r/AskComputerScience • u/Motor-Strawberry8787 • Jul 03 '21
Will Software engineers become oversaturated and obsolete? And will their salaries drop?
I'm about to get in college, and i've been thinking in pursuing a CS degree, but i'm concerned about my future and the future of that career.
I think that in 6 years, there will be a surplus of engineers, i think that because i'm seeing a lot of people pursuing a CS degree, there a lot of books, online courses, Youtube videos, bootcamps to learn how to code, I've learned a ton by myself without the need of college education, i've even seen that you dont need at CS degree to be a software engineer. It is possible to be autodidact and become a software engineer. And as i said a lot of people are getting into this career because of its high salary, and when there is more supply of people with a certain skill, salaries decline because of supply and demand.
Also, programming is becoming easier overtime, it's easier to build a website today than it was back then in 2010, because of the new programming languages, frameworks and technology. So the barrier of entry is becoming lower overtime, making the supply of engineers increase. And when the easier a skill is, the less people pay for people with that skill.
Let me know what you guys think.
50
u/coolSnipesMore Jul 03 '21
Don’t believe the online ‘coaches’ that say anyone can become a developer within 4 hours.
They’re trying to sell their courses.
It’s far harder to actually become a developer.
A good one at least.
95
u/chrisgseaton Jul 03 '21
People have been saying this for 25 years, yet salaries only go up.
As long as you enjoy programming and you’re good at it, ignore this noise.
7
Jul 04 '21
Agreed. Also, it seemed like OP was leading into creative destruction, which is a thing. But you still need engineers to build out AI and program ML, they're not magic bullets.
But OP should realize we're on the brink of massive creative destruction across almost all industries. And so what? We're not there yet, and we're already having the conversations (good thing) so that we have some options should we let automation en masse completely redo civilization In a great "automation revolution"!
19
Jul 03 '21
No haha, we are just starting in the conversion of whole industries to tech. And that will require more software engineers.
Right now there is a glut of really inexperienced engineers who can barely handle basic work at the entry level. But that will slowly pass over time as more and more get jobs or leave
12
u/GabrielForth Jul 03 '21
If you're going to learn engineering let's start with induced demand.
A surplus and availability of resources will result in things arising to consume them.
Our internet bandwidth now is vastly larger than it was in the 90's, so services such as streaming cropped up which make use of that bandwidth.
Also in terms of ease of access, yes it is getting easier. However there are still a huge amount of the population who looks at software like wizardry and know next to nothing about computers.
Also something to consider is the scale of the field. Yes there are online courses that will teach you to be a developer in one technology. But they do so by focussing on a depth in one tech rather than a breadth in the field.
So they'll skip stuff like how a processor functions, multi threading, memory accessing, information theory because those aren't necessary to know to use the one tech they're teaching.
I always look at those courses as a good way for someone to step their toe in the water, and likely land a job if it's just that one tech but it's no substitute for studying the wider field and learning broadly.
4
u/IAmNotNathaniel Jul 03 '21
But they do so by focusing on a depth in one tech rather than a breadth in the field.
I think this is one of the most important things. And it ties into the idea that while you can learn a breadth of things on your own, it's a very difficult thing to do on your own.
9
u/bonestormII Jul 03 '21
Back in 2010, the expectation was server rendered templates still. There is a strong consensus that building substantive web applications has gotten stupidly complicated.
And yet, there's a lot to do in business with programming that doesn't involve web pages. You'd be surprised what people need.
8
u/TransientVoltage409 Jul 03 '21
On one facet, people have been chasing this dream of "anyone can author their own software" since...well, day one. I think COBOL was supposed to be the first grab at that ring, and see how that turned out. And today's systems are sophisticated indeed...but to quote a meme, in order to solve a problem, you must first state the problem in clear and unambiguous terms. Once you actually meet a few customers, you'll begin to understand that the art of converting customer needs into actual specification is not a problem that can be automated out anytime soon. At least that aspect of software development isn't going to be shrinking in the foreseeable future.
1
15
u/roman_fyseek Jul 03 '21
Your class is going to start with 30-50 CS majors and by graduation, you'll be down to 3 or 4.
You're right in that anybody can be a programmer. Programmers are a dime a dozen.
Good programmers are few and far between.
Be a Good programmer and you'll never stop making money.
4
Jul 04 '21
You’re so right man. I’m a horrible “developer” and I have two more semesters till graduation and so many people I used to see they’re dropping like flies
7
u/roman_fyseek Jul 04 '21
Almost all college students are horrible developers. It's because a CS degree doesn't teach you to be a developer. It teaches you how to be efficient when you become a developer. It teaches you to not trust bubble sort, to never write your own encryption algorithm, how to convert an algorithm into code.
