r/Artifact • • Feb 24 '19

Complaint we don’t need to hear about every reason you stopped playing

11 Upvotes

these posts aren’t refreshing to hear. you’re adding nothing to the conversation that hasn’t already been said hundreds of times by different players who have quit. ENOUGH with these types of posts.

it would be different if this was a massive game with a huge player base and you’ve decided to stop playing, but it’s not. by now, if you’ve stopped playing, you’re part of the majority of players who have tried and disliked the game enough to not play it anymore.

the reasons are the same

the suggestions are the same

please stop posting your essays about what you think valve should have done to keep you personally as a player. they are very aware of what they’ve done wrong and are in the process of fixing it.

all you’re doing is dragging on a discussion that nobody wants to hear if they’re still actually enjoying the game—which is the type of person that this subreddit is here for. it really is getting boring and i think mods should do something about it.

edit: prepare to get downvoted if you comment that you like the game and enjoy positivity


r/Artifact • • Dec 03 '18

Discussion If Valve made Artifact in 2013...

39 Upvotes
  • Game would either be 100% free to play, or $15 entry fee.

  • All cards would be free for the player to use (this includes and new card sets added in the future), create decks and experiment with. The idea would be to put everyone on an equal playing field where the player has all the tools available to them.

  • All modes would be available for the player to play for free. Ranked mode released post-launch for free.

  • Purchasable card packs would be available for each released set that include several rarities of cosmetic changes to the cards. Ranging from rare cards that make subtle changes to the card such a shiny border, to legendary cards that feature fully animated cards.

  • An actual healthy marketplace economy.

  • Being able to actually trade these cosmetic/holographic cards with your friends.

  • Seasonal Events with timed special events earning unique rewards. As well as seasonal cosmetics to purchase.

Valve, what happened to you?


r/Artifact • • Dec 24 '18

Discussion Why Artifact isn't a good game (played over 100 hours)

355 Upvotes

Being competitively viable isn't enough, in fact, for most people its competitive viability isn't even something they consider. I've played over 100 hours of it, yet I wouldn't say I've enjoyed playing Artifact, I just keep giving the game a chance because it's DOTA 2 related (I want to love it). So here's my personal impressions as to why Artifact is still bleeding players and why it will probably continue to do so.

Matches are long, yet uneventful

There are no interesting individual moments in any of the matches. It's a string of bland (if difficult to make) decisions one after another. Once a game has ended, the only "memorable" thing is the result of the match, this is unlike not just DOTA 2, but unlike any good game.

Argentine writer Julio Cortazar famously argued that a story is a boxing match between its readers and the author, and that short stories needed to win the fight by KO, while novels needed to win by points. The same concept can be applied to videogames.

Games of Artifact are very long, so it needs to win over the player by "hitting" him consistently. It does not accomplish this. It tries to win by KO through the final exciting moments at the end of a game, but the games are just too long for that, the payoff would have to be extraordinary to counterbalance the previous tediousness, not to mention the KO moment isn't particularly great or memorable either.

Cards don't do anything fun or even interesting

The best way I've come up with to convey this idea is by asking people to imagine how an episode of Yu-Gi-Oh would be if they were playing Artifact instead:

Yugi: I play shortsword. This item card gives any equipped hero +2 attack, by equipping it to Lich, I increase his attack to 7, enough to kill Drow Ranger. If we both pass, she will finally fall.

Crowd: Come on, Yugi, you can do it!

Kaiba: So predictable. I knew you'd try to kill my Drow Ranger using that cheap item from the very beginning... I play Traveler's cloak!

Joey: Oh no.

Tea: What?

Joey: Traveler's cloak increases the HP of any equipped hero by 4, Yugi's Lich won't be able to kill his Drow Ranger if they both pass.

Tea: I'm sure Yugi has something up his sleeve.

(...)

Most of the effects are so uninspired they resemble filler cards from other games.

The combat system is flavorless and boring

The game is built around piles of stats uneventfully hitting each other after each player passes, combat isn't 1/1,000,000 as satisfying as it is on Magic or HS. Units will attack pass each other, their combat targets are chosen somewhat randomly...

Compared this to games where players control the entirety of "fights" one way or another. Players feel that the combat, the main element, is under their control and they've got to be strategic about what to target and what to protect.

In Artifact, the most important decisions are about how many stats to invest in each individual lane, not about the combat itself. This is inherently less fun. The combat in Artifact is so boring the screen starts moving to the next lane before the animations from the current battle are finished.

You don't learn much by playing the game

Artifact does a terrible job of explaining to players what's a good and what's a bad play. For example, too often the right play is to let your hero die, that's just bad game design. It's very confusing to players and a poor use of contextual information.

Let me put that in perspective, why are we defending with plants in Plants vs Zombies? Is it just because it sounds fun, cute, or something like that? No, it's because plants don't move in the real world, so to the player it makes immediate sense why his or her defenses can't switch from one lane to another.

Compare this to Artifact's random mini-lane targeting mechanic. Why are our heroes standing next to each other, ignoring each other, and hitting each other's towers? This a textbook example of good game design vs poor game design.

In general, Artifact doesn't provide clear and consistent feedback to the player about his actions, nor it leverages from its knowledge of everyday things to convey its rules and goals more effectively, therefore, players don't understand why they lose, why they win, and don't feel like they're improving, killing their interest in the game (maybe, they start thinking, it's all RNG).

Heroes make the game far more repetitive

Because heroes are essentially guaranteed draws and value, games are inherently more repetitive than in other card games, this is probably why Valve added so many RNG elements elsewhere and why there's no mulligan.

To add insult to injury, there are very few viable heroes (despite launching with 48 different ones), making games extremely, extremely repetitive. Worse yet? Many goodheroes are expensive, so new players just find themselves losing to the same kind of things over and over and over again, and considering all that I've said, why would they want to pay for the more expensive viable heroes?

Its randomness feels terrible

By this I don't mean that they determine the outcome a match often, there's so much RNG per game of Artifact that almost all of it averages out during the course of a single game (there are some exceptions to this, like Multicast, Ravage, pre-nerf Cheating Death, Homefield Advantage, Lock...), this is particularly true of arrows.

However, that doesn't mean RNG in Artifact is well designed. Arrows and creep deployment feel absolutely awful to the player that didn't get his way, same with hero deployments. Whether they're balanced or not is of secondary importance, that only matters if players want to keep playing.

Conclusions (TL;DR)

Artifact is boring and frustrating. The combat, card design and match length are killing the game. There are too many RNG variables that are balanced, yet frustrating to play around.

