r/AskBaking • • Sep 25 '25

Cakes Angel food cake with blood, troubleshooting.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hello! Complete amateur- Ive challenged myself to make an angel food cake with half eggs and half pork blood as an egg substitute. Made a half-batch today that went really well (awesome texture, moist, not dense) EXCEPT for when it reaches its peak height in the oven, it deflates!

is this inevitable? Can i be a cheater and sneak in baking soda? do i whip it to even stiffer peaks?

recipe is here, i halfed it: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/15432/angel-food-cake-iii/


r/AskBaking • • Apr 20 '25

Cookies This cookie recipe is a lie lol. They come out NOTHING like the picture. They are just bland, bread-y lemon cookies. I wonder if baking them for 8-9 minutes and then basting them with a bunch of hot melted butter then finishing them on high broil for 2 or 3 minutes would create this result?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm at 5800' elevation so I baked 15° hotter and added an extra 1/2 egg and 3 tbsp butter. I basted them in melted butter after they finished in the oven and they are light and fluffy and delicious. But not cracked or crispy at all. Also, the recipe calls for dusting them with powdered sugar but it's dead obvious that they are topped with granulated sugar in the pictures. I hate when people post click bait recipes 😒


r/AskBaking • • Jun 14 '26

Techniques are silicone molds non-stick? forgot to spray ):

Post image
0 Upvotes

forgot to spray my silicone molds with cooking spray before placing bread pieces & custard in the molds. will these give me hell trying to release them after baking??


r/AskBaking • • Dec 17 '25

Cookies Why do my peanut butter protein cookies come out pale?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Here’s the ingredients:

Pescience vanilla whey/casein blend

Coconut flour

Peanut butter

Egg

Egg white

Baking powder

Vanilla extract

Bake for 6 minutes at 350

For some reason when I bake them, they come out all crumbly and pale. taste delicious but just any idea why?


r/AskBaking • • May 25 '24

Cookies What happened to my aquafaba merengues…

Post image
0 Upvotes

They just… evaporated? I did use monkfruit sweetener instead of regular white sugar, so was that what affected it?

The only ingredients I used were aquafaba (salt included) and monkfruit sweetener.


r/AskBaking • • Apr 28 '26

Cakes/Cheesecakes First cheesecake

Post image
12 Upvotes

I made my cheesecake with 550g cream cheese, 120g sugar, 280g heavy cream, and 3 eggs, baked at 220°C (425°F) for 20 minutes, followed by a 3 min full grill/broil. I would like it to be more liquid/runny inside, what should I do?"


r/AskBaking • • Sep 01 '26

Cookies What's the appeal of browned butter?

0 Upvotes

I don't understand the appeal of browned butter. People say it adds a nutty flavor but that's...not really the flavor I taste. Even if it was, why not just add a nut extract?

Is it just the latest fad like sous vide was a few years ago? Or did I miss an episode of some Gordon Ramsey show where the six-year-old impressed all the judges with her deconstructed brown butter peach cobbler with a butternut squash reduction?

I've tried it in a few different cookie recipes (choc. chip, etc.), but I didn't feel like it made any of them better. It wasn't horrible, just... unnecessary. At least in my opinion.

Is there a recipe/food that absolutely needs browned butter? Or can I just go back to lazily using regular ol' butter in all my recipes? Thanks


r/AskBaking • • Aug 27 '26

Ingredients Crisco Alternative?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hello All! I'm planning on making a chick fil a cookie copycat recipe that calls for 50:50 butter and crisco. I'm looking for a healthier shortening alternative and I found an avocado oil shortening that I'm considering. Would that work? I don't want to drop $12 on an ingredient that would ruin my cookies. Thanks!


r/AskBaking • • May 21 '25

General Why are muffins baked in the little reased paper cups? Is there a purpose or is it just for decoration?

