r/AskCanada • • Dec 19 '24

Approximately 25% of employed Canadians work for the government. How is this sustainable ?

5 Upvotes

As of 2024, approximately 25% of employed Canadians work for the government across various levels (federal, provincial, and municipal). Between 2019 and 2023, public sector employment surged by 13%, outpacing private sector employment growth (3.6%) by 3.6 times. This marked the largest four-year expansion in public sector employment since 1976.

The federal public service, a subset of this broader government employment, has seen even more substantial growth. In 2024, it reached 367,772 employees, an increase of 10,525 from the previous year. Notably, since 2015, the federal public service has expanded by 42%, significantly outpacing Canada's population growth of about 14% during the same period.

How is this Sustainable long term, and do you think this trend will reverse after Trudeau leaves office ?

sources: https://www.canada.ca/en/treasury-board-secretariat/services/innovation/human-resources-statistics.html


r/AskCanada • • Nov 19 '24

We are on track to overshooting the 1.5C global temperature threshold. Even after the fires in Jasper, why does no one seem to care?

17 Upvotes

While I too am frustrated with Trudeau’s policies, I don’t understand how many voters would choose the CPC over NDP. The NDP is proposing a windfall tax for big corporations that profited from the pandemic. The CPC doesn’t have a climate policy and would likely gut environmental regulation. Instead of pushing for a just transition away from fossil fuels, it’s seems that many would rather to continue growing our fossil fuel industries. I’m genuinely trying to understand why people would vote CPC despite this.

Source: https://www.npr.org/2024/11/18/nx-s1-5183222/1-5-celsius-global-warming-climate-change-cop29

Edit: Regarding the comments on China, it would be relevant to note that they are investing heavily into renewables and were projected to peak in terms of emissions this year : https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-chinas-emissions-set-to-fall-in-2024-after-record-growth-in-clean-energy/#:~:text=Lauri%20Myllyvirta,-13.11.2023%20%7C%2012&text=The%20strongest%20growth%20was%20in,and%20newly%20emerging%20interest%20groups.


r/AskCanada • • Jan 06 '25

Is there any chance, a new Liberal leader such as Mark Carney would be able to reduce the conservatives to a minority government?

1 Upvotes

r/AskCanada • • Dec 23 '24

Why don't Canadians seem to like Jagmeet Singh?

0 Upvotes

I like Singh for the following:

  1. Seems a decent person who has overcome a lot

  2. Pushed for better policies with the Libs even though it cost him and NDP some popularity by being associated with them

  3. Even more likeable when compared to Trudeau, Poillievre, and Blanchet. Only May seems on par.

But I get the sense most people just do not like him. If you are one of those people, why?


r/AskCanada • • Jan 09 '25

Should I cancel my trip to Canada?

96 Upvotes

I’m an American who planned a monthlong trip to BC and Alberta in late April. Two of my grandparents were born in NB. I hate Trump, who’s a traitorous criminal in service to Putin and Xi, and I actively encourage both Americans and Canadians to hate him, too.

I understand that Canadians are righteously angry at Americans. I am, too.

Should I cancel my trip?


r/AskCanada • • Jan 04 '25

Why so many people want Trudeau out

391 Upvotes

First I would like to clarify I am not a hardcore Trudeau fan, I am simply puzzled after being in Canada for 8 years.

  1. There is really no good alternatives to him right now, Singh has great ideas but is too weak to act on them. PP is simply a fanatic and a direct replica of Trump. His trickle economy logic looks good at first glance but will just aggravated all the problems that Canada is facing by making the rich (like himself) richer and the poor much poorer.

  2. Come on let's face it, we all say the problem with Canada is with housing, immigration and healthcare and we blame everything on Trudeau, but really the root cause is with income inequality. Say if from tomorrow on everyone in Canada earns the same amount equal to GDP per capita, most of the problems people complain will be gone in a blink.

  3. We should all understand that Trudeau being bad does not mean PP is good. Politics is not a simply binary choice where the con of one party indicate the pro of another party. So far I have not seen any valid political ideas that comes from PP besides attacks on the Liberal party and personal attacks on Trudeau. Be mindful that PP is not new to politics, he have been in it for 20 years.

I really recommend everyone to look at the 2024 BC elections, at how the BC conservatives "almost" became a majority government but shot themselves in the foot at the very last moment, when the final campaign speech by John Rustad is seen clearly as a victory speech (before vote count completes, before any party is declared majority), and from someone first time watching a BC elections campaign speech, the arrogance he had, without any sense of humbleness.

As for the content of the speech, in 20 minutes he never once spoke about how he is going to serve, but rambled on continuous about his adventure on becoming the party leader, and his plans to "relentlessly block" what the NDP (ruling party) is going to present at the legislature...


r/AskCanada • • Jan 13 '25

Future of trans rights in Canada?

