nicest people you’ll ever meet, I literally treat everyone I meet as an equal, so to insinuate that I’m unstable or shouldn’t have my kids, you have no idea what you’re talking about. I’m the one who put my kids in therapy, I pay for their insurance, I never filed for child support because I knew my ex would make the kids suffer and blame it on me. He doesn’t help with their therapy copays because ‘he’d have to cut his cable off’ yet this man makes almost the same amount of money I do except I have the kids 5 nights out of 7 and I pay for their healthcare. With just the cost of groceries and inflation alone, doing all this without child support-i’d say I do a remarkable job supporting my family and trying to maintain their mental health.

  5. This neighbor heard it as an official call because she came over with an AED, but she stayed outside with it until the other personnel arrived, I was doing CPR this whole time. She didn’t tell my ex out of kindness, she did it out of spite because I have made it clear I do not care for her because when my ex and I split she ‘ministered’ to him as a ‘good Christian’ but literally only wanted details to have to gossip about after church on Sundays. Obviously as a narcissist he has never done anything wrong and made me out to be the devil, honestly I don’t care about that, I’m just happy to be away from him and I hate myself every single freaking day for not getting my kids away from him sooner.

  6. In case it comes up, I will be going to file for child support because it’s not fair that I’ve supported the kids for this long and I’m not going to let fear dictate my life anymore. For those that bring it up, yes my late love did help with the bills, my ex felt that he should have to support our kids instead of him since he was the one living with them (absolutely ridiculous and irresponsible but whatever), but I am going to hold him accountable now and yes I should have years ago and yes I hate myself for this as well but if you’ve never been traumatized by someone than you have no cause to speak on what emotional abuse can do to you.

  7. I would normally never do a Karen thing such as pursuing a lawsuit but there’s no doubt in my mind this woman shared this information out of spite. Her and my ex combined hurt my kids and this has brought out the mama bear in me and that’s why I’m considering it now and why I’m absolutely going to file for child support. I don’t care to fight for myself but if you mess with my family then I take action and I’ve been like that since I was a kid. I tried to be kind because I truly try to live by the golden rule and treat everyone as I wish to be treated but my ex no longer deserves any kindness nor does she.


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 09 '24

What rights does a spouse have if you die 10 years separated, but not divorced?

1.4k Upvotes

My boyfriend or 8 years died last week, and his family abruptly changed the locks on his apartment (we didn't live together), and cut off communication with me "until the matter of who is the executor has been settled". I know that he didn't have a will, and just assumed that his mom would handle the estate, and that everything would go to his daughter. I don't have any intention of trying to get control or take anything from his daughter. There are some things of his I would like to have, but I would offer to buy them from the estate, and only if his daughter didn't want them.

The only thing I can think of is that his wife is trying to get control of the estate. They've been separated for 10 years, but the divorce was never finalized, because she refused to pay her part of the court costs, and my bf was too stubborn to pay them for her. (She initiated the separation and filed for the divorce.)

Would she be able to take over as administrator of the estate, since they're still actually married? We're in New York State.

ETA: This only affects me since I would like to buy some of the paintings he made and some of the things we bought together. I know I don't have any legal rights, but his mom would probably let me have some things; whereas I'm scared his wife would not.


r/AskLawyers • • Feb 08 '25

[US] Elon.. this can't be legal right? I feel like I'm the crazy one here.

1.4k Upvotes

So Elon hiring armed Paramilitary members to keep Congress members outside of their own government buildings... that can't be legal right??


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 07 '24

FL Charter School blocked me from taking my kid to medical appointment.

1.3k Upvotes

My child was waitlisted for an important medical appointment, I was called from the provider last minute. I called the school prior to notify I was on the way to pickup my kid, but the line was busy as usual. I went in thru office to pickup my kid (was about 2:13pm), the rep. at front office started raising her voice when I was trying to explain the circumstances since she said I was too late to pick her up in the office. The Dean of Students, was there with staff, looked at me and decided to completely ignore me, disregard my request and left without even addressing me directly which was so disrespectful. I was told to go through the car line instead which is the method to pickup children at the school. The problem is the car line takes about 30-45min. My kid ended up loosing the medical appointment. My kid was blocked from receiving medical care because this staff says the 2:00pm checkout rule "is their law". If I go to the school to pickup my child early it's because it's an important matter and they had the audacity to block me from giving me my child. The staff are known for behaving very arrogant, cruel, cold and unprofessional towards parents.

