r/ArsenalWFC • • Jan 26 '23

Discussion/Question Uncomfortable Question - Why is the team so white?

0 Upvotes

[Some background: As a white person with racist parents, I've done a lot of work to correct my own racism and unconscious biases. This includes noticing when there aren't many people of colour (POC) or women of colour (WOC) in the room, or in a group.]

The observation:

While watching some old matches recently, I noticed we used to have more black players. I also noted that Alex Scott and Lauren James both came out of the Academy, but James is playing at Chelsea. Then we lost Mana and I took a look at our team roster. It's very white. There are no black women on it at all. I noticed that the teams that we played against - especially the better teams - were often more racially diverse than Arsenal. I wanted to find out if this was my imagination, or if I could back it up with data.

The Method:

Long story short, I decided to compare our Roster to other teams in the WSL, the UEFA Women's Champions League, and the FA Cup. All in all, I've looked at the rosters of over a hundred teams, and put them all into one of three categories. (This part sucked because categorising people by their perceived race/ethnicity is shitty and race is a social construct anyway, mostly created by white people to have an excuse to hurt others and both Irish and Italian people didn't count as "white" at various points, but I'm getting off track).

The categories were:

  1. Diverse team - at least one black woman, and other women of colour on the team.

  2. Less Diverse - a team with one black woman on it.

  3. Mostly White - a team with no black players, maybe one or two women of colour.

Now obviously some people would have a problem with classifying "black" as the only way to be diverse, but again there is a lot of info out there about model minorities, anti-black racism and so forth, so I'm happy to defend that choice.

In this instance, Arsenal is in the third category i.e. "mostly white".

The Results:

FA Football Teams Comparison:

WSLFA Cup 4th RndFA Cup 4th + 3rd*
Diverse Team75%53%56%
Less Diverse17%31%25%
Mostly White8%16%19%
n=12n=32n=52

(* This is the 32 teams from the 4th Round, plus the 20 knocked out in the 3rd)

(Yes that 8% in the WSL Mostly White category is JUST Arsenal)

UEFA Women's Champions League Comparison:

UWCL KnockoutUWCL GroupUWCL All
Diverse Team63%63%35%
Less Diverse13%6%14%
Mostly White25%31%50%
n=8n=16n=71

If you'd like to check my working and don't fancy finding the rosters for 130 clubs on your own, or if you're just a spreadsheet nerd, you can find it here. [ETA: as stated below, anyone's welcome to use my data and spreadsheet to improve the club.]

Conclusions:

Firstly, more diverse teams are more successful teams. That's pretty clear. Correlation does not equal causation, so there might well be other factors at play (more successful teams have more money to buy better players etc.) But I don't think we can put down the whiteness of the team to Arsenal lacking the money for good players or being a small local team. The whitest teams in the UWCL are often from Scandinavia, Eastern Europe, or smaller countries, but that's not universal - the teams from Khazikstan are pretty diverse, for example.

Arsenal is much whiter than other comparable teams, within the UK and among its European peers. It's the whitest team in the WSL, and the only WSL team without a black player. It's also whiter than 81% of the FA cup 3rd/4th round teams, and whiter than 75% of the UWCL knockout teams.

So now I have the data to back up my observation, I want to ask you all this awkward question... why is the team so white?

ETA: So I see from the 52% 45% 43% upvote stat (and falling) that this was indeed an uncomfortable question. Thank you to everyone who gave a thoughtful response, and for the awards.

Edit 2: On the Club's careers portal, there's a job opening for a Diversity & Inclusion Manager. Anyone who wants to use the data in this post and the attached spreadsheet to improve the club is welcome to do so, no citation is necessary. (But if you get the job and wanna buy me a pint, I won't complain).

