I recently got quoted $180 to repair a small kitchen appliance that I could replace with a comparable new one for about $120.
The technician wasn't trying to rip me off. Between diagnosing the problem, ordering the part, labor, and the shop's overhead, the quote actually seemed reasonable.
But it made me wonder about something from an economics perspective.
Somewhere in the world, a factory can extract raw materials, manufacture dozens of components, assemble an appliance, package it, transport it across an ocean, distribute it to a retailer, and still sell it profitably for less than a local technician charges to replace one broken component.
Obviously mass production and cheaper labor explain part of this. But it still feels like a strange outcome: the process involving substantially more physical production can have the lower market price.
I started wondering whether this is an example of Baumol's cost disease. Manufacturing productivity keeps improving, while an individual technician still has to spend time diagnosing and fixing one appliance.
But I'm not sure whether that explains most of the price difference or whether other factors are more important.
For example, if repair is frequently uneconomical, shouldn't there be strong incentives for businesses to develop cheaper repair methods? Or does the relatively small and unpredictable demand for each particular repair prevent those economies of scale from developing?
I'm also curious whether economists distinguish between something being cheap in monetary terms and something being efficient in terms of the actual resources society uses.
Is there research on why the relative cost of repairing consumer goods has changed over time? And is this mainly a productivity story, or a market structure problem?