0 Upvotes

I tried using the little paper cups when I first made muffins at home and they just stuck to the muffins and the paper tore in little pieces when I tried peeling it off, it was impossible to eat the muffins without eating bits of paper. Since then I just skip the paper and the muffins turn out fine, they're just a little crunchy at the bottom.

Is there a reason why muffins are made in these cups? Is it there for decoration? Is there some kind of muffin superstition I'm not aware of since I'm not from a muffin-making culture? I can't think of another desert that's baked and served in paper like this.


r/AskBaking • • Sep 18 '26

Pie Question for experienced bakers: can I use egg whites instead of whole eggs for pumpkin pie?

Post image
8 Upvotes

I’m vegan and normally make pumpkin pie recipes that use cornstarch as a binder, and while they work well and taste great I have recently been using this product and wanted to experiment to see if it would work for pumpkin pie. I would use coconut cream as well in the recipe, which should add a good amount of fat to replace the egg yolks. I have used this product successfully in many baking recipes before, including some amazing meringue, it works exactly like regular egg whites since it is, but I have yet to use it in anything custard based like pumpkin pie. Any experienced bakers want to weigh on this? :) thank you!


r/AskBaking • • May 27 '26

Cakes/Cheesecakes Why is my cake so dense?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Why do my cakes keep coming out like this? The last cake I made was really dense as well (But it was vanilla). This cake seems even more dense. You could see it. When I first took it out of the oven it was really tall and when it fully cooled down it was this short, deflated a lot. The outside is really hard and the inside is dense. You can see how dry and hard it is by the color change. I followed the recipe (I kind of made it my own because I put chocolate in it but I added a little bit of milk), but the vanilla cake I made, I followed to a T. I forgot to take pictures of it but just imagine same density, but vanilla. Nothing was expired, all ingredients were fresh (to my knowledge).

For the chocolate cake: I did pinch a little bit off the top when it was still piping hot to taste it, it was nice and fluffy. When it came out it was already cracked down the middle almost to the edges so I figured it wouldn't hurt too much to pinch a little bit off to taste. I took it away from the heat to cool down and I kept it in the hot pan for a while (I used my cheesecake pan so I was able to take just the sides off but the bottom was still on it) I live near sea level, and the house was slightly cold but still room temperature (probably around 65-70).

The recipe I followed: https://tastesbetterfromscratch.com/homemade-rum-cake/

The Cocoa measurements I followed: https://bakersroyale.com/chocolate-rum-cake/

For the vanilla cake: I took it out, put it somewhere away from the heat but I used a regular cake pan so I wasn't able to take the sides off and it still was really dense like this, and deflated. The only difference is that it wasn't ~as~ dense (But still very dense!), and the sides were not all hard like the chocolate one. Nevertheless, the textures were nearly identical. That was back in April, it was slightly warmer so I don't think that would have made a difference 🤔. I followed the recipe to a T, The only things I didn't do was weigh everything, and measured the temperature with a thermometer (don't have a scale or thermometer). The only thing I have is my thermostat and the temperature on the oven. Here is the recipe: https://wonkywonderful.com/buttermilk-vanilla-cake-recipe-from-scratch/#recipe


r/AskBaking • • Feb 14 '26

Ingredients How best to keep butter from oxidizing in the fridge?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I swear this fridge oxidizes butter faster than any I’ve ever had before. Will storing it in a plastic bag help? I know freezer is best for longer term but I like to keep a couple in the fridge so I don’t have to remember to defrost ahead of time.


r/AskBaking • • Oct 19 '25

Techniques Trying to mix melted butter and sugar together. What went wrong?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm trying to follow Tasty's fudgy brownies recipe on Youtube. I reduced 1¼ cups to 70 gr. I ended up mixing it for 30 mins since I thought it's gonna eventually mixed and get fluffier. I'm worried it has too much air from overmixing now.

I'd appreciate any advice. Thank you!