Edit 3 - 9 Months later: With the departure of Rafaelle, this has of course gotten so much worse that it's actually made the news today [Link]


r/ArsenalWFC • • Jan 16 '25

Discussion/Question Lack of representation

9 Upvotes

I believe Jonas said nearly three window’s ago that the club were aware of the lack of diversity in the squad. And hardly anything has been done (at least on the outside) to improve this. I totally get that you can’t just sign players for the sake of it but you have to start somewhere and a player like Kerolin would’ve been perfect. They don’t call us Blonde FC for no reason 😖 Thoughts?


r/ArsenalWFC • • Dec 23 '25

What's Gone Wrong for Jenna Nighswonger at Arsenal?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ArsenalWFC • • Sep 12 '25

Saw this on the bbc

Post image
0 Upvotes

And honestly it confused me so much for second. Was like since when does Russo play for City 😂


r/ArsenalWFC • • Oct 12 '25

Renee’s red flags

0 Upvotes

I don’t wanna be super negative but I just have to say what’s on my mind currently, I love our gaffer but I think she has so many red flags in management and until she changes that I don’t see her lasting long here.

she has some of Jonas eidevall traits which is being so rigid and not changing your ways and personnel, our 3 biggest problem so far this season is lack of recruitment in centre backs(esp after Leah Williamson injury), mariona caldentey shocking form in that deep lying midfield, and our goalkeeper somehow is starting to play like she is zinsberger…

While I get the non recruitment ain’t up to her you can shuffle the pack esp in midfield, 20 minutes plus of Kyra has shown she is more than capable of starting esp when mariona keeps losing the ball and giving up chances, she needs to also know the games to use different personnel in that defence if you want ball progression you can’t start Katie Reid over lotte, lotte shouldn’t have played against city should have been Reid and games at home to Brighton and Villa lotte should be starting..

I dunno we look bad and she has to change something unless you ain’t gonna have a job here and last ssn is gonna look like a massive fluke

Today we couldn’t get the ball to our forwards cos the midfield was non existent something needs to change cos, all I see currently is a team devoid of ideas and so many players look so out of form at the same time, how do you remedy that by using the full length of your squad rotate make the so called starters esp in midfield feel uncomfortable that their place is for grabs don’t reward series of shit performance with starts..


r/ArsenalWFC • • Apr 30 '25

No words…

9 Upvotes

I am finding it hard to know what to say to be fair…. What the hell happened tonight!? We put out our reserve team, and wow .. Manu .. well I know there is 2 pots of peoples with Manu. I am sorry but she was part of the collective to perform bad tonight … I said it before but she is not good enough to be in Arsenal as our 2nd goal keeper… we need another keeper … Reid.. given a full game… made lots of critical mistakes … McCabe…. She had a shocker tonight … Wubben .. given a full game when just back to the squad… too much too soon … she needed more time..

To be honest .. too many things to mention .. no one person to blame, but tonight I think Renee got it very wrong… but it was an embarrassing performance tonight … definitely a hard pill to swallow


r/ArsenalWFC • • Sep 21 '25

Just some opinions

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone I hope you are doing well.So decided to write about what we are lacking and what needs to be some issues which may cause bigger problems in the future. First of all as I said in the live thread during the game we are not used to playing against physical teams and we get pushed around when we play them. You could see stina being thrown around. If we play like this soft in champions league it will be hard to finish top 4 to avoid playing in playoffs. Other issue is that I saw some people talk about mariona and how she seems off for the past game(s). I think she was really good last year that she raised the bar too high and when she plays a bit down that people doesnt like it. But it has been 3 games so she may need to step it a bit. Another issue is our freaking sloppy passes. If we play a quick and creative team we are doomed. We give away the ball in very stupid ways like passing the ball where no one is there or like in a space where the opponent can get it quickly. The other thing is I don’t know if I saw anyone talk about this but katie mccabe is off. Like past seasons she was going forward passing and assisting foord causing problems on the left for the opponent. This year she goes inwards to much to be honest so this may cause some issues on the left side since sometimes it is left unattended and steph is not that fast so if we play against a team with a fast no 9 or a fast right winger we may conceed. I said this before and people said it will be fine etc but we need a creative midfielder. We need a midfielder who could break defence down who can create something especially when others cannot. We need someone who can dribble pass defender and score or who can find gaps and create. We play west ham or lcl of course we can create but as we saw today against top teams we just cannot. I don’t think it will be done if I don’t say a thing or two about kcc or jenna “situation”. I think it was a bit an issue when renee said now that lia left kcc will have the no 6 position because like if she isn’t gonna be your main 6 starter just don’t say it and make the hopes go up for both the fans and probably for kyra too. In this market, most clubs are hungry for a good number 6 and kyra is one of them for me so I wouldn’t be so shocked if she leaves in January are worse she leaves for free next summer( I assume her contract is for 3 years). Kim little seems really good these past days but mariona could have been replaced even kcc may come later in game to replace her. For jenna situation I think she was really never given a chance things happened after things so she was a bit unlucky so I hope she leaves in January to a club that will cherish her talents and good work.