P.S. There are things Artifact does well, but this ain't a post about that.


r/Artifact • • Feb 24 '19

Fluff Today on Comedy Sunday: this comment by SirBelvedere

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Artifact • • Nov 11 '18

Discussion Save yourself: don't buy Artifact

178 Upvotes

First let clarify something: I don't have any conflict of interests, I don't get any financial benefit from writing this, I don't own any stock from companies making competing games.

Valve, Gabe, Garfield, and everyone else at Valve, is unlike me in that regard. People defending Artifact's business model are cultists, blinded by tribalism.

On the other hand, I'm just trying to stop people from getting scammed. Many people don't seem to quite understand just how abusive Artifact's business model is, so I'll try to explain it.

Card packs:

  1. The price of cards is determined by the price of packs. The existence of a market is not relevant to the price of an entire collection. The price of an entire collection is the price of opening an entire collection.

  2. Buying from the steam market can't ever be consistently cheaper than buying packs, if the market is too cheap, people will simply stop buying packs, drying up the supply in the market and raising the price of cards.

  3. The only thing the market does is drive the price of bad cards down and increase the price of good cards (unlike HS, for example). A bad legendary in HS is worth 1/4 of the best legendary, a bad rare in Artifact will be worth far less than 1/4 of the best rare.

  4. How many cards are good and how many are bad, only affects the price of good decks. The more diluted the pool is with bad constructed cards, the more the price of good decks increases (the more bad cards, the more the price of a deck approaches the cost of an entire collection).

  5. A 15% fee per transaction is absurdly high. After 10 transactions, 80% of the value is gone, this was Wizard's wet dream.

Game modes:

5. Entry ticket gauntlets actually take money out of the system (about 10%), they're not there to help you progress, they're there to charge you even more for packs.
6. You won't go infinite. Gauntlet uses MMR, that means that on average your win rate will be around 50%. You need at least a 60% winrate to go infinite, this simply won't happen. It doesn't matter if you're in the top 10%, or the top 2% or the bottom 50%, as long as there are other players of your skill level connected at any time, you won't go infinite.
7. The keeper gauntlet is even more outrageous.

Please, don't buy into this game. Don't let yourself be scammed. Even though it's just a game, it's a good skill to have in life to look at what's being offered to you and make savvy financial decisions.

There're plenty of games out there, pretty much all of them have better business models (including HS).

If you really want to play a card game, Shadowverse has a pretty decent f2p experience compared to most other games. It's similar to Hearthstone, probably a bit more mechanically interesting.

Faeria is a LCG, every time you buy an expansion, you buy the entire set of cards. The mechanics are very interesting, and it has a ton of decision making and not a lot of RNG.

Prismata is even more competitive, both you and your opponent get the same random set of "cards" every match, so it's purely about outplaying them. Every match is different because every match you and your opponent get a different set of resources.

Take care, good luck and have fun (while not being scammed).

P.S. I wrote this late at night and I didn't realize I'm wrong about the win rate in gauntlet, if you lose twice, then that means you are out. So you actually need to go 3-1, in other words, you need about a 75% win rate to go infinite.


r/Artifact • • Mar 11 '19

Personal I'm done with Valve; Artifact has exposed them

5 Upvotes

The level of disrespect is astounding. We are paying customers, many of us sinking hundreds of dollars, and hundreds of hours. Their "our actions speak louder than words" meme motif makes zero sense, WHEN THEY MAKE NO ACTIONS. I am done. I can't just be led on like some child. We have to have some standards here, and I refuse to think that what Valve did is "okay" or that some magical patch is going to come and make the 24hr peak go from 450 to 450,000. Even a 1000% increase would put it at January highs.

Valve, you've lost yourself a customer. As far as I'm concerned, I'm done with Valve games, and if the opportunity arrives, I'm buying my games from GOG or other sources. Long haul, my ass.


r/Artifact • • Nov 11 '18

Misleading Artifact compared to other Digital Card Games.

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/Artifact • • Dec 19 '18

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Artifact is not complex.

36 Upvotes

I'm both a Hearthstone and DOTA player, but mainly DOTA and just wanted to give my thoughts on Artifact. I see a lot of posts about the cash model, but this post has nothing to do with that. Many will probably disagree with me, but since I haven't seen this really talked about, I wanted to make sure it was out there. I don't think Artifact is a well designed complex card game that many make it out to be. Many say it's very deep and takes a lot of skill. I don't think so and if it is in fact deep, it's deep for the wrong reasons.

IMO the three lanes in Artifact adds complexity in a non-complex way. Valve's implementation appears to be more of a dull tack on component of the game. It does not embody the complexity of DOTA where people can teleport to a tower and defend or set up a gank, etc... In Artifact, the player is going from lane to lane doing the exact same thing...literally (FYI, In DOTA, each lane is very different with different player positions). Instead of playing once, you play twice more to total to three lanes. If you add 2 more boards/lanes in Hearthstone, of course it's more "complex", there are more things to think about, cards to play, and do, but I argue it would be complex in a non-complex way - hopefully that makes sense. It's simply unoriginal, dull, and lacking in depth and design IMO.

Even then, the majority of a player's actions is playing with numbers. A lot of the cards just add numbers/stats to another card, which I feel like wtf is the point of me doing this managing numbers thing two more times. Lets save some time and just make the game one lane in all honesty. I say this, because in Artifact, the lane mechanics and interaction is not a defining and prominent feature like in a MOBA. It feels more like a cheap add on giving the illusion of complexity.

I hadn't heard about Richard Garfield until Artifact came out (I'm not a MTG player) and when I heard he was legendary and had all these credentials, I was excited to see what a DOTA card game would look like. I was shocked by what they did with Artifact, here we have a legendary card game designer and this is all he could come up with? Artifact does not embody DOTA, it's a player going from lane to lane doing the same shit twice more for no freaking reason really... but to add complexity.

So this was one of the main reasons, for me at least, for the disappointment of the game. Now back to DOTA2. :)

EDIT: So I just wanted to respond to everyone. I'm not trying to be negative or shit on Artifact, I'm just trying to have a discussion. Many of you have mentioned about I'm not accounting for card colors, deployment, lane mechanics, and initiative, etc... Yes all that adds to the depth AND complexity of the game. Basically how I feel is that if Hearthstone were 3 boards, it'd be pretty much the same thing as Artifact. You'd have all these things to consider which adds to depth and complexity, BUT this would mean... IMO Artifact is simply not unique or original in design. As /joseph66hole pointed out below, which is what I personally can't get over, Artifact is pretty much playing 3 games in 1 at the same time and wtf would anyone want to do that or even enjoy that? I know many of you disagree, but for me, this is how I personally feel about the game and I cannot accept this.


r/Artifact • • Oct 24 '18

Discussion I'm worried about the fact that Artifact is going to come out with solved meta

5 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying that I'm mostly fine with however late release is going to be, I'm not mad about a long closed beta from the stand point of someone who wishes to become a content creator or to compete in high level tournaments. I'm just a guy who loves card games.

