r/Arianespace • • Dec 29 '18

Article even an economic friendly german newspaper figured out that the ariane 6 is a problem

Thumbnail
sueddeutsche.de
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jun 09 '22

ESA needed to save NASA’s Moon plans.

3 Upvotes

The SLS was planned to have a large upper stage called the Exploration Upper Stage(EUS). This would take the SLS Block 1 to the SLS Block 2, needed for a single flight lunar architecture. However, the multi-billion dollar cost for development of a large upper stage from scratch means it’s unlikely to be funded.

NASA is proposing a solution using the Starship making separate flights. But this plan takes 6 flights total or likely more of the Superheavy/Starship for the Starship to fly to the Moon to act as a lander. One look at this plan makes it apparent it’s unworkable:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/d9/Artemis_III_CONOPS.svg/640px-Artemis_III_CONOPS.svg.png

Everyone, remember the Apollo missions where we could get to the Moon in a single flight? In fact, this would be doable with the SLS given a large upper stage. Then the suggestion is for the ESA to provide a Ariane 5 or 6 as the upper stage for the SLS. It would save on costs to NASA by ESA paying for the modifications needed for the Ariane core.

As it is now ESA is involved in a small role in the Artemis lunar program by providing the service module to the Orion capsule. But it would now be playing a major role by providing the key upper stage for the SLS.

The argument might be made that the height of the Ariane 5/6 is beyond the limitations set forth by NASA for the EUS. However, if you look at the ca. 30 m height of Ariane 5 core compared to the 14 m height of the interim cryogenic upper stage now on the SLS, this would put the total vehicle height only a couple of meters beyond the height that had already been planned for the SLS Block 2 anyway:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/db/Super_heavy-lift_launch_vehicles.png

See discussion here:

Budget Moon Flights: Ariane 5 as SLS upper stage, page 2.
https://exoscientist.blogspot.com/2013/09/budget-moon-flights-ariane-5-as-sls.html

Coming up: ESA also could provide a low cost lander for the Artemis lunar program.


r/Arianespace • • Dec 24 '21

So is the JWST launch coverage from Arianespace going to be garbage?

4 Upvotes

Question as per title. Arianespace have a storied history with extremely underwhelming launch coverage from past flights. One would hope given the stature of this mission and its predominant NASA ownership, we might have more to see than a talking head covering "planned" launch events?

Are we going to even see the telescope separate from the stage?


r/Arianespace • • Jan 02 '19

A problem with "Adeline"

0 Upvotes

I decided to post this here instead of on r/SpaceXLounge where I make most of my space related posts, as this is more related to the Ariane rockets.It has to do with this concept, known as "Adeline"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tV29pEvZvZwIt is a good idea for low-effort reuse of the most expensive parts of a rocket. But there is a glaring problem I see that I just can't take my eyes off of - the wings.

The wings are always there and exposed, even on ascent. These wings would make the rocket aerodynamically unstable - they would produce unnecessary aerodynamic forces that would try to tilt the rocket, and would to my understanding require some sort of compensation by the engines that would waste fuel.


r/Arianespace • • Nov 06 '22

The EU’s galactically bad space programme

0 Upvotes

Interesting article about the state of human spaceflight:

The EU’s galactically bad space programme https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-eus-galactically-bad-space-programme/

The author decries the fact for example there is no European human space launchers. Remarkably, the greatest advance in European space flight could be made by a journalist. All it would take would be well-recognized European space journalist to ask the impertinent question: how much would it cost to put a 2nd Vulcain engine on the Ariane 5/6 core, and for them to then publicize the answer. For in actuality, it would only take in the range of $200 million development cost, and the two-stage all liquid launcher, no solid side boosters required, could be man-rated and only cost $70 million per launch:

On the lasting importance of the SpaceX accomplishment, Page 3: towards European human spaceflight. https://exoscientist.blogspot.com/2013/05/on-lasting-importance-of-spacex.html

But no one asks that impertinent question of those in European space agencies so it is not recognized how low cost and easily Europe could have it’s own manned spaceflight capability.


r/Arianespace • • Nov 29 '19

Musk wants to colonise LEO - Stéphane Israël

Thumbnail
businessinsider.com
3 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • May 14 '21

Ariane 5 issue could delay JWST

Thumbnail
spacenews.com
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jan 06 '19

India to become a manned space-faring nation in 2022. ESA could beat that.

