r/AskHistorians • • 11h ago

Why is War and Peace considered THE long book?

205 Upvotes

"It's not War and Peace" is a phrase I've heard in many contexts regarding length so I'm curious how that reputation developed over the years. It is a massively long book and certainly well-known, but why is it the massively long book?


r/AskHistorians • • 3h ago

When AK and HI were admitted in 1959, how was it decided which classes their senatorial seats would be?

47 Upvotes

Also, did they have elections before statehood, so the senators would be ready on signing day, or did they just go without for a bit?


r/AskHistorians • • 10h ago

In European antiquity nudity was seemingly frowned upon. Who was posing nude in portraits throughout the ages? Where did artists find their models?

69 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 13h ago

When did retirement become economically viable? Or is it only “viable” because we coupled all growth into stocks?

113 Upvotes

I remember reading in regency England people would live off 4% of growth of things like dowerys etc, implying that there was some way that money made money even back then. Which would allow someone to retire off this if they managed to earn enough. If that is true. In today’s world I was wondering if retirement is even an actual possibility or a fabricated one. You cannot save enough to retire off working even a high paying job without investing that money, meaning an average persons paid wage doesn’t generate enough capital on its own and it has to be coupled to larger growth economy wide.

Ofc labor value is not distributed evenly today either and most of the money a worker makes “goes to the top” so perhaps in today’s world it would be true you could save enough if that distribution was more even.

Questions!

My overall set of questions is, when did that even become something economically viable? Was it ever and is it even today? How did it work in regency England with those 4% returns. Is inflation much faster now than it was 200 years ago? Is retirement actually more accessible today and what changed to make that true?


r/AskHistorians • • 2h ago

The history of Islam, Christianity and Judaism told in an unbiased but educated manner? (Book rec)

13 Upvotes

I finished reading No God But God by Reza Alsan that I absolutely loved for not only looking into common misconceptions of Islam but also the history of its beginning including the formation of tribes with Jewish and Christian’s to make the Middle Eastern region monotheistic.

I was wondering if anyone knows any similar books that focus on the historical side of religious empires, whether rising or failing, or just in general about the Abrahamic religions?


r/AskHistorians • • 3h ago

Did women accompany South Indian merchants on overseas trading voyages during the medieval period (c. 9th–14th centuries)?

11 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 32m ago

Did more people make a living as entertainers (actors, musicians, storytellers) before mass media, or now?

6 Upvotes

By this, I mean did a higher percentage of people make it as entertainers then?


r/AskHistorians • • 5h ago

What did the American founding fathers anticipate the future of racial relations to be like?

13 Upvotes

If you told Thomas Jefferson that the descendent of a slave would become president some day how surprised would he be?


r/AskHistorians • • 9h ago

Did Japan really have child sacrifices?

21 Upvotes

It's a common trope not only in horror movies but historical movies and anime as well. Was there any truth to it?

edit: I meant human sacrifices not just for children


r/AskHistorians • • 6h ago

How did school history classes during ww1 or ww2 deal with those events?

11 Upvotes

could be America or any other nation, I’m curious like if it was taught at all while it was going on, was wondering by world history classes teaching near “modern times” and covering the war as a event going on but just how was classes during this time in general


r/AskHistorians • • 15h ago

Given the misogyny behind the notion of cooking and home care being "women's work," how did professional chef become a male field?

59 Upvotes

Given the unfortunately common, though getting less common, notion that cooking is "women's work," why were professional chefs -- even throughout history -- always male? How would they have learned and progressed their careers, given the women's work notion outside of professional settings?


r/AskHistorians • • 18h ago

How did Coalition forces convince their troops to continue fighting Napoleon despite the near certainty to be defeated -not even speaking of the huge casualties? Did they suffer mutinies or rebellions of sort?

92 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 6h ago

Pursuing history studies as a "second act"?

9 Upvotes

In a few years, I'm going to be retiring as a 50 year old. Through a lot of hard work, and even more luck, I have zero debt and almost no expenses. I have a master's degree in economics with a strong focus on statistics, though that was earned in my 20s so it's been a minute.

After retirement, I'm considering starting PhD studies focused on 19th century Chinese conceptions of language and statehood. I speak Mandarin decently and read it well. I read about the topic a good bit, insofar as I'm able, though that's limited by time and access to publications (and guidance!). I'm not exactly interested in pursuing a tenured position somewhere -- my end goals would probably be to research, mentor, and teach, and of course more than anything to learn.

What should I consider before starting to look for a PhD program? How can I "test" my interest in this path before retirement? What questions should I ask myself and others that I might not have thought about yet?


r/AskHistorians • • 6h ago

What's the history of public opinion swaying legal decisions?

8 Upvotes

I've lived through plenty of instances (outside the 20y rule of course) in which public opinion has either changed the course of a prosecution, or someone or other has credibly claimed it has (those end up being shockingly legally similar).

It occurs to me that at some times and in some places, the public wouldn't have had enough information to have a shared opinion as a mob. In and at others, they might be too educated and reticent to be considered a mob. In and at even others, they might be upset but be powerless to have their opinion seen as anything other than mistake. And at the time and place (other than my own) that I'm most familiar with, a clear line between 'public opinion' and 'legal opinion' is difficult to even draw - every literate male who thought poorly of you could perhaps become a judge against your case.

