r/ArduinoProjects • • May 01 '21

Please stop posting video guides

They aren't helpful for Arduino projects. No one wants to sit through five minutes of video to see the equivalent of four lines of code and a wiring diagram.

44 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

7

u/JCRiotz May 01 '21

People learn in different ways. A video can often show more than pictures, and assure you that you are doing things properly.

Please don't assume that, because you don't find something useful, that no one will.

4

u/fursty_ferret May 01 '21

But wouldn't you say it's harder to learn from a video when any sample code has to be typed out letter by letter into the editor? If you put yourself in the shoes of someone brand new to Arduino, C++, or both, tiny mistakes such as "=" instead of "==" or a missed semicolon can be incredibly frustrating to track down.

If the video includes a link to a Github project page, great.

3

u/GaCoRi May 01 '21

That's true . I think there's a middle ground here

3

u/JCRiotz May 01 '21

I definitely agree that a video is next served with some supporting documentation, such as source code. I agree with you there.

1

u/NZNoldor May 01 '21

Generally the videos have a link to the code included with them.

1

u/Tooni_Warri May 02 '21

I really thought of that. I've thought about people requiring to share their code when showcasing their project. However, I am a bit afraid of missing some great or complicated projects of people wo just don't like to share their code. Beginners could also be not self confident enough to share, even while their creations are great.

27

u/Dwagner6 May 01 '21

I’m not against posting video tutorials altogether, but I am really tired of all the low-effort tutorials that are posted.

Like, great, you figured out how to use your capacitive soil moisture sensor. So did thousands of others who’ve also made videos.

6

u/MeatyTreaty May 01 '21

If you want low-effort, do it properly and just straight copy one of the official tutorials.

25

u/[deleted] May 01 '21

I think a lot of people are missing the point that this sub is overrun with repetitive low effort content and that's a bad thing for this community. Video tutorials are great and can be a cool and fun if they add value to the content they are presenting. But lots of people have presented Arduino content before. This ecosystem has been around long enough that there's tons of resources, help, and similar projects out there to fit any learning style. We don't need to see every tutorial creation on our homepages.

1

u/Tooni_Warri May 02 '21

The thing is the content could be low effort and repetitive, but that doesn't mean that people didn't give it their own touch. People could use the exactly same sensor and wiring in totally different applications, giving people some new ideas. That's mainly my reason why I'm really permeable on people creating content for others

9

u/Enlightenment777 May 01 '21

unfortunately, far too many technical videos suck

6

u/SkullRunner May 01 '21

I think if you’re going to do a video tutorial, a link to editable files and wiring diagrams would help a ton.

42

u/klaymon1 May 01 '21

Stop watching the video guides then.

They are helpful for others. For some who are starting out, there is expanded understanding on what certain lines of code do, or why something is wired the way it is.

4

u/RaymondoH May 01 '21

Videos are great and I have nothing against them. Personally I prefer things written down and drawn so that I can learn from them. You can only access videos in a linear fashion so if you are trying to code from a video example you have to keep going back if you missed anything.

4

u/Tooni_Warri May 02 '21

As the owner of the subreddit, I'm really open to get in discussion to improve the subreddit.

The reason why I'm pretty easily satisfied with all the creatures, is that in my opinion the subreddit was made for getting inspiration and seeing people using sensors in different contexts. As example I've seen some temperature sensors came along in different settings (in example attached it to my oven or in a weather station). My view of the sub always was always more to inspire people instead of giving technical information. On the other hand, when people do like certain (non-project-posts) in the community, I'm also more trying to be good for what the most people like :)

In the end, I'm running the subreddit a long time, it gets harder and harder to motivate myself everyday to go through each post and filter the bad ones out. The logs of people do help me a lot, but still aren't enough to create the niche page I've always wanted to be. I'm hoping this one clarifies a bit more on what my vision is on the page, if you have more ideas or want to get involved, feel free to answer of send me some private messages

10

u/BOBDOBBS74 May 01 '21

On the contrary, I've found video guides to be quite helpful. Some more then others of course. So if you don' t like them, consider not watching them.

7

u/meisdug May 01 '21

Too bad you can't just skip over things you don't want to watch

-2

u/Shakespeare-Bot May 01 '21

Too lacking valor thee can't just skip ov'r things thee wanteth not to gaze


I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.

Commands: !ShakespeareInsult, !fordo, !optout

6

u/LucVolders May 01 '21

Or even worse: hundreds of lines of code, that nobody can read or can scroll through to examine the code. Please write an instructable or make a webpage with instructions. Far better as a video guide.

1

u/Tooni_Warri May 02 '21

Would an arduinoprojects website maybe be a plus? That people are forced to put the project in a certain format which is unique for all the projects?

1

u/LucVolders May 04 '21

There is already an Arduino projects website. It is called Arduino projects hub. You can find it here: https://create.arduino.cc/projecthub

1

u/Tooni_Warri May 04 '21

Clean site! Exaclty on how I've wanted this reddit to be..

0

u/AdamTheHutt84 May 01 '21

If only there were a way to like “stop” or “pause” a video...

I think I’m gonna post like this entire thread on choosy beggars because it’s hilarious to see some people complaining about the ways others try to help them for free...

0

u/BfuckinA May 01 '21

Or on the other hand, a video guide on a single line of code. Idk what's worse

7

u/atdForge May 01 '21

Leave them alone. They might be useful to others. If you dont like them you're free to ignore them.

3

u/kapege May 01 '21

There might be some useful vids. But most of them are junk. Those useless vids are posted only for collecting upvotes and gaining money on YT. That's not the purpose of Reddit and I always look for the Redditor's name and if the same vid is spread over many communities I downvote them all and report them as spam. If others would do it this way, too, that junk may disappear in a while.

3

u/Jaskier_The_Bard85 May 01 '21

I also don't want this sub to die due to lack of content.

Instead of trying to get the sub to cater to you, you should probably just filter and avoid things you don't want to see.

2

u/Tooni_Warri May 02 '21

Your totally right! I'm also open to people just joined and start experiencing their first impressions on Arduino.

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '21

Actually, this kind of video help me a lot when I was starting to learn. Anyway who the Fu&¥k are you to asking something like that!? You’re the owner of this subreddit!? Sh$t up.

1

u/GaCoRi May 01 '21

Really? If i were a mod of this sub it would be a requirement that u show how to do it.