[Note, I'm not suddenly reinventing the wheel. Much of what is said here has obviously been argued before. Most notably by William Lane Craig. All I did was add some of my own arguments to better supplement what he says, as I'm mostly looking to inform, not debate. Argue amongst yourselves if you must pick apart what is said here, because non-believers tend to argue the exact same things in response to all this and I'm kind of tired of proving the same old arguments wrong. I will chime in if something new is actually argued in spite of the facts laid out.]
I want to give empirical evidence for God through the resurrection of Christ. The entirety of the Christian faith hinges on this event happening. If Christ did not rise from the dead, the whole Bible is untrue and all Christians have wasted their time believing in something that holds no water. However, if it is true that Christ did rise from the dead, the whole Bible is therefore true and Christianity has the right God.
Before we can even begin discussing the resurrection and whether or not it even happened, I want to discuss something more fundamental. Ever since the movement began, followers of Jesus Christ have said He was God in human form. But what about Jesus Himself? Who did He think He was?
With the rise of textual criticism, and the modern study of history, historians have developed tools to unlock this question. Today, Jesus of Nazareth is no longer just a figure in a stained glass window, but a real person of history whose life can be investigated historically. So let's examine the New Testament not as inspired Scripture, but as an ordinary collection of ancient documents. Let's apply to them the standard tests we would use with regard to any other ancient sources. When historians investigate the Jesus of history, what do they find?
Firstly, Jesus claimed to be the Messiah. The Jews of Jesus' day were waiting for a promised Messiah, a descendant of king David, a warrior king, who would bring military victory and spiritual renewal to Israel. They were familiar with the Prophet Zechariah's ancient words:
"Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion; shout, O daughter of Jerusalem: behold, thy King cometh unto thee: he is just, and having salvation; lowly, and riding upon an ass, and upon a colt the foal of an ass."-Zechariah 9:9
Jesus' triumphal entry into Jerusalem on the back of a donkey the final week of His life is attested in independent sources (Mark 11:1-11, John 12:12-19), one of the most important criteria for the historicity of an event. In doing this, Jesus was deliberately and provocatively declaring that He was the promised Messiah. The King of Israel.
Moreover, the plank nailed to Jesus' cross stated the charge against Him in mockery of His Messianic claims. "King of the Jews." The fact that later Christians did not use this derisive title for Jesus underscores its authenticity. For first century Jews, the word Messiah was packed full of meaning. Messiah comes from the Hebrew word mashiach and means “anointed one” or “chosen one.” The Greek equivalent is the word Christos or, in English, Christ. The name “Jesus Christ” is the same as “Jesus the Messiah.” In biblical times, anointing someone with oil was a sign that God was consecrating or setting apart that person for a particular role. Thus, an “anointed one” was someone with a special, God-ordained purpose. By assuming the title of Messiah, Jesus was claiming all this and more for Himself:
(Isaiah 9:6)- Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace
(Zechariah 9:9)-Bringing Salvation
Secondly, Jesus also claimed to be the Son of God. Jesus' consciousness of being God's Son in a unique sense comes to expression in His parable of the vineyard. This parable matches Jesus' teaching style and employs Jewish motifs typical of His day such as Israel as a "vineyard," God as a father, the religious leaders of that time as "husbandmen" (tenants), and God's prophets as "servants" sent to the tenants. The parable goes a little like this:
Once there was a man who planted a vineyard. Before leaving the country, he leased it to tenants. At harvest time, he sent a servant to collect his share of the fruit of the vineyard. But the tenants beat him away empty-handed. So, the owner sent more servants, but these too were beaten or killed. Finally, he sent his one and only son saying "Surely they'll respect my son." But those tenants said to one another "This is the heir. Let's kill him and the vineyard will be ours." So they killed the owner's son.
What do we learn from this parable about Jesus' self-understanding?
He thought of Himself as the only Son of God, God's final messenger, distinct from all the prophets, and even the heir of Israel itself.
