r/Apologetics • • Apr 20 '20

"Why Did God Create the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil?"

55 Upvotes

Since the earliest ages of human history, people have tried to excuse their wrong actions, and thereby avoid their personal responsibility. In the beginning, man used his mental capabilities to “ingeniously” create the first excuse that would absolve him of his culpability for breaking the law of God. He declared in his own defense:

“...The woman whom thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree, and I did eat.”-Genesis 3:12

The woman, following the “shrewd example” of her mate who thought he had placed the guilt upon her, quickly pondered:

“...The serpent beguiled me, and I did eat.”-Genesis 3:13

Actually, the situation has not changed much since then. Man has continued in his endless search for ever more subtle, sophisticated, and convincing excuses that could set him free from his moral and/or spiritual responsibility. In a more brazen way than the first man—who charged the woman directly, and God indirectly, when he said: “The woman whom thou gavest to be with me...”-Genesis 3:12—many today have puffed themselves up with pride to set God up as the initiator, promoter, and instigator of the tragedy in Eden.

"Tell a child or juvenile not to do something and you’re immediately establishing the temptation to do it. If you don’t want to tempt them you never mention it—and make sure the temptation is not available to be yielded to."

With this single defamatory charge, many men have attempted to forsake all weight of culpability and responsibility. [The truth is that if God is accused of our tragedies, errors, and corrupt actions, then man becomes “free” of his responsibility to God—and it is this freedom (or licentiousness) that many want to attain]. However, these men simply have not wanted to retain God in their lives (Romans 1:28), and in their efforts to find some peace in their licentious actions that impute their conscience, they have involved themselves in a deliberate search for a kind of intrinsic evil in the Divine nature.

The truth of the matter is that love requires free will—and free will, for its consummation, requires the possibility that a choice one way or the other can be made. In order for man to have choices that allowed for the use of his personal volition, a divine command was necessary. Simultaneously, of course, having the command in place paved the way for the possibility of freely choosing to either obey or to disobey such a command. God, in His infinite love, wanted for man to enjoy free will, and to choose to do His will. He wanted for man to love Him, not because it was the only option available to him, but because it was the only option that would guarantee him eternal joy.

God did not want Adam and Eve to sin. God knew ahead of time what the results of sin would be. God knew that Adam and Eve would sin and would thereby bring evil, suffering, and death into the world. Why, then, did God allow Satan to tempt Adam and Eve?

God allowed Satan to tempt Adam and Eve to force them to make the choice. Adam and Eve chose, of their own free will, to disobey God and eat the forbidden fruit. Most do not consider that perhaps this was all a test of our love for Him. Of course, if you or I did such a thing, it would be evil, twisted, and intolerable simply because we are imperfect and anything short of holy (that is, 100% perfect) is by defintion, unholy. But because God is 100% perfect (holy), knows past, present, and future, and only seeks what's best for us, it is completely justifiable for Him to do all this considering such a test might've just been to humble the man. After all, the man was quick to shift blame on the woman and God for what he did. Yet man still considered himself good.

"Every way of a man is right in his own eyes: but the LORD pondereth the hearts."-Proverbs 21:2

What if God is just trying to prove to the man that he is not good? That he is completely dependent on God for everything? Thus, God can accomplish His goal of making Himself the only option that would guarantee the man eternal joy, if man is truly given a choice to either choose to be with Him in eternity or choose iniquity instead. Considering our alienation from God due to sin, such a process could prove beneficial to serving God's glory and our eternal joy since He would have people in His presence that chose to turn to Him and genuinely love Him, despite us being in the midst of a fallen creation and given the option to blame our suffering/love for sin on Him instead.

"I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things."-Isaiah 45:7

This may seem strange at first. It would seem God is responsible for sin. However...

"And they built the high places of Baal, which are in the valley of the son of Hinnom, to cause their sons and their daughters to pass through the fire unto Molech; which I commanded them not, neither came it into my mind, that they should do this abomination, to cause Judah to sin."-Jeremiah 32:35

"They have built also the high places of Baal, to burn their sons with fire for burnt offerings unto Baal, which I commanded not, nor spake it, neither came it into my mind:"-Jeremiah 19:5

This seems contradictory to Isaiah 45:7 at first, however, if we just look at the two verses prior to Jeremiah 19:5...

And say, Hear ye the word of the Lord, O kings of Judah, and inhabitants of Jerusalem; Thus saith the Lord of hosts, the God of Israel; Behold, I will bring evil upon this place, the which whosoever heareth, his ears shall tingle. Because they have forsaken me, and have estranged this place, and have burned incense in it unto other gods, whom neither they nor their fathers have known, nor the kings of Judah, and have filled this place with the blood of innocents; They have built also the high places of Baal, to burn their sons with fire for burnt offerings unto Baal, which I commanded not, nor spake it, neither came it into my mind:"-Jeremiah 19:3-5

This shows that God is not responsible for sin, but evil rather. Different things. God merely uses evil to satisfy His will. Whether to bring about a greater good, or satisfy His due justice. Sin is merely men choosing evil over good out of their own will, not God's. All sin is evil, but not all evil is sin.

"O Lord, how long shall I cry, and thou wilt not hear! even cry out unto thee of violence, and thou wilt not save!... Behold ye among the heathen, and regard, and wonder marvelously: for I will work a work in your days which ye will not believe, though it be told you."-Habakkuk 1:2,5

In the book of Habakkuk, the prophet decries the sins of Judah but grapples with the fact that God’s chosen people will suffer at the hands of enemies even more wicked than they. God answers some of Habakkuk’s questions, as well as informs him of the fact that Babylon (the already wicked nation that God is using to judge Judah), will get their due punishment in time too. This results in a continuing faith from Habakkuk in God’s wisdom, sovereignty, and salvation.

"For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the Lord. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts."Isaiah 55:8-9

The problem is that we are limited in space and time, and in intelligence and insight. God, on the other hand, sees every detail of history from beginning to end, and orders it through people’s free decisions and actions. In order to achieve His purposes, God may have to allow a great deal of suffering along the way. Suffering which appears pointless in our limited scope of understanding may be seen to be justly permitted by God in His wider framework.

“Jesus answered and said unto him, What I do thou knowest not now; but thou shalt know hereafter.”-John 13:7

Sometimes what we experience makes no sense, until we gain a wider perspective and see the big picture designed by the Creator.

Furthermore, the chief purpose of life is not happiness. People often assume that if God exists, His role is to create a comfortable environment for His human pets. They think the ultimate goal of our lives on earth is happiness, and therefore, God is obligated to keep us happy.

However, Christianity presents a radically different view. That the purpose of life is to know God. This alone brings true, lasting fulfillment. Suffering can bring about a deeper, more intimate knowledge of God, either on the part of the one who is suffering or those around him. The whole point of human history is that God, having given us free will, is drawing as many people as He can into His unending kingdom. Suffering is one of the ways God can draw people freely to Himself. In fact, countries that have endured the most hardship have shown the highest growth rates for Christianity.

Something else to consider, God's purpose is not restricted to this life, but spills over beyond the grave into eternal life. This world is just the beginning. The entry way to an unimaginable, never-ending life beyond death's door. The apostle Paul underwent afflictions, hardships, calamities, beatings, imprisonment, hunger; yet he wrote:

"For which cause we faint not; but though our outward man perish, yet the inward man is renewed day by day. For our light affliction, which is but for a moment, worketh for us a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory; While we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal; but the things which are not seen are eternal."-2 Corinthians 4:16-18

Paul understood that life on earth, and whatever suffering it holds for each of us, is temporary. Our pain will not endure forever, but our lives with God will. Paul was not belittling the plight of those who suffer horribly in this life. Indeed, he was one of them; but he saw that those sufferings will be overwhelmed forever by the ocean of joy that God will gift to those who freely receive it.

