This is mostly a rant, but seriously, why can't Apple give us more control over how iCloud Photos manages local storage?
I recently bought an iPhone 18 Pro Max with 512GB of storage, and I have Optimize iPhone Storage enabled.
The problem? It seems to offload photos and videos almost immediately. Even pictures taken just 2–3 days ago are already removed from local storage. So whenever I want to edit or share one of them, I have to wait for it to download from iCloud.
And here's the ridiculous part: I still have around 400GB of free space on my iPhone!
But if I disable optimization and choose to download and keep originals, iCloud wants to download my entire photo library, which is around 372GB. That's obviously not a great solution either.
Why can't we have something in between?
For example:
* Keep the last 365 days of photos and videos stored locally. * Let users allocate a specific amount of storage, say 50GB, for recently taken photos and videos. * Give us some control over how aggressively iOS offloads older content.
I've been using iPhones for 14 years. I have a massive photo and video library, I travel a lot, I have kids, and I'm a photographer. Taking and managing photos is a big part of how I use my phone.
I bought a 512GB iPhone for a reason. I don't expect it to keep my entire iCloud library downloaded, but having to download photos I took a couple of days ago while sitting on a phone with hundreds of gigabytes of free space is just frustrating.
Am I missing something, or is this really all the control Apple gives us?
Hi, I suddenly see that my gallery doesn’t show any content other than yesterday’s. The icloud does say the actual amount of photos that I have and I have started the “restoring” from it. But this is weird what is happening?? what to do? I have an iphone 13.
I just bought a new iPhone and set it up using a backup of my existing iPhone. I subsequently bought a 200GN iCloud+ subscription and started syncing on my Mac and the old phone. However I’m a bit worried about turning it on on my new phone because the number of photos on all 3 devices and iCloud differs.
On my Mac I have 14,432 photos in the library and the same in iCloud. However, i only have 11,320 on the old iPhone and I currently have 25,230 on the new iPhone.
When I went to turn on iCloud on the new iPhone I got a message telling me it is going to remove thousands of photos. Is it possible to see which photos it will remove? I’m worried that I’m about to lose 11,000 odd photos that I will not be able to get back! I tried to backup the new iPhone in both the Photos app and Image Capture but neither show the 25.230 photos to select. I also tried downloading iMazing but that isn’t working for me either.
Can anybody please advise on how I can backup the full 25,230 photos before I turn on iCloud?
I recently cleared my SSD with all my home photos and added it all to the photos app. The duplicate finder found duplicates and i cleared them all.
Now the issue is there are more duplicates but they are differently rotated. If i orient them both the correct way the in built duplicate finder works else no. Idk if it is meant to do this or not.
What i wanted to know if there is a tool like osxphotos (i currently use this and powerphotos to manage the library) or if osxphotos has the option which can correctly orient and rotate images in bulk so the duplicate finder can find them again.
Hey everyone! I’m an amateur photographer who has recently started exploring RAW photography. I’m shooting 48MP ProRAW on my iPhone 15 Pro. The photos look beautiful in the Photos library, with vibrant colours, good contrast and plenty of detail. But the moment I tap Edit in Photos or import the original DNG into Lightroom Mobile, the image looks noticeably flatter, brighter and washed out. The colours and contrast seem to disappear. I’ve tried different Lightroom profiles, changed RAW default settings to Camera Settings and experimented with HDR settings, but nothing seems to help. Is this normal behaviour with Apple ProRAW? Is there a way to retain Apple’s original rendering while still having the flexibility to edit RAW files? Would love to hear from anyone who’s faced this and figured out a solution. I’m still learning photography, so any advice is appreciated!
I’m transferring my DSLR images, mostly raw, to Photos. After importing, I find several thousand images have had their file extension changed. These are mostly Sony (ARW) and Nikon (NEF) image files. These Sony files end up with NEF extensions and the Nikon files end up with ARW extensions. I have exported these files back to my system drive and corrected the extensions with Finder. Upon re-importing, the file extensions get incorrectly tagged again.
Is anyone familiar with this issue? I have not found any bugs known by Apple or any mention in Apple forums.
I’m Akina, and I work on Layerlight, an iPhone photo editor. A small thing that helped when testing HEIC exports: HDR playback and the Styles button in Photos are two separate checks.
I save the export as a new photo and open it in Photos on the same iPhone. First I compare the highlights with the source. Then I tap Edit and check whether Styles is available on that copy. An image can display in HDR even if Photos can’t edit its Photographic Style. The Styles part depends on the file and the device/OS.
If it still looks right in Photos but looks flat after sharing, I’d keep the local copy and check what the receiving app is displaying before changing the edit. The export preview and the published feed can show different versions.