These are all valuable skills to have when you become a developer, but a lot of your 'developer' skills are going to come from your first few jobs and mentors having you do grunt work and holding your hand while you do it.
You're going to be reading other people's source code and picking up tricks and following tutorials on the libraries that your company uses and asking stupid questions that have been answered a thousand times before you arrived and making dangerous mistakes and re-writing your code that your reviewer has kicked back to you.
Don't expect to come out of school an expert developer. You're literally just beginning. But, you'll have that degree that the majority of your developer peers won't. After a couple of years, your opinion will be respected more than theirs.
*probably*
*pro
3
Jul 04 '21 edited Jul 04 '21
This has been great to read honestly. I’ve been suffering from serious imposter syndrome lately and I was thinking my ability to code had regressed.
1
u/Thin_Cauliflower_840 Feb 08 '24
Your opinion will be respected more than the others if you can formulate it better than the others. Degrees have nothing to do with this skill. It’s communication.
6
u/ggchappell Jul 03 '21
I think that in 6 years, there will be a surplus of engineers, i think that because i'm seeing a lot of people pursuing a CS degree, there a lot of books, online courses, Youtube videos, bootcamps to learn how to code, I've learned a ton by myself without the need of college education
Pretty much all of your observations have been true for the past decade, many for the decades before that (with appropriate changes; obviously, there were no YouTube videos before there was YouTube). And yet we haven't been seeing this huge surplus, yet. I'm not saying your conclusion won't happen; but I think it is clear that your observations do not justify it.
In particular: I'm a CS professor, and our entering classes are generally quite a bit larger than the number of people graduating with a CS degree. Lots of people thinking they're going to get a CS degree is just normal. Most of them end up elsewhere.
6
u/ghjm MSCS, CS Pro (20+) Jul 03 '21
One of the uncomfortable truths of this field is that aptitude matters. Some people have minds that naturally gravitate towards the kind of artificial/formal symbolic systems that are fundamental to math and CS. Other people have other talents: music, art, being good with people, the ability to perceive pricing errors in equities markets.
It so happens that there is great demand for software developers, so it's pretty likely there's someone who could have been the next Beethoven, but who never took up music and instead struggles along as a web dev. Our society doesn't do a very good job of matching aptitudes to occupations.
As long as there have been computers, people who are really good at CS have never lacked for employment and good pay. The business cycle comes and goes for people who are just okay at programming. Right now there's a glut of junior devs and people are finding it difficult to break into the field. But this doesn't really affect the top end people (including the top end of new grads).
So my advice to you is to take enough CS classes to find out if you struggle or if the light bulb goes off. If your classmates mostly ask you for help rather than vice versa, and you have trouble figuring out how to explain things to them that just seem obvious to you, then continue in CS. If not, switch to another major.
It's not about finding your passion. It's about finding your capabilities.
5
u/electricfoxx Jul 04 '21
Programming is more than just transcribing words and symbols into a machine. You are a problem solver. There are plenty of problems out there.
My current problem:
Cash register has semi-stable software.
Register sometimes crashes.
Current transaction is lost.
Customer is pissed off.
(There is a reason why registers are called POS.)
3
3
u/nzre Jul 04 '21
I won't answer all your points because most folks have already done so, but...
i've even seen that you dont need at CS degree to be a software engineer
Not having a degree severely limits which jobs you can pursue and which companies will even give you fair consideration. At higher-paying companies they'll actually start filtering by where you got your degree from.
0
Jul 04 '21
[deleted]
1
u/nzre Jul 04 '21
I think you're the exception to the rule. I work at one of FAANG and I've never seen anyone here without a degree in math/engineering/compsci. The hiring process is also pretty picky. It's not to say it doesn't happen that people get hired at these companies from experience alone even without a degree, it does, but some doors will just be closed based on prejudice/hiring simplicity alone. Regarding whether or not stopping for 4 years to get a degree is worth the 3/4 years you'd likely have to postpone the start of your career for compared to bootcamp, I think the safe answer in most cases is yes.
0
Jul 04 '21
[deleted]
1
u/nzre Jul 04 '21
I do know the backgrounds, yes, it's something that we talk about often. The sample is about ~200 people from Brazil and ~50 from the US on the engineering side. It could just be that we're both right and just looking at different biased samples? I'm sure there are actual numbers available somewhere that might help reach a non-biased conclusion.
