You know the kind of discourse I'm talking about.
It's true that South Korea has real social problems, such as inadequate welfare for young people who fail to find employment, elderly poverty, gender discrimination, and the gap between Seoul and the rest of the country.
But there are people who seem to have learned about Korea only through Parasite, Squid Game, and Teach You a Lesson. They end up believing that South Korea is an extreme dystopia where every evil in the world is at its worst—that corporate capitalism is even more oppressive than in the United States, that sexism is as severe as in Islamic fundamentalist countries, that naturally attractive men or women simply cannot exist, that no one can naturally have fair skin because everyone has undergone skin-whitening treatments, that the entire population is addicted to plastic surgery, enslaved by Samsung, and either a school bully or a victim of school bullying. That's the kind of narrative I'm talking about.
What's even funnier is that some of these people are huge fans of K-pop or Korean actors, with Korean celebrities as their profile pictures on Twitter, yet they'll turn around and say things like, "South Korea is nothing but a prison where those handsome oppas and beautiful unnies are trapped." Then they try to lecture actual Koreans about Korean society and Korean history—even though their "sources" are Panchoa and TikTok.
What's funny is that the exact opposite seems to happen with weeaboos, who idolize Japan—the country that paved the way as a modern soft-power superpower before South Korea.
Japan has its own well-known social problems. Until recently, female doctors were not even allowed to step into the sumo ring for ceremonial purposes. Princesses still cannot inherit the Chrysanthemum Throne, and there are politicians—including women—who defend aspects of Japan's traditionally patriarchal social norms. The economy has struggled for more than three decades, anti-immigrant sentiment has become increasingly visible, and there are even far-right political groups. Historically, Japan was also responsible for atrocities such as the massacre of Koreans following the Great Kantō Earthquake.
Yet, despite all of that, many weeaboos continue to romanticize Japan as a fascinating country of samurai, ninja, giant monsters, pocket monsters, virtual singers, and even anime full of panty shots of schoolgirls—things they often find far more "appealing." Some even glorify darker parts of Japan's past, such as the kamikaze and kaiten suicide attacks, the battleship Yamato, or the Rising Sun flag, portraying them as symbols of the "honorable spirit of the samurai."
I am actually an otaku myself who enjoys ecchi manga like To Love-Ru Darkness. However, I also understand that even in Japanese society, these kinds of works are niche content enjoyed by people with tastes like mine. They are closer to what you would call a "guilty pleasure" and exist on the edge of social acceptability, carefully walking a fine line.
Where do you think this contrast comes from?