Lastly, the knowledge of God is an incomparable good. If God exists, knowing who He is is just about the most important thing a person could possibly do in their life on earth, as well as in the beyond. Knowing God is the ultimate fulfillment of human existence, an infinite good. Thus, the person who knows God, no matter how much they have suffered, can still say "God is good to me."

"And not only so, but we glory in tribulations also: knowing that tribulation worketh patience; And patience, experience; and experience, hope: And hope maketh not ashamed; because the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Ghost which is given unto us."-Romans 5:3-5

The truth is that when man falls into sin and disobedience, God should not be blamed. The inspired writer James declared:

“Let no man say when he is tempted, I am tempted of God: for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man:”-James 1:13

It is further revealed that in the book of Job, it is God merely allowing Satan (whose on a leash) to tempt us, and not Himself (Job 1:12; 2:6). God only allows us to suffer and/or be tempted by Satan so much as we can handle (1 Corinthians 10:13). God ultimately just wants us to trust in Him rather than continue to trust in ourselves (Isaiah 53:6). Bible believers, then, can be sure that, in our exercise of personal volition, God’s desire will be always our well-being (Romans 8:28). In the same way that Adam had to choose between life and death, you and I are called to make our own choices. It is the will of God, of course, that we choose life. Moses urged the people of God:

“I call heaven and earth to record this day against you, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing: therefore choose life, that both thou and thy seed may live:”-Deuteronomy 30:19

[A whole lot of credit (obviously) goes to William Lane Craig in writing some of this. Make sure to check out some of his other arguments on suffering.]


r/Apologetics • • Apr 19 '20

A question I’ve always had: How could Satan and other angels rebel?

47 Upvotes

We’re told Satan and many angels betrayed God, essentially, and now exist here on Earth to turn us away from God.

But how, not why, could they rebel? Satan, like every angel, was created in Heaven in the direct presence and power of the reality creating, all powerful God, and created before the fall. We also know Satan betrayed God before the Fall of Man. How could a being created and existing in the presence of the Glory of God (unlike Earth) actively and with full understanding come to hate and betray God?

Does this imply that hate can infiltrate heaven? When the ultimate plan is finished, and the new Earth and new Heavens are established and all the believers are living with God, what’s to stop the angels from rebelling again?

EDIT: Thank you atheists who have replied so far. However, I should have made it clear I'm looking for biblical Christian perspectives on this question.


r/Apologetics • • Apr 18 '25

Did Roger Penrose Accidentally Prove God Exists? The math says yes. The scientific elite still can’t say it out loud.

39 Upvotes

When I was a kid people used to say “What if science ends up proving God?”

It was one of those late night hypotheticals people laughed off... but here’s the thing:
That moment already happened.
And we moved on like it didn’t.

In 1989, Nobel Prize-winning physicist Sir Roger Penrose calculated the odds that the universe....the exact low-entropy conditions that allowed for structure, order, and life....could’ve happened by chance.

His result?

1 in 10^10^123

That’s a 1… followed by a 123-digit number of zeros.
So incomprehensibly small, you couldn’t write it out even if you used every atom in the universe as ink.

This wasn’t a theologian with a calculator.
This was one of the most brilliant minds in physics saying:

“This now tells us how precise the Creator’s aim must have been.”

But did the scientific community pause and ask “Maybe the religious folks were onto something?”

Nope.
They buried it.

Because here’s the uncomfortable truth:

Penrose’s math exposed the illusion of “random chance” behind our universe’s existence.
But even Penrose....*and the scientific class he belongs to....*refused to say what the numbers clearly pointed to:

A Designer.

Why?

Because it would mean admitting the people they once mocked… were right.
And it would mean acknowledging **accountability.....**the one concept no academic echo chamber is comfortable with.

So instead, they turned to **multiverse theory.....**an untestable, unfalsifiable escape hatch dressed up in scientific language.

One intelligent cause = irrational
Infinite invisible universes = science™

Got it.

We’re living in a universe so statistically precise......it shouldn’t exist...
...and pretending it’s all a coincidence.

Science didn’t disprove God.
It quietly pointed right to Him.

Most people just weren’t listening.


r/Apologetics • • Jan 10 '25

Wesley Huff Gives Historical Take on The Death and Resurrection of Jesus

Thumbnail
youtu.be
36 Upvotes

r/Apologetics • • Apr 12 '20

Evidence for the Resurrection

35 Upvotes

[Note, I'm not suddenly reinventing the wheel. Much of what is said here has obviously been argued before. Most notably by William Lane Craig. All I did was add some of my own arguments to better supplement what he says, as I'm mostly looking to inform, not debate. Argue amongst yourselves if you must pick apart what is said here, because non-believers tend to argue the exact same things in response to all this and I'm kind of tired of proving the same old arguments wrong. I will chime in if something new is actually argued in spite of the facts laid out.]

I want to give empirical evidence for God through the resurrection of Christ. The entirety of the Christian faith hinges on this event happening. If Christ did not rise from the dead, the whole Bible is untrue and all Christians have wasted their time believing in something that holds no water. However, if it is true that Christ did rise from the dead, the whole Bible is therefore true and Christianity has the right God.

Before we can even begin discussing the resurrection and whether or not it even happened, I want to discuss something more fundamental. Ever since the movement began, followers of Jesus Christ have said He was God in human form. But what about Jesus Himself? Who did He think He was?

With the rise of textual criticism, and the modern study of history, historians have developed tools to unlock this question. Today, Jesus of Nazareth is no longer just a figure in a stained glass window, but a real person of history whose life can be investigated historically. So let's examine the New Testament not as inspired Scripture, but as an ordinary collection of ancient documents. Let's apply to them the standard tests we would use with regard to any other ancient sources. When historians investigate the Jesus of history, what do they find?

Firstly, Jesus claimed to be the Messiah. The Jews of Jesus' day were waiting for a promised Messiah, a descendant of king David, a warrior king, who would bring military victory and spiritual renewal to Israel. They were familiar with the Prophet Zechariah's ancient words:

"Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion; shout, O daughter of Jerusalem: behold, thy King cometh unto thee: he is just, and having salvation; lowly, and riding upon an ass, and upon a colt the foal of an ass."-Zechariah 9:9

Jesus' triumphal entry into Jerusalem on the back of a donkey the final week of His life is attested in independent sources (Mark 11:1-11, John 12:12-19), one of the most important criteria for the historicity of an event. In doing this, Jesus was deliberately and provocatively declaring that He was the promised Messiah. The King of Israel.