Thirdly, Jesus claimed to be the Son of man. This was Jesus' favorite self-designation, being used some 80 times in the gospels. This has convinced the vast majority of historians that Jesus did, in fact, think of Himself as the Son of Man. Notice, not just a son of man, but the Son of Man. Jesus was directing our attention to a vision described by the prophet Daniel:
"I saw in the night visions, and, behold, one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of days, and they brought him near before him. And there was given him dominion, and glory, and a kingdom, that all people, nations, and languages, should serve him..."-Daniel 7:13-14
At Jesus' trial, the Jewish high priest accused Jesus: "Art thou the Messiah, the Son of the Blessed (God)?" His answer left no room for doubt. "I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven." (Mark 14:61-62).
Applying all three of these titles to Himself (Messiah, Son of God, Son of Man), Jesus was claiming, in no uncertain terms, that He was the very God His accusers worshipped. It's no surprise the Jewish court charged Him with blasphemy and condemned Him to death.
But that's not all! New Testament historians are agreed that the historical Jesus also claimed to have divine power and authority to perform miracles, cast out demons, revise Old Testament law, and forgive sins. He even went so far as to claim everyone's eternal fate is determined solely by whether we believe in Him.
Jesus' self-understanding cannot be reduced to that of a Jewish teacher or a charismatic leader. No, in fact, by putting Himself in God's place, Jesus was making a far greater claim about Himself than anyone else ever has before or since. So the question Jesus asked His disciples confronts each of us as well: Who do you say that I am?
How would you feel if someone said "Hello, I am God"? Throughout history, lots of people have claimed to be a god, but they lived in cultures that believed in lots of gods. And although these gods were more powerful than humans, they had limits. So, for example, when the Roman emperor claimed to be a god, it was not a big deal. But when Jesus of Nazareth claimed to be God, things were quite different. Jesus didn't say He was just one of many gods. His claim was much bigger than that. He had the audacity to identify Himself as the one true God of the universe.
You see, Jesus was a Jew and the Jewish conception of God was absolutely unique. It was unlike that of any other culture. Jews firmly believed there is only one God and He alone is the perfect, all-powerful, all-knowing, uncreated ruler of all things. He is without beginning or end and He alone created and sustains the entire universe. He is without limits, and He has no competition. So when Jesus claimed all of this for Himself, it's no surprise that He ignited a firestorm of opposition. No one had ever done this before. In fact, for the Jews, the very idea of God taking the form of a man (Isaiah 9:6) was lost on (most of) them after centuries of religious leaders perverting the Scriptures. Jesus thus created an identity crisis. Each of us must decide for ourselves: who was Jesus? Because, if He's not God, how can we possibly explain His unprecedented claim? He certainly wasn't crazy, joking, or lying. Let's consider five other explanations.
First, maybe Jesus was misunderstood. Perhaps He "never really claimed to be God" (despite everything already said). However, the historical evidence says otherwise. Centuries before Jesus, God revealed Himself to Abraham (a patriarch of Israel) as the great "I AM." So when Jesus said "Before Abraham was, I am," as recorded in the gospel of John, His Jewish audience knew full well that He was claiming to be equal to God. That's why they picked up stones to kill Him. And, as already stated, when Jesus identified Himself as "the Son of Man" mentioned in Daniel's prophecy, the Jewish High Court was well aware that He was claiming to be the pre-existent ruler and judge of the universe. As a result, they unanimously condemned Him to death. So no, Jesus wasn't misunderstood. To the Jews, His claim to be God was unmistakable. This explanation, then, fails.
But what about the second option? Maybe, Jesus was "just a legend." Maybe, in the first few centuries after Jesus lived, His followers merely "invented" the idea that He was God. Is this valid? Was belief in the deity of Jesus added centuries later? Or, did the very first Christians believe that Jesus was God? Again, the historical evidence speaks loud and clear the earliest Christian writers made clear reference to Jesus, who is "...our God." Jesus, who is "...both God and man." Jesus, who is "...not a mere man but was God." (Ignatius, Irenaeus, Clement, Justin Martyr, Paul, Polycarp).
So the idea that Jesus of Nazareth is God was not invented after the Christian movement began. No, not at all. Christians always believed it from the very start. So, this explanation fails too.