Having said that, I must say - I love the time when a new expansion comes out in a card game, I love to watch everyone experimenting and to see metagame evolve from week to week. It's always the best and most fun time to me in every card game.

In artifact, we had pros and content creators grinding this game for months before anyone had a chance to play. I fear all the interesting and fun stuff has been figured out and we are going to get a solved and stale meta from the start.

Like, people are putting out deck lists and stuff. Pro players promising to put out their card tier lists for gauntlet. And people are somehow happy with it because it will "help everyone catch up with beta testers". Well I don't want to catch up with beta testers. I'm not going to play versus Stancifka in a tournament finals two weeks after release.

What I do NOT want on the other hand is to face off against net decks from day 1. I don't like the feeling that there is nothing for the rest of us to solve. I don't like the feeling that the whole community is starting to play in what essentially will be mid-expansion meta-wise.


r/Artifact • • Mar 11 '18

Discussion We have to say NO to card-set rotation if there is no way to get cards without a purchase

24 Upvotes

Edit: I wish I could change the title since the one above doesn't seem to get the point across. So how about:

"A discussion about Rotation Metas and costs in a closed market without trading."

Before we get to the subject of this thread, here are some basic infos for those who have missed it in the storm of exciting info: A game-informer article has unveiled some concerning details about the game's busniess model and balance-design.

We already heard that the game would be pay-to-play and here we get another confirmation that we will buy the base-game which will come with a limited starter-pack of cards (at least it will be "playable", whatever that means). That is no problem in itself, of course.

However, it also reveals that there will be no direct trading of cards (at least initially), meaning that all single-card purchases will be done through the Steam Marketplace. If you want a specific card, you have to buy it there. No way to get it otherwise, unless you get lucky by buying packs instead or selling unwanted cards to gain funds for cards you do want. However, since Valve gets a cut of every sale, you can't even exchange cards of even value 1:1.

But what is even more concerning is that they are planning to adopt CARD ROTATION. This means that they will hardly balance cards (unless they become a must-have). At first this sounds great, this is what Gabe meant when he said they would not devalue cards. It also shows their committment to this game in the long term. But what he failed to mention is that

They will ban/remove entire sets of cards from competitive play over time as they add new ones to buy.

RG: We would rather let the metagame play out and if a card is a problem, it’s going to go away anyway.

GI: So you plan to use that rotating format?

RG: Yes.

So instead of losing value gradually, they will lose worth ALL AT ONCE. Sure, there may be a "Wild/Legacy" mode where you can use your old, obsolete cards for fun, but they are no longer usable in competitive play. Afterall, we do not know how much they will support such modes and "it is going to go away anyway" does not sound encouraging. I have personally never played MTG because I am aware of the costs that are related to staying relevant. But at least Trading is still possible there.

I REALLY hope that we are still missing crucial details in this puzzle because my excitement for Artifact is slowly turning into sketicism and concern. Gabe did mention that time is being considered a currency as well, so I hope that we can unlock cards simply by investing time into the game as well.

Because what I am worried to see so far, is a game which asks us to pay money upfront, then asks us to buy packs to make the basic deck competitive, then asks us to sell and pay for single since trading is purposefully disabled AND THEN, over time, rotates relevant sets of dozens (perhaps hundreds) of cards, so the collection has to be constantly updated or even replaced to play the game competitively at all.

I really hope I am wrong. Either way, I hope Valve knows that this speculative but vicious money-vampire is not the game most want or, depending on prices, can afford. Hopefully this feedback will make them release more info to fill in the gaps of knowledge on our side.

I have been excited for this game since the initial announcement and even after Gabe's presentation and the P2P confirmation, I was sure Valve would find a way to keep it fair, balanced and financially reasonable. But these recent info has me worried.

Personal Note: Valve is the last company I would expect a bad businessmodel from. I hope this is just one of their misguided ideas like the paid mods workshop, when they thought they could grow the mod scene by turning it into a career, rather than a community-driven hobby. The cosmetics of the game are hopefully successful enough to keep other costs low.

EDIT:

The concept of rotation itself isn't bad, as long as there are other ways to get cards/packs. I get the point about keeping the meta/game fresh and always having an achievable entry-point for new players. The problem is that each rotation would be like buying into the game all over again if cards/packs are buy-only. Even paper-based cards can be traded directly, at least. Rotation is not the problem, it is the combination with the business model (or what we know of it so far). As user u/Arachas puts it in another thread, Artifact is NOT A TCG, since there is no trading but only the market, making it an MCG.

TL;DR

There should be more options for getting cards than purchasing them; Directly trading with other players, grinding, winning in automatic tournaments, anything.


r/Artifact • • Feb 19 '19

I waited a year and paid $20+ and all I got was this lousy Prismata clone

0 Upvotes

I mean come on, given how much time and resources that were put into this game, it's a train wreck.

It tries to do too many things that aren't interesting at all. Three lanes didn't really make the game more exciting, just added a layer of restrictive strategy. Gold can significantly impact a game after the first turn, when RNG regarding draws and positioning can be at it's most unpredictable. The RNG factors often feel annoying and unnecessary while taking away from the chess-like style of gameplay, where things feel even, fair and a pure battle of wits. But that it far from what this game is.

What this game is, is an overhyped lottery machine where not only do you need to buy the game to play it, you need to buy the cards, and then buy tickets to compete. It's really sad to see Valve degrade to the point where they're making mobile games for PC with even more greedy and ferocious nickel and dime tactics. It's a scam preying on gambling impulses and the nostalgia associated with familiar DotA 2 characters.

I really tried to like this game, but it just feels so half-assed and dead on arrival. There are so many better, free alternatives around that existed before this game. If you're still playing for a shot at that million, I get it. But please, be real, they could have done so many things better with the time they had. It's a fucking mess and Valve has completely lost my interest as a game developer/publisher.


r/Artifact • • Jan 04 '19

Fluff I too can manipulate data for a narrative (in response to Petrify's post)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
3 Upvotes

r/Artifact • • Sep 23 '18

Article Ten Reasons why Artifact will be the biggest eSport title, ever

78 Upvotes

Ten Reasons why Artifact will be the biggest eSport title, ever

Written by Michael "rokman" Weldon

Hello r/Artifact! Before I get into the meat of the article, I thought I’d introduce myself. My card game experience comes from the Pokemon Trading Card Game. I started collecting and playing way back in the nineties. After nearly a decade playing casually, I ended up moving toward the competitive scene for a handful of years. I had a few big tournament wins and a lot of success playing the game. There was even a point that I was a paid writer for a Pokemon Trading Card Game website known as SixPrizes, you can see my articles here.