Moreover, the plank nailed to Jesus' cross stated the charge against Him in mockery of His Messianic claims. "King of the Jews." The fact that later Christians did not use this derisive title for Jesus underscores its authenticity. For first century Jews, the word Messiah was packed full of meaning. Messiah comes from the Hebrew word mashiach and means “anointed one” or “chosen one.” The Greek equivalent is the word Christos or, in English, Christ. The name “Jesus Christ” is the same as “Jesus the Messiah.” In biblical times, anointing someone with oil was a sign that God was consecrating or setting apart that person for a particular role. Thus, an “anointed one” was someone with a special, God-ordained purpose. By assuming the title of Messiah, Jesus was claiming all this and more for Himself:

(Isaiah 9:6)- Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace

(Zechariah 9:9)-Bringing Salvation

Secondly, Jesus also claimed to be the Son of God. Jesus' consciousness of being God's Son in a unique sense comes to expression in His parable of the vineyard. This parable matches Jesus' teaching style and employs Jewish motifs typical of His day such as Israel as a "vineyard," God as a father, the religious leaders of that time as "husbandmen" (tenants), and God's prophets as "servants" sent to the tenants. The parable goes a little like this:

Once there was a man who planted a vineyard. Before leaving the country, he leased it to tenants. At harvest time, he sent a servant to collect his share of the fruit of the vineyard. But the tenants beat him away empty-handed. So, the owner sent more servants, but these too were beaten or killed. Finally, he sent his one and only son saying "Surely they'll respect my son." But those tenants said to one another "This is the heir. Let's kill him and the vineyard will be ours." So they killed the owner's son.

What do we learn from this parable about Jesus' self-understanding?

He thought of Himself as the only Son of God, God's final messenger, distinct from all the prophets, and even the heir of Israel itself.

Thirdly, Jesus claimed to be the Son of man. This was Jesus' favorite self-designation, being used some 80 times in the gospels. This has convinced the vast majority of historians that Jesus did, in fact, think of Himself as the Son of Man. Notice, not just a son of man, but the Son of Man. Jesus was directing our attention to a vision described by the prophet Daniel:

"I saw in the night visions, and, behold, one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of days, and they brought him near before him. And there was given him dominion, and glory, and a kingdom, that all people, nations, and languages, should serve him..."-Daniel 7:13-14

At Jesus' trial, the Jewish high priest accused Jesus: "Art thou the Messiah, the Son of the Blessed (God)?" His answer left no room for doubt. "I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven." (Mark 14:61-62).

Applying all three of these titles to Himself (Messiah, Son of God, Son of Man), Jesus was claiming, in no uncertain terms, that He was the very God His accusers worshipped. It's no surprise the Jewish court charged Him with blasphemy and condemned Him to death.

But that's not all! New Testament historians are agreed that the historical Jesus also claimed to have divine power and authority to perform miracles, cast out demons, revise Old Testament law, and forgive sins. He even went so far as to claim everyone's eternal fate is determined solely by whether we believe in Him.

Jesus' self-understanding cannot be reduced to that of a Jewish teacher or a charismatic leader. No, in fact, by putting Himself in God's place, Jesus was making a far greater claim about Himself than anyone else ever has before or since. So the question Jesus asked His disciples confronts each of us as well: Who do you say that I am?

How would you feel if someone said "Hello, I am God"? Throughout history, lots of people have claimed to be a god, but they lived in cultures that believed in lots of gods. And although these gods were more powerful than humans, they had limits. So, for example, when the Roman emperor claimed to be a god, it was not a big deal. But when Jesus of Nazareth claimed to be God, things were quite different. Jesus didn't say He was just one of many gods. His claim was much bigger than that. He had the audacity to identify Himself as the one true God of the universe.

You see, Jesus was a Jew and the Jewish conception of God was absolutely unique. It was unlike that of any other culture. Jews firmly believed there is only one God and He alone is the perfect, all-powerful, all-knowing, uncreated ruler of all things. He is without beginning or end and He alone created and sustains the entire universe. He is without limits, and He has no competition. So when Jesus claimed all of this for Himself, it's no surprise that He ignited a firestorm of opposition. No one had ever done this before. In fact, for the Jews, the very idea of God taking the form of a man (Isaiah 9:6) was lost on (most of) them after centuries of religious leaders perverting the Scriptures. Jesus thus created an identity crisis. Each of us must decide for ourselves: who was Jesus? Because, if He's not God, how can we possibly explain His unprecedented claim? He certainly wasn't crazy, joking, or lying. Let's consider five other explanations.

First, maybe Jesus was misunderstood. Perhaps He "never really claimed to be God" (despite everything already said). However, the historical evidence says otherwise. Centuries before Jesus, God revealed Himself to Abraham (a patriarch of Israel) as the great "I AM." So when Jesus said "Before Abraham was, I am," as recorded in the gospel of John, His Jewish audience knew full well that He was claiming to be equal to God. That's why they picked up stones to kill Him. And, as already stated, when Jesus identified Himself as "the Son of Man" mentioned in Daniel's prophecy, the Jewish High Court was well aware that He was claiming to be the pre-existent ruler and judge of the universe. As a result, they unanimously condemned Him to death. So no, Jesus wasn't misunderstood. To the Jews, His claim to be God was unmistakable. This explanation, then, fails.

But what about the second option? Maybe, Jesus was "just a legend." Maybe, in the first few centuries after Jesus lived, His followers merely "invented" the idea that He was God. Is this valid? Was belief in the deity of Jesus added centuries later? Or, did the very first Christians believe that Jesus was God? Again, the historical evidence speaks loud and clear the earliest Christian writers made clear reference to Jesus, who is "...our God." Jesus, who is "...both God and man." Jesus, who is "...not a mere man but was God." (Ignatius, Irenaeus, Clement, Justin Martyr, Paul, Polycarp).

So the idea that Jesus of Nazareth is God was not invented after the Christian movement began. No, not at all. Christians always believed it from the very start. So, this explanation fails too.

Another way to try to make sense of Jesus' claim to be God is "He was a clever political strategist." He "falsely claimed" to be God in the hope of focusing Jewish resistance against their Roman oppressors. However, in Jewish culture, claiming equality with God was not a good idea. In fact, it was a crime punishable by death (blasphemy). Jesus made it clear that He was not a political revolutionary and the Roman government itself officially declared Jesus not guilty of inciting rebellion. So this explanation doesn't work either.

The fourth explanation would be: what if the historical Jesus never even existed? Is this plausible?

No.

This explanation seems to run rampant amongst the uninformed. Contrary to this assertion, here's the facts: in addition to the eyewitness testimony of the four earliest biographers (Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John), multiple Greek, Roman, and Jewish historians document the existence of "Jesus, who is called Christ," (Lucian, Celsus, Tacitus, Pliny the Younger, Seutonius, Josephus, and the Talmud). In fact, there is as much documentary evidence for the existence of Jesus as there is for Julius Caesar. This is why the vast majority of New Testament scholars affirm that Jesus was an actual living, breathing, and historical figure. Again, just like the ones before it, this explanation just doesn't work either.

For those who examine the evidence objectively, all of these explanations fall short. But, for the open minded, there is at least one other option to consider. Perhaps, Jesus was who He claimed to be. Unlike the other options, this explanation fits perfectly with the historical data. But it does have one major problem.

It's not safe.

This is because, if Jesus actually is God in human flesh, your life is ultimately not your own. And true life can only be found in Him (John 14:6).

So, why was Jesus of Nazareth crucified? Because He made outrageous claims about Himself. He claimed to be the one and only Son of God. Why would anyone take His claim seriously? Well, that all depends.

If Jesus actually rose from the dead, His claim to be God's unique Son carries considerable weight. On the other hand, if the resurrection never actually happened, Jesus can be safely dismissed as just another interesting, but tragic historical figure.

Did Jesus rise from the dead?

As we explore this question, we need to address two further questions.