Is it illegal for a child to be held by the school and not be given to their parent when they request it?


r/AskLawyers • • Jan 22 '25

[FL] My 16 year old divorce order gave my wife the house and me 1/2 of the future proceeds/appraisal if it was ever sold or transferred out of her sole name. She died and her surviving spouse is claiming over the phone the home is exempt from my probate claim due to homestead laws. Is this true?

1.3k Upvotes

Hi Reddit, The surviving spouse is handling the estate. The divorce decree specifically provides that if the home is ever sold, transferred, or bequeathed out of my ex-wife’s name, I am entitled to 1/2 of the proceeds of the sale or the appraised value if it is not sold. I called my ex-wife’s surviving spouse, who I am usually on good terms with, and he expressed to me my claim is not allowable because the house is his homestead. Is this true? Wanted some insight before I hire an attorney. Do I need to file a lien along with the probate claim?Thank you.


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 11 '24

My husband is already married!

1.3k Upvotes

I left my abusive husband after 3.5 years of trying to make it work, I couldn’t take it anymore and escaped. I filed and was granted a protection order for domestic violence/stalking. Three weeks later I received a letter from his lawyer informing me that he has legally been married since 2006, which makes our marriage void. I gave him everything and by the time i left I had nothing. He had my car repossessed because he was angry with me. I had no access to money. It also turned out that “our house” actually belongs to his father. He hides money and dresses like he’s poor so he can manipulate people. He is an IT Director and works for an upscale non profit. He makes close to 100k a year and barely has bills. I live in a basement and I’m 3 months behind on rent because I have to work 60 hour weeks just to make $800. His father was a MA state trooper and he was NYPD. He has gotten away with assault and battery, menacing with intent to harm, fights, speeding, car accidents, debts, etc. He used his connection with law enforcement and relationship with police in our small town to intimidate me so I never called for help when he was scaring me.

I have court coming up, my lawyer (I don’t have much faith in) told me that I should just agree to the annulment if he takes responsibility for the total debt of the repossessed car. My credit is ruined now. He controlled all the finances and I was never able to pay any of my bills either.

My question is: What are my options to hold him accountable for anything? Do I have to just accept it and let him continue on like he “didn’t even know he was still married”?

PLEASE HELP!


r/AskLawyers • • Feb 28 '24

I was caught having sex in my car years ago, but I got a warning. Is that recorded?

1.2k Upvotes

I'm in the fire academy and I've been told that there's a background check in the hiring process that gets pretty intense.

A 3-4 years prior, I hooked up with a girl in my car. It was night time, and we were in what I thought was a very off-grid kinda area. Well, luck would have it a cop rolls in and caught us.

We hand over our IDs, we both were of age, we were sober, nothing illegal in the vehicle.

Cop ran our names in the system, didn't find any warrants. Ended up giving us a warning and told us to scram.

Now honestly I didn't think anything of it, I wasn't charged, I don't believe it would ever haunt me. But from Stories I hear from firemen about their background checks they really go in deep into your history and find whatever your name is attached too, no stone unturned.

What are the chances this incident will pop up for me?


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 13 '24

Should I be worried

1.2k Upvotes

I

Hello. I own a business where a customer dropped off an item to see about getting repaired that broke. We left a voicemail for the customer that it is not repairable and is too damaged. We never heard back and tried calling again 30 days later.

Customer never called or came to pick up their item. We discarded the item 14 months later.

She just came in last week after 19 months asking to pick up the item. She is now threatening to sue us.

The client never paid for a repair as it wasn’t fixable. Also our tickets/ receipts say not responsible for items left over 30 days as well as we have a visible sign posted on the store.

Should I be concerned? Or am I correct to think it’s absolutely crazy she expects us to still have her beyond repair item after 19 months in which she abandoned it.

Thank you for your input.


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 19 '24

[MN] Police charging a "discovery" fee of $30 to get a dash cam vid - can they do that?

