r/AskComputerScience • • Jun 28 '22

Laptop Recommendations

Hello, everyone, I am just ending my first year at uni as A computer science student and I want to invest in a laptop as my main machine. My use for the laptop would be of course reading pdfs and the usual when it comes to studying, But also I would want to program the uni's projects but also start mine too. Also because I will choose a career path in Networking and in the fourth year of cyber security I want the laptop to be capable of handling a couple of VMs so I am planning to have a bunch of RAM. The thing is that every laptop I've searched has a Huge problem. For example, The xps13 9310 battery 2-3hours M2 air To expensive in Europe starts at 1500€ the base model The Lenovo laptops don't have enough RAM and the Hp elite book 855 g8 the new Ryzen CPU has a problem when it comes to cooling and fans on Linux because I would like to dual boot the machine. I know that I can't have it all but when you want to spend 1500€ on a laptop I think you can be picky. If anyone can help with any suggestions I would really appreciate it!

My Candidates are

1 Dell XPS 13 9310 i7 1185g7/32gb/1tb SSD

2 HP EliteBook 855 G8 15.6" IPS FHD (Ryzen 7-5800U/32GB/1TB SSD

3 Lenovo IdeaPad Slim 7 Pro 14IHU5 14" IPS Touchscreen (i7-11370H/16GB/1TB SSD

4 Lenovo Yoga 7 14ACN6 14" IPS FHD Touchscreen (Ryzen 7-5800U/16GB/1TB SSD

5 Lenovo ThinkPad E15 Gen 3 (AMD) 15.6" IPS FHD (Ryzen 7-5700U/16GB/1TB SSD

6 Lenovo ThinkPad E14 Gen 3 (AMD) 14" IPS FHD (Ryzen 7-5700U/16GB/1TB

7 Dell Inspiron 5625 16" (Ryzen 7-5825U/32GB/512GB SSD

8 Macbook air m1/m2 16gb/512gb ssd

P.S I spend my whole day in uni with classes and later I study in the library so I want a laptop with a reliable battery and somewhat lightweight so that is why I did not choose a gaming laptop.

1 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

3

u/hinziboy Jun 28 '22

ThinkPads are great. If you discover that the 16GB RAM won't be enough you can upgrade one of the sticks to 16 or 32. However, I think 16GB in total will be enough for your usage.

Screen size depends on your preference but I'd go for 15,6

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

Thanks for the time replying. Unfortunately those ThinkPad models the ram it can't be upgraded and am worried if I should go with a 32bg in order to future-proof the device and don't arrive at any limitations

3

u/hinziboy Jun 28 '22

Are you sure?

One of the sticks is soldered, the other should be removable.

See here, here and here

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

Great thanks for informing me!!

1

u/hinziboy Jun 28 '22

My pleasure, good luck with your final choice :) Don't forget to look for special student discounts!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22

If you're going to be an IT pro, you're going to need to get used to leveraging cloud resources. I think you should not worry about how robust your laptop is and just run your more resource intensive applications and VMs in Azure or AWS. I do that pretty exclusively now and my 4 year old Macbook is WAY overpowered.

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

I understand thanks for the advice

1

u/CoopNine Jun 28 '22

1 or 8 in my opinion are your best overall options. Not sure where you're getting 2-3 hours of battery on the XPS though. I have an older version of the XPS and I get generally in the 6-8 hour range depending on type of usage, and this is a 3 year old battery. New, it was quite impressive, especially coming from a latitude.

If you're wanting to run x86 VMs, you won't be able to do that on a M1 or M2 processor. Likewise you can't virtualize ARM on x86. So it depends on what you want to virtualize. There's also not a slew of free to use VMs for the M1. You'll probably end up buying Parallels.

Both machines will run containers well. You don't mention this, but I suspect you'll be running a lot of docker containers. There's occasionally some jankyness in both windows and the M1 version of OSX. Usually these things can be overcome, and are usually due in both cases for things being targeted to x86 unix based systems.

The Mac's native unix shell is nice to have. But, WSL has come a long way, the disadvantage is the file system is not unified You can get to anything, but it's not quite as simple as what you have on a mac.

One potential bad thing about the M1/M2 chips are the lack of ability to push to more than one external display. Not sure if this is an issue, but something to keep in mind. If a single external display is all you need, no big deal.

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

Thanks for the detailed explanation you helped me a lot!! If you do a Google search There are a lot subreddits that are just for complaining for the battery of the xps.I think even i have thw Unix i would steel need Vm's so i think that is going to be the deal breaker for me.Again thanks a lot

0

u/CoopNine Jun 28 '22

Well, mine is a 9370, and I've always been happy with the battery life, The 9310 seems to test out well, and is a decent improvement over the 9300 it seems.

With any laptop your brightness settings make a huge difference, as does usage. But 2-3 hours is way below what any reviews are saying, and I'd guess either there is a defect with the unit, software issue, or any machine trying to perform the same workload would have similar issues. While user experiences are valuable information they aren't always typical. i.e. I was downloading 10GB of data while trying to build WeirdDistro 1.9 from source, my battery drained to zero (started at 60%) in 90 minutes.

Even my 13" macbook pro, normally extremely power efficient, will eat through battery if I crank the brightness and tax the processor WiFi and ssd.

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

I get your point But I try find reviews in the reddit post's in order to have a full view of what i am getting and the xps 13 is the laptop that is the closest to perfection and if the battery achieves 7-8 i will be happy

1

u/Rare_Expression_9045 Jul 02 '22 edited Jul 02 '22

Personally I find 13" screens too small.

If you're considering a Mac then I'd look at the 14" MBP. XPS the 15" version.

In cases you weren't aware: as modern Macs use an M1/M2 System on a Chip (SOC) the RAM and SSD aren't soldered in, they are literally a part of the chip. Completely un-upgradeable.

On the plus side, as a result the SSD is much faster than any NVME drive out there, and you don't need as much RAM. 16GB is plenty, 32GB overkill.

1

u/Tobi_16w Jan 07 '24

MacBook Air (M1) or Lenovo ThinkPad

0

u/Treyzania Jun 28 '22

If you're inexperienced, your best best would be the XPS or a Thinkpad with Ubuntu preinstalled. Comes out of the box with everything you need set up properly. There's Asahi working on getting Linux running on Apple ARM silicon but it's not nearly ready for real use, it's a prototype. Plus, they're wildly overpriced.

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

Thanks for the advice unfortunately in my country they do not come with Linux built-in so in that scenario, I will dual boot to use windows but I am afraid of picking an XPS because there are a lot of subreddits that complain about the battery

1

u/Treyzania Jun 28 '22

There's a chance that they might be referring to how it's annoying to set up the graphics settings properly if you have one with both integrated intel and nvidia graphics. Although this is less of an issue now than it used to be. You don't really need high performance graphics on a laptop, you're better off getting a low-end laptop with just the integrated graphics and using the money you save to build a mid-range desktop that would have a better cost to performance ratio.

For work I use an XPS (not sure which particular model, lshw says 2XXFW11) with an i7-1165G7 running Ubuntu and I have no issues with the battery. It gets like 8 hours of active usage on a single charge and it's over a year old at this point.

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 29 '22

Maybe is because you use Linux full time they complain except for the battery overheating and loud fans maybe it has to do with windows

1

u/Treyzania Jun 29 '22

Not sure what you mean but I have no issues like that whatsoever.

1

u/themariocrafter Jun 29 '22

So just dualboot it, and getting a windows environment just in case apps don’t work tin wine

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Th4nosBoiiiiii Jun 28 '22

I have done my research and I think it is not suitable for me and also for my specs it gets expensive really quickly