  1. What are the facts that require explanation?

  2. Which explanation best accounts for these facts?

There are three main facts that need to be explained:

Fact #1 - The discovery of Jesus' empty tomb.

Fact #2 - The appearance of Jesus alive after His death.

Fact #3 - The disciples' belief that Jesus rose from the dead.

Let's examine each of these, starting with the first. Fact #1. The discovery that Jesus' tomb was empty is reported in no less than 6 independent sources, (Luke 24:1-12, John 20:1-8, 1 Corinthians 15:3-5, Mark 16:1-8, Matthew 28:1-10, Acts 2:29-32), and some of these are among the earliest materials to be found in the New Testament. This is important because, when an event is recorded by two or more unconnected sources, historians' confidence that the event actually happened significantly increases. And the earlier these sources are dated, the higher their confidence. Moreover, the Gospels indicate that it was women who first discovered that Jesus' body was missing. This is likely historical, because in that culture, a woman's testimony was considered next to worthless (Mark 16:9-11, Luke 24:10-11). A later legend or fabrication would have had men make this discovery. Our confidence in the empty tomb is further increased by the response of the Jewish authorities. When they heard the report that the tomb was found empty, they said that Jesus' followers had stolen His body. Thereby admitting that Jesus' tomb was, in fact, empty.

"Most scholars, by far, hold firmly to the reliability of the Biblical statements about the empty tomb."-Jacob Kremer, professor of NT studies, University of Vienna

Fact #2. The appearances of Jesus alive after His death. In one of the earliest letters in the New Testament, Paul provides a list of witnesses to Jesus' resurrection appearances:

"And that he was seen of Cephas [Peter], then of the twelve: After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep. After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles. And last of all he was seen of me also..."-1 Corinthians 15:1-8

Furthermore, various resurrection appearances of Jesus are independently confirmed by the Gospel accounts, (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John). On the basis of Paul's testimony alone, virtually all historical scholars agree that various individuals and groups experienced appearances of Jesus alive after His death.

"It may be taken as historically certain that Peter and the disciples had experiences after Jesus' death in which Jesus appeared to them as the risen Christ."-Gerd Lüdemann, New Testament scholar, University of Göttingen

Fact #3. The disciples' belief in the resurrection. After Jesus' crucifixion, His followers were devastated, demoralized, and hiding in fear for their lives. These Jews had no concept of a Messiah that would be executed by His enemies, much less, come back to life. A Messiah, mind you, that most Jews had no idea would be Jesus Himself, despite all the prophecies He was fulfilling left and right. This was due in part to the 400 silent years in between the OT and NT. Thus, Jews forgot that their Messiah would literally be the sacrificial lamb due to the Pharisees and Sadducees perverting the Scriptures for so long. In fact, because of this, the only resurrection that Jews (besides the Sadducees) believed in was a universal event on judgement day after the end of the world, not an individual event within history. Moreover, in Jewish law, Jesus' crucifixion as a criminal meant that He was literally under God's curse.

Yet somehow, despite all of this, the disciples suddenly and sincerely came to believe that God had raised Jesus from the dead. They were so completely convinced that, when threatened with death, not one of them recanted. Even the Pharisee, Paul, who persecuted Christians, suddenly became a Christian himself, as did Jesus' skeptical younger brother James.

"Some sort of powerful transformative experience is required to generate the sort of movement early Christianity was."-Luke Timothy Johnson, New Testament scholar, Emory University

"That is why, as an historian, I cannot explain the rise of early Christianity unless Jesus rose again, leaving an empty tomb."-N.T. Wright, New Testament scholar, University of St. Andrews

These three firmly established facts cry out for an adequate explanation. How do you make sense of them? Down through history, various naturalistic explanation have been offered to explain away these facts:

-The Conspiracy Hypothesis

-The Apparent Death Hypothesis

-The Displaced Body Hypothesis

-The Hallucination Hypothesis

-The Legend Hypothesis

All of these have been nearly universally rejected by contemporary scholarship. The simple fact is that there is just no plausible naturalistic explanation of these three facts. The explanation given by the original eyewitnesses is that God raised Jesus from the dead. If it's even possible that God exists, then that explanation cannot be ruled out.

"For a God who is able to create the entire universe, the odd resurrection would be child's play!"-Peter Slezak, professor of Philosophy of Science, University of New South Wales

An empty tomb, Jesus' mass appearances alive after His death, and a group of dejected followers suddenly transformed by a radical new belief in a risen Messiah. These are independently established, historical facts. How do you explain them?

“This Jesus hath God raised up, whereof we all are witnesses.”-Peter (Acts 2:32)

For the sake of the argument, let's actually delve further into the naturalistic explanations offered that attempt to explain away what's been said. I already listed them all earlier, but I will only go over the first 4 for having disproven the 5th already (The Legend Hypothesis) when concerning the historicity of Jesus of Nazareth.

First, the Conspiracy Theory. According to this view, the disciples faked the resurrection, stole Jesus' body from the tomb, and then lied about seeing Jesus alive. Thereby perpetrating the greatest hoax of all time. However, this theory faces overwhelming objections. It's hopelessly anachronistic. It looks at the disciples' situation through the rear view mirror of Christian history instead of from the standpoint of a first century Jew. As already discussed, Jews (for various reasons, despite what their Scriptures had already told them) had no concept of a Messiah that would be defeated and executed by Israel's enemies, much less rise again. At this time, in Jewish thinking, the resurrection of the dead was:

  1. A general event

  2. Something that takes place only after the end of the world

  3. Has no connection to the Messiah

The conspiracy theory also fails to address the disciples' obvious sincerity. People don't willingly die for something they know is not true. An honest reading of the New Testament makes it clear. These people sincerely believed in the message they proclaimed and were willing to die for.

"But people die for lies all the time. Fanatic Muslims blowing themselves and some innocent people up for the lie that they will be rewarded by God for it--would certainly be an example of one dying for lies--but trusting in someone's (in this case, Mohammad's) teachings and thinking it was the truth."

This seems like a good point at first. However, the Apostles who were with Jesus for 3 years, and then saw him resurrected, had an important difference. They would have known it was a lie--and they would be enduring torture knowing that Jesus was a blasphemer and fraud and that there would be no reward of eternal life for them. If they believed in God, they would be more likely terrified of God's judgement on them for dying for the cause of someone who blasphemed God.

For these and other reasons, no scholar defends the Conspiracy Theory today.

A second attempt to explain the facts is the Apparent Death Theory. "Jesus didn't really die. He revived in the tomb, somehow escaped, and managed to convince the disciples He was risen from the dead." This theory also faces insurmountable obstacles.

First, it's medically impossible. The Roman executioners were professionals. They knew what they were doing and made sure their victims were dead before taken down. Moreover, Jesus was tortured so extensively that, even if He was taken down alive, He would've died in the sealed tomb.

Second, this theory is wildly implausible. Seeing a half dead man who crawled out of the tomb, desperately in need of bandaging and medical attention, would hardly have convinced the disciples that He was gloriously risen from the dead.

As a result, no New Testament historians defend this theory today either.

