r/AskFoodHistorians • • Mar 07 '25

How did mesoamericans figure out that soaking and cooking corn in limewater gives it its nutritional value?

1.4k Upvotes

Hi, I went to Mexico last month and I have been learning a lot about pre-Columbian cultures and habits.

I know that dented corn is not a very nutritious food unless processed with an an alkaline solution, but I cant see how they figured out how to make it "worth" to cultivate. My thought process is that since Maize was domesticated from wild teocintle, why would you bother to spend hundreds of years domesticating a non-nutriotious food.

I have another question as well. Was limewater found in the wild by the mesoamericans or was it mixed separately? Maybe some water had residues of quicklime resulting in limewater being "accidental" produced? How did they figure out that the corn processed was nutritious and the one that wasn't was not? Did they compare people who ate corn cooked with different "waters" and took note of who had more vitamin deficiencies?

Its a really interesting topic but I haven't been able to find an exact answer to this question.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Jul 04 '26

Why did Europeans never jump onboard the peanut butter train

1.2k Upvotes

In the US, there was this window just before petrochemical fertilizers, where the peanut was cheap, because it allowed the rehabilitation of land depleted by big cash crops. So peanuts were cheap, almost a byproduct. So poor Americans jumped at a cheap protein and vegetable oil source. It isn’t as if we developed a lot of recipes for it, but a peanut butter sandwich certainly became a cultural staple.

Why didn’t it catch on in a similar fashion in Europe?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Feb 27 '25

When did Japanese-style dark soy sauce become the "default" soy sauce in the US, even in Chinese restaurants?

800 Upvotes

Did it have something to do with the popularity of sushi?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • May 19 '17

Drunk Americans today enjoy gorging on wings, pizza, and other bar/drunk foods. However, these foods are quite new. What did drunk Americans eat before deep fryers and pizza?

764 Upvotes

Alternatively, if you know what drunk people were eating in another time and place please don't hesitate to comment!


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Apr 02 '25

What made food "gross" to early Victorian Americans?

755 Upvotes

What were the early Victorian standards of food being appetizing or not, in a time in which pickled tongue was popular?

The women in my 1830s book are debating what to serve at a tea party in order to impress their female guests. The joke of the scene is that one suggestion is gross, and everyone else tries to steer the conversation away from that particular option.

What dishes would have appealed to very few people--and why?

The rejection could come from a class judgment, but I'm more interested in understanding what food might have appealed to very few people in 1830s America--and why.

For context, I'm writing in a small, newly established town in 1834 Indiana.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Mar 12 '25

Is corned beef and cabbage historically Irish or is it something Americans made up and associated with the Irish?

740 Upvotes

With St. Patrick's coming up and my irish roots I was wondering how "authentic" corned beef and cabbage is. Is it like the US version of Cinco de Mayo?

Edit: Thank you for all the responses, I did not know about the Irish and Jewish connections when they came to America and I appreciate being educated today.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Mar 16 '25

Old hotel menus were enormous. Did their kitchens really offer all those options every day?

726 Upvotes

Over on r/vintagemenus you can see old (pre-WWII) menus that seem to list just about every kind of dish you can think of. Hotels especially. I find it hard to believe their kitchens could provide so many different foods, especially since freezers were not available (in the 19th Century) for convenience. Everything was made fresh and from scratch.

Were the menus merely possible offerings from the kitchen? “I’ll have the clam chowder.” “Sorry, we don’t have that today.” That way they would only have to print one menu.

Or maybe not. The kitchens must have been packed with staff.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • May 09 '26

Why have cafeteria-style eateries (for adults) largely disappeared in the U.S.?

706 Upvotes

When I was recently in France, our university dining hall offered a 4 course meal presented cafeteria style: two starters, a main course (which itself consisted of a starch, vegetable, and protein), and fruit/cheese/dessert. It was quick (lots of students had to be served quickly), tasty, and healthy.

In the U.S., the only cafeteria-style I know of is IKEA, which offers meals that are similarly quick, tasty, and healthy. Other cafeteria-style restaurants of my youth seem to have disappeared, although perhaps there are some I don't know about.

Why have cafeteria-style eateries disappeared? It seems like a solution to so many food service problems (by which I mean, food-consumption problems) in the U.S.

Edit: Several commenters have mentioned restaurants that offer buffets, including for example the hot bar at Whole Foods. I think buffets are quite different (fixed-price buffets encourage people to overeat, for one thing) but perhaps I am being narrow-minded.

Edit 2: I don't know what modern University cafeterias are like. I have the idea that they are more like food courts but perhaps I am wrong.