Within the eSports world, I have worked in the production side of things at a few major tournaments. As a Production Assistant and Camera operator, I worked at IGN Pro League 3 in Atlantic City (Here’s a picture of me and Idra), as well as IGN Pro League 5 in Las Vegas (Here’s a photo before we opened the main stage). Live eSports events are so unbelievable to witness, as a fan. Twitch is convenient, but it is just not the same. Being there, LIVE, with people who share your interest, who will shout and scream with you when your favorite team wins? There is nothing like it. You have to go to a live event for your favorite game, if you haven’t already.

The last thing about myself I’d like to cover is what drew me to Artifact. I’ve always been a fan of the RTS genre. DotA, Heroes of Newerth, League of Legends, you name it. If you played HoN, you might remember that “Too Bad it’s Me, Blacksmith” meme? Yeah, that was me. Sorry! Ha!

Truth be told, I’ve had an off-and-on relationship with all of these games. Going from riding a high of winstreaks to the inevitable burning out when paired with casual players who are playing to have fun and goof around. Who even plays games to have fun? Totally insane, right? Sheesh!

So finally, there’s Artifact, a game that I can only blame myself when I lose. One versus one in an RTS style game, based around trading cards, it’s basically the exact type of game I’ve been looking for my entire life. That’s why I’m writing this article on reddit, and that’s why I know Artifact will be the biggest eSport title, ever. Here’s ten reasons that’s going to happen --

1. Valve

Valve has such an incredible track record of PC titles. Half-Life, Counter-Strike, Team Fortress, Portal, Left for Dead, DotA 2, it’s actually unbelievable. And when Artifact was announced at the DotA International 7, it wasn’t received well. But that’s because those people in the crowd were just plain ignorant. (Yeah, I said it!) They were thinking Valve was piggy-backing off of Hearthstone’s success.

I guess you can’t blame them for thinking that, many developers have entered the genre of digital trading card games, but none of them have had Hearthstone’s financial success. And damn, Hearthstone has been an extremely profitable title. In the most recent Financial report from Activision Blizzard, the company was reporting that pre-orders for the Boomsday Project were exceeding any previous expansion. That’s actually off the charts, because Hearthstone has been around for over FOUR YEARS now!

But there’s a few things Hearthstone hasn’t done right, from a competitive standpoint. And now that I think about it, has Blizzard ever handled eSports correctly? If you ask me, they’ve only ever been interested in making games that are popular, which is fine, and clearly worked for them as a business model. But that doesn't translate into a competitive eSport.

But Valve though? Get out of town! They’ve been a major player in eSports for many years. Just take a look at the DotA International’s prize support! Here’s a list of the Top Games awarding prize money across all tournaments. DotA 2 and Counter-Strike: Global Offensive are the top games. But get this, after adding up ALL of the prize support between the next THIRTY games on this list, you STILL don’t exceed the total prize support from DotA 2 and CS:GO. That’s BONKERS!

I know what you’re going to say, and I agree, prize support isn’t everything. But it’s definitely a massive part of a game’s success (And by extension, the developer of that game). Think about all the people involved when a game is successful, other than players. Production crew at live events (I was one of those guys!), camera crews, media companies, eSports organizations, even a company like Twitch, which live streams events. All of this infrastructure keeps the whole thing in motion, so having massive prize support for players is the very reason all of these other companies have spawned underneath a video game title.

And that’s why Valve is the number one reason I think Artifact is going to take over eSports. They know what they are doing. They organize these events. They create the prize pool for the DotA International. And they do that by offering all players the ability to buy cosmetics, with a portion of their purchases funding the actual tournament.

I put all my faith in GabeN and Valve to do this right. They’re the best in the business when it comes to this type of thing. But that’s not the only thing you need to take over eSports. You KIND OF need a good game, right? Well, let me introduce you to --

2. Dr. Richard Garfield

Is there really anything else I need to say? The man himself, the CREATOR of the modern collectible card game. If the out-of-this-world success of Magic the Gathering isn’t enough to convince you, his understanding of skill versus luck in a game should do the trick. This is an hour long presentation he gave. If you haven’t listened to it, you should do so immediately.

Many of the following reasons on my list will reference some of the concepts Dr. Garfield covers in his presentation. Also many mechanics in Artifact are built on these concepts presented here, and because of that, there isn’t much more I need to elaborate on, for now.

If you weren’t aware, Magic the Gathering is the biggest card game, ever. Despite the current drama taking place, Magic the Gathering has been the premier card game to play if you were looking to make a career out of cards. While it isn’t always a profitable career path, there are a small group of players that have raked in quite a bit of prize winnings over the years. Take a look at the Top 200 All-Time Money Leaderboards. That’s some eye-popping dollar signs, if you ask me.

But Dr. Richard Garfield doesn’t only want to cater to that tiny small percent of players, working toward big paychecks, and Magic the Gathering has recognized the different archetypes of players, known as Timmy, Johnny, and Spike. Dr. Garfield has even explained that he builds all kinds of cards, with these different player archetypes in mind.

I’d even say some of the core strategies amongst the four colors in Artifact embody a lot of the Timmy/Johnny/Spike concepts. This is important to mention because it means Dr. Garfield will cater to various playstyles in Artifact, which will allow people to be creative with their decklists, tailored to their individual style. And if you ask me, that is a recipe for some very exciting Artifact games!

So, looking at where we are now, we’ve got Valve developing a game designed by Dr. Richard Garfield. Already, that should be enough for you to believe in this game’s success. But I’m going to break it down even further. For a game to be the number one eSport, I think the most important thing has got to be the most obvious, a --

3. High Skill Ceiling

Let’s take a look at Basketball. There’s many levels of basketball, from friendly pickup games on the street, to community leagues at the local recreation center, to high school, to college, to professional foreign markets, to the very top at professional NBA basketball. In each of these levels, you would imagine anyone in one level could take on a person in a level below theirs, and beat them greater than 99% of the time. While that isn’t always the case (Haven’t you heard of The Professor?) it clearly shows the extremely high skill ceiling of Basketball, just because it can facilitate so many different levels of expertise. This isn’t a difficult concept to grasp, I just wanted to go over it briefly.

For a video game title to completely dominate the eSport world, it has to have an extremely high skill ceiling. And this is a broad concept to cover, so I’m only going to cover one aspect of it, which is the one I think defines it the greatest… Decision making.