2 Upvotes

I (30-something MtF) am feeling a lot of uncertainty about the future. If I've ever felt any sense of patriotism, it's been because Canada has typically been on the leading edge of inclusion and equality, and has generally been more progressive on social issues that have been major hang-ups for other countries. But as I'm progressing in my transition, I'm actively witnessing the pendulum swinging the other way, and that scares me.

Polling from IPSOS shows that Canadians' attitudes towards LGBTQ+ issues have regressed over the last few years [https://www.ipsos.com/en-ca/canadians-support-protection-lgbt-community-but-support-declining ]. There's been a noticeable adoption of right wing American taking points in Canadian political discourse, specifically about trans issues, over the last two years. Provincial leaders are proposing legislation that copies some of the most regressive policies from the States, albeit with less success. But with another Trump presidency and the SCOTUS poised to roll back any guarantee of safety and dignity for trans people, I'm mentally preparing for another deluge of hate. I'm particularly worried what things will look like with Pollievre as PM, given that he's already been taking strategy from the Trump playbook.

I'm not going to detransition; I know that I'm just trying to go about living my best life in peace, and that what I decide to do with my body is nobody's business but mine. I don't think my rights will be legislated away here, but I am worried about a cultural shift away from respect and inclusion. I'm worried about an increase in street harassment, open discrimination, and threats to my personal safety and the safety of trans and queer people across the country. I remember the open hostility towards Muslims, people of colour, and immigrants during the Harper years, and I fear a similar thing will happen under Pollievre.

Anyway, I'm curious to know your thoughts, dear subreddit. Am I getting worried about nothing, or should I be gearing up to defend my basic humanity on a daily basis?

Edit: fixed broken link


r/AskCanada • • Dec 11 '24

How can we as Canada…troll trump back?

0 Upvotes

With all this funny stuff going on…how could we as the Canadian people troll trump?


r/AskCanada • • Jan 20 '25

Trump's inauguration is happening right now, Fell free to vibrate in the comments section

0 Upvotes

Let your anger out people !!!


r/AskCanada • • Oct 02 '24

Why has there been such a backlash against immigration in Canada?

1 Upvotes

As an American from an immigrant background, I’ve always viewed of Canada as a very welcoming nation towards immigrants, several of my family members lived in Canada for decades prior to settling in the United States or Western Europe. Though I’ve noticed recently there has been a huge backlash against immigration that I’ve seen online and in polling on the subject.

Seems like this has accelerated post COVID and is more similar to Western European attitudes towards immigration since it doesn’t seem to be a left/right issue like it is in the States.


r/AskCanada • • Nov 15 '24

What do Canadians think about the Khalistanis saying Canada is their country and white people should go back to europe?

1 Upvotes

Disclaimed : I am an Indian living in India.

I saw a tweet where Khalistanis were starting to claim that Canada as Khalistan and wanted the White people to go back to Europe.

This is the same kind of shit they do with India, while being in canada and America. They represent less than 1% of the sikh poppulation, let it be India or canada.

And If you are taking the percentage of the whole country's poppulation, there are more percentage of Khalistanis in Canada than India.

So what are your thoughts in this subject?

https://x.com/DanielBordmanOG/status/1856837451697844720


r/AskCanada • • Jan 11 '25

People calling for deportations should practice basic self-honesty and admit that what they really want is ethnic cleansing.

0 Upvotes

Boo hoo, you see more Indians working at Tim Horton's now, boo hoo, there are some international students from India now, boo hoo, an Indian was mean to me one time so now I hate anyone with brown skin.

Enough with the excuses. Every few years there's a new scapegoat for problems.


r/AskCanada • • May 09 '25

Political Why are there so few women in the Canadian parliament?

0 Upvotes

Women only make up 30% of the Canadian parliament, which means there are two times more men than women in the parliament. Why do you think that is? What could be done to change it?


r/AskCanada • • Jan 04 '25

Pierre Poilievre's latest Jordan Peterson interview is a clear signal that Canadians need another option. What about The Canadian Future Party?

171 Upvotes

The party's early stances involved positioning themselves as political centrists while trying to differentiate themselves from the Liberal and Conservative Parties. The party's 'interim policy framework' lists five areas of concern: Personal Freedoms, Open Government, Responsible Spending, Stronger Together (At Home), and Stronger Together (Abroad).