Thumbnail
self.esa
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Nov 20 '14

Space tourism is a waste of humanity's time, says Arianespace CEO, Stephane Israel

Thumbnail
canberratimes.com.au
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Mar 17 '20

This is a news edit underscoring the need to reform space administration in India

Thumbnail
newsroom24x7.com
1 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • May 20 '23

A fast route to a European low cost, reusable, manned launch vehicle.

0 Upvotes

European space advocates have been lamenting there appears to be no near term route to getting a launcher competitive with the SpaceX Falcon 9, getting launcher reusability, and getting a manned launcher.

Actually, Europe already has the needed components to produce a launcher that's even cheaper than the Falcon 9, reuse capable, and manned spaceflight capable.

All it would require is someone, anyone in the European space community to ask the impertinent question, "How much to add a 2nd Vulcain to the Ariane 5/6?"

For once that question is simply asked, and ArianeSpace forced to answer honestly, it would become obvious how to proceed.

The situation is analogous to the famous "Emperor has no clothes" story. The youngest babe could simply ask the question, and the answer once given would make apparent the solution has been right in front of them all along.

Who in European space will ask the impertinent question: How much would it cost to add a second Vulcain to the Ariane 5/6?

https://exoscientist.blogspot.com/2023/05/who-in-european-space-will-ask.html

Robert Clark


r/Arianespace • • May 31 '23

Towards every European countries own manned spaceflight.

0 Upvotes

In my blog post I noted the only reason why ArianeSpace is using the more expensive solid rocket boosters rather than just adding another Vulcain is political. The majority of the development funds and revenues from launch go to those ESA member states producing the solids. If those solids were no longer used that majority of funds would go down to nearly nothing.

So that‘s a severe political problem for the other member states who might want to go to an all-liquid propulsion form for the Ariane 6. But there may be away to get to it anyway. If a member state wanted to spend their own money to build a prototype Ariane 6 core using two Vulcains how could other member states prevent it? It’s their own money. They can spend it anyway they want. As discussed in the blog the Ariane 5/6 core stage price is less than the Falcon 9. Then remember quite key to why the all-liquid this is approach is preferable is because how low cost the development costs would be. The example of JAXA adding a second hydrolox engine to the H-IIA core for ca. $200 million demonstrates this:

In point of fact it’s probably even cheaper than this just to add the second engine. The transition from the H-IIA to the H-IIB actually involved multiple systems:

Then conceivably the cost just for adding the engine only might be only $100 million or less. But when there is no multi-billion dollar development cost, any of the ESA member states could afford to add an additional engine to an Ariane 5/6 core on their own. It’s so low that even the member states that spent billions developing the solids could also adapt a Ariane core to have two Vulcains at this low cost.

At such a low development cost and each per rocket cost being even lower than the Falcon 9 each ESA member state could have their own independent all-liquid Ariane launchers. And then without the safety issue of solids, each ESA member state would have their own independent manned flight capable rockets.


r/Arianespace • • Jul 11 '24

Help me find a quote about a high ranking official in the European space scene critical about SpaceX

0 Upvotes

I remember vaguely that there was a high ranking executive of ESA? or Ariane? Airbus? speculating SpaceX will fail because he doesn't see the market for rockets exceeding 20 per year or something.

I googled extensively but couldn't find anything but I'm sure i read it years ago and got mad...

edit: thanks for the replies!


r/Arianespace • • Apr 19 '18

Russia appears to have surrendered to SpaceX in the global launch market

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
10 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Apr 20 '21

Amazon contracts nine Atlas 5 missions for Kuiper broadband satellites

Thumbnail
spacenews.com
14 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jun 27 '19

Europe says SpaceX “dominating” launch, vows to develop Falcon 9-like rocket

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
18 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Feb 06 '19

"French auditor says Ariane 6 rocket too conventional to compete with SpaceX"

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
4 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jul 06 '23

Ariane five

1 Upvotes

As the Ariane five is currently flying for the first time I relished something, the Ariane 5 was made with human space flight in mind, now that it is retired how come it never flew humans


r/Arianespace • • Nov 04 '19

Space Transportation at Space 19+

Thumbnail
esa.int
1 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jul 12 '22

Video SpaceXCRS - 25 / July 14th

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jul 12 '19

Will the failure of Vega redirect contracts to SpaceX?

17 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Dec 03 '14

French space minister Fioraso's view of SpaceX is unchanged: SpaceX bills NASA 2X the price of acomparable commercial missions, she said. #ESAMC14

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Nov 30 '20

Video Arianespace Flight VS24 (EN)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Arianespace • • Jan 14 '24

“We are worried,” says European rocket chief at prospect of launch competition [from European startups, among others]

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
5 Upvotes