1.2k Upvotes

I allegedly rolled a stop sign (I don't think I did), got a ticket, requested the video of me doing it, and got a response that says: we can't release the video unless you choose to get a lawyer or represent yourself, and if that's the case you request the video as part of discovery with a fee of $30.

It feels odd that they can withhold the video unless you pay, so I'm just wondering if that's true?

It honestly wouldn't surprise me, but it would be a fucked up system. I just want to see if I actually did what you are accusing me of, and if so I'll pay the ticket and move on. If I didn't, then drop the case and move on. Don't jerk me around for an extra $30 just to figure it out


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 27 '24

[NJ] I was hired as a salaried employee, but get deducted money out of pay for every minute late regardless of total weekly hours worked

1.2k Upvotes

New Jersey, employer hired me years ago salaried, employment contract listed compensation as $xx,xxxx per year. Employees still have to clock in and out at a time clock, as well as in and out for lunch daily (45 mins).

The problem is their policy regarding lates and compensation, regardless if I work 40, 50, or even 60 hours in a week, if we clock in after 9am, out before 5:30pm, or take any additional time for lunch longer than exactly 45 mins, our pay gets deducted those minutes. There have been payrolls where my pay was deducted $1 because I clocked in at 9:02 one day, despite working overtime above the required 80 hours for that two week pay period. (Paystub lists the deduction as a fraction of an hour for missed time).

Essentially I’m being treated as a salaried employee in that I’m not entitled to overtime pay, but also an hourly employee having my pay deducted by the minute that I am not clocked in during the 9-5:30 working day. Is this legal? And if not is there an anonymous way for me to report this?


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 28 '24

[MN] The attorney I hired works for my accusers and he never disclosed it. Spoiler

1.2k Upvotes

I would just like everyone to know that I will be using sentences. Punctuation. Structure. Particulation. And most of all paragraphs so that everyone can read this without confusion because I am no longer in a manic state. And for those of you who forgave me or didn't mention the fact that I was writing like some kind of a mad person I appreciate your patience with me. And for those of you who I upset I apologize hopefully this will make up for that.

Well his promised I'm giving everyone an update on what I've been going through over the last 2 years with this domestic case. Originally I posted on here because it was looking for advice on whether or not I should take action against the attorney I had hired when I found out that he was connected to the victim.

Those of you who aren't familiar and are just reading this for the first time I'll give you a brief description. About 2 years ago I was accused of domestic assault. I was arrested and charged. I then hired an attorney who came recommended from a friend. I paid this attorney $10,000. When I hired the attorney he never mentioned to me that he knew the family of my victim in any way shape or form but he had a very intimate relationship with them and they have a lot of money they're very wealthy. When I found out that he had worked for my victim's family I decided it was a conflict of interest and I freaked out. That's when I started posting here to Reddit and I was just leaving long run on sentences with no paragraphs and no punctuation because I was just literally freaking out because I didn't know what to do it was the craziest situation I'd ever been in and I was terrified. I wasn't sure if I should fire the lawyer. I wasn't sure if I could should confront the lawyer. I wasn't sure if I should just go straight to the bar. I was desperate for answers.

Thanks to everybody who responded to my issues and who were taking me seriously I was able to get very good advice so anyone who says you can't get good advice from Reddit is completely wrong. The best advice that I received was to approach him talk to him about it and the then depending on what he gave me for his reasons I should take it from there. He assured me that there was no conflict of interest because no matter what he was going to do the best job for me that he possibly could and he also said he might have information that others might not that might help the case which is kind of the reason he took it. He agrees he should have probably mentioned it to me He then offered to return all of the money to me. Instead we agreed he would returned half of the $10,000 to me and said that he would do this whole thing for 5,000. That I was a willing to agree to.

So for the last 9 months I've been going back and forth to court while we tried to figure this out and we tried to find a resolution because I believe that if we are able to show text messages and we are able to show other video evidence of things that happened in the house that I would definitely be exonerated because what I did was not a violent act it was not meant to cause fear it was not meant to cause harm bodily or otherwise and also I had never physically harmed her in the first place. And we stayed together for 3 months after that so if she was afraid for her life or she was afraid for her safety why not report it immediately.