Interim Policy Framework

Freedoms

Remaining uninvolved in anything considered a private matter for adult citizens

Governance

Electoral reform resulting in mixed-member proportional representation

Increased public participation in policymaking as part of the legislative process

Greater transparency by ensuring all public government documents are easily available online

Improving the timeliness of responses to the public from government offices

A national internet strategy to protect privacy rights

The creation of an independent office combatting disinformation Combatting abuses of artificial intelligence

Fiscal policy

Reform of the civil service to refocus government efforts to where the most impact can be made

Allowing the private sector to take a larger role in society with government oversight

Simplifying the tax code to close loopholes in cooperation with the provinces and territories

Ending corporate subsidies and supply management where a return on investment cannot be delivered

Improving government procurement based on private sector best practices

Lowering the national debt

Domestic policy

Combatting climate change with carbon capture, nuclear, renewables, and democratically sourced fossil fuels

Imposing the costs of emissions on large emitters rather than directly on citizens

Respecting areas of provincial authority and ensuring data is shared on how federal money is used

Negotiate self-government and resource sharing agreements with First Nations

Forming a national civil defence corps to handle national disasters and provide opportunities to youth

Restructuring the RCMP into a domestic intelligence service and leaving policing to the provinces and territories

Working with the provinces and territories to build housing and direct immigrants to areas they are needed

Ensuring provinces and territories share data on healthcare spending

Allowing immigrants qualified in healthcare to be assessed for work within six months

Investing in scientific research and development to attract Canadian youth and immigrants to tech roles

Foreign policy

A comprehensive review of foreign and defence policy

Supporting an alliance of democracies starting with Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom

Increase military spending to 2% of GDP to meet NATO goals

Russo-Ukrainian War

The Canadian Future Party supports the aid granted by the Government of Canada to Ukraine since Russia's full-scale invasion of the country began in February 2022. It has also been critical of the Conservative Party for voting against the Canada–Ukraine Free Trade Agreement over the language on carbon pricing, claiming they sacrificed Ukrainian interests to appease pro-Russian and climate change denying influencers on social media. The Future Party calls for more monetary, diplomatic, and material aid to be given to Ukraine. It also would like to see greater spending on the Canadian Forces to support NATO and other democracies globally, and has expressed discontent with cuts to defence spending by the Liberal Party.

Housing

Citing forecasts by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation that five million new housing units will be needed by 2030 to meet current needs, the Canadian Future Party has proposed directly involving the federal government in new developments. It proposes first engaging in areas under federal responsibility, such as housing for military bases and government employees, which can take pressure off of local supply. This housing would also prioritize the use of new technologies to minimize their environmental impact. Housing for indigenous communities is also something the party would look into, building off-reserve stock to address their needs.

Furthermore, the party aims to encourage remote work. Ultimatums requiring employees to return to the office are seen as a negative factor in dense urban centres. Flexible workforces are seen as a possible solution to maximizing existing housing stock. The party also sees it as a way to revitalize smaller communities across the country in the process of alleviating large cities.

Foreign interference

The Canadian Future Party expressed concerns regarding allegations of the Liberal nomination of Han Dong in Don Valley North having been subject to foreign interference. Referring to a report by the Foreign Interference Commission, which stated that nomination contests can be gateways for foreign states wishing to interfere in democratic processes, the following four recommendations were put forward for the party's own operations:

Only Canadian citizens can become voting members of the Canadian Future Party

Permanent residents can be engaged but will be given observer status

Voting members will have to join the party in advance of a nomination to participate

The disclosure of any candidate's relationship to a foreign power will be required

Bill C-70 has been described by the party as containing many positive elements they have called for. These include the foreign agent registry, new powers for CSIS, and new criminal offences aimed at protecting Canadian institutions. An additional recommendation was made to amend the Elections Act to strengthen oversight over party nominations. Due to the possibility that Bill C-70 may not be in force in time for a future election, it was suggested that Elections Canada create voluntary guidelines for all federal parties to update their nomination processes beforehand.


r/AskCanada • • Dec 17 '24

How can anyone think the NDP would run a competent government?

0 Upvotes
  • Trudeau pushes through a gst holiday and tries to pass $250 cheques over the objections of his finance minister and amid ballooning spending.

  • Jagmeet votes down the $250 cheques because he wants them sent to even more people.

  • The finance minister resigns over conflict with the PM over spending.

  • The NDP then say the PM should resign and afterwards we find out Canada really is in a huge deficit.

I know the NDP has zero chance of forming a government but how can anyone realistically think they would be competent after witnessing such a disconnection from reality and endless conflicting messaging?


r/AskCanada • • Nov 15 '24

How much have the pro Palestine protests affected your stance on the matter? And to which side.

23 Upvotes

No matter what part of the country/ North America you are, you must have seen/ heard about/ been a part of/ faced a Palestine protest.

How effective has it been towards changing YOUR mind ? Do you lean more one way or the other ? Do you lean more towards “don’t care” now ?

Edit- I’m not asking you to take a side. Dont know why a question would piss some people off. Don’t shoot the messenger.


r/AskCanada • • Dec 06 '24

Why does this sub put up with all the blatant racism?