A third explanation is the Displaced Body Theory. "Perhaps Joseph of Arimathea placed Jesus' body in the tomb temporarily because it was convenient, but later he moved the corpse to a criminal's common graveyard. So, when the disciples visited the first tomb and found it empty, they concluded that Jesus must have risen from the dead." Once again, this theory cannot make sense of the facts. Jewish laws prohibited moving a corpse after it was interred (except to the family tomb). What's more, the criminal's graveyard was located close to the place of execution. So the burial there would not have been a problem. Also, once the disciples began to proclaim Jesus' resurrection, Joseph would've corrected their mistake. This theory doesn't even attempt to explain all the appearances of Christ after His death, disciple or not. Furthermore, it seems to imply again that the disciples lied about said appearances. Otherwise, they wouldn't have even mentioned them had this really happened. We already discussed how impossible it was that they lied.

So, once again, no current scholars endorse this theory.

Finally, the Hallucination Theory. "The disciples didn't really see Jesus, but just imagined that He appeared before them. They were all hallucinating." This theory also faces considerable problems.

First, Jesus appeared not just one time, but many times. Not just in one place (Judea), but in different places (Galilee and Syria). Not just to one person (Mary Magdalene), but to different persons (James the Greater). Not just to individuals (Bartholomew), but to groups of people (the rest of the disciples). And not just to believers, but to unbelievers as well (Saul of Tarsus and James the brother of Jesus). There is nothing in the psychological casebooks on hallucinations comparable to these resurrection appearances.

Second, hallucinations of Jesus would have lead the disciples to believe at most that Jesus had been transported to heaven, not risen from the dead, in contradiction to their Jewish beliefs. Moreover, in the ancient world, visions of the deceased were not evidence that the person was alive, but evidence that they were dead and had moved on to the afterworld (Matthew 14:26-27, Mark 6:49-50, John 6:19-20).

Finally, this theory suffers from the same kind of weakness that the last one does. It, too, doesn't even attempt at explaining something major. However, unlike the Displaced Body Theory when concerning appearances, it is instead the empty tomb that the Hallucination Theory can't bother itself to explain.

Thus, the four most popular naturalistic theories fail to explain the historical facts. Where does that leave us? Another possibility is the explanation given by the original eyewitnesses: that God raised Jesus from the dead. Unlike the other theories, this makes perfect sense of the empty tomb, the appearances of Jesus alive, and the disciples' willingness to die for their belief. For the materialist, this conclusion is by default wrong, despite no one being able to conceivably reach any other conclusion (and supposedly wanting evidential proof for God). However, if this indeed happened, that would not only mean that God exists, but that He's the Christian God. If it didn't happen, that would not rule out all possibility that a God exists. All it would do is shut down any notion that He is the Christian God.

But the facts don't lie. It's just plain unreasonable to continue to vehemently deny the validity of the resurrection in spite of them. The evidence proves that God exists, and that He is the Christian God, no less. And for all my evidentialists out there, this was done through evidential means. Thus, knocking out two birds with one stone: God exists, and He's the God of the Bible.

Case closed.

"But he answered and said unto them, An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign; and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas: For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale's belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth."-Matthew 12:39-40


r/Apologetics • • Apr 19 '20

Is God Evil for Creating Someone He Knew Would Go to Hell?

33 Upvotes

"Is God evil for creating someone He knew would go to hell?"

To this I would say: Is it the judge's fault if you break a law and reject His offer of mercy?

No.

This is ultimately a free will question. Logically speaking, God can't make you love him because love is freely given. He wanted to create creatures that would love Him back, so he gave them free will. It's their fault if they decide not to turn to Him. Not God's.

None of this is to say, however, that God can't still get His will done through evil people. Every Christian understands this but non-believers usually don't because they don't have as firm a grasp on Christian beliefs. So a good example I would bring up would be something like Joseph in Genesis.

Joseph's own family sold him into slavery to Egypt. However, that eventually turned into him getting into a position of prominence. Since God knows past, present, and future, He warns Joseph of a coming famine. So, Joseph stocks up on grain and puts it aside in case there is a famine. Then there is a famine, and Joseph's family comes to Egypt to escape said famine. They go to Egypt not knowing that Joseph is in the position he is, and begs him for food. Joseph sees them and (essentially) says "You sold me into slavery. You meant it for evil. But God meant it for good, by the saving of many lives that is going on right now." Joseph then saves and forgives the very same family that sinned against him, and saves many others along with them.

We all have atheists in our bloodlines. I'm a pretty good example of this. My dad is a very staunch atheist. I, obviously, am not. If my dad never met my mom, I would not have been born. God can get His will done and turn something bad into good. But it's not God's fault if someone continues to harden their own heart towards Him. I was much like my dad for most my life. That changed now. If I could change, so could my dad. He decides not to though, (as much as it grieves me).

But this still begs the question. "Is God evil for creating someone He knew wouldn't turn to Him?"

Well, is God morally obligated to not create a universe where even one person rejects Him? No, of course not. If He creates a universe and there's two Christians and one atheist, God is not suddenly obligated to not create that universe. It might not even be realistic for Him to create a world where there were only believers who freely chose to believe. If He did make such a world, it would be a rather small world considering He wouldn't allow for Christians to be born from atheists (since no atheists could even exist in this kind of world). Why would God keep so many potential believers from the gift of being eternally in His presence just because their parents might've refused to accept that gift themselves? God created me knowing I would become Christian, but He also created my dad knowing he would be an atheist. Thus, even though God can know someone would reject Him ahead of time (due to Him being outside of time), He is not culpable at all if someone freely denies Him.

If you are really struggling with how God is sovereign and yet we have free will, try molinism. Molinism teaches that God does not only have knowledge about the past, present, and future, but also has middle knowledge. For example, He knows what would've caused you not to believe in Him in world X versus what would've caused you to believe in Him in world Y. So, God has created a world set in motion from the beginning to save as many people as possible through people's free actions. This is how there is an "elect," and yet we have free will. Some complain that molinism is just calvinism with extra steps because some are obviously left out of this plan (I.E. those that chose not to believe in this specific world). However, I just explained why it's not God's fault at all if someone goes to hell.

Some Scriptural support for molinism would be the following verses:

• 1 Samuel 23:8-14

• Proverbs 4:11

• Matthew 23:11

• Ezekiel 3:6-7

• Jeremiah 38:17-18

• 1 Corinthians 2:1-8

• Deuteronomy 28:51-57

• Matthew 23:27-32

• Matthew 12:7

• Matthew 24:43

• Luke 16:30-31

• Luke 22:67-68

• Matthew 17:27

• John 21:6

• John 15:22-24

• John 18:36

• Matthew 26:24

• John 9:41


r/Apologetics • • Dec 29 '19

Mental note: avoid.

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/Apologetics • • Sep 11 '25

General Question/Recommendation Kirk

29 Upvotes

I would like to encourage you, but my heart is like melted wax. I’d like to mourn with you all but I’m too angry. I’d like to celebrate a race ran well, but that is for tomorrow, in heaven.

What i can tell you is that pain you are feeling over the loss of Charlie Kirk is more universal than you think. So if you have a ray of sunshine or sober word of peace that you can give. Speak up!

“Your enemy, the devil, prowls around like a roaring Lion seeking someone to devour.” 1 Peter 5:8

Charlie was not devoured, he finished his race, those who the enemy is seeking to devour are those who now entertain lies, rage, and retribution as solutions to a problem only God can handle.

So be diligent and sober minded.


r/Apologetics • • Feb 03 '26

My Apologetics Platform

27 Upvotes

Hey guys! I’m Carter. I’m a Christian, an apologist and a developer, and I just finished building an apologetics platform called Truth Be Told.