Edit: Thank you for everyone who helped. I only just replied because I was busy after making the brownies. I've now known not to take suggestions from Youtube comments since they probably didn't tell the full story or fake, that I can't willy nilly change the recipe, and that sugar isn't just for sweetening.


r/AskBaking • • 18d ago

Brownies/Chocolate Greasy vegan brownies

Post image
7 Upvotes

I have quite a banger of a normal brownies recipe, with help from The Elements of Baking-cookbook I’m trying to make them vegan.

I’m using the same amount of vegan butter versus normal.
To replace my eggs I’m using soy milk, and adding some cornstarch, flour and baking powder as she suggests.

But I get these “puddles” of vegan butter on the bottom of the brownies and would like to fix that.
I’ve reduced butter amounts already, but the texture is off then. So I don’t know how to go about this?


r/AskBaking • • Feb 22 '25

Bread What is the worst thing to cook in and why is it glass??

1 Upvotes

Very bitter about my milk bread not being cooked through to the center 😡😡


r/AskBaking • • Feb 04 '24

Cakes American recipes are sickeningly sweet

0 Upvotes

I started baking at home recently and made some cakes and pastries based on American recipes.I’ve found that American recipes contain TOO MUCH sugar. Yesterday was the death blow when I was trying to make cream cheese and almost all recipes called for 4 cups of powdered sugar (448 gr).I couldn’t believe my eyes.I thought maybe I was calculating something wrong and finally decided to use only 90 gr of sugar.My mom and I tasted it and agreed that it was pretty sweet. So my question is are all the people who give 5 star ratings okay with this much of sweetness? And if not where can I find good recipes for cakes and pastries that are not overly sweet but still moist? Also almost all cakes are made with butter which I think makes them very heavy.The amount of butter and sugar used in cakes is crazy.(I know sweets are not supposed to be healthy but anyways) Sorry for my bad English it’s actually my third language.


r/AskBaking • • Sep 03 '26

Cakes/Cheesecakes Using expired vegetable oil in a cake

2 Upvotes

CRYING because I just put my cake batter in the oven (broma bakery chocolate cake) and when I was cleaning up I realized the vegetable oil I used expired in 2021 😭😭 I thought it was the new bottle of oil I just bought but NOPE it’s old vegetable oil that my boyfriend has had in the cabinet from a long ass time ago. Pretty sure I know the answer I’ll receive here and that it’s not safe to eat so I’m going to throw the cakes away and restart but I’m so upset rn 😭


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Why did my banana bread came out like this dense and wet?

Post image
5 Upvotes

What happened to my banana bread? Before i take it out from the oven, I did the toothpick test. The toothpick came out clean. However when cooled down it became like this. It’s not chewy it melts in your mouth even the open crumb looking part - it’s actually doughy and wet.
I used loaf bread pan, maybe it was too deep? Idk.

The recipe i used
4 bananas
100 g sugar
100 g light Brown sugar
200 ml buttermilk
2 eggs
170 ml melted butter
320 g flour
5 g baking soda
6 g baking powder
Cinnamon, salt, vanilla

Thanks in advance


r/AskBaking • • Jan 31 '24

Doughs What did i do wrong?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm making buns, and i had a trouble making the dough, it's suposed to feel like, dough, but instead i ended up having a gooey consistance, do i need to add more flour the next time? More yeast too? More of every dry ingredient or less milk or eggs or what should i do? It is my first time making bread-

(my sister took a ball of the vready goo and dropped it in the flour bottle, we bakes it alongsode it and turned out tasting like a "Micha" (The type of bread in spanish) and looking like it, so i don't know-)


r/AskBaking • • May 29 '26

Techniques I always wanted a chocolate lava wedding cake when I get married, and have a couple theories about how to do it. Thoughts?

3 Upvotes

Idea 1) Have a wedding cake with a hollow tube cut out of it fitted with a tube of hard caramel. Before serving, fill the tube with hot dark chocolate or warm ganache so that when you cut into it it has the molten chocolate effect.

