There’s been a lot of discussion over whether ai art is real art or not and whether ai artworks deserve to stand alongside other digital art, so I’m just going to give my two cents.
AI art CAN be art, but not in the way most people use it.
Firstly, I do think that whatever aspect of an entity is considered “art” is entirely the human involvement of the entity. A mountain range is beautiful, but it is not art. The existence of a mountain range in a photograph is not art, but the decision to photograph it and frame it in that moment and manner by a photographer is art. Based on the level of intention and the prospect of the human involvement, we can then subjectively judge the artistic merit of a piece. Even art pieces where the intention is unknown always generate discussion because of either the artist's technique, or their choice to include aspects of the piece, regardless of interpreted meaning.
In this sense, it’s easy to see why there’s so much discourse surrounding AI art. Most of it thrives on visual beauty, and the actual technical aspects of it are independent of human involvement. There is no art in making an ai picture that has good rendering or pretty visuals, because that aspect of ai art is automated. I do believe, however, the decision to include content in the ai art, and whatever human involvement was required to direct the ai art IS the artistic aspect of an ai image.
Now, my biggest gripe with classifying ai images as “art” is not necessarily calling it “art” but by comparing its artistic merit to the art forms in the mediums it imitates. An AI generated Painting is NOT a digital painting. Digital painting is a medium, and there is no painting involved in generating an AI “painting”. What it IS, is digital image generation. The easiest way to think of this is photography. AI images are to digital painting what photography is to hyperrealistic painting. Yes, visually, they are very similar. But artistically, as an art form, as a craft, they are not comparable. I think the exact same visual can have different artistic merit depending on the medium. A hyperrealistic painting of an apple will likely have more artistic merit among viewers than a simple PNG of an apple printed out. Photography, in that case, is not about the accuracy or realism of the depiction, and instead about the composition and the idea behind capturing the image.
I believe AI images are what some could call “digital photography”. Just like the apple example, the exact same painting made using digital brushes would likely have more artistic merit than if it were generated by AI. As such, the only way an AI “artist” can create artistic merit is through the human involvement that is actually present in AI art, and that is the content of the image, i.e, the prompt. I heavily disagree with the idea that most digital art has been “outperformed” by AI, and that AI can make “better paintings” than digital artists, because they’re simply not in the same art form, they’re not paintings.
This is where I stand in the middle of the debate, slightly leaning “anti-ai” art but not in the typical way. I do believe that aspect of AI art is artistic, but in 99% of cases, there’s very little room for actual artistic expression, and very few AI art pieces I’ve seen so far have managed to make use of what little human involvement there is to make something more profound. Because of this, AI art as an art form is just boring to me, atleast right now, because people are focusing more on the pretty visual than the idea behind the image. And a pretty visual created by a machine is not that interesting by itself, because that is the norm for AI imagery, just like hyperrealism is the norm for photography. If someone can create an image where simply the content, the actual story being depicted, is profound, then I will fully accept it as “good art”.