2
2
u/940387 Jul 04 '21
No, if anything there will be another layer of abstraction and entropy will make things over complicated again, like vms to docker to k8s. Or if business people can just write a spec and the program happen we will all become business people, this is very unlikely tho. If there is an AI singularity there's no telling what will happen, by definition.
2
u/playclothing101 Nov 09 '21
YES there will be a huge oversupply of engineers. If you want to be a software engineer. That has already happened . Don’t get a degree unless from a top school. Also the pay isn’t worth it unless you’re a top performer I.e working for Google, Uber, Lyft. Might be better getting a tech more adjacent role like cyber security, scrum master or product manager
2
Dec 02 '21
the fact we can have a peice of metal do all this math stuff is just amazing in that fact. Im trying to get in software development, since its a field iv been playing around with since grade 6 lmfao.
People say in the comments that alot of people that go into CS, eventually drop out because they dont have the aptitude. Hopefully that wont end up being me lmfao. Im not the best in math, but its my favourite subject so far. Im about to get into calc which im honestly hyped for after binge watching 3blue1brown videos. Before programming seemed easy, and felt like tryna make small mechanisms work with eachother. but then i figured out the math side of this shit, and honestly it just blows my mind. Its borderline amazing seeing how seemingly basic shit has the most interesting math behind it. Never thought i would be actually hyped about learning ahead in shit like integrals and fourier series. I still dont properly comprehend how those formulas get those coefficients, but shit still interesting regardless lmfaooo
Dont know what this rant was supposed to be directed to, but i just wanted to vent lol.
1
u/Lazy_Connection7507 Jan 28 '24
programming seemed easy, and felt like tryna make small mechanisms work with eachother. but then i figured out the math side of this shit, and honestly it just blows my mind. Its borderline amazing seeing how seemingly basic shit has the most interesting math behind it. Never thought i would
btw 3blue1brown videos are pretty cool. but to be excel in maths one has to be natural in maths or has to give a decent amount of attention to simple math concepts piling up to complex problems rather than watching those YouTube videos. If you wanna learn easily about Fourier series, you better ask ChatGPT to explain it a child. That is the good way to start into mathematics. Concerning with the CS, I think the only area where most developers have to apply maths is where they have to deal with complex algorithms and managing serious data loads and some specialized areas like AI and Game programming where heavy calculus arithmetics are required. Otherwise, developers are mostly fine with binary operations, in my opinions.
1
1
u/cyRUs004 Jun 08 '24
Its not 'will", Software Engineering is already "oversaturated". For good or worse.
1
u/Fabulous_Sea2385 May 05 '25
As someone who has spent 3.5 years learning and building a damn good portfolio, I have applied to over 1200 jobs and haven’t even gotten one legitimate interview, phone call or email back. I enrolled in the radiography program at my local college today. Tech is over saturated. Don’t waste your time.
1
u/Objective_Mine MSCS, CS Pro (10+) Jul 03 '21
Will salaries drop? Maybe, I don't know. I wouldn't expect a drastic over-saturation let alone obsolescence, though.
At least in my country, CS has been a large field with lots of students, relatively speaking, for at least a couple of decades. I don't know how the numbers have changed over the years, and it might indeed be that it's an even more popular field to study than it used to be, but just because there are lots of students doesn't mean there will be a surplus of competent workforce. So far the demand has kept up.
As for the abundance of learning materials, that's partially true. Getting started with programming or software development might be easier than it was ten years ago. Tutorials may have been getting better. The usability of development tools may have improved. Programming being advertised as something anyone can do might make it less intimidating to get started.
However, I don't know if I'm a little old-fashioned with how I approach learning (I entered the CS/IT workforce about 15 years ago), but I don't necessarily see the abundance of YouTube videos and programming blogs inflating the supply of programmers. First off, while some of the material is excellent, I think quantity has increased more than quality. Of course you might only need to find one really good set of materials, or one good video to explain a difficult concept, and the other 100 of them not really being that high quality wouldn't matter. But especially when you're starting out, it might be difficult to tell which ones to follow. There are lots of good material, but there are lots of noise as well.
Secondly, while videos and other low-barrier material can sometimes help in understanding concepts, and they could also lower the barrier for getting started, the only way to really learn is by doing, thinking about what you're doing, and having in-depth material to learn from. The real complexity of software development (let alone computer science proper) does not come from having to learn a bit of programming syntax; it comes from software systems being complex and having to operate in a complex environment. I don't know if this comes off as a bit harsh, but people don't gain the expertise for that by watching YouTube videos. The difference between a person who can get some kind of software up and running and an experienced engineer is pretty large. Any well-designed material can help with learning another useful concept or another bit of insight here or there, but it's not going to turn the majority of people into competent developers.