Edit 3 (most important): Thanks to everyone who has responded & opened my eyes. I realized that my "models" are a specific mix of quasi-automat (cold and room-temperature food served on a prepared plate that the diner served himself to) and cafeteria (hot food main dishes available in a serving line). Both examples are healthy and the portions are restricted.

This allows -- or requires, depending on your viewpoint -- the diner to have a meal that is close to restaurant style (specified portions, but also not pre-packaged) but quickly and with less labor involvement in serving. This is what I would like to see come back.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Jan 03 '26

Did people who took part in 90s "Second Wave Coffee" culture actually enjoy biscotti?

697 Upvotes

I'm currently reading the (fiction!) book Legends and Lattes, which is a novel about an orc who hangs up her broadsword and decides to open a coffee shop in a loosely D&D or Tolkienesque fantasy setting. The core narrative structure early in the book is that of translating specific coffee shop tropes and conventions to a high fantasy setting. For example in the book coffee is an " exotic gnomish invention", the cafe becomes the hangout of magical/wizardish university students who never want to buy anything, there's a quirky lyre-playing experimental folk musician who passes a hat, pastry confections invented by a hobbitlike humanoid mouse, etc. (For the record I highly recommend this book to people who enjoy this sub!)

One thing I was mildly surprised got a mention in the book was biscotti, which I associate with 90s coffee culture, but which seems to have mostly faded in popularity in the 21st century. I'm in my 40s and have never actually eaten biscotti or known anyone who especially liked it. I was a barista for a while in the 2010s, and the shop I worked in didn't sell it.

So, like... what's the deal (Seinfeldian/Chandler Bingian tone intended) with biscotti? Was it ever a truly popular cafe menu item among actual 90s coffee shop regulars? What led American cafe owners of the 1990s to introduce it beyond its practicality as something that wouldn't go stale on a daily basis?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • May 11 '24

How is it that Americans eat so little offal?

687 Upvotes

It seems to me that almost all of the cultures from which Americans originated enjoyed and still enjoy a lot of organ meat while it is rare to see it eaten regularly outside of immigrant communities or maybe restaurants. How did this come about? And when did the change become so universal?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Jan 21 '24

How did black olives make their way into Americanized Mexican recipes?

668 Upvotes

It just seems like such a strange addition. Did this start in a particular area? Is it based on flavor? A substitute for a more traditional ingredient?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Oct 06 '25

Fried onions & poverty?!

657 Upvotes

My husband is frying onions, which is one of my favourite aromas. When I said that, he pointed out that Emile Zola, in the novel Germinal, used the smell of fried onions to convey brutish poverty and squalid living conditions.

It broke my brain. 🤯

Did late-19th century French really denigrate this most satisfying of smells? Was it truly a food relegated to the lower classes and if so, when did that change?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Jan 12 '26

[US] It is the early 1900's, and you are dining at a chop house with a menu that is a mile long. What is the food option that most people would avoid ordering, almost like today's 'diner lobster'?

625 Upvotes

I already posted this on r/AskHistorians , and I got a really great answer about the hamburger. I have since discovered this sub - I hadn't known that there was a sub specifically for food history - so I thought I would also try asking here in case there are any other historians that may have another perspective on a different dish.

Original:

I recently took a tour of a restaurant that had once been a famous chop house for 125 years. During renovations, the new owners found in a crawl space boxes and boxes of old menus dated throughout the original restaurant's run.

The menus were massive and filled with a lot of dense writing, with every category having a huge number of options. I took a photo of the potato section, and I can count 17 different vegetable dishes, 17 different potato dishes, and more than 16 salad options. And according to the owner, the menus never changed from year to year, only the prices.

Today, an indicator that a restaurant might not be that good is having too many menu options because there are few places that could make that many dishes at a high quality. The first thing that came to mind was that diners often have massive menus, but I think that the chop house menu far exceeded even the longest diner menu I've ever seen. So I'm wondering: back in the day, which would have been the dishes that chop houses wouldn't have been known for, the types of dishes that people would have given you the side eye for ordering, almost like ordering lobster at a diner today?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Mar 20 '26

Has anyone actually figured out what the third commonly used mystery shaker spice was?

590 Upvotes

I've read that historically, there was a third spice commonly used in table-top shakers alongside salt and pepper but it has been lost in history and there is only speculation as to what it was, likely paprika, I think? Did anyone ever truly figure out what that spice was?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Jul 18 '26

What could a traveler actually get to eat at a 14th-15th century European inn, and did they have any choice in the matter?