So these are just my opinions that I think is our downsides and of course may be fixed in the future games. You may say who are you to say something but these are just what I think. Btw of course I have many positive things to say too but this is reality and we lack these things for now and to win a trophy this year hopefully all 4 we need to work a little on these issues. Ps no 1:Sorry if my English doesn’t make sense. English is not my first language. Ps no 2: I have no hate towards any player or any coach or any staff member just opinions🙏


r/ArsenalWFC • • May 14 '24

Other [caitlinf0ord] Jonas Viv altercation

Thumbnail
x.com
0 Upvotes

Shocking to see at the least. Hayes was waffling when talking about "male aggression" in the conti cup final touchline incident but this is clearly unnecessarily aggressive behavior for a male coach in a woman's sport and Jonas has to understand that


r/ArsenalWFC • • Jun 02 '26

Thoughts on McCabe

0 Upvotes

Going to Chelsea in the women’s game is the same as going to spurs in the men’s game….

I can accept city cos they have no fans even less in the women’s game they legit have like 4 fans in women footy…

Hopefully she gets booed a lot and Olivia smith runs it back what she did to her in that fa cup semis when she was at Liverpool…

How can you go to the club where they have insulted you all your career called you the most vile names including some of the worse insults like just this season some Chelsea fans were questioning your gender, they was literally giving you death threats in your dms and comment section you had to turn it off, we all love money e.t.c but somethings are not morally right cos how can you look at those same fans that wanted you gone out of existence and play for them …

and you defo saw all the insults.. she is legit so weird

Let’s not talk about her slow ass every fast winger legit just runs past her, give it 3 months and Chels fans would be tired of her antics

we Arsenal fans fought your corner blindly mutiple times even when you was getting the most daft yellow cards and how many times you cost us games against Chelsea cos you are so slow and just do daft things … yeah F off and bye


r/ArsenalWFC • • Oct 12 '24

Arsenal Starting 11 What I want to going forward

0 Upvotes

When I saw the lineup it was good players not good balance. Goalkeeper Daphne or Manuela start consistently to build defense chemistry. Full Back Katie McCabe and Emily fox but please rotate them Steph and McCabe to right back. Defense Codina and Lotte or Leah no explanation as they are to similar profile. Midfield pivots Kyra and Little or Lia because of " aging leg" to provide some fresher legs I prefer Frida slightly deeper as another option of pivots wings the winger position Mariona and Foord. Beth will crowd the center of the pitch and disrupting play and have one winger cutting inside and one holding width. The ten Alessia Russo. Striker should be Rosa or Beth that only place she should play to not over crowd the center.

Jonas if you are not sacked please read this ps you might win some matches.


r/ArsenalWFC • • Oct 06 '26

Line-Ups For fun, not to be taken too seriously or arguments to happen. But what would be your main starting lineup given current conditions and player performance? Remember, there is no wrong line up, justcopinions.

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is mine, moving Russo back as lately she's been marked heavily and isolated in attack, giving her the opportunity to move freely.

Smith is good at upsetting the defence either making them angry or getting through.

Williamson i feel like so far hasn't even been 90% of what she can do, recently had many slip ups, errors or just lack of urgency to stop the ball (which i cant believe crossed my mind when it comes to her) which then opens RB up for Holmberg who can press up high on that wing to get us more scoring opportunities.

Would love to see your version below.


r/ArsenalWFC • • Sep 02 '25

Our Women's Super League 2025/26 Predictions!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ArsenalWFC • • Mar 26 '24

Discussion/Question Arsenal Down Under!

0 Upvotes

So I just spent a small fortune on tickets to see our favourite players when they tour down under. I booked flights from Queensland and was about to book accommodation, then I thought, I wonder if the brains trust would know where they could be staying? Would be super amazing for the kids (let’s face it, my wife too), to be staying at the same hotel and maybe bump into them. Any thoughts?


r/ArsenalWFC • • Sep 18 '21

WSL Reaction | Arsenal v. Chelsea (09.05.21)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ArsenalWFC • • Mar 14 '24

Discussion/Question Pregnancy and playing

0 Upvotes

I have a question on players being pregnant and not playing. Cause why is it that once you’re pregnant, that even in the early months, you won’t play games anymore like we’ve seen Amanda do?

