Hi everyone,
I’m hoping someone familiar with Israeli inheritance law or the legal profession in Israel can offer some perspective, because my family and I are becoming increasingly uncomfortable with how our lawyer is handling things.
My father passed away earlier in May this year. He lived in Europe but owned an apartment in Israel, which is currently rented out, as his parents were from Tel Aviv and bought him a property in Israel. There are four heirs (my mom and my two brothers), all living abroad.
The Israeli lawyer who managed the apartment during my father’s lifetime has continued looking after it since his death. All four of us subsequently signed notarised powers of attorney so she could represent us in the inheritance proceedings.
There are a few things that have started bothering us:
First, the rental income. The lawyer has been collecting rent since my father’s death and is apparently keeping several months’ worth of payments in cash in her personal safe. She says she cannot release the money until the inheritance order is issued.
I understand that the money might legally have to remain part of the estate until everything is settled. Fair enough. But why is it being kept in cash rather than in a separate client or trust account? Is that actually acceptable practice for a lawyer in Israel?
Second, her explanation about what she can and cannot do doesn’t quite add up to us. My father’s original POA expired when he died, as far as we understand. Yet she continued handling the apartment afterwards, including rental arrangements. We only granted her new POAs later.
She says she cannot distribute the rental income without an inheritance order, but apparently she can continue managing the property and potentially renew the tenancy. Maybe there’s a perfectly reasonable legal distinction here, but so far we haven’t received a clear explanation.
Third, the powers of attorney themselves. When I read them more carefully, I realised just how broad they are. They don’t merely allow her to handle the inheritance application. They also authorise property sales, mortgages, financial transactions and even certain transactions involving the lawyer herself, potentially without payment.
Is this normal boilerplate in Israel? It seems excessive when all we wanted was someone to sort out the inheritance.
Then there’s the question of fees and progress. We’ve been quoted a considerable amount for the inheritance process, plus an additional fee for an expert opinion on foreign inheritance law. Several months have passed, and as far as we know, the application hasn’t actually been submitted yet.
I’m not saying the fees are necessarily unreasonable or that the delay is her fault. But we’d like to understand what has been done, what we’re paying for and why the process hasn’t progressed further.
What finally made me question the whole arrangement was her reaction to our latest email. Until now, she has mainly communicated through WhatsApp and individual phone calls with different family members. It became confusing because not everyone knew what had been discussed.
So we sent a polite email, signed by all four heirs, asking for the rental statements, the current tenancy agreement, an explanation of the fees and clarification of the legal situation. We also asked that future communication happen by email with everyone copied in, and that no further decisions be made without our written agreement.
Instead, she tried calling me individually. When I asked her to reply by email, she responded with a blunt “No” and told me to call her. The email was only sent recently, so I’m not accusing her of withholding the requested documents. But that reaction to a fairly reasonable request for transparency really didn’t sit right with me.
I’m now wondering whether we’ve been too trusting and whether we should consider replacing her.
A few questions I’d really appreciate help with:
- Is it normal or legally acceptable for an Israeli lawyer to keep estate rental income in cash for months?
- Are such extensive POAs standard for inheritance cases, or have we granted far more authority than necessary?
- Can we revoke the POAs, take over the property management ourselves and request that the accumulated rental income be moved to a proper account?
- Does anything I’ve described raise potential professional ethics issues under Israeli law? And if we change lawyers, what’s the safest way to handle the transition?
I’m not suggesting she’s stolen anything or deliberately done something illegal. There may well be explanations we’re not aware of. But the combination of the money being held in cash, the broad POAs, the lack of progress and her reaction to our questions has made us lose confidence.
I’d really appreciate an outside perspective, especially from Israeli lawyers or anyone who’s been through something similar.
Thanks!