Idea 2) Use some sort of electric feature to pump chocolate into the cake, similar to a chocolate fountain.

Last resort) have multiple layers separated on a structure so that you can have each individual layer be molten chocolate cake.

Edit: Yes I obviously know that I could just serve regular chocolate lava cakes.


r/AskBaking • • Aug 06 '26

Cakes/Cheesecakes Fix an avocado cheesecake that has a bitter aftertaste

Post image
1 Upvotes

I made an avocado cheesecake and I didn't notice any bitterness while tasting the batter but after baking the result was a nice cheesecake that smacks u with a bitter aftertaste and I have no idea what to do about it 😭 would covering the cake in a sweet sauce help mask it?


r/AskBaking • • Mar 22 '26

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Is it possible to make icing using only lemon extract and flour, with no heat?

4 Upvotes

EDIT: Thanks so much for your comments, everyone! After reading responses here and also after my husband tried another kind of search, I figured my son must have meant powdered sugar, not flour. I was confused because my son and I often bake together and we've made icing using powdered sugar before, so I figured he would have remembered it. But when I showed some to him and had him taste a little, he said that this was what the teacher had used, not flour.

As for the teacher, I should have mentioned that this was a substitute, not a regular teacher, so I wasn't able to contact them.

Thanks again for your help, everyone. I was thinking I should delete this post since the question really came down to a kid's mistake (and my going along with it). But maybe there's another parent out there who'll find themself in a similar situation, so maybe I should leave it up.

ORIGINAL POST:

My 11-year-old did an activity at school the other day where he says a teacher mixed flour and lemon extract to create an amazing icing. He wanted to know if I could make the same thing to put on top of his homemade birthday cake. (We live in a country where pre-made icing isn't available and practically no one ices cakes, so unfortunately, there are no mixes, pre-made products, etc., like this. All icing has to be homemade.)

Every recipe I've found for a lemon/lemon extract icing with flour comes up as ermine frosting or flour frosting, and includes these ingredients but also a milk/cream element (usually just milk) and sugar, at least. Every recipe I've found also involves heating up the mixture to create the icing.

But my son insists there was nothing added but flour and lemon extract and there was no heat involved.

I can maybe understand why he'd say there was no heat, since this was done in a classroom. But I can't find any recipe for flour icing that doesn't involve heating it up, and I can't find one that is only lemon extract and flour.

Does anyone know of a recipe like this? Is it even possible to make icing like this?

Any help would be appreciated, especially since I have to make this cake for tomorrow night.


r/AskBaking • • Jun 16 '26

Cookies How to get soft and chewy cookies?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I like to make cookies with oats but I can never get them to be soft and chewy! I follow the recipe and they’re always thick, dry, and crumbly. I have an oven thermometer so I know that the temperature is accurate. What else can I do?

Edit:

Here’s the recipe: https://bakingbites.com/2016/03/dried-peach-oatmeal-cookies/

But this happens with every oat recipe I use


r/AskBaking • • 17d ago

Pie When you don't want cocoa, what can you substitute?

Post image
0 Upvotes

This traditional homemade recipe has been passed down through our family from parent to child all the way back to an ad clipped out of a magazine in the 70s for the 1934 Hershey's Cookbook. I like chocolate just fine but I thought it might be fun to try making it with a different flavor.

What can you substitute for cocoa (sprcifically Hershey's cocoa or similar) that provides a flavor that is not chocolatey? Like maybe ginger or Christmas spices or… I don't know, just brainstorming. It's not all that difficult to find substitutions for when you don't want a flavor, except chocolate.

There are a bunch of posts here describing how you can (or can not) substitute a different chocolate for cocoa, or make up for volume if you're a bit short, but I couldn't find anything for substituting when you just want to taste a second flavor for once.

(yes, the pie is excessively sweet & somewhat crude, but you try it, it's pretty tasty)