It’s a forum designed for serious engagement with Christianity by taking on real questions, real objections, and providing answers that actually try to satisfy. The goal is rigorous, honest analysis of Scripture and challenges to the faith by steel-manning arguments instead of giving weak arguments such as “evil exists because free will” or other lame ‘answers’ like that.

Here’s how it works: someone asks a question, someone gives a comprehensive answer, and then there’s a limited back-and-forth of up to three rebuttals. The reason behind this is to make every response count and avoid the endless mudfights and cage matches you see on places like Reddit. If responses are limited, people are way less likely to give cheap answers that aren’t going to hold up in the next rebuttal. Askers can mark answers as accepted, and moderators can mark answers as ‘moderator approved’, meaning they align with our core philosophy in tackling steel-manned arguments comprehensively, without settling for the weak arguments most people are used to giving.

My hope is to pull apologetics out of the rut it’s been in for a long time. No more weak answers. No more dodging the hardest objections. I want this to be a place that takes the strongest versions of the strongest challenges to Christianity seriously and quits making apologetics look like a joke.

Whether you’re Christian or not, I’d genuinely love for you to check it out, ask a question, or jump into a discussion. It’s still small right now, but I’m hoping you guys will help bring it to life. The platform literally exists for your questions, so if you want to ask any, go right ahead!

If you are interested, here you can access it at: https://www.tbtold.com/


r/Apologetics • • Apr 21 '19

Evidence of Christ’s resurrection is one of the big reasons I have my faith today. Happy Easter y’all!

27 Upvotes

There is a lot of evidence that tells us Christ did, in fact, rise from death. Here is one small article on it but there are many more.

evidence of the resurrection.


r/Apologetics • • Apr 19 '20

Do you think that the intuition that we have free will is as strong as the intuition that we have objective moral duties?

24 Upvotes

I'm thinking that it is, since ought implies can.

If I know I ought to do something, then I know I can do it.

If I know I can do it, then I know I have free will.


r/Apologetics • • Jul 09 '19

Mixing Jesus and Gaming?

24 Upvotes

Hey guys, I had this idea to try to reach a group of people who are widely untouched, very susceptible and most of the time just really in need of the gospel. I started an instagram and started posting clips of my gaming. Recently I starting writing about what I’ve learned in the scriptures or concepts that new believers should know along with my clip.

Trying to combine both of these worlds has been challenging. I want to use myself as a resource for people to learn the fundamentals of Christianity. I want to have a platform to speak to people in a meaningful way. Is this a dumb idea? Any ideas on how to do it better?

I am a theology student hoping to one day be a pastor. My flock just might be somewhere in the internet

If anyone has Instagram I’m thesilencer1104 I would love any helpful comments.


r/Apologetics • • May 16 '25

Roger Penrose’s fine-tuning number is so extreme it makes atheism mathematically hard to defend

22 Upvotes

Back in 2004, Penrose estimated the odds of a universe like ours forming by chance:
1 in 10^10^123. It’s not just improbable... it’s off the edge of probability itself.

That kind of precision seems almost... intentional. Like someone rigged the machine.

I came across a short 7-minute video that frames the number in a pretty wild way --curious if others here see this as strong evidence for fine-tuning, or if there’s a better natural explanation:

📺 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7iPt1HRu4_4

Would love your take-- especially from people who’ve debated this stuff before. Is this kind of math meaningful? Or just coincidence dressed in science?


r/Apologetics • • Jun 19 '24 Heart of Silver

American nationalism is killing Christianity in America. Not Science.

22 Upvotes

As a Christian myself, I can’t help to observe the ongoing theme of churches basing their theology/faith into different sides of the American political system. For example, when a pastor makes a comment like “vote the Bible”, it’s often correct to interpret that as “vote Republican”. I lean closer to the right than I do the left, but biblical Christianity doesn’t fall under the extremes of either views. I think it’s a great and. honest discussion to have with people of faith (as well as those who aren’t considering themselves Christian), to have as a whole and friendly space to talk about what keeps people away the most.

I often wonder if Jesus were to walk into a conservative church, would they say He’s “too liberal” in His views? Or if Jesus were to walk into a more progressive church, would they claim He’s too conservative? The truth is, that the biblical/historical Christ wouldn’t fall under any of the two.

All throughout history, we see nations fall which were headed by Christian leaders and governments. Human nature seems to take place and that gift that God granted these leaders, is abused and Christianity begins to be used as a way to gain support for the people, rather than its intention. (Crusades as a big example). I’m afraid that the church in America is going through this fall.

On the contrary, the Christian movement in China, Africa, and many other overseas countries is growing rapidly, all while being “underground” and “under persecution”.

It’s almost like Jesus knew what He was talking about when He said “the meek will inherit the earth” and “the first will be last and last be first”.

Ik this was lengthy, but I just figured it’s a good convo to have. Thank you to all who may read this!


r/Apologetics • • Apr 10 '20

NT Scholars review The Case for Christ: "This book will make you dumber."

21 Upvotes

I'm constantly seeing Christians reference Lee Strobel's book The Case for Christ. Here is a podcast where two New Testament Phd candidates explain how and why this book is dishonest, factually wrong, and manipulative.

These are not angry atheists stubbornly resisting the overwhelming evidence for Jesus...these are Christian saying this. These are believers.

The Case for Christ is bad. It's bad history, bad arguments, bad scholarship...it's just bad.

Link to Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/30-lee-strobel-the-case-for-christ/id1377442882?i=1000470187480

Link to Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/4aeO3BzdCU2lHQnLRgfdGb?si=ERaSC09xQRGQFnEpyl4F8g#_=_


r/Apologetics • • Feb 10 '20

Atheists Only Have Three Possible “Explanations” of the Universe

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/Apologetics • • Nov 12 '24

Challenge against Christianity Why didn’t God make us sinless?

17 Upvotes

This is a question that nobody has been able to satisfyingly answer for me. We have free will in heaven and are able to not sin, so why didn’t God just make us like that from the get go if it’s possible to have free will and not sin?

There’s also the common catholic belief that Mary was sinless, if it’s demonstrably possible for humans to be born without sin—why didn’t God just do that for everybody else?

I hope I was able to word my issues well


r/Apologetics • • Apr 14 '20

Two very big brain chemists debate the origin of life (Details in the comments)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

r/Apologetics • • Jun 27 '24

Best apologists to watch?

16 Upvotes

Hi guys....I'm looking for some apologists to watch and learn I've been watching David Wood and Christian Prince for a while now...Need some other suggestions pls...thank you and God bless


r/Apologetics • • Jun 16 '24

Show these verses to Jehovah witnesses.

16 Upvotes

To make a long story short, you just need to ask them questions. Never teach them what a verse means. They will just ignore everything if you are telling them what it means.

I'll be quoting from their own translation. Ask them to read John 5:22

NWT John 5:22 For the Father judges no one at all, but he has entrusted all the judging to the Son

Who is the one that will judge everyone? Jehovah (they only believe the father is Jehovah) or the Son?

According to John 5:22 it is the Son. Hammer this point! "The Son will judge right"? You just read it.

NWT Matthew 16:27 For the Son of man is to come in the glory of his Father with his angels, and then he will repay each one according to his behavior.

Who will repay everyone for what they have done? According to Matthew 16:27 it is the son

NWT Rev 22:12 “‘Look! I am coming quickly, and the reward I give is with me, to repay each one according to his work.

This is Jesus since he will be repaying each one with the work they have done.

