While it might not prevent job loss, I believe it's reasonable and respectable that people would like the option to opt out of having their work used for training AI, without having to remove it from public view or depriving humans of the chance to engage with it in more traditional ways.
The staunch Pro-AI side would say that our artwork is part of the public space, and so anything can be done with it. But the thing is, our understanding of public space was different at the time at which we shared our artwork. Our understanding of "public" changes when new tech like AI enters the scene, and it requires us to re-evaluate the situation rather than simply adhere to past rules based on past situations.
An example I like to use (which I'm sure I don't have to explain to you all because you already feel it inside), is a public square where security cameras are already allowed for safety purposes.
These cameras merely record what happens; they don't analyze the data. Now, imagine a new scenario where the cameras are not just recording but also using advanced software to analyze your movements, behavior, and facial features to create detailed virtual profiles or clones of you. In many jurisdictions, this added layer of data analysis could be considered invasive or intrusive surveillance, and people might reasonably want to opt out of it. Yet, opting out shouldn't mean you have to avoid public spaces or wear disguises to prevent being captured and analyzed by these cameras. That would be pretty dystopian.
That said, I understand the arguments of the pro-AI side that requiring consent could concentrate power in the hands of big companies that can afford to pay for it.
And to that I say – I don't know! But just because we haven't come to a reasonable solution yet, doesn't mean that the notion of consent should be thrown by the way side.
At the very least, until we can find legal protections that are reasonable, we can encourage consent by choosing to support models that use "consensually-sourced" data, similar to how we might opt for local food businesses that source their products in ways we believe are ethical. In fact, I think this backlash has already started to make a tiny difference to companies who care about their public perception.
Another idea might be government or third-party grants aimed specifically at supporting ethical AI development among smaller companies or academic researchers.
So to reiterate, being pro-consent won't save jobs from automation, which I think is the genuine source of rage and grief. For that, other forms of protection like more government funding for the arts, a universal basic income, etc might be nice.
But I still think seeking consent or some sort of reasonable protections is the right thing to do ethically, and we shouldn't give up on finding ways to do so.
And as more of a meta point –
Just because we disagree on some things with people who are pro-AI, it doesn't mean we can't agree on some things. We can leave room for nuance, our independent evaluation of the situation, and for humility. We don't know all the answers yet, but we can work towards figuring them out in a way that can benefit the most people. (This paragraph doesn't apply to everybody, but it does apply to some of us)
Thoughts?