In Artifact, the number of decisions you make, and their future impact is one of the biggest elements that separate Artifact from other card games. Within the umbrella of decision making, are concepts like Hero deployment, spending resources in one lane over another, when to give up a lane, and many other specific examples like these. (I’ll probably cover this topic directly in it’s own article at another time.)

Comparing Artifact to Hearthstone, the average number of decisions per game has to be an astronomically different number. Unfortunately, I’m not able to play Artifact currently so I can’t give you these statistics. But I’m basing this assumption off of PAX West game videos that I watched. And I think a lot of people can agree with my assumption here. If not, go ahead and tell my why you disagree in the comments.

By having so many instances where players have to make decisions, even in a perceived simple concept like initiative, your game will automatically open itself up to a high skill ceiling. Bare with me here, I’m going to break this down, as simple as I can…

  • Assumption one, Artifact is a game that forces players to make MORE decisions over the course of a single game, when compared to other card games.

  • Assumption two, when faced with those decisions, the higher skilled player will make BETTER choices over the course of a game, giving them a higher percentage chance to win.

Similarly to basketball, you would assume that 99% of the time, the higher skilled player will win? Obviously the numbers won’t be that high. Nobody can say for sure what that number is for Artifact, but many experts believe that in Magic the Gathering, the higher skilled player has somewhere around 60 and 70% of winning. Let’s hope Artifact is above that number.

Now let’s take a look at the opposite of skill. That pesky thing that everyone says is the worst part of Artifact. And the one thing I think they are all dead wrong about, of course it’s --

4. RNG

How many different possible unique games of Tic-Tac-Toe are there? The answer is 255,168. That’s every single unique series of plays you can make in Tic-Tac-Toe, period. But how many unique games of Dota 2 are there? Well, before the game even begins there over two quadrillion possible team compositions. (I don’t do math. These guys did though) And that’s before the games even begun!

What about professional sports, like Baseball? I’d say it’s essentially infinite, when taking into consideration so many variables about the athlete's body, different flights of the ball on a pitch, various types of swings, and if the bat makes contact, the nearly infinite points of contact that a baseball could land in a stadium, and that’s not even taking into consideration random things like a player tripping, or a fan in the audience interrupting the play. You get the idea.

This is an incredibly important detail when considering how successful a game can be in the eSports space. Card games are at a massive disadvantage, there’s only so many possible things that can happen, it’s actually a fairly small finite number of unique games, when compared to something like DotA 2.

So what’s the deal with adding in paths in front of creeps? What about the RNG Flop at the beginning of the game? These things are SO INCREDIBLY good for the game, it honestly perturbs me how many people following Artifact are unsure of this design choice. By adding in these variables into the possible unique games of Artifact, it increases the number by a HUGE MARGIN. I would argue this makes Artifact the number one card game, when it comes to the number of possible unique games. But why is this a good thing? Two reasons --

  • One, it makes the game more fun to play.

Even with a small deck of forty cards, you’ll have tons of unique games, even when facing opponent decks that are all the same decklist. Each game can be very different based on the minute RNG built into the game! That means you won’t get burn out playing the same decklist. Meta is stale and boring? At least your games will play out slightly different!

  • Two, it makes the game so much more interesting to spectate.

How does a player react to certain possible Flops? How does a player recover from poor creep spawns during redeployment phases? These variables create a much more exciting spectating experience! Which brings us to the next point --

5. Spectator eSport

LuminousInverse, SUNSfanTV, SirActionSlacks, and fwosh did such an amazing job commentating games during the PAX West live streams. If you haven’t had a chance to watch them, I’d highly recommend it. During the commentary, in many situations, the commentators would talk about potential lines of play from the Challengers on stage. In almost every scenario, there were multiple plays to choose from, and many of them were fairly equal in perceived value.

In many other card games, there is a clear best play from your hand, every turn, and any other line would be called a “misplay”. But in Artifact, that line separating a viable play and a misplay is quite blurry. Without knowing future creep deployments, some plays could end up being better than others, even when they aren’t necessarily the number one best option at face value. This creates a scenario where commentators have A LOT to talk about during matches, sometimes too much.

On YouTube, you can find a guy making videos named Jackson Walters. I highly recommend his videos and would like to mention him for one specific reason. He uses a program to draw on the screen when he does his gameplay commentary. If you’ve ever seen an NFL broadcast, you would know this is a common feature during a replay. A yellow line, drawing over a freeze frame of the last play.

No other video game I know of uses this type of technology, and Artifact is absolutely an AMAZING candidate to take advantage of it. There is so much going on, when choosing a lane for a hero to go to, when choosing a spot for a creep to spawn in lane, potential pathing of units, all of these examples would make this technology great for commentators to relay pertinent information to the audience.

But those two things aren’t the only thing that makes Artifact a great spectator eSport. And this is a topic that is debated frequently amongst the community. Is Artifact going to have good “streamability” on Twitch? My answer is a resounding YES. Because Valve has done such an unbelievably good job designing the User Interface, a lot of things are clearly displayed to the audience.

Even to people who have very little knowledge of the game, just understanding the basics, they’ll be able to recognize when a player is put in a bad position (Here’s a hint -- there’s giant red X’s all over his units!) and the audience can understand when a player is forced to make a big play to turn things around.

Furthermore, with the UI clearly labeling Tower health and incoming Tower damage, the audience is given obvious indicators for “points” or a way to keep track of the “score” in the game. Which actually isn’t that common amongst many popular eSports titles. Speaking of eSports titles, let’s talk about the biggest thing Artifact has, that other card games don’t --

6. Deck sharing

“Valve is even working on a deck sharing system that will let you lend a deck to a friend for a match just like you would in a physical card game.” Excuse me? I actually can’t believe this! I know a lot of you young people won’t appreciate how awesome of a concept like this really is, but I’m going to break it down for you.

Before the internet existed and everyone had everyone’s decklist, people actually had to work out decks on their own, and with their friends. I personally have spent hundreds of hours “solitairing” decks against no opponent, testing a deck’s consistency and working kinks out of the list. With the current state of electronic card games, people can get detailed statistics of all the top deck lists in the game, what the best players are using on ladder, and so on and so forth. Even in some games, at top tournaments, everyone’s deck list is public knowledge before it begins!

This is not how things have always been. Back in my day, people could go to major tournaments and whip out a completely unknown, Secret.dec, that no one has seen before. That player and his group of friends have already tested it a thousand games against the most popular decks in the meta. When things like this happened, people LOST their freaking minds. And to be honest, this is how some stars were born within some trading card game circles.

With Artifact’s Deck Sharing, Players will be able to put multiple decks together and give them to their friends, without them needing to invest money in the game, bring them in and use them as exclusive testing partners. While this might understandably sound a bit insane, I can see small groups of friends using this feature for testing purposes.