Additionally, while things like getting a relatively simple website up might have been getting easier [1], more complexity keeps being added at the other end. As languages and tools improve, so do the expectations of what a modern website looks like increase. Software security is more complex than ever, if largely because we know more about potential problems than we did in the past. Improved tooling helps save time, but every time a new tool is added, you'll need to learn to use it.
I don't think software engineering is going to become obsolete soon. If engineers need to fear becoming obsolete, it's only because the technology keeps changing at an increasing pace, and keeping up might become harder. But that won't reduce the demand for those who can manage that.
Just my two cents.
[1] I'm honestly not sure this is entirely true either, though; it wasn't prohibitively hard to get some kind of a dynamic website up and running with PHP and some elementary HTML in the early 2000's. The quality might have sucked, and present-day tools probably allow you to get a better-built simple website done easier, but at the same time, the expectations and requirements regarding software quality and security have also increased.
1
Jul 03 '21
I interview a lot of candidates. I see a lot of impressive CVs, but very little in the way of usable skills. And I see a lot of people get hired who can't find their ass with both hands, and become project managers inside of six months. Very few people with engineering resumes actually become and remain engineers.
Caveat: I'm a netsec engineer, not a developer. But I'm confident the situation doesn't change much between the two disciplines.
1
u/MarsLanded Jul 03 '21
Like others have said there is a lot of noise to ignore. Software engineering has many domains. Some areas may be saturated but others lack people with specific skills. At my company it took over a year to fill a position with a qualified individual. Use of computing power will only grow and so will the demand for coders.
1
u/CrazyJohn21 Jul 03 '21
5 friends of mine went for a CS degree. Only one is still getting a CS degree. plus even besides software engineering the united states have a huge cyber security demand which you can do with a CS degree
1
u/var_semicolon Jul 03 '21
I've thought about this myself. I'm a JS developer with a focus on Front-end. Yes SOME things have gotten easier but oddly enough alot of languages are becoming more and more abstract the easier they become. Take SCSS/LESS for example alot of it looks like Assembly at this point. You have to remember that just because the tools have gotten better the tools are useless without the right people. Not everyone can become a developer regardless of how easy it is for the developer to do the job, we know this because the rates continue to grow. Yes, there is alot of new people getting into CS but having a CS degree is hardly ever the first part of actually being a developer. Also, some people get a CS degree and don't even get into programming they become sales or something totally different. Rant over, p.s. you are doing fine, our field and propaganda around our field has always tried making it seem like developers are a dim a dozen, we aren't and from the looks of it, we won't ever be.
1
u/Razor_Storm Jul 04 '21
Working at sf tech companies, we continue to have trouble hiring enough people. The candidate pool expands every year but so do the number of companies who are competing for them. Also despite there being more applicants, the number who actually pass the bar also haven’t risen too quickly.
1
u/Calypsocrunch Jun 04 '22
The field will probably tighten up in the future based on who they let in, but not in scale. A lot of these boot camp graduates are good for entry level, but as soon as the software becomes abstract they tend to fall short and burn out. I think the field is going to remain wide open for those with a CS degree and it will be invaluable when applying for jobs.
1
0
Jul 03 '21
all jobs are going to be automated not just programming.
it is time people stopped confusing education with a shortcut to getting jobs.
study cs if you just want to learn how computers work from a theoretical level. how the universal turing machine led to the von neumann architecture, how the first logic gates were created using transistors, why formal languages and automata theory are essential for creating compilers, or even the history of amazing software systems like the linux kernel or even the internet.
will all this help you stay relevant as an employee after the robots take over? no. you will probably just starve to death. doesn't matter.
51
u/Elkripper Jul 03 '21
There's a lot more software development going on around the world than just building websites. I've built a few along the way, but most of my career has been backend work. The fact that some of the things I build are exposed via a website is often irrelevant to what I'm doing. I can write CSS/HTML when I have to (although obviously not at the level of someone who does it daily). But I go months at a time without even touching any.
This is true. Most of the people I've worked with have degrees in other things, or sometimes no degree at all. However, a solid understanding of the theory behind software development can be very valuable, and a CS degree is a reasonable way to get that. I personally find architecture work fun, and also not the sort of thing that people with bootcamp backgrounds tend to be good at. Sure, exceptions apply, some people are just good at certain things, and you can absolutely learn all that on your own. But a CS degree can give you a leg up on it.