0 Upvotes

It seems like most of the posts are thinly-veiled xenophobic ejaculations.


r/AskCanada • • Nov 29 '24

How were the international students supposed to benefit Canada?

0 Upvotes

From what I understand, the intention was for them to get an education and leave. But how does this help Canada? What was the point if they take their new skills back home? - From, Freedom Land


r/AskCanada • • Nov 18 '25

Why do so many people say that Canada is “cooked” or screwed after the budget passed?

0 Upvotes

An


r/AskCanada • • Dec 25 '24

How much of the outcry over Trudeau is bots and propagandists?

330 Upvotes

Trudeau's not perfect, quite obviously. No sitting PM is; they all accrue wins and losses while in office, and Trudeau's had some of both. He has failed in a number of ways, and perhaps most critically, he's failed to deliver some of his promises and has failed to take ownership and responsibility for those failures. We all have our personal picadillo's ... SNC Lavelin ... Electoral Reform ... lack of attention on the affordability crisis ... inability to get renegade and distructive premier's under control ... continuing failure to meet NATO obligations ... the list goes on and on.

That said ... compare him to the orange small handed man, Ron DeSantis, or Matt Gaetz and you'll get a sobering look at how far from the bottom of the barrel he is. And, compare what he's said and what he's done to Poilievre ... and at least for me you see a posivie and hopeful leader ... and a petulant child who's only tool is blaming others.

As we head into an election next year, during a time when we really need mature and capible leadership, I have to admit that as much as I dislike Trudeau ... there seem few alternatives.


r/AskCanada • • Jan 21 '25

Question for Conservatives

9 Upvotes

So we know that Nazis, racists, bigots, transphobes, anti-vax and other conspiracy theorists, foreign adversaries like Russia, and billionaires only looking to enrich themselves off the backs of middle/working class all support Poilievre for PM. Given the company he keeps, why do you support him?


r/AskCanada • • Jan 04 '25

As a Canadian, why should I care about foreign issues?

20 Upvotes

Let's take the Israel-Palestine conflict for example. I'm not Israeli or Palestinian. I have no ties to that part of the world and I've never been there. Nor would the leaders of either side listen to or care about anything I have to say about their conflict. So why should I care and why would I want my government to be involved in that mess instead of focusing on what's going on in Canada?

I saw a news story where a pro-Palestinian activist in Canada was complaining that he wasn't welcomed in some pro-Palestinian organizations because he's not Palestinian. As for Israel, the country was explicitly founded as a Jewish state, and everyone who is Jewish (by descent and maybe by conversion as well) has a constitutional right to become a citizen. Non-Jews can become citizens, but have to renounce their previous citizenship.

So basically Israel is explicitly a country that is mainly for Jews, and openly discriminate against non-Jewish people immigrating there. Likewise, Palestinian organizations opposing Israel, at least in Canada, are basically excluding non-Palestinians.

That tells you everything you need to know about this conflict. This is an issue that doesn't apply to people outside of their groups. So I don't see why Canada should be involved in it at all.

Same goes for all these other foreign conflicts. That thing with the Sikh Punjabi Khalistani separatists in India vs. the Hindu-dominated government has nothing to do with us either. I'm neither a Punjabi Sikh separatist nor a Hindu Indian nationalist. I've never been to India.

I think the Canadian government should be making sure all Canadians have access to healthcare and housing, not worrying about foreign conflicts that have nothing to do with most Canadians.


r/AskCanada • • Nov 30 '24

What did Stephen Harper do wrong that caused Canadians to vote in Trudeau as prime minister in 2015?

3 Upvotes

… and why are Canadians likely to vote Pierre Poilievre and the Conservatives in office in the next election?


r/AskCanada • • Dec 09 '24

Why does Canada look so similar and identical to the US in so many terms?

0 Upvotes

Like Canada looks so similar to the US in so many ways and looks very indistinguishable in alot of terms. Canada has big box stores (Walmart, Costco, etc) just like in the US and with the same architecture/design. The design of big box stores there is different from my home country of Thailand, Canada even have strip malls that look like strip malls in the US. The highways look no different from the US but execpt for that it has different signs and managed by different authorities (speaking of signs, Canada and the US use the same font but execpt for that Canada uses metric units but still look pretty darn similar.). The typical Canadian city (ok we're not gonna get into how Toronto or Vancouver is different but tbh it is similar if we don't count the landmarks or whatever, the cities we're talking about here is stuff like St.Catherines and London, Ontario) looks no different from an American city. Canada even have McDonald's, KFC and other fast food restaurants with architecture and design looking so similar to the ones in the US. and also a Chick-Fil A and Canadian suburbs looks just like the American suburbs. But for Quebec I am not sure but I assume it is different from the rest of Canada.