Other than the obvious, it being a gigantic tool to bring more players to Artifact, I’m looking at it from the competitive perspective. I could even solitaire games against myself, playing both decks simultaneously! Nice!

While this feature is great at bringing new players in and keeping the cost of entry low, there is something else Artifact has already taken into consideration, you guessed it --

7. Card accessibility

Black Lotus $6,500. Ancestral Recall $3,363. Time Walk $2,628.

Yikes. This is the exact reason Valve has gone on record stating that they don’t want this to happen. Their first step in preventing this, at least in the first set, which releases on November 28th, is only having three rarities of cards. Common, Uncommon, and Rare. Also guaranteeing that one of the twelve cards included in each two dollar pack is a Rare.

They’re going to take things even further for an electronic trading card game, and allow players to buy and sell cards on the steam marketplace. Looking at it from a business standpoint, how genius is that? They not only sell every card pack in client, but they ALSO get a cut of every transaction made on the secondary market! Absolutely genius! (~15% of all secondary market sales goes right into Valve’s pocket!!!)

As of now, nobody can predict the average costs of cards, or the average cost to create a popular meta deck. But one thing is certain, we won’t have to buy hundreds of booster packs hoping to open some specific super-rare necessary-for-laddering “legendary cards” that can’t be resold in a secondary market! Yeah, I’m looking right at you, Hearthstone!

So we’ve got a situation where the game is designed by Richard Garfield, developed by Valve, has a high skill ceiling, with RNG that makes things interesting, great for spectating, allows deck sharing, and will have accessible cards? What’s even missing in something so amazing like that? Oh, I know, SirActionSlacks favorite topic --

8. The Lore

Let’s say the 482,000 average players of DotA 2 won’t be interested in the amazing game I just described above. Well, I’d call them crazy, but let’s go with this for a moment. What is the one other thing that could potentially make them want to at least open the game and poke around? Yeah, it’s all those interesting characters they’ve known for years, it’s that universe they have spent thousands of hours playing in. A massive chunk of that playerbase might be interested in Artifact, just for the LORE.

And if you haven’t seen it already, definitely check out SirActionSlacks Loregasm videos on youtube. I had no idea how much lore was actually in the DotA universe, and it gave me a whole new appreciation for the game I spent many hours playing.

From the bits and pieces I’ve been able to piece together during the card reveals, inspecting the artwork and reading the flavor text in the tweet’s on the official Artifact Twitter page, it seems to me that the first set will be based around the Bronze Legion and the Red Mist Army.

There’s plenty of great lore to explore there, but it might even give us some clues about the first expansion set for Artifact? Maybe an Abyssal Horde expansion? Or even just a straight up Roseleaf Expansion? Only time will tell…

Even though I covered this subject briefly before, I’d like to mention it again, in it’s own bullet point --

9. Prize support

Remember when I linked the Top 200 All-time Money leaders from Magic the Gathering? Number one on the list is Paulo Vitor Damo da Rosa, with total winnings of $497,785. That’s quite a bit of money playing a card game! Well, that is until someone is crowned victor of the first Artifact Tournament, slated for the first quarter of 2019. First place gets a cool $1,000,000. That’s more than DOUBLE any Magic the Gathering player has made... in all of it’s 25 year history! Yikes!

None of the details have been released yet, but if you play close attention to the Artifact website and the Official twitter @PlayArtifact, they’ll be announcing it soon, hopefully. Many players hoping to take a stab at that prize pool are anxiously waiting to hear how they could potentially qualify for the big tournament, myself included.

But as I’ve mentioned before, a giant prize pool isn’t the only key to success as an eSport, it’s many other things. What I would like you to remember, is how many industries can be supported when a prize pool gets that large. But money doesn’t just bring in a bunch of companies underneath it, it also brings in SPONSORS!

Sponsors support all those gaming organizations, that sign pro players to represent them, and allows for such a competitive space to become an eSport. This in turn creates an environment where many people can provide for their families, support each other, and their communities, all from a video game. If that doesn’t get you excited, then you’re truly dead inside. Or your a hundred years old and don’t know what a video game is.

And finally, the above nine things would make a pretty great game, but there’s still one last thing that makes all the difference. In my opinion, it’s the most important piece of success for a video game title to be the number one eSport...

10. Content creators

Here’s a list of some of the best content creators out there right now, making amazing content for Artifact. If you aren’t already following all of these guys, I highly recommend you do so immediately, not just because what they’re making is awesome, but also because they are giving away beta keys!

Artifaction

The Artifaction podcast is hosted by SUNSfanTV and SirActionSlacks. They just held a massive create-a-card competition for 2 beta keys! If you missed it, that’s unfortunate, because it was great watching how miserable these two were after they reviewed over a thousand cards on stream (Which was only half of the submissions!).

BTS Podcast

Hosted by LuminousInverse and Hotbid. One of my favorite podcasts out there right now, these guys are great. Hotbid is a natural talent for keeping the podcast moving and making sure everyone on mic stays opinionated, taking hard stances. That’s what creates discussion, that’s what makes a podcast interesting. Creating debates. I can’t recommend these guys enough!

Artificer’s Guild

This is an all encompassing youtube channel, covering news, card releases, reviews, lore, it’s a great channel to have on subscribe. Check out their videos, they come out every few days!

RobAJG

What a great twitch channel this guy is running! He’s offering gameplay reviews, interviews, card reveals, as well as personal commentary. He does stream a lot of games other than Artifact, but when he streams Artifact, he can bring the house down.

Jackson Walters

While a newer content creator for Artifact (he’s only got three videos up), these videos are absolutely PACKED with amazing information you can break down. He is on another level when it comes to breaking down some pinpoint decision making moments in games. If you want to play on a high level in Artifact, definitely watch his videos.

Swim

Swim is a top Gwent streamer and dabbling with the idea of moving to Artifact. Personally, I think he’d be an amazing addition to the Artifact community and he’s got only one video up currently, breaking down the Black cards and revealing his own card, Slay. Make sure you give him plenty of love because he is a great creator!

Lastly, I’d like to include myself in this list of content creators. You can check out my twitter here.

I’m looking to write more articles like this in the future (If you guys enjoyed it, that is) Some of the topics I’ll be covering are going to be pretty heavy, like this article, but also decklists, analyzing metas and tournament results, maybe patch notes (if Valve decides to patch Artifact and change cards), interviews, pro scene topics, maybe even tracking cards on the marketplace, and predicting future meta shifts! I’d also like to do a card reveal, if Valve is interested in spreading the love. Seriously, Valve, I’d die if you sent me a card reveal...