587 Upvotes

My understanding is that the modern idea of a menu is anachronistic. An inn served the ordinary, meaning whatever the pot held that day, and real choice was more of a cookshop and urban tavern thing. I'd love to know how right or wrong that is and how it varied: between England and the continent, between a roadside establishment and a city inn, what a peasant or a merchant would be served on the same evening.

Context: I am building a (deliberately fantasy) inn menu generator for tabletop games and I want it anchored to reality before I go further. The generator has biomes, inn tiers, regional exports and stuff like famine or war. I'm aiming the baseline results to be plausible even if it doesn't aim to be fully realistic. It's open source and you can ask for the URL but I'm not here to self-promote but to learn. Sources and reading recommendations very welcome; I have Peter Clark's The English Alehouse on the list and would love more.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Aug 17 '24 Polished Silver Turd

Historian demolishes "Italian food tradition", is this just marketing?

581 Upvotes

The Austrian Standard just published an interview with historian Alberto Grandi in which "Italian food tradition" is pretty much demolished.

While it's understood that "tradition" always is fabricated to a certain extent, I as a mod of a food-related sub would be very much interested on food historians' take on this interview, in particular whether this is just marketing in order to sell his book about that topic.

Source (in German): https://www.derstandard.at/story/3000000232054/historiker-die-italienische-kueche-ist-nichts-anderes-als-marketing

Translation from German into English via DeepL:

---

Historian: ‘Italian cuisine is nothing more than marketing’

When we think of Italy, we immediately think of pasta, pizza and other delicious food. Specialities such as Neapolitan margherita or Roman carbonara have become as legendary as the Colosseum, the Amalfi Coast and Pompeii. Italian cuisine has long since developed a cult following. People refer to alleged original recipes from the times of the Medici dynasty or which originate from poor shepherds in the Apennines. Deviations from these recipes are met with veritable shitstorms on social media.

Cucina italiana, the traditional cuisine, is not to be trifled with. Historian Alberto Grandi is particularly annoyed by this glorification of food. That's why he researched the true history of the origins of Italian dishes. What did he find out? Everything is fake. The carbonara, the origin stories, even the culinary figure of the nonna. In his book Mythos Nationalgericht*, he claims that Italy's famous cuisine only developed after the Second World War.*

STANDARD: In some articles about your book, you are described as the ‘destroyer of Italian cuisine’. Is that true?

Grandi: I'm not destroying it, I'm telling a different kind of story about Italian cuisine.

STANDARD: What is that?

Grandi: We have simply invented a lot of recipes and stories over the last 50 years. There is an excess of myths and legends surrounding Italian cuisine. It's nothing more than marketing.

STANDARD: So when I read that tiramisu originated from a dish in the 17th century and was eaten by the de Medici family, that's a fairy tale?

Grandi: Yes, it's marketing. There's nothing reprehensible about it. Marketing is there to sell products. Tiramisu could only have been invented in the 60s or 70s. Mascarpone requires refrigeration to produce and was not available to everyone. It only became possible with the development of supermarkets. My mum is now 90. 50 years ago, mascarpone was an absolute novelty for her.

STANDARD: Why do you have a problem with the way stories about food are passed on?
Grandi: Food has such an enormous significance in our culture. And I find that strange. As a historian, I find it difficult that food is now the most important aspect of identity for Italians. I find that dangerous. Just this morning I was discussing this with a friend. He said that everything in Italy depends on tourism and food. That is not true. 90 per cent of Italy's GDP cannot be attributed to tourism. The reactions to my work show that many Italians are unaware of the economic and social reality of our country.

STANDARD: Food is an emotional topic. Just when it comes to preparing a dish ‘properly’. For many people, carbonara can only be made with guanciale and pecorino.

Grandi: Ten or 15 years ago, Gualtiero Marchesi, one of the most important Italian chefs, added whipped cream to carbonara. Today, people would go crazy over it. Carbonara is not a recipe, it's a religion. A Roman journalist once threatened me with a beating because of such statements in my book.

STANDARD: Is there such a thing? A right or wrong?

Grandi: The story of the Amatriciana sauce comes to mind. If you use onions for the sauce today, you are declared crazy. But the long history shows that the only really constant ingredient from the beginning of the 20th century until ten years ago was the onion. So: what is the right recipe?
STANDARD: But why is that happening?

Grandi: Cuisine is no longer part of our identity, it is our identity. Italians have no faith in the future, and that's why they invent a past. The one true Italian cuisine doesn't exist. It's the same with the Nonnas, the grandmothers. They can't cook as well as is always claimed. Grandmas can make two or three good dishes and that's it.