Now this happened almost two years ago this incident. Since then I've lost my business I have given up my dream. I used to be a self-employed barber with the busiest shop around and that is all gone now. I've had to sell the building sell the shop the depression and things that I went through you couldn't imagine. I've gone through other forms of torment in the fact that she has literally told me that if I did not have sex with her she would call the police and say that I assaulted her or that I threatened her and that she would get away with it because she had already gotten away with it. She had actually called me once and told me that the kids wanted to see me and I should come over for a little bit and being an idiot I agreed because I was still in love with her even after everything she did and I still had a lot of love for the kids and then when I left she called the police and told him that I had come to her house and taken her car when in reality she had asked me if I wanted to use it to go see my mom at the memory Care Center she's in. So as I'm sitting at my barber shop getting stuff ready I had 50 cops come to my shop and arrest me. She set me up she's that vindictive.

So after 9 months of dealing with all of this and going back and forth to court not everything else they have decided that they are going to drop the domestic altogether because after looking at the video and hearing my side of the story and looking at what could happen if we went to trial because I have witnesses who are willing to say that under oath that they have witnessed the emotional mental and physical abuse that she has inflicted on me.

So after everything I've been through this is now getting dropped from a domestic assault to a disorderly conduct and it will be a misdemeanor on my record. That means it will not affect my rights as a citizen. I will not lose any of my rights. And I also will not have a domestic on my record.

But I would just like to get back to the original point of all this which is I could not have gotten through this nor could I have been able to navigate these murky waters without the help of everyone that was willing to give good advice and willing to help me out with the situation I was dealing with. I know a lot of you did not believe me and I don't blame you for that. But what I said was the truth I never hurt her and I never intended to. I was still worried because again Minnesota has some very weird rules and things when it comes to domestics. But in the end the prosecution decided that in light of what people have seen on TV that constitutes domestic assault because there's been a lot of it in the news and in the video it shows I was not trying to hurt her and in fact I was very gentle so there's probably not a jury in the world that would have convicted me of assault in that situation. So why don't I take it to trial? Because I don't want to press my luck. If they're willing to give me a disorderly conduct and that's it I'm going to take it. to take a chance at trial when they're giving me an offer like that would be foolish because if there's one person on that jury who looks at my my past being a former cage fighter and also looks at my past as having done executive protection armed security and combat Jiu-Jitsu as well as the fact that I'm a guy twice her size anything could happen. If there's one person on that jury that has been affected by domestic violence and cannot be swayed then I could be putting myself in grave danger.

So again thank you to everyone who took me seriously. Thank you to everyone who gave me great advice. And for those of you who used the opportunity to talk down to me or call me a wife beater or a piece of shit or whatever else I don't blame you for having your opinion not at all. Your opinion is valid for what you saw but in the eyes of the court now and the justice system, in their eyes I am not a piece of shit nor am I a wife beater and nor am I a bad guy. And I think my attorney did a great job a really wonderful job of getting me a really good deal and so I'm glad that I didn't just go to the bar or didn't just fire him or didn't try to get my money back The fact he was willing to offer me half of it back and take the case and do the best he could and then he was a man of his word worked out the best.

So again thank you everyone for everything. I really appreciate it I promised you all I would get back to you and I don't know if any of you will even read this or look at it because it's been so long since all of this took place and I'm not really sure where to put this in order for people to get a notification but I really hope that everyone does and again everyone who help me thank you so much and even the people who you know were negative and naysayers you still helped me as well you know in some way shape or form because every time someone said something negative to me I was able to remind myself that they were wrong the negative things being said about me and it just gave me that much more courage to try to do anything I could to prove my innocence.

Yours truly

Grateful


r/AskLawyers • • Sep 28 '24

[NC] My boss fired me for having my pants up on the toilet

1.1k Upvotes

[NC]

I posted this on a different thread and was told this was a better place for this.

I got fired from my previous job and their leading argument was that my manager stared at me through the bathroom stall door long enough to tell I had my pants pulled up while on the toilet.

For backstory, I worked in a warehouse and was not given breaks but 1 30 minute lunch during my 10 hour shift. It was bad conditions in the middle of the summer so when I found a good short stopping point I’d go sit in the bathroom for a couple minutes to cool off and take a seat.