In case they don't think this is the son then have them read Rev 22:20

NWT Rev 22:20 “The one who bears witness of these things says, ‘Yes, I am coming quickly.’” “Amen! Come, Lord Jesus.”

There's no way around it. Jesus is the one coming quickly.

This time have them read Rev 22:12-13

NWT Rev 22:12-13 “‘Look! I am coming quickly, and the reward I give is with me, to repay each one according to his work. 13 I am the Alʹpha and the O·meʹga, the first and the last, the beginning and the end.

Why is Jesus claiming to be the first and the last, beginning and the end, alpha and omega? These are all titles for Jehovah.

They will probably argue that he was an agent of Jehovah. That does that work here. The disciples are agents of Jesus. Can Peter go and say, "I am Jesus who died for you". I don't think so!

The angle who showed John these things is an agent of Jesus and God (Rev 19:10). How come he didn't allow John to worship him if we go by your agent argument?

Glory to the Triune God.


r/Apologetics • • Apr 08 '20

Why God's Existence is Intuitive

16 Upvotes

[A whole lot of credit goes to William Lane Craig in writing all of this. Though I disagree with him in that his arguments support an old earth (hence, why I adapted and changed the first argument to better fit the rest of them), he has some good stuff that I really think everyone should look into. I have made a post like this one before, but there's a huge amount of differences between this post and that one to warrant bringing this back up. Especially considering it's been weeks since I put it up and there are many who may have not seen it the first time around.]

Before I begin, I have to address a rather common issue between theists and atheists. The latter tends to assert that physical hard evidence is required to prove the existence of God. Whereas, the former (usually) believe that God's existence can be proven intuitively rather than necessarily being contingent on such hard evidence (though, hard evidence can indeed be provided on top of that, but that comes in finding out which religion/belief has the right God, not before). For example, we can intuitively figure out that 2+2=4. We don't need to pour through all the physical evidence that supports the notion as it doesn't take a genius to figure this out. It's the same way with God (at least for the most part). I'm going to show you why my position is the case rather than what the atheist presupposes. The following is a list of arguments and reasons for why belief in God is much more reasonable than a lack thereof. Let's jump right in, shall we?

  1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause

  2. The universe began to exist

  3. Therefore, the universe has a cause

Is the first premise here true? Let’s consider:

Believing something can pop into existence without a cause is more of a stretch than believing in magic. At least with magic, you’ve got a hat and a magician. If something can come from nothing, why don’t we see this happening all the time? No, everyday experience and scientific evidence confirm our first premise. If something begins to exist, it must have a cause.

But what about our second premise? “The universe began to exist.” Did the universe begin, or has it always existed? Atheists, in the past, (and even some in the present), have typically said “the universe has been here forever,” to conveniently dodge this line of reasoning. To shut this idea down, let’s consider the second law of thermodynamics. It tells us that the universe is slowly running out of usable energy. And that’s the point. If the universe had been here forever, it would’ve ran out of usable energy by now. This scientific fact points us to a universe that has a definite beginning.

Any universe which has finite energy cannot be eternal in the past and must have an absolute beginning.

Some still theorize that the universe is eternal by conveniently asserting that it continually expands and contracts in a series of "Big Bangs," each of which eventually collapses on itself and becomes yet another dense piece of concentrated and volatile matter, from which springs another "Big Bang.” This variant model of the Big Bang is known as "the Big Bounce." This is how the second law of thermodynamics is made to fit with the atheist's worldview.

There are two problems with this, however:

  1. We should always consider Occam's Razor in whatever we do, especially philosophical arguments. You've probably heard it before: The simplest explanation is usually the right one. Detectives use it to deduce who's the likeliest suspect in a murder case -- you know, the butler did it. Doctors use it to determine the illness behind a set of symptoms. This line of reasoning is used in a wide variety of ways throughout the world as a means to slice through a problem or situation and eliminate unnecessary elements. Taking this into account, it involves a whole lot of mental gymnastics to justify the belief of a "Big Bounce" rather than to simply consider what appears to be a beginning is indeed just that. A beginning. [Mind you, this doesn't necessarily prove my argument. Rather, it just significantly lowers the likelihood and possibility of the atheist's argument.]

  2. For my argument to be successful, an infinite regress must be impossible. My argument supporting the impossibility of an infinite regress is as follows: An infinite regress proposes an explanation, but the mechanism proposed stands just as much in need of explanation as the original fact to be explained. It is literally an infinite series of propositions where each proposition relies on the previous proposition. It is equivalent to saying: "Each and every single human being was created by a human being before them." According to this logic there can be no "first" human or even an origin for the species. Is this not a logical fallacy that is impossible?

Scientists “can no longer hide behind a past-eternal universe. There is no escape, they have to face the problem of a cosmic beginning.”-Alexander Vilenkin, Cosmologist

This means that both premises of the argument raised are true. Those being “Whatever begins to exist has a cause” and “The universe began to exist.” Therefore, the third and last premise is true:

“The universe has a cause.”

Since the universe can’t cause itself, its cause must be beyond the space-time universe. It must be space-less, timeless, immaterial, uncaused, and unimaginably powerful. Much like God.

Am I making an assumption in saying that this cause is indeed God and not something else? Well let’s see if I am by raising an, albeit, similar argument I raised before. Though, it is not exactly the same and I will show you why.

  1. Everything that exists has an explanation of its existence.

  2. If the universe has an explanation of its existence, that explanation is God.

  3. The universe exists.

  4. Therefore, it follows logically that the explanation of the universe’s existence is God.

The logic of this argument is airtight. If the three premises are true, the conclusion is unavoidable. But are they true rather than false? The third premise is undeniable for anyone seeking truth. But what about the first premise? Well we’ve already established that everything needs an explanation. But what about God? Doesn’t He need an explanation? If God doesn’t need an explanation, then why does the universe need an explanation? To address this, we need to make the distinction between things that exist necessarily and things that exist contingently.

Things that exist necessarily exist by necessity of their own nature. It is impossible for them not to exist. Many mathematicians believe that abstract objects like numbers and sets exist like this. They’re not caused to exist by something else, they just exist by necessity of their own nature. Math is necessary because it exists whether we are here to apply it or not. Just because we label a singular unit “1” and a pair of units “2” doesn't mean the intrinsic definitions for those labels can ever change. For example, if we switched the symbols 1 and 2 for meaning the other, we would still intuitively know what each symbol is trying to represent. Thus, abstract objects do exist and they exist necessarily. Regardless of what label or symbols we give them, they exist independently of us.

Things that exist contingently are caused to exist by something else. Most of the things we’re familiar with exist in this manner. They exist contingently. They don’t have to exist; they only exist because something else caused them to exist. For example, if your parents never met, you wouldn’t exist. There’s no reason to believe the world around us had to exist. If the universe developed any differently, there might’ve been no stars or planets. It’s logically possible that the whole universe might not have existed. It doesn’t exist necessarily, it exists contingently. If the universe might not have existed, why does it exist?

The only adequate explanation of a contingent universe is its existence depends on a non-contingent being. Something that cannot not exist by necessity of its own nature. It would exist no matter what. This changes the argument:

  1. Everything that exists has an explanation of its existence, either in the necessity of its nature, or in an external cause.

  2. If the universe has an explanation of its existence, that explanation is God.

  3. The universe exists.

  4. Therefore, it follows logically that the explanation of the universe’s existence is God.

But what about our second premise. Is the explanation for the existence of our universe God and not something else?