STANDARD: You're telling me the dear old Nonnas are fake?

Grandi: When it comes to cooking, yes. They cook big meals on public holidays, but the rest of the year they cook badly and monotonously.

STANDARD: Nonnas are the experts for Italian food on social media.

Grandi: Massimo Bottura, a very well-known chef, says he learnt everything from his nonna. That's completely impossible. The ingredients, the flavours, the cooking techniques that a nonna had at her disposal before the world wars are completely different to today. That's another legend.

STANDARD: What did people eat then if not pasta and pizza?

Grandi: Until the First World War, pasta was only known in Naples. The rest of the Italians ate a lot of vegetables, soup and polenta. They cooked with chestnut flour and lard. So not the Mediterranean diet that we know. That is also an invention. Nobody ate like that.

STANDARD: Really?

Grandi: If you look at southern Italy today, it is the region with the highest obesity rate. In the past, people ate badly and little, today they eat too much and too much.

STANDARD: Which true story of a dish surprised you the most?

Grandi: Perhaps the strangest story is that of Parmigiano Reggiano. Parmesan has a very long history, almost 2000 years. During this time, the cheese has undergone many changes. In its original form - small, soft, greasy and black on the outside - it is produced in Wisconsin in the USA. Italian emigrants brought it with them. It was not until the 1960s that it was developed into its current form in Parma.
STANDARD: So how did the terrible Italian food become the fantastic Italian food?

Grandi: On the one hand, the great emigration of Italians between 1860 and 1960 was a factor. At that time, 25 million people left the country. Thanks to economic growth, some of them came back in the middle of the 20th century and brought with them dishes and recipes that are now sold as originals.

STANDARD: Which dishes would that be?

Grandi: Pizza, for example. Pizza was invented in Naples, but it tasted awful. The dough was firm, burnt on the outside and still doughy on the inside. And without tomatoes. It was only thanks to the Italian diaspora that pizza was further developed and improved in the USA.

STANDARD: One of the most famous stories is that the pizza was created for Queen Margherita's visit and represents the colours of the Italian flag.

Grandi: There is a document on which this story is written. It's a forgery. Pizza Margherita was only invented years after the Queen's death. She never ate it. What you find in Naples today is an American invention.

STANDARD: So the Americans put mozzarella and tomatoes on the pizza?
Grandi: Exactly. Tomato sauce is not Italian either. It comes from Spain. It only really became established after the Second World War. Tomato sauce is difficult to preserve. It needed industrialisation for that.

STANDARD: Is there any real traditional Italian food at all?

Grandi: The worst word you can use for Italian cuisine is traditional. There is no culinary tradition.

STANDARD: You have falsified tomato sauce, parmesan, tiramisu and pizza. What about Bolognese?

Grandi: Everyone makes Bolognese differently. There is no original recipe. Today, however, people say that Bolognese is cooked without tomatoes. But you can't prove that.

STANDARD: And carbonara?

Grandi: Carbonara is a little different. Although it originated in Italy, it comes from the Americans. At the end of the Second World War, after the conquest of Rome, the soldiers combined their rations of egg powder and bacon with pasta. They called it ‘spaghetti breakfast’. So it didn't come from the charcoal burners in the Apennines, who prepared pasta with bacon and cheese during their break. Incidentally, the first recipe for carbonara was published in Chicago in 1952. Only two years later in Italy. And even that was different from the modern version. Gruyère cheese, pancetta and garlic were used.

STANDARD: In Austria, carbonara is also cooked with whipped cream and ham.

Grandi: Whipped cream was often used in carbonara recipes right up until the 1970s.

STANDARD: So our version is not a fake carbonara?

Grandi: There is no such thing as a fake carbonara. Every recipe has its justification. But don't say that out loud when you're in Italy.

STANDARD: Let's go through the rest. What about olive oil?

Grandi: That's a very strange story. Fifty years ago, olive oil was used for everything except cooking. For oil lamps, for example. It tasted very sour and very intense. It was unsuitable for food. Italians tended to cook with lard, butter or margarine. It wasn't until the 80s that the quality of the oil improved so that it could be used for cooking.

STANDARD: Pasta comes from China, doesn't it?

Grandi: Yes and no. Pasta came into the country via Sicily through the Arabs. Pasta used to be eaten by hand and only mixed with garlic, fat and cheese.

STANDARD: Can you still go out to eat in your home country without being insulted?