In places where it was commonly acknowledged to happen, how has public perception of legal process come to affect it while it's in progress?


r/AskHistorians • • 45m ago

Why did France invade Algeria and then fully annex it as french territory?

3 Upvotes

And why didnt they do this for their other colonies, though I reckon the treatment of the natives wouldn't be much different considering native algerians were essentially 3rd class after annexation.


r/AskHistorians • • 13h ago

Deterrence theory before World War 2?

27 Upvotes

I often return to Stanley Baldwin's 1932 speech about strategic bombing, "A Fear for the Future", in which he states: "It is quite true that it [strategic bombing] may act as a deterrent in people’s minds against war, but it is much more likely to make them want to increase armaments to protect them against the terrors that they know may be launched against them."

There also seems to have been great fear of mass death as a result of strategic bombing, particularly chemical warfare. Hobsbawm states in The Age of Extremes (page 35) that "Those who became adults in the 1930s expected it [another world war]. The images of fleets of airplanes dropping bombs on cities and of nightmare figures in gas masks tapping their way like blind people through the fog of poison gas, haunted my generation: prophetically in one case, mistakenly in the other." And as I read the September 1, 1939 edition of the New York Times earlier today, there was discussion of the evacuation of millions of children from British cities alongside a picture of German children in gas masks getting ready to go to school.

So, did Europeans have a notion of deterrence theory (e.g. MAD) before World War II? If so, how did it compare to the way we think of, for instance, nuclear war? Did major figures think strategic bombing ruled out the possibility of another world war? Did major figures think strategic bombing was unthinkable, and if so, why was strategic bombing used so extensively throughout the war to the extent that atomic weapons were invented (and deployed)?


r/AskHistorians • • 19h ago

The first celebration of Christmas (day) is recorded as 366CE under Constantine. What does that mean exactly? What makes that celebration different from the years before? Was it a "smash success" or was there pushback in the years after?

61 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago

Why did both Greece and Japan have myths that warned about not eating food while in the land of the dead?

645 Upvotes

Ancient myths from cultures as diverse as Greece and Japan have tales that warn of eating food while in the land of the dead (e.g., the myth of Persephone, the myth of Izanagi and Izanami). In both cases, eating the food binds one to the land of the dead.

Is there something about food culture or understandings of death (or associated elements that the myths were about) in early human history that would lead to both Eastern and Western cultures having such a similar plot element?

Are there any attempts at an explanation or hypothesis as to why both of these cultures have stories like this?

I don't mean to imply some kind of evidence for people being spirited away. I simply find it fascinating when diverse cultures end up with similar (or fully the same) behaviors or beliefs. I feel such things prompt us to ask why.


r/AskHistorians • • 1h ago

Could anyone recommend me some good Documentaries and Books about the history of Los Angeles?

2 Upvotes

Been really wanting to watch and read up on the L.A. history. Would prefer something comprehensive if possible.


r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago

How women checked if they were pregnant in the past?

121 Upvotes

Both before modern home tests and blood tests.


r/AskHistorians • • 2h ago

Did the Catholic Church fabricate the documents it used to claim authority over the city of Rome? What was the fall out when the forgery was discovered?

2 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago

Why was Susan B Anthony outspokenly opposed to giving black people the right to vote?

156 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 11h ago

Historians, do you have any ideas or preferences for how historical films should be approched?

7 Upvotes

This isn't really a question about 'history,' but rather, I'd like to hear the opinions of historians on a given subject: That being, what do you think is the preferable (if there is one) of depicting history in film or art. And I have a pretty interesting case study:

Conspiracy (2001) and the Conference (2022) are two, excellent, excellent (in my view) movies about the Wannsee conference. And they both take difference approaches to this.

The Conspiracy is a great drama while also being a horror movie. It does a great job of putting you, the typical viewer, in the front row seat of being confronted with the bureaucratic mundanity of the evil involved in something like the holocaust. And it alters the historical characters in order to make the movie more enjoyable to watch. Ex: There is shouting, rivalries between different people present at the meeting, and very good character work where all of these different people have a different shade of reaction to the Holocaust. Some characters who we know were willingly complicit are shown to be more morally conflicted than they were in real life, all to give the audience a wide range of possible reaction to stuff like this.

But the Conference? The Conference is way more down to earth and even more mundane. Everyone in the movie is shown to be basically on board with the idea from the get-go, and that everyone who showed up to this meeting probably already kinda knew what this conference was going to be about. And from what I know of the recorded minutes of the meeting, this is much closer to how it went down.

Which of these to approaches do you 'prefer?' Is the Conference better for this change or does Conspiracy stretch the truth, but since it does so for arguably good reasons is it better?


r/AskHistorians • • 50m ago

How neither one of japanese syllabic writing system, hiragana or katakana become obsoletes?

1 Upvotes

I do know that hiragana & katakana has separate use today like hiragana mostly used for natives word while katakana used for scientific word, loanword & all of them is also used to support for chinese logographs. I wonder how did not one of them become so populer that it make the other obsoletes across century like say hiragana become the primary uses for everyday writings that it kill katakana's relevancy?