In conclusion, because of the ten reasons stated above, I believe Artifact will be the biggest eSport title, ever. I’d love to hear why you agree or disagree, so comment below! Also, one last thing, I do have a beta key to give away, if you follow me on twitter @rokmanfilms, I might do something fun to give the key away. I know you fiends are only motivated by the chance of winning a key! Ha!

Thanks for reading! I’ll be posting again soon…

  • Michael “rokman” Weldon

ONE LAST THING -- I am interested in being a writer for a publication or website. If you’re interested in adding a writer like me to your team, you can Direct Message me on twitter, message me on Discord at rokman#5483, or message me here on Reddit! Sorry, not sorry, for the shameless plug!


r/Artifact • • Mar 08 '19

Discussion 45,000 active playerbase, not 500: Correction regarding Biweekly Active User Numbers

2 Upvotes

I think we've all seen a lot of posts about active users. And it's true that recently the concurrent player count has dropped to about 250 to 500. But that's not the same as 500 active players total. Obviously, people don't play the game for 24 hours a day. So how many monthly or weekly active users are there?

Over the past two weeks, the best estimates suggest something like 30,000 to 60,000 active players. That means, over the past two weeks, approximately 30,000 to 60,000 started the game at least once.

The reasoning is:

  1. Over the past 30 days, there's been an average of 622.3 concurrent players according to steamcharts. But this has probably fallen over time, so let's say over the past 14 days, there has been only 450 concurrent players.

  2. In a two week period, there are 336 hours. Thus, there have been 450 players * 336 hours = 151,200 player-hours over the past two weeks.

  3. According to Steamspy, the average total play time for active players is 4 hours and 51 minutes for the past 2 weeks. According to steamdb, the average play time for active players is 2.6 hours over the past 2 weeks. It's unclear where this discrepency is coming from, as steamdb supposedly gets the estimates from SteamSpy.

  4. If the average play time for bi-weekly active users is 4.85 hours, then we have 31,175 biweekly users as 151,200 hours / (4.85 avg over 2 weeks) = 31,175.

  5. If the average play time for bi-weekly active users is 2.6 hours, then we have 58,153 biweekly users as 151,200 hours / (2.6 avg over 2 weeks ) = 58,153.

Even if there's some debate about whether the average is 2.6 hours or 4.85 hours, an average in the range of 2 to 6 hours over the past two weeks seems reasonable to me, and in the absence of better data, seems like a good starting point.

The median is also less than the average, which is typical for games of this sort as they resonate with certain players (e.g. TeamFortress 2 has a median of 3 hours vs avg of 16 hours over 2 week period). Also note that the median of 0 hours and 51 minutes, means probably 30 to 40% of players open it up, only play one to three games and then don't play again for at least 2 weeks. That's not great for the health of the game in some ways, as some may never return. But they are still part of the active player base until they stop coming back. In a month or two perhaps the bi-weekly player base might drop further to 15,000 or 30,000 or less (who can say).

Note: One might wonder if the above 4.85 or 2.6 hours estimates include the people who play 0 hours. This seems unlikely for two reasons.

  • Steamspy lists the median time as 0 hours and 51 minutes. If steamspy included those who play 0 hours, the median would almost certainly be 0 as well, if at least 50% have left the game.

  • Old Single Player games with low concurrent counts also have high average and medians on Steamspy. Consider Final Fantasy 3, with 126 concurrent players yesterday -- it has an estimated 10 hour average playtime and 12 hour median playtime over the past 2 weeks. I doubt the average owner of FF3 played for 10 hours in the past 2 weeks. Far more likely, the average owner of FF3 who played at least a little played for 10 hours in the past 2 weeks.

Probably unnecessary mathematical derivation -- Ignore everything below if you already understood the logic above

Edit: I wanted to reassure I wan't doing anything strange with the expectations (sorry but reddit doesn't support LaTeX):

Step 1 and 2. For simplicity, consider i = {1,....,N} total owners and t = {1,2,...,336} hour segments over the past 2 weeks.

h_{i,t} = Binary variable for whether player i plays at hour t. 0 if not playing, 1 if playing.

Thus,

Total hours played in 2 week period = Sum_t ( Sum_i ( h_{i,t} ))

It's also clear that

Sum_i ( h_{i,t} ) = Concurrent player count at time t

Thus,

Total hours played in 2 weeks = Sum_t ( Sum_i ( h_{i,t} )) = Sum_t ( Concurrent player count at time t )

Note that what I call the "average concurrent player count over 2 weeks" is just Sum_t ( Concurrent player count at time t ) / 336 hours. Thus, if we agree that the average concurrent player count is 450 players, from the above, Sum_t ( Concurrent player count at time t ) = Average Concurrent player count over 2 weeks * 336 hours = 450 * 336 = 151,200.

Thus, total hours played in 2 weeks is indeed just Average Concurrent player count over 2 weeks * 336 hours = 151,200.

Step 4 or 5:

Let's call the number of biweekly active users U. If a player has any h_{i,t} = 1 for any t={1,....336}, I will call them a (biweekly) active user. Clearly, U< N, not everyone who owns the game will play.

Average playtime over two weeks is just Total hours played in two week period / U

Put another way,

Avg Playtime = T / U

We can solve for U by rearranging:

U = T / Avg Playtime

Recall we calculated T (Total hours played) in steps 1 and 2, which is 151,200. The Avg Playtime is reported by Steamspy / Steamdb, though it is an estimate.

One might ask, "Doesn't this assume that if I play at all, even for one minute, that I play for the whole hour?" Not quite. One could break t into minutes t={1,2,...20160} and the equations are the same.

However, our estimates of "concurrent playerbase" is actually only hourly. Steamcharts does not take a minute-by-minute estimate of playerbase. So... in theory, if there was a conspiracy going on, players could all log in at 9 am and quit at 9:01. Then log in at 10 am and quit at 10:01, etc. This WOULD mess with our results, but is obviously ridiculous. As long as the hourly estimates of average concurrent playerbase are "smooth", that is, there's no big increase or decrease between 9 am and 10 am that isn't captured at either the 9 am or 10 am estimate, it's fine. In other words, you might log in at 8:59 am and play for 10 minutes, and be counted in the 9 am estimate. I don't need you to play until 9:59, because there are people logging in and logging out all the time, in other words, probably someone started the game at 9:06 or 9:14 and will also play for a little while. In other words, if there are 360 people playing at 9:00 am and 380 people playing at 10:00 am, there's probably approximately 370 people playing at 9:30 am, approximately 361 people playing at 9:03 am, etc. On average the linear approximation between hourly estimates of concurrent player base is "good enough".


r/Artifact • • 28d ago

Article Does anyone want the source code for this game? I'm pretty sure I can reverse-engineer it in less than a week and open-source it—then everyone can just mod it and make it a success

0 Upvotes

I love this game to btw - It was a shame that it was not successful


r/Artifact • • Dec 19 '18

Other Next patch is Artifact's do or die.