Like yes football is a physical sport but surely when you’re pregnant you can atleast join a full training session instead of only “undertaking light training”. It’s not like the day you find out you’re pregnant you’ve suddenly gotten a major injury.

Btw this is not critisising Amanda, just something that crossed my mind when I saw the statement. I’m just genuinely curious why she would suddenly get treated like fine china lol. But maybe this pathway is what’s in some rulebook or something.

However, I do think that it’s nice that they’re now allowed to sign another player to replace her immediately. Any guesses on which defender would be available? I’ve heard Girma but tbh I don’t know if that’s actually realistic. Rafa would be nice but since she has her foot injury she’s not immediately available so I’d say no. And then Dominique Janssen I guess? Unless we get a nice surprise


r/ArsenalWFC • • Feb 04 '24

Discussion/Question AWFC is putting players back in the game too soon

0 Upvotes

I'm not sure if anyone else feels this way, but putting Williamson in the starting lineup for her second or third match is far too much. We need to give our ACL injuries more time to improve instead of giving into fan pressure and getting them straight back on the pitch, I know they need game time to improve, but putting this much pressure on recovered players is just asking for more injuries!

Edit: I am not trying to say that her coming back was what caused the loss, I am just concerned (as lots of AWFC players have suggested) that the schedule is too packed and throwing LW in for a full 45 mins so soon after her injury could be risky. Also respect the fact that I know nothing about being a physio, just don't want these players to have to go through the heartbreak of another injury due to over working too soon.


r/ArsenalWFC • • May 18 '24

Miedema Farewell Chant

23 Upvotes

“Oh Jonas do you know what that’s worth

Viv Miedema’s the best on earth

The silky Dutchie is just what we need

You’re a muppet for letting her leave”

Sung to the tune of ‘Heaven is a Place on Earth’


r/ArsenalWFC • • Apr 26 '21

Discussion This is considered a controversial topic but we need to be honest. There's a player that is a fan favorite but I really think is replaceable in the starting eleven.

0 Upvotes

She's had a decent season but I think we need better if we really want to challenge for the Championships League next season. This player is amazing but she's not the best at anything in the squad. Which is why I believe she has been placed out of position for the entire season. With Steph Catley coming back into the fold. I think this player would be starting from the bench. The player I'm talking about is not Katie McCabe.


r/ArsenalWFC • • 11d ago

Coaching option for us?

Thumbnail
bbc.com
4 Upvotes

Nice article. Could be a future option.


r/ArsenalWFC • • Nov 07 '24

Rumour Arsenal Evict Women’s Team From Emirates Stadium For Crucial UWCL Tie

Thumbnail
forbes.com
26 Upvotes

It has been confirmed that our home game against Bayern Munich will NOT be allowed to change date or time, per UEFA's rules and regulations. It now looks likely that our game will be moved to Meadow Park (also per the UEFA regulations) as teams have to put forward two home locations for their games.


r/ArsenalWFC • • Jan 02 '24

Arsenal chance to grab more points in WSL and FA WSL

0 Upvotes

What the most success arsenal (women) tactic and strategy this half season?


r/ArsenalWFC • • Jul 20 '24

Discussion/Question Is Jonas Underrated….?!

15 Upvotes

Hi Gooners…I just thought this was a very very interesting question I’ve been thinking about this for a while

And I think Jonas is Underrated if you think about. Let’s just run through some of His accomplishments as Arsenal Manager so far

-Year One •Made it to Champions League QF •Lost the league by ONE point •Made it to the Semis of the FA Cup •QF of Conti-Cup

-Year Two •Won the Conti-Cup (after Arsenal haven’t won a trophy in four years) •Made it to the Semis of Champions League (even though all of his “top players” were injured)

-Year Three •Won the Conti-Cup

-I will say that this past season was not this best performance as Arsenal Manager but I still think that every Manager goes through a season that’s not the best but…I know that not a lot of Managers can come in first season and almost win the league. Also stay as composed as he did when all of his players were injured so…

This Question is all yours to answer so…Gooners let me know what you thoughts are.


r/ArsenalWFC • • Jun 21 '20

if your a racist football fan

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes