r/AskIreland • u/No-Cartoonist6900 • 6m ago
Work Repeated Probation Reviews Despite Good Performance – Is This Normal?
I'm looking for some advice from people who have experience working in Irish companies, particularly regarding probation periods and workplace management.
I joined my current Irish company in Cork in April 2026. Before that, I had worked for another company in Cork for approximately two years. Overall, I have around six years of professional experience across different companies, and I've never experienced anything like this before.
When I joined my current employer, I informed them in advance that I would need parental leave in May, as we were expecting a baby. They were aware of this before I started.
One of the biggest challenges has been my commute. I live in West Cork, approximately 67 km from the office. I tried my best to find accommodation closer to work but unfortunately couldn't find anything suitable.
Initially, I was occasionally late by around 4–7 minutes. I understand punctuality is important, and I'm not denying that. However, the commute is approximately one hour, and since having a newborn, our morning routine has become more challenging. I help my wife get things ready, prepare breakfast, wash baby bottles and take care of other responsibilities before leaving for work.
Here is how things have progressed:
1. First probation review – After four months
They raised concerns about my timekeeping and said I had developed a habit of coming in late. They told me they would review the situation again.
2. Second meeting – End of August
Around 15 days later, they called another meeting and again raised concerns about punctuality and phone usage.
I explained my circumstances and the challenges I was facing. Importantly, since 9 August, I had managed to improve my timekeeping and had not been late.
3. Third probation review – Mid-September
They acknowledged that my timekeeping had improved, but instead of passing my probation, they extended it by another three months.
4. Fourth probation review – October
Again, they acknowledged improvements in my timekeeping. However, this time they raised concerns about using my phone and watching videos on social media. They mentioned that other managers had noticed me doing this.
For context, listening to music through headphones is quite common in our department, and many employees do it while working.
5. November – More criticism
Now, during November, they have started highlighting very minor mistakes in my work. Honestly, these are the kinds of small mistakes that even experienced senior employees sometimes make.
I feel that when I make a minor mistake, it gets highlighted, but the amount of work I complete and the progress I've made rarely gets acknowledged.
I can confidently say that my productivity is very good. I often handle significantly more work than some of my colleagues, and I have never received any serious complaints about the quality of my work or my technical progress.
Something else that makes me question the situation:
Last month, in October, an engineer from our department who had been working for the company for approximately three years was let go. Interestingly, he received a redundancy compensation package.
This made me wonder: if the company has concerns about an employee, why wouldn't they simply terminate someone during probation rather than continuously extending it?
I also want to mention that during recruitment, I was told that after six months, my salary would increase by €2,000.
There are also promises regarding employee benefits that make me question how the company operates.
For example, I was promised medical insurance after completing one year of service. One of my colleagues, who has already been working there for approximately two years, was also promised medical insurance but still hasn't received it.
Whenever he follows up, he gets passed between departments:
- His manager tells him to speak to HR.
- HR says the manager needs to approve it.
- The director gives another explanation.
Essentially, nothing happens.
My main concern is this:
I've worked for six years across different companies, and I've never experienced this level of scrutiny.
My work performance is good, my technical progress is strong, and my timekeeping has improved significantly. I accept that I made mistakes with punctuality initially, and I also understand that personal phone usage during working hours is something an employer can reasonably address.
But I feel like the focus is increasingly shifting from one issue to another.
First, it was punctuality. Then phone usage. Now minor mistakes.
The company regularly says that it doesn't believe in micromanagement, but this experience is starting to feel like exactly that.
I'd genuinely appreciate advice from people familiar with Irish employment law and workplace culture.
Is it normal in Ireland for employers to keep raising new minor concerns at every probation review?
I'm not looking for sympathy. I genuinely want an objective opinion from people who have experienced similar situations in Irish workplaces.
Am I overthinking this, or are these legitimate red flags?