Disclaimer, this is my own reasoning and posted merely for generating discussion. By no means is this a decree for people to give up their fav Korean products. Also, I’m a paranoid fuck.
Firstly, I live in Hongcouver so my AB options are wide and bountiful as long as I am willing to step outside (ha). I will not and need not put up with this whole shipping debacle. Even other Canadians that live near a T&T and a Superstore within the vicinity of said T&T will find some pretty decent options. The Ordinary is also situated in Canada so we have that going on for us.
A while I ago I came across this post. While I always suspected this to be the case (since I’m Asian and know exactly how pricey ginseng is) I never consciously thought too much about it until then. After that post I started to critically examine the situation and the things that come out of Korea. If the government can’t even control something as easily verifiable as fake ginseng, what else can’t they regulate?
All this is especially concerning when Korea’s cosmetic export business is going through rapid growth – what other things are going under the radar? What corners are being cut in order to meet the rapid demand? Are all the exotic plant extract actually what they claim to be? Is anyone monitoring how they are grown? You know, to prevent people from using potentially dangerous pesticides to maximize yield and profit. Or sourcing them from places like China where even food safety is highly questionable.
Also, how much do the Korean government actually care about these things that are hidden out of sight but are important for consumers even if they may not be aware of it? Korea’s cosmetic exports is about $2.4 billion in 2015 so I’ll just go out on a limb and say that ousting big cosmetic brand names for having fake ingredients will probably not be favorable for the national tax department. All this is, of course, merely speculatory deductions so anyone with more insight are welcomed to share their experiences.
Anyways, since then I’ve been considering going full Western and Japanese (which T&T has a lot of and is actually comparative to online prices when it goes on sale regularly. Maybe +$1 for the instant satisfaction). Japanese cosmetics have a much longer history and stellar track records so I feel very confident purchasing from them (some cosmetic companies are literally more than a edit:thousand hundred year old!).
This whole thing with Canada Customs/Post and Korean online companies changing their shipping policies is probably the last push I needed. I will not be repurchasing any of my current Korean stuff.
Except for Cosrx cuz first love is hard to deny. -Although this is also subject to change. I have send them an email regarding ingredient sourcing along with other questions around a month ago and still have not heard back from them. This is in comparison to Kikumasamune where a representative replied to me within the week. (Thanks Masato-san!) I will try again and post it on Cosrx's social media sites when I have time.
So far I’m set and feel no regrets.
Edit 1: To all the people down-voting, please also post a reply as to why you disagree! Isn't it better to have your reasoning heard than silently thumbing down? :c
Edit 2: The above edit was made when I was getting +9 upvotes then -9 downvotes with no comments as to why they are downvoting. I am glad people are voicing up there and there are some items I wish to put here so I don't have to reply to the 12th person mentioning it:
1. Since I started AB last year three posts popped up on my news feed.
https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/comments/4ztiku/anyone_aware_on_ongoing_sheet_mask_hygiene_issue/
https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/comments/5ildwu/illegal_korean_cosmetic_samples_sold_4_billion/
https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/comments/5n3hx2/psa_almost_all_red_ginseng_products_sold_in_korea/dc8x941/
All these are issues popping up from Korea. I did not actively seek this kind of posts out and I have not seen anything close to such things for Japanese products (or western products) for that matter.
2. People replying with "Japan/FDA/Health Canada/X is just as bad"
No they are not. Any individual company can do illegal shit (based on some user's comments who won't actually share exactly what those illegal activities are...). However, I have not seen anything close to the scale in which it happens in Korea. (To be honest, I really hoped that the fake ginseng was actually fake news, but of all the people disagreeing with me none of them addressed this issue.)
Imagine if on the news next it got announced that Nuetrogena, Aveeno, Cerave, L'Oreal, etc. had all been using the SAME FAKE ingredient in their products. Can you imagine it? I cannot. Those companies will all get their pants sued off if something like this came to light. Curious, what happened to all those companies (pretty much everyone) that used fake ginseng? Any serious repercussions? Hmmmm....So no, not every country's cosmetic standard is "equal".
And to the people who really believe that American stuff is "just as bad" should write to their Representatives and outline their concerns with the massive cosmetic fraud that is going on. Do Western companies mislead the consumers? Definitely. However, this can easily avoid with a little consumer education. The same cannot be said when a large amount of brand name companies flat out LIES on their ingredient lists.
What I have a problem with is not even the regulations of each individual country's regulatory body - and trust me, I got beef with all of them. What bothers me is the widespread FRAUD that is taking place in Korea and the government is ineffective (for whatever reasons) in preventing it.
3. Some users (not going to mention names) is taking this opportunity to show their blatant racism towards Japanese people
I asked another user to dig up dirt on Japanese cosmetic industry as I could not find any. Instead, WWII gets mentioned. How Japanese people and companies were awful to Koreans, etc. Sorry, I made this thread to discuss the trustworthiness of cosmetic products. I refuse to talk politics to you.
"Japan don't have cosmetic scandals because they are a secretive people who are better at hiding them," was essentially the comment I got back.
No, it is not because Japan may actually not have these type of problems because they have a longer cosmetic history, is wealthier country, have a more efficient regulatory body, provides its enforcers with more resources, or any other logical reasonings. No, there are no Japanese cosmetic scandals because the Japanese people as a whole are more shaddier of a people than the Koreans who let their scandals be known to others. Users of this subreddit, are you really okay with this? These type comments are getting upvoted too. As an Asian Beauty community, is this really something that is acceptable here???
4. My Apologies
I am truly sorry. I started this thread to generate discussion. Maybe to be given counter evidence that will restore my faith in Korea's rapidly expanding cosmetic industry. Instead, I get called a xenophobe (for daring to not have confidence in a country riddled with scandals) and ended up attracting people who see this (admittingly unpopular) opinion thread as a socially acceptable outlet to bash on Japanese people. If the mods feel like this thread needs to be locked up then no hard feelings, I completely understand.