Despite being a long time fan of the Aptera vehicle due to its efficiency and affordability, I really can't root for Aptera Motors anymore since they seem to be their own worst enemy. There are a few points I would like to discuss constructively and I'm curious as to everyone's thoughts.
1. Design Choices:
Automotive Grade Solar Panels That Bend in 2 Axes:
-Although these are cool, they should be developed and integrated after mass production begins and the company is more stable
-A $26,000 EV that is 2.5x more efficient than a Model 3 still has enough merit on its own
Width:
-Although the wheels being further out makes sense aerodynamically, 87.6 inches is absurd even by American standards (an F-150 is 80 inches wide for reference)
-Aptera should have elongated the nose, like an F1 car, to bring the wheels inboard. It would still be a reasonable length for most people.
NACS Over CCS:
-Although NACS has a nicer form factor and more chargers in North America, CCS was open for anyone to use from the very beginning, whereas NACS is still largely proprietary
-Aptera should have started with CCS and then integrate NACS whenever the software becomes open, especially now that some CCS cars can charge with NACS anyways
Hub Motors:
-Although hub motors are great for packaging, they increase unsprung mass which results in a worse ride, especially for a 3 wheeled vehicle
-Unsprung hub motors also experience higher forces and wear
Carbon Fiber Over Fiberglass Sheet Moulding Compound (SMC):
-Although carbon fiber structures are far lighter for an equivalent amount of strength, weight is the last thing Americans care about and it doesn't affect range nearly as much as one might think
-The CF body needs to be made abroad whereas a fiberglass body can be made in the US, so both material and shipping costs would decrease significantly, especially since this is a $26,000 vehicle
2. Business Practices
Show Don't Tell:
-If the Aptera is even only 80% as efficient as claimed, that's still twice as efficient as a Model 3-It doesn't make sense not to have a fully instrumented prototype range test by a third party to convert skeptics and raise money
-Tesla's acceleration demo on the Roadster prototype and Bugatti's top speed record on the Chiron SS prototype gave them significant credibility. No more excuses for Aptera, the silence on this is deafening
Lack of Transparency in 2022:
-Everyone knows the auto industry supply chain is still a disaster, so delays are understandable. Poor communication and lack of transparency are not.-The webinar in January with the Delta renders (no prototype though), no DCFC, and the $50 million required to get into production was a complete bombshell after months of mostly silence
-Telling early reservation holders to put up $10K, in a recession no less, to keep their reservation spot or lose it to the accelerate program is disrespectful and tone deaf, as necessary of as it may be
Stop Clout Chasing:
-The Sustainability Sooner "announcement" was the last straw for me. Really amateur and unprofessional. I can't even argue in good faith that Aptera isn't a fraud anymore and won't have any sympathy if Aptera fails again
-They didn't even bother integrating any sensors for the Open Pilot announcement, so the cynical side of me believes it was only announced to distract from criticism of the Sustainability Sooner one
TLDR: The Aptera is more complicated than necessary and Aptera Motors has questionable business practices
Congratulations on making it to the end of the post. Please share your thoughts in the comments and whether I am overlooking or mistaken about things. Edited for clarity and because I somehow forgot to mention the width*