Throwaway account.
Hello to my fellow high school seniors applying to college. I’m making this post because I’m bored (knocked out supplementals for 24 schools back in August) and also because I'm done gatekeeping.
People automatically assume that with the increasing number of applications to top schools, there must be more competition.
But that’s a misread.
Competition, in the traditional sense, happens between any subset of students. But when individuals are evaluated under the facadey nature of "holistic" admissions, all that gets thrown out. The U.S. college admissions system isn’t like some other countries where you’re literally taking a test against thousands of competitors.
College application culture gravitates individuals to a mold
Students have always chased the highest grades (it’s been like this for a while)... but only recently have competitions and so-called extracurriculars blown up in the spotlight. Extracurriculars have become checklists. Most high achievers understand you don’t just join a bunch of clubs to "farm stats" for applications. But think about what that shift has done. There are students right now being misled, whether by social media or their parents, to believe the wrong things.
These are the kids who prioritize things above all else:
All-night study sessions.
Trying to maintain a 4.0.
Panicking over whether a 1470 is good enough for T20s.
Asking if a 3.8 GPA is “doomed” or if missing ECs means they’re screwed.
All of it? Noise. As more people apply to college, pressure grows. Pressure makes people break down and cling to these empty markers of validation. And still, most don’t even understand how the admissions system actually works.
As you’ve probably seen, more and more kids are founding nonprofits, doing research, running six-figure businesses, etc. Will that actually help them? Let's see below.
How your competition is being eroded
If you’re gunning for these schools, you already know that “crackhead” kids who aren’t taking school seriously aren’t your real competition. The presumed real pressure comes from the ones grinding academics, ECs, and college essays to perfection. But here’s the twist: all that grinding is actually eroding their chances, because it’s all surface-level.
Understand these 2 points:
The sole guiding principle of your college application is to show you can succeed academically while being a fit for their culture.
The sole guiding principle of your college essay is to make your admissions officer like you.
Accomplishments, credentials, awards... they become a vacuum chamber. People complain that admissions is random, that legacies and recruited athletes are cheat codes.
Grinding for medals, ECs, and essays becomes an outlet. It confirms for people that their work is paying off. That there are tangible result and a significant reward will be awaiting them if they just do the hard thing now.
It’s deeply ingrained within their identity. All that effort can actually hurt you. Tons of stuff, but no substance. No WHY or SO WHAT. Attempts to FORCE the mold.
This is the root of all those questions you see. Doubts, worries, even parents' fears.
Am I standing out? Am I memorable? What are the secrets of admissions? Is my college essay good?
You see these questions everywhere. All of it comes from trying to hold onto something concrete in a process that’s inherently fuzzy.
From an admissions officer's perspective, they could care less about you. There's no emotional attachment because you're just another carbon copy robot. They have many more of your exact archetype lined up. What's in it for them?
Start looking at the big picture. The little things you obsess over in your essay or that activity you think will make you "stand out" are NEGLIGIBLE. They only seem important to you because of the emotional weight and attachment you have behind them. Below, I'll show you how to get your admissions officer to feel the same way.
How do you actually get in?
Stop performing.
No one can be you better than you. Instead of trying to win on magnitude, win on self-expression.
Stop scrolling subreddits for the best essay tips. Just understand: while others drive themselves crazy chasing random crap, you can start articulating yourself. The sooner you free yourself from the pressure/need of performing for admissions, the sooner you can craft something meaningful: a methodical compilation of your life that shows a couple key things...
Academic vitality and ability to perform.
Exploration and proof of your niche interests beyond empty promises.
A thematic narrative line that emphasizes your unique insight and, above all, your humanity.
Eh? Seems pretty basic and like shit I've heard before.
YES. EXACTLY. You know what needs to be done but again, the need for validation is pulling you down. Find WHO YOU ARE and then build your application BOTTOM UP, as opposed to TOP DOWN. How do you expect for someone else to understand you when you don't even understand yourself?
At first, you’ll feel lost. I know I did. Nothing concrete to latch onto. But give yourself time to think. Literally think. Be bored. Brain dump, write, speak out loud. Use your brain for what it was supposed to be used for.
Show admissions you are NOT the most accomplished, or the most perfect, or the most flawed, or the even the most "authentic". Show them that you are the most true version of yourself.
Kids with flawless prose get in. Kids with robotic “doggedness” get in too.
Both were just good at expressing themselves.