One time, my manager walked in and stared at me through the stall door opening and asked about my stomach issues I’d previously mentioned upon hiring.

When I was getting fired, that’s how they led the conversation and ultimately fired me. I was a model worker and got along with everyone including customers and made everyone’s job easier.


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 10 '24

Why hasn’t any 20.3 year old tried suing in a US state that they should legally be allowed to drink 9 months before their 21st birthday if life begins at conception?

1.1k Upvotes

Or 20.5 months if you can proof you were in your mom’s womb when a heart beat was detected? I realize not all births are exactly 9 months.


r/AskLawyers • • Jan 20 '25

[US] Assuming Trump really can end birthright citizenship with an executive order, would citizenship be revoked for people who were born prior to the order?

1.1k Upvotes

I know that a lot of legal scholars are saying that Trump can’t end birthright citizenship by executive order. But a lot of lawyers are also saying that it’s completely within his power.

My question is, what happens to the people who are currently considered citizens if Trump ends birthright citizenship? Are they immediately not citizens? Or do they get grandfathered?

If they don’t get grandfathered, What happens if that creates a cascading chain of non-citizenship through multiple generations? What happens if you have people who can’t definitively prove their citizenship across 100+ years?

Won’t this affect a lot of people? My understanding is that a lot of people used birthright citizenship to establish their citizenship in the WWI - WWII era. How will anybody know who a “real” citizen is?


r/AskLawyers • • Dec 17 '24 Heart of Silver

Car salesman mad I didn’t lie to insurance

1.1k Upvotes

I recently bought a car that got totaled in an accident the next morning (not my fault.) the my insurance, the bank, and the dealership were all notified and the car salesman knew me car was ruined. He called me a few days ago and angrily asked if I had told the bank my car was totaled. When I said yes he got irritated and said that I should have told them my car was fine. Do you guys think I should tell his boss since he’s trying to get me to lie to the insurance? I asked another thread and I decided to ask this one as well since I got mixed responses EDIT: new info as of about an hour ago. I called them leinholder bank what happened and they told me my contract hasn’t even been sent over so they can’t make my account. The dealership is the leinholder


r/AskLawyers • • Dec 23 '24

[NY] Would you want Luigi Mangione as your client, legally speaking?

1.0k Upvotes

The premise here is that Reddit is full of people who would never vote to convict. Of course, the real world isn’t Reddit- but would you expect there are enough people who are that sympathetic to LM that you might be able to get one on a jury who would acquit (or repeatedly manage to get at least one so as to hang juries)?

(Relatedly: Is it certain that a judge would let the defense being up UHC’s history of claims denials?)

If not acquitted, what does a “win” look like? Is it dodging the terrorism or most severe charges? Is it avoiding the death penalty?

Finally, what would you argue in your closing arguments? (Is it some emotional appeal? Is it a technicality maybe?)

EDIT: It should be said that— I’m only interested from a legal point of view. Not a publicity perspective (we all know about OJ’s lawyers)


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 27 '24

[OH] Wife received a write up for a call off.

975 Upvotes

She's 20 weeks pregnant and has having sharp pains and not feeling good so she went to physicians care who gave her an excuse and referred her to the ER. She was in the ER all night and released with ANOTHER work excuse.

She presented the work excuses and other documentation showing that she had a medically excused absence and presented it to her supervisor via Photographs sent through text.

She still got wrote up and they threatened to fire her if she done it again.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think they can legally write you up much less terminate you if you have a Medically Excused absence and you have Work Excuses signed by physicians detailing the reaon for the absence. So if she ends up getting fired should we take legal action ?


r/AskLawyers • • Mar 14 '24

Mini mart employee broke into my truck while he was working.

914 Upvotes

He stole my wallet with 800 cash in it,, cards ,, etc.. he was on camera but his manager refused to release it until finally after almost two weeks had gone by and I made the cops go get it , she finally did and acted like she was surprised to see it was her employee that did it. I believe she knew and was avoiding givin it up because it would be wiped after two weeks. But anyway , should I pursue some kind of legal action against the store ? For my money and pain and suffering, I am afraid to leave my vehicle now and honestly have PTSD from this bullshit.