Has anyone seen a file look different while swiping through Photos versus after opening it? It would be interesting to know if that happens with exported HEICs too.
I have almost 77,000 photos and screenshots and I have no desire to swipe right or left on them all.
What I’m looking for is an app that can scan all my photos, ignore (or segregate) all the ones I take at my home or my workplace and file the remaining photos and videos into albums *within the photos app* based on where they were taken.
A single photo, or two, taken on a specific day can probably be ignored.
However if I took 24 photos on the 3rd of March 2009 in a place I don’t spend 90% of my time at there’s a fairly good chance some event happened and I want them all in an album. Just call it “2009-03-03 Dublin 024” for now and I can rename it to something more meaningful, like “Granny’s 90th B’Day” later.
If it saves everything it scans but didn’t file into an album into an “unprocessed” album that also helps later.
Are there any apps that do this, or similar ? I don’t care if they’re vibe coded as long as they work.
I know Apple Photos does smart albums but they’re just not comprehensive enough.
Problem Large videos can fill an iCloud storage plan or a Mac’s drive. I built Video Space Saver so I could keep lighter clips in Apple Photos for everyday viewing and store the full-resolution files on an external drive.
Solution
The app saves your full-resolution originals to a folder you choose, including an external drive, and imports smaller 1080p copies into Apple Photos. It then deletes the originals from Apple Photos. If you use iCloud Photos, the copies will sync across your devices with time and location.
My husband gifted me an Iphone 18 end of October and my old phone got formatted and returned. Four days ago, I discovered that most of my photos and videos (~20K) had disappeared, leaving only approximately 1,800 items on the device.
When I checked my iCloud account, it showed only 2 GB of storage. I purchased additional iCloud storage, but my missing photos and videos have not returned.
I have contacted customer support multiple times. During those conversations, I was told that when iCloud storage is full and Photos syncing is enabled, older photos are deleted to make room for new ones. Please confirm in writing whether this explanation is accurate.
I do not understand why insufficient iCloud storage would cause photos and videos to disappear from a phone with 1 TB of local storage. I understood iCloud to protect my memories, and I was not aware that syncing could result in their removal from my device. These photos and videos contain irreplaceable personal and family memories.
Has anyone else experienced something like that?
P.S. we checked all recently deleted and hidden files on the phone and iCloud.
I know it's probably really annoying to see another app for sale here but I really think this could help a lot of people. And for the amount of money it would save you and the work I put into it, I think the price is really fair ($4.99 after promo code). Its also free to try and is a lifetime download.
Update (Nov 21): Thanks for all the feedback, and sorry to anyone still waiting on a code, its coming to you soon hopefully. For most people the app is running smoothly. One warning before you compress: videos with more than one audio track, like spatial audio on newer iPhones, can come out sounding hollow. The fix is coming in the next update, 1.2.2. Until then, keep the originals of those videos. The rest of what people ran into is at the bottom of this post.
Update 2: If you like the app please leave a review :) Why it matters: I've started looking into ad spending, since feedback has been so great. I didn't realize just how expensive it is. At my current prices, it will most likely break even at best. Unfortunately without ad spending, the app is mostly invisible burried deep down in the rankings of a very flooded search term. So my best bet to try and keep the price low for everyone that doesn't buy from reddit is to have good reviews for better conversion which lowers ad spending and helps me with my rankings.
Update: Reddit is limiting how many new chats I can start, so just send me a chat saying Family or Individual and I'll send it there. If you already commented, the code will come eventually but if you want it sooner just send me a dm.
I'm the solo dev behind Cloud Media Shrinker. I have a big gap in my resume from quitting my software eng job to travel the world for 2 years. I gathered up a ton of videos while traveling. My iCloud Photos library hit 1.8 TB. I knew it was mostly long videos i took but theres no way to sort videos by size in the photos app.
So I built an app that sorts iCloud media largest to smallest files. Then you have 3 options, Keep, Delete or Compress. Compress makes a much smaller copy (HEVC for video, HEIC for photos) and puts it back in Photos with the original's date and location. The original is only deleted once the copy is in, and you can still get it back from Recently Deleted for up to 30 days. You can usually save around 50% on a video without dropping 4K. Because everything only gets sent to recently deleted everything is reversible EXCEPT one situation; if your iCloud is already full Apple doesnt keep recently deleted files, it will permanently delete. So I recommend reviewing or saving a copy before deletion if your iCloud is already full. There is also an autopick feature for quickly batch selecting media that meets your filter criteria.
Here's the scan on my own library. It says I could free about 1 TB of 1.42 TB through 1080p conversion aka "balanced". Honestly I only use Keep 4K because it still cutes the file size by about 45%.
I posted it on r/macapps a couple weeks ago and got way more feedback than I expected. Most of it is already out in 1.2.1, released today.
Its $9.99 for life, but Im giving 50% of coupons since I still would like to get more feedback and since Redditors have already been so helpful. So $4.99 for individual, $9.99 for family (anyone in your family can download it free). If you want to try it,leave a comment saying Individual or Family and I'll DM you a code.
All I ask is honest feedback, good or bad: what confused you, what broke, what you'd want added.
The iOS app has a nicer interface for going through your library quickly by just swiping through cards, the only thing is that iOS compression is a lot slower. In the future I will try to make it able to trigger the compression on your computer instead.
The biggest feature request on r/macapps was to add message attachment sorting and deletion. Good news is that is possible and coming in 1.3, bad news is I can only support that through direct link download. Still notarized and signed app but can't put that on the App Store because it requires screen accessibility permissions. But if you paid for the apple app you will be able to get the direct download free as well.
If a compressed video sounds hollow, like it was recorded in a tin can, that’s a bug with videos that have more than one audio track, like spatial audio on newer iPhones. The fix is coming in the next update, 1.2.2. Until then, keep the originals of those videos. If you already deleted one, it’s usually still in Recently Deleted for 30 days.
Slo-mo videos still play slow after compressing, but Photos can’t change the slow part anymore. 1.2.2 adds a warning plus a Slo-mo tag and filter. For now, skip the ones you want to keep editing.
On a Mac, a long queue can stall when the screen turns off, even if the Mac stays awake. For now, keep the screen on while it runs (or press Cancel on a stuck video and the queue carries on). It also needs free space, because originals are only removed once the whole queue finishes.
Codes only work in the App Store. One purchase covers iPhone and Mac with the same Apple Account, so on a Mac get it from the Mac App Store. The download on my website is a separate purchase and codes don’t work there.
To redeem, tap the link I sent, or open your account in the App Store and choose Redeem Gift Card or Code. The price shows in your local currency.
Seeing the same video twice? Those are usually real duplicates in your library. Photos can merge them under Utilities > Duplicates.
Hi again. I posted Selects here about a month ago. It’s a free app for tidying up your photo library. It finds the photoshoots (the 30 shots of the same thing) and suggests which few to keep, rounds up the screenshots, big videos, exact copies and blurry shots, and can compress the videos you want to keep but smaller. There’s also a swipe mode if you’d rather just go through photos one by one. Quick update on what changed since:
It works on iPad now. Any orientation, and you can resize the window.
There’s a map. You can see where your photos were taken and go through just the ones from one place, which is handy after a trip.
Compressing now works with slow-mo video too.
Also, a lot more people found it this month, about 20x more than the month before (mostly after a German site wrote about it), and it’s at 4.9 from 175 ratings. Thanks to everyone here who tried it and left a rating.
Same as before: free, no subscription, no ads, no account. There’s an optional tip jar and it doesn’t unlock anything. Your photos never leave your iPhone or iPad, nothing is removed until you confirm, and Recently Deleted keeps everything for 30 days. Needs iOS / iPadOS 26.
I'm the solo dev behind PicLoom, a photo journal and cleanup app. I've lived in Ottawa for almost three years, and my camera roll has 14,999 photos from here, taken on 1,003 different days.
I rebuilt the app next version, the Footprints map around one idea: browsing by where instead of when.
What it does
• Every photo sits where it was taken, as small round bubbles on a satellite map.
• Drag the map and the bubble nearest the center grows into a big lens. If it's a Live Photo or a video, it plays right there on the map.
• Tap it and it expands into a full-screen viewer with a filmstrip of everything shot around that spot.
• It's all read from the location already in your photos and worked out on your iPhone. Nothing is uploaded.
The new map interaction is coming in the next update; the Footprints map itself is already in the app.
Problem Big photo libraries are sorted by date, but a lot of memories are tied to a place. "That street", "that café", "the first apartment". Finding them by scrolling a timeline doesn't work.
Comparison
• Apple Photos (Places / map): shows thumbnails on a map, but you tap a cluster and land in a grid. Nothing plays, and there's no sense of moving through a place. In PicLoom you keep dragging and the photos come to you, Live Photos included.
• Google Photos map: a heatmap plus a grid, and it needs your library in the cloud. PicLoom works on your on-device library and never uploads it.
Pricing
• Free download; the Footprints map is free.
• Pro: $14.99 one-time, no subscription (unlimited photo reviewing, journal videos, trip albums, themes and more). Family Sharing on.