Grandi: (Laughs.) I don't know what it would be like in Naples, I haven't ventured there yet, but yes, I can still go out to eat.

STANDARD: What do you eat then?

Grandi: Spaghetti with tomato sauce.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Dec 23 '25

Why do the British eat so little fish and seafood?

580 Upvotes

I know fish and chips is synonymous with Britain however I'm familiar with the UK and one thing I noticed is that British people don't really eat / like seafood and fish that much. They'll have the odd white fish and its usually battered. I've met alot of people who say that beyond a simple salmon or cod, they don't like the taste or smell of fish and seafood. Except for a few seaside towns, there's not much of a seafood culture (like Japan or Norway or Spain etc), alot of seafood is frozen or mediocre quality. Despite having such rich fishing waters, Britain doesn't seem to be much of a fish nation, to the extent that a massive chunk of British seafood is sold to France and Belgium first and then if they don't sell, frozen and reexported back to the UK.

Why is that? Most island nations love fish or nations with long coastlines and deep maritime histories. Britain seems to not be so fond of it.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • May 18 '26

Chocolate, vanilla, and ... strawberry? When and why did strawberry become the traditional third flavor?

579 Upvotes

This question prompted by an episode of The Pitt, where someone is offered their choice of three flavors of Ensure: chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry.

And it got me wondering why strawberry became (perhaps?) the most common fruit flavor/third option for dairy treats.

Milkshakes, ice cream, flavored milk — other flavors are often available, but if options go beyond chocolate and vanilla, strawberry seems to be codified as as the go-to third. It's codified in Neapolitan ice cream, which offers all three flavors in one batch.

Why strawberry? Why not raspberry or lemon or peach? Why is one flavor more common than the others? How far back does that go? Is it even accurate, or only accurate in the US or parts of it?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Apr 11 '25

What were people making with pretty much only flour?

563 Upvotes

“Two pounds of sugar, two pounds of flour, some butter and some tea, that’s all they to a hungry man until the seventh day” is a line from an old Australian folk song I heard, I’m wondering, what did people make with pretty much just flour? Was it all just bread? Did they have any other uses for it?

Edit: might as well add the song as well (in the name of historical preservation, or for anyone else who might find it interesting.) The song in the post starts at the 1:00 mark


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Mar 30 '25

Did people in the past drink alcohol while pregnant?

543 Upvotes

Hi! I’m curious about alcohol and pregnancy in historical times. A few quick questions:

  • Is it correct that in the Middle Ages or earlier, people drank wine or beer due to unsafe water?

  • Does this mean that the women also drank alcohol during pregnancy?

  • Wouldn't that have lasting effects on the children and their development?

  • Were there any folk beliefs or warnings about alcohol and pregnancy?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • May 06 '26

The cultural myth of "Heat-Inducing" and "Cold" foods: Is this unique to India, or do other regions share this?

533 Upvotes

I grew up in India, and my whole life I was warned not to eat too much of certain foods like almonds, eggs, mangoes, and a bunch of other random stuff because they are supposedly "heat-inducing" and will cause "body heat." No one could ever explain how.

I studied biochemistry, physiology, anatomy in college none of this shit ever popped up or was even eluded to.

I was just wondering does the concept of hot/cold nature of foods exist anywhere else too?

Edit 8th May, 2026: A lot of different counties and cultures around the world seem to have very similar practices of categorizing the foods hot/cool and then using them accordingly to cure the opposite condition. I am yet to find any explanation of any common compound or feature among all the hot categorized foods. The cold categorized foods mostly seem to be high in water content and electrolytes. But even this doesn't track across board. So many responses from people around the world damn near got me teary eyed in the middle of a work day lol.


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Jan 10 '26

Why does French cuisine use so much butter?

532 Upvotes

To be clear, this is not at all a complaint, just pure wonderment. I for one think this is one of many things the French got right with their cuisine, butter really does make nearly everything taste better, and the cultured butter that France is known for takes it to the next level

So my question is, how did the French arrive at this (very correct) conclusion for their cuisine? What’s the history behind so much butter use in French dishes as opposed to other European cuisines?


r/AskFoodHistorians • • Aug 08 '24

What would the oldest recognizable prepared dish be that we still eat today?

Thumbnail reddit.com
494 Upvotes

r/AskFoodHistorians • • Mar 08 '26

What do actual food scholars think of Tasting History with Max Miller?

488 Upvotes

He does a lot for visibility and education in terms of getting people interested in historical foodways. But what do think about his level of research, methods, and do you have any criticisms?

Remove if wildly off-topic.