6 Upvotes

At least for me. There are so many elephants in the room and it's baffling me that Valve and some fanboy couldn't see it.


r/Artifact • • Dec 11 '18

Unconfirmed PSA: Progression system most likely won't be until after christmas.

0 Upvotes

Make sure to tailor your expectations. I am sure they have been working on it for awhile now. But even if they were ready to go with it right now it would probably be a bad idea to launch a system that will need bug fixing and iteration right before the holidays. We know they are working on it, we just need to be a bit patient.


r/Artifact • • Apr 16 '19

Discussion Why don’t they release the next set?

0 Upvotes

If they actually plan on letting this game die without a rework, there’s no harm in giving the last few players the next set of cards that we know they already made.


r/Artifact • • Nov 27 '18

Complaint A visual example on why the F3 funcion is really bad. Got Obliterating Orb on Secret Shop, Pres F3 and look if they have some improvement worth to destroy. No? Save 10 gold on buying a useless item.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Artifact • • Apr 01 '19

Article Artifact monetization was way better than Hearthstone

Thumbnail
polygon.com
71 Upvotes

r/Artifact • • Sep 11 '18

Fluff I don't think Artifact is worth investing time and effort into it.

8 Upvotes

I mean, It looks cool and really fun right now, it may attract tons of people but it would inevitably fail longterm. No way it can still be popular if it's only going to have 2 card expansions after release.


r/Artifact • • Mar 10 '19

Personal One of the streamers for Artifact has been promising to hold a 10k tournament among it's viewers and when the time came went radio silent about it.

0 Upvotes

I know that Artifact isn't popular right now and I guess it was expected to have more viewers income but one of the reasons I committed to this was this promise. It's a lot of money for a person especially from my country and I had high hopes to have a chance on this new scene. Because of this, I dumped a lot of money in the game cause I wanted to practice with all meta decks to have a decent chance. It's just not fucking fair to treat people who trusted you like this, just ghosting them when you didn't earn enough money to stick to your word and keep your promise. Yea, it doesn't make sense from the financial perspective for you but you fucking made a promise and I think a lot of people spent money on you and watched you at least partially because you made this promise!

Now change that streamer that never existed to Valve and 10k to 1kk and answer me, you dancing hypocrite monkey, why were you pissed about shit that this non-existed streamer pulled towards people but at the same time think it's okay that Valve did this beCaUsE iT dOeSn'T mAkE sEnSe To HoLd It NoW?


r/Artifact • • Jan 01 '19

Fluff "RNG doesn't influence the game that much"

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/Artifact • • Jan 04 '19

Discussion So when Artifact hits 2k players, will y'all believe the RNG isn't fun?

2 Upvotes

This isn't about "you should have" or "you obviously misplayed" or all the other excuses the defenders of Artifact's overwhelming RNG keep parroting. This is about "Is the game fun?"

I'm borderline like/dislike the current game. Some of my complaints are things that make no sense at all. Why can't I unlock the stupid camera? Why don't we have replays? Why can't I be trusted to know my own MMR? Why don't we have any card statistics? Why don't we have a real rank system? These are things that Valve has gotten right in other games, so it's silly they're not right here.

But the single biggest complaint I, and many others, have is that there is too much RNG. Worse, it's RNG you cannot reasonably react to. I'm a huge proponent of player agency, even in card games, and Artifact takes tons of it away and doesn't provide anything in return that is fun.

Card draw RNG. Shop RNG. Melee creep RNG. Arrow RNG. Deployment RNG. Ogre Magi, Bounty Hunter, other hero RNG. Card effect RNG (ie. Fog of War).

Now, card draw RNG is fine. It's the nature of a card game, and reacting to card draw is a big part of what gives card games their unique gameplay. Players even have agency over how much effect this RNG aspect has in that you can reduce the number of different cards in your deck or add card draw. I suspect eventually we'll also start to see tutoring cards. But the short version is, card draw RNG is what makes the game, and working with it makes the game fun.

But then we get into the borderline stuff. Is Bounty Hunter's Jinada fun? Wizards of the Coast has done marketing studies on coin flip and dice roll cards that say no, it's not. The extreme rarity of random cards in tournaments backs that up. Ogre Magi and Tidehunter are in the same boat. They have effects that are game changing, but not necessarily stuff that happens to win or lose games often enough that people quit over it.

But then we get to the RNG that is winning and losing a measurable number of games. Before you say, "No it doesn't." Spend real time watching the good streamers play. Or go watch tournament replays. Melee creeps chump blocking, and lucky arrows saving towers happen all the time. It'd be hard to find a game where one of those two things didn't extend a game. And when you're talking about equally skilled players, that can be enough to decide the outcome.

Of course, you don't have to believe me. You can believe all RNG can be overcome, and that I'm obviously a bad player with no clue and blah blah blah. It doesn't matter, BECAUSE I'M NOT THE POINT OF THIS POST. The point is that Artifact is still bleeding players. I checked just before starting this post, and it was just about to drop below 3k. And it's no secret why people are continuing to leave.

It's not the paywall or pay to win. Those complaints pretty much died out in meaningful amounts not long after release. It's not the lack of grindy rewards as we have those now. It's not the lack of real progression because we lost the people who care about that for the most part after the second patch didn't give it to them. All that's left that's driving people away is the RNG. And the thing is, none of the excuses defenders keep making matter because none of them address the fact the game's RNG level isn't fun.

No matter how many times you tell someone, "you can overcome the RNG," you're not going to convince them to keep playing if they're not having fun. It also doesn't help your argument that you're wrong since there are more sources of RNG than a player could ever respond to. That even goes for arrows since over the course of an average game, you'll have more arrows than you could have reasonably included redirect cards in your deck. And of course, players have no control over shop offerings, and extremely little control over melee creep deployment. But it doesn't matter. If people think the RNG isn't fun, then it's not fun. And they quit.

Oh, and the lack of players is going to start to matter sooner rather than later. At the point where those of us still playing have to wait more than a minute or two for a match, we'll start leaving as well. That becomes a death spiral that is really hard to dig out of, especially in a world where there are so many alternatives for entertainment.

And my final point is that last sentence. Artifact isn't competing against Hearthstone, Gwent, and Magic. Artifact is competing against every other video game, movie, television show, streaming service, youtube video, book, and on and on. And it's failing. And that bothers me because you can see how close the game is to being a lot of fun.