Another way to try to make sense of Jesus' claim to be God is "He was a clever political strategist." He "falsely claimed" to be God in the hope of focusing Jewish resistance against their Roman oppressors. However, in Jewish culture, claiming equality with God was not a good idea. In fact, it was a crime punishable by death (blasphemy). Jesus made it clear that He was not a political revolutionary and the Roman government itself officially declared Jesus not guilty of inciting rebellion. So this explanation doesn't work either.
The fourth explanation would be: what if the historical Jesus never even existed? Is this plausible?
No.
This explanation seems to run rampant amongst the uninformed. Contrary to this assertion, here's the facts: in addition to the eyewitness testimony of the four earliest biographers (Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John), multiple Greek, Roman, and Jewish historians document the existence of "Jesus, who is called Christ," (Lucian, Celsus, Tacitus, Pliny the Younger, Seutonius, Josephus, and the Talmud). In fact, there is as much documentary evidence for the existence of Jesus as there is for Julius Caesar. This is why the vast majority of New Testament scholars affirm that Jesus was an actual living, breathing, and historical figure. Again, just like the ones before it, this explanation just doesn't work either.
For those who examine the evidence objectively, all of these explanations fall short. But, for the open minded, there is at least one other option to consider. Perhaps, Jesus was who He claimed to be. Unlike the other options, this explanation fits perfectly with the historical data. But it does have one major problem.
It's not safe.
This is because, if Jesus actually is God in human flesh, your life is ultimately not your own. And true life can only be found in Him (John 14:6).
So, why was Jesus of Nazareth crucified? Because He made outrageous claims about Himself. He claimed to be the one and only Son of God. Why would anyone take His claim seriously? Well, that all depends.
If Jesus actually rose from the dead, His claim to be God's unique Son carries considerable weight. On the other hand, if the resurrection never actually happened, Jesus can be safely dismissed as just another interesting, but tragic historical figure.
Did Jesus rise from the dead?
As we explore this question, we need to address two further questions.
What are the facts that require explanation?
Which explanation best accounts for these facts?
There are three main facts that need to be explained:
Fact #1 - The discovery of Jesus' empty tomb.
Fact #2 - The appearance of Jesus alive after His death.
Fact #3 - The disciples' belief that Jesus rose from the dead.
Let's examine each of these, starting with the first. Fact #1. The discovery that Jesus' tomb was empty is reported in no less than 6 independent sources, (Luke 24:1-12, John 20:1-8, 1 Corinthians 15:3-5, Mark 16:1-8, Matthew 28:1-10, Acts 2:29-32), and some of these are among the earliest materials to be found in the New Testament. This is important because, when an event is recorded by two or more unconnected sources, historians' confidence that the event actually happened significantly increases. And the earlier these sources are dated, the higher their confidence. Moreover, the Gospels indicate that it was women who first discovered that Jesus' body was missing. This is likely historical, because in that culture, a woman's testimony was considered next to worthless (Mark 16:9-11, Luke 24:10-11). A later legend or fabrication would have had men make this discovery. Our confidence in the empty tomb is further increased by the response of the Jewish authorities. When they heard the report that the tomb was found empty, they said that Jesus' followers had stolen His body. Thereby admitting that Jesus' tomb was, in fact, empty.
"Most scholars, by far, hold firmly to the reliability of the Biblical statements about the empty tomb."-Jacob Kremer, professor of NT studies, University of Vienna
Fact #2. The appearances of Jesus alive after His death. In one of the earliest letters in the New Testament, Paul provides a list of witnesses to Jesus' resurrection appearances:
"And that he was seen of Cephas [Peter], then of the twelve: After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep. After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles. And last of all he was seen of me also..."-1 Corinthians 15:1-8
Furthermore, various resurrection appearances of Jesus are independently confirmed by the Gospel accounts, (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John). On the basis of Paul's testimony alone, virtually all historical scholars agree that various individuals and groups experienced appearances of Jesus alive after His death.
