r/AskComputerScience • • Aug 14 '17

Should i buy a Macbook for Software development?

Hi everyone,

I'm a college student currently using a Windows laptop for all my projects. Seen as we mostly work in C# at school, this has all been fine. Recently i have been wanting to get into IOS Development. Unfortunately to do so i need a Mac (i know about Xamarin, but i can't get it to work on my laptop, and i will still need a mac at some stage anyways)

I've been contemplating on selling my old laptop and buying one of the new Macbook pro's. I would dual boot it to run Windows 10 aswell as OSX.

Would this be a good / or bad idea from a developers point of view, and if so why?

3 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

10

u/quacho Aug 14 '17

Obviously a good idea if you want to get into iOS development. Get one with decent storage to accomodate the Windows install.

Dual booting should work fine for C# development. You could also use a VM inside Mac to run Win10 if it's lightweight development. Btw, aren't .NET and Visual Studio available for Mac now? I remember reading something like that but not sure.

If budget is a concern I'd also have a look at used 2016 or even 2015 MacBook Pros, and also the refurbished Apple stuff.

3

u/adipisicing Aug 14 '17

Btw, aren't .NET and Visual Studio available for Mac now?

Sort of.

.NET Core, the next generation of the language runtime and build tools are available. Not all of the APIs that people expect are, though. For example, if you have a course built around creating a web app with IIS, you're going to need a different web server with different APIs on other platforms.

There is a product called Visual Studio for the Mac, but it's actually heavily based upon Xamarin Studio. The interface has some major differences, and I'm not sure whether it can even open .sln files.

If budget is a concern I'd also have a look at used 2016 or even 2015 MacBook Pros, and also the refurbished Apple stuff.

Agreed. Apple refurbs are a great deal, and are eligible for AppleCare. AppleCare is a good idea as a student who is carting around your laptop all the time, and your campus computer repair shop may even accept AppleCare.

0

u/dl1509 Aug 14 '17

Thank you for the advice. Do you think 512GB would be enough to run both Windows and OSX?

Was also wondering if maybe it could be an option to run Windows completely off an external SSD using Bootcamp.

2

u/quacho Aug 14 '17

I run both on 256GB, along with 2 Linux VMs. 512GB would be great.

Windows 10 takes 20-25 GB if I'm right for a clean install. Office and Visual Studio would add significantly more, but I wouldn't think about it if I have a 512GB SSD. Of course your usage may differ, but 512GB is a good amount of storage. Why do you think it wouldn't be?

2

u/Daanvz Aug 14 '17 edited Aug 14 '17

I guess 512 should be enough then. Still wondering if it wouldn't be cheaper to opt for a lower storage model (256gb) and running windows off a cheaper external ssd. That would save some money i think, which is quite useful as a college student haha. Think that's a possibility?

Edit: original post is on my alt accout

1

u/Eduard_Ewout Aug 14 '17

I advice you to take 512 GB of storage at least if you are going to run both Windows and Mac. Windows updates are horrible and take up a lot of space. Also if you want to run your builds fast and make the programming experience fluidly you should grab a Quad core. I have it in mine and it is super fast. Additionally it will be great for the future (3-5Years) since Macs are freaking expensive you should get a good one so you can use it longer ;)

And of course you need the Mac for iOS development :)

Good luck with your search, and please keep us updated on your decision.

1

u/ImaginationGeek Aug 15 '17

Agree. You could get by with a dual-core, but you'll have better VM performance with the quad core. One important thing I didn't see mentioned is RAM. If you're using a VM then you need more system memory than if you just dual booted. I'd say get at least 8 GB, though you might be able to get by on 6 GB if you really must. 4 GB is not enough to have a VM, IMO.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '17

I used a model from 2015 I think with macOS sierra, and it worked perfectly. Don't feel like you have to buy the newest one because it's. Not worth it in my opinion for the price.

1

u/roma-ru Aug 14 '17

Is it possible to run 3 boots osx/win10/ubu ? I have a 1TB ssd in my 2009 macbook pro, splitting it 200GB or so each. Would make the ssd unstable or? Recommendations:?

1

u/autoshag Aug 15 '17

I work at a large silicon valley tech company. Everyone is given the choice between Mac, Windows, and Linux. 99.9% of devs have a Mac. Thats definitely not a coincidence.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '17

[deleted]

5

u/gandalf-the-gray Aug 14 '17

Unix terminal! Linux is open source mac is proprietary

1

u/sierrawhiskeyfoxtrot Aug 14 '17

Not linux. BSD unix. Though you will get comfortable with the unix command line if you use it, it's not 100% the same as Linux.