"It may be taken as historically certain that Peter and the disciples had experiences after Jesus' death in which Jesus appeared to them as the risen Christ."-Gerd Lüdemann, New Testament scholar, University of Göttingen
Fact #3. The disciples' belief in the resurrection. After Jesus' crucifixion, His followers were devastated, demoralized, and hiding in fear for their lives. These Jews had no concept of a Messiah that would be executed by His enemies, much less, come back to life. A Messiah, mind you, that most Jews had no idea would be Jesus Himself, despite all the prophecies He was fulfilling left and right. This was due in part to the 400 silent years in between the OT and NT. Thus, Jews forgot that their Messiah would literally be the sacrificial lamb due to the Pharisees and Sadducees perverting the Scriptures for so long. In fact, because of this, the only resurrection that Jews (besides the Sadducees) believed in was a universal event on judgement day after the end of the world, not an individual event within history. Moreover, in Jewish law, Jesus' crucifixion as a criminal meant that He was literally under God's curse.
Yet somehow, despite all of this, the disciples suddenly and sincerely came to believe that God had raised Jesus from the dead. They were so completely convinced that, when threatened with death, not one of them recanted. Even the Pharisee, Paul, who persecuted Christians, suddenly became a Christian himself, as did Jesus' skeptical younger brother James.
"Some sort of powerful transformative experience is required to generate the sort of movement early Christianity was."-Luke Timothy Johnson, New Testament scholar, Emory University
"That is why, as an historian, I cannot explain the rise of early Christianity unless Jesus rose again, leaving an empty tomb."-N.T. Wright, New Testament scholar, University of St. Andrews
These three firmly established facts cry out for an adequate explanation. How do you make sense of them? Down through history, various naturalistic explanation have been offered to explain away these facts:
-The Conspiracy Hypothesis
-The Apparent Death Hypothesis
-The Displaced Body Hypothesis
-The Hallucination Hypothesis
-The Legend Hypothesis
All of these have been nearly universally rejected by contemporary scholarship. The simple fact is that there is just no plausible naturalistic explanation of these three facts. The explanation given by the original eyewitnesses is that God raised Jesus from the dead. If it's even possible that God exists, then that explanation cannot be ruled out.
"For a God who is able to create the entire universe, the odd resurrection would be child's play!"-Peter Slezak, professor of Philosophy of Science, University of New South Wales
An empty tomb, Jesus' mass appearances alive after His death, and a group of dejected followers suddenly transformed by a radical new belief in a risen Messiah. These are independently established, historical facts. How do you explain them?
“This Jesus hath God raised up, whereof we all are witnesses.”-Peter (Acts 2:32)
For the sake of the argument, let's actually delve further into the naturalistic explanations offered that attempt to explain away what's been said. I already listed them all earlier, but I will only go over the first 4 for having disproven the 5th already (The Legend Hypothesis) when concerning the historicity of Jesus of Nazareth.
First, the Conspiracy Theory. According to this view, the disciples faked the resurrection, stole Jesus' body from the tomb, and then lied about seeing Jesus alive. Thereby perpetrating the greatest hoax of all time. However, this theory faces overwhelming objections. It's hopelessly anachronistic. It looks at the disciples' situation through the rear view mirror of Christian history instead of from the standpoint of a first century Jew. As already discussed, Jews (for various reasons, despite what their Scriptures had already told them) had no concept of a Messiah that would be defeated and executed by Israel's enemies, much less rise again. At this time, in Jewish thinking, the resurrection of the dead was:
A general event
Something that takes place only after the end of the world
Has no connection to the Messiah
The conspiracy theory also fails to address the disciples' obvious sincerity. People don't willingly die for something they know is not true. An honest reading of the New Testament makes it clear. These people sincerely believed in the message they proclaimed and were willing to die for.
"But people die for lies all the time. Fanatic Muslims blowing themselves and some innocent people up for the lie that they will be rewarded by God for it--would certainly be an example of one dying for lies--but trusting in someone's (in this case, Mohammad's) teachings and thinking it was the truth."
This seems like a good point at first. However, the Apostles who were with Jesus for 3 years, and then saw him resurrected, had an important difference. They would have known it was a lie--and they would be enduring torture knowing that Jesus was a blasphemer and fraud and that there would be no reward of eternal life for them. If they believed in God, they would be more likely terrified of God's judgement on them for dying for the cause of someone who blasphemed God.
For these and other reasons, no scholar defends the Conspiracy Theory today.
A second attempt to explain the facts is the Apparent Death Theory. "Jesus didn't really die. He revived in the tomb, somehow escaped, and managed to convince the disciples He was risen from the dead." This theory also faces insurmountable obstacles.
First, it's medically impossible. The Roman executioners were professionals. They knew what they were doing and made sure their victims were dead before taken down. Moreover, Jesus was tortured so extensively that, even if He was taken down alive, He would've died in the sealed tomb.
Second, this theory is wildly implausible. Seeing a half dead man who crawled out of the tomb, desperately in need of bandaging and medical attention, would hardly have convinced the disciples that He was gloriously risen from the dead.
As a result, no New Testament historians defend this theory today either.
A third explanation is the Displaced Body Theory. "Perhaps Joseph of Arimathea placed Jesus' body in the tomb temporarily because it was convenient, but later he moved the corpse to a criminal's common graveyard. So, when the disciples visited the first tomb and found it empty, they concluded that Jesus must have risen from the dead." Once again, this theory cannot make sense of the facts. Jewish laws prohibited moving a corpse after it was interred (except to the family tomb). What's more, the criminal's graveyard was located close to the place of execution. So the burial there would not have been a problem. Also, once the disciples began to proclaim Jesus' resurrection, Joseph would've corrected their mistake. This theory doesn't even attempt to explain all the appearances of Christ after His death, disciple or not. Furthermore, it seems to imply again that the disciples lied about said appearances. Otherwise, they wouldn't have even mentioned them had this really happened. We already discussed how impossible it was that they lied.
So, once again, no current scholars endorse this theory.
Finally, the Hallucination Theory. "The disciples didn't really see Jesus, but just imagined that He appeared before them. They were all hallucinating." This theory also faces considerable problems.
First, Jesus appeared not just one time, but many times. Not just in one place (Judea), but in different places (Galilee and Syria). Not just to one person (Mary Magdalene), but to different persons (James the Greater). Not just to individuals (Bartholomew), but to groups of people (the rest of the disciples). And not just to believers, but to unbelievers as well (Saul of Tarsus and James the brother of Jesus). There is nothing in the psychological casebooks on hallucinations comparable to these resurrection appearances.
Second, hallucinations of Jesus would have lead the disciples to believe at most that Jesus had been transported to heaven, not risen from the dead, in contradiction to their Jewish beliefs. Moreover, in the ancient world, visions of the deceased were not evidence that the person was alive, but evidence that they were dead and had moved on to the afterworld (Matthew 14:26-27, Mark 6:49-50, John 6:19-20).
Finally, this theory suffers from the same kind of weakness that the last one does. It, too, doesn't even attempt at explaining something major. However, unlike the Displaced Body Theory when concerning appearances, it is instead the empty tomb that the Hallucination Theory can't bother itself to explain.
Thus, the four most popular naturalistic theories fail to explain the historical facts. Where does that leave us? Another possibility is the explanation given by the original eyewitnesses: that God raised Jesus from the dead. Unlike the other theories, this makes perfect sense of the empty tomb, the appearances of Jesus alive, and the disciples' willingness to die for their belief. For the materialist, this conclusion is by default wrong, despite no one being able to conceivably reach any other conclusion (and supposedly wanting evidential proof for God). However, if this indeed happened, that would not only mean that God exists, but that He's the Christian God. If it didn't happen, that would not rule out all possibility that a God exists. All it would do is shut down any notion that He is the Christian God.
But the facts don't lie. It's just plain unreasonable to continue to vehemently deny the validity of the resurrection in spite of them. The evidence proves that God exists, and that He is the Christian God, no less. And for all my evidentialists out there, this was done through evidential means. Thus, knocking out two birds with one stone: God exists, and He's the God of the Bible.
Case closed.
"But he answered and said unto them, An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign; and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas: For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale's belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth."-Matthew 12:39-40