Well what is the universe? It’s all of space-time reality. This includes all matter and energy. It follows that if the universe has a cause of its existence, (which it does, as proven already in my very first argument that it indeed has a cause), that cause cannot be part of the universe. It must be non-physical and immaterial, beyond space and time. A list of entities that could possibly fit this description is fairly short.

  1. God

  2. Abstract Objects

Abstract objects cannot cause anything, as an equation unapplied is just that. An equation. Nothing more, nothing less. So that crosses that out. This argument shows that the explanation for the existence of our universe can only be found in God. Or, if you prefer not to use the term “God”, you may call Him “The extremely powerful, uncaused, necessarily existing, non-contingent, non-physical, immaterial, eternal being who created the entire universe and everything in it.”

Most atheists with a strictly material worldview believe in the Big Bang. The Big Bang theory has this idea of an initial "singularity" that sprung everything into existence. This initial singularity was a singularity of seemingly infinite density thought to have contained all of the mass and space-time of the universe before quantum fluctuations caused it to rapidly expand in the Big Bang and subsequent inflation, creating the present-day universe. This is a problem because of the following reasons:

  1. Nothing means absolutely nothing. As Aristotle put it, "Nothing is what rocks dream about." If this singularity supposedly held all the mass, density, and space-time of the universe, that's not nothing. It may get real close to nothing, but it's still something.

  2. If this singularity held everything indefinitely, then why did it not "go off," if you will, at any point prior? We've already established why the universe could not be eternal. The belief of this "singularity" is just another form of the belief that the universe "was always here." It's just masqueraded under the guise of it having a cause with a definite beginning, (the big bang), but isn't really if this supposed singularity still held everything in our present-day universe.

  3. This is the model of the Big Bang that most people think about when they hear the words “Big Bang.” Atheists will object to what I've said by saying that I'm using an “outdated model.” The newer and most popular model is something called “the Hot Big Bang.” The difference between this model and that one is that the latter throws out the idea that all mass was held in a singularity, but instead believes that, quite literally, nothing “passed” into something, so to speak. Obviously, this newer “model" is proposing something even more ridiculous and less plausible already. The argument that I'm using an older, (yet more popular amongst most laymen), model doesn't work in favor of the atheist. In fact, it only works against them.

I know there’s many, (and I mean many), staunch atheists out there, but if you are, let me put it to you this way. Do you believe the scientific impossibility that something can come from nothing? That nothing created everything? Can nature make itself? Nature can’t come from nature because nature had to exist prior to nature existing for nature to produce itself. Do you see how ridiculous this sounds? When you look at a building, you know there’s a builder. If you look at a beautiful and intricate painting, you know there is obviously a painter. It doesn’t matter if you don’t see the painter or that the painter has been dead for 500 years, you know that it would be impossible for that painting to exist on its own. Creation testifies to the existence of God! There is no excuse for any man to believe otherwise for this very reason. If even that isn’t enough for you, I’ll go even further. What is a book? It’s got pages, letters, sentences, page numbers, a cover, a title, and a front and back. Do you think a physical book can make itself? That it can just appear out of nowhere without an author or creator? No, of course not. Everyone in their right mind knows that. Now, what is DNA? It is a book. Scientists call it the book of life. It’s full of coherent information. Instructions for how to make eyes, hair, skin, blood, and personality. Everything was in your DNA from the moment you were conceived. So, what would you think of the mentality of someone who thought a physical book can make itself and pop into existence on its own? You’d think they’re crazy! It's ludicrously unscientific and absurd. What would you think of the mentality of someone who thinks DNA can make itself? The mentality of an atheist?...

“The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork. Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge. There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard.”-Psalm 19:1-3

“Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:”-Romans 1:19-20

[Note, I'm not “using the Bible to prove the Bible” or even arguing that God is the Christian God. I'm just referencing verses that just so happen to pertain to the subject matter here. I intend to repeat this pattern for proceeding arguments for the sake of accentuating the truths I argue every man can know intuitively. Truths that are found outside of religion, even. So cool your jets, atheists.]

What I just presented to you was essentially just the Kalam cosmological argument, Lebniz's argument from contingency, and the intelligent design argument. All arguments that are very strong alone, but make for a powerful trio that pretty much undeniably proves God if interwoven. However, I’m about to give you one last one to stack on top of all this as the final nail in the coffin. It’s called “the moral argument.” It goes a little something like this:

  1. If God does not exist, objective moral values and duties do not exist

  2. Objective moral values and duties do exist

  3. Therefore, God exists

Is the first premise true? Let's consider.

Before we even delve further, we must address a common and rather fallacious counter-argument against the first premise. An atheist will demonstrate why the moral argument “fails” by demonstrating it in the form of a neat little real world example. For the sake of the point I'm trying to make, I'll pretend I'm an atheist and give this “shut down" with a simple story:

John is an atheist. John is walking down the street and minding his own business when all of a sudden, * gasp *, there's a cat stuck in a tree! John hurries to the rescue and saves the cat. The day is saved.

Wow. We did it. We proved we can be good without believing in God. I guess that's the end of that.

Now hold on a minute. The question here isn't “Can people be moral without believing in God?” The question is “Can morals objectively exist without the existence of a God?”

If there is no God, what basis remains for objective good or bad, right or wrong? If God does not exist, objective moral values do not exist. And here's why: without some objective reference point, we have no way of saying if something is really up or down. God's nature provides an objective reference point for moral values. It's the standard against which all actions and decisions are measured.

But if there's no God, there's no objective reference point. All we are left with is one person's viewpoint, which, is no more valid than anyone else's viewpoint. This kind of morality is subjective, not objective. Subjective morality is like a preference for strawberry ice cream. The preference is in the subject (the person), not the object (the ice cream). So this preference doesn't apply to other people. After all, everyone else could prefer an entirely different ice cream flavor. In the same way, subjective morality applies only to the subject. It's not valid or binding for anyone else.

So, in a world without God, there can be "...No evil and no good. Nothing but blind, pitiless indifference."-Richard Dawkins, Atheist, evolutionary biologist, Emeritus Fellow at New College, Oxford

If morality is to be objective, moral laws must be independent of us much in the same way that other abstract objects like the laws of science and mathematics are independent of us (this means morality must be necessary, not contingent). Moral laws provide the basis for moral duties. Laws must have a law giver. There could be no other law giver besides God that could give us objective moral values. If anyone else gave us these moral laws, morality would automatically, by default, become subjective and no longer objective as no one has the power or authority to command abstract objects (laws like morals, science, math, etc.) into existence.

God has expressed His moral nature to us as commands (I.E. laws) and these commands provide the basis for objective moral duties. For example, God's essential attribute of love is expressed in His command to love your neighbor as yourself. This command provides a foundation upon which we can affirm the objective goodness of: generosity, self-sacrifice, and equality, and we can condemn as objectively evil: greed, abuse, and discrimination.

At this point, the atheist will object to everything I've said by proposing “The Euthyphro Dilemma.” It's usually framed like this:

“Is what God commands good because He arbitrarily decided certain things were good? What if he decided rape was good tomorrow? Or charity was evil?

Or, is what God says good because He draws morality from something above Him? If so, why worship Him if we can look to this moral standard ourselves without the need for Him in the picture? Wouldn't this require a greater God than He to draw these morals from anyway? And one greater than that? And so on and so forth?

Thus, morality is contingent and not necessary, despite God Himself supposedly being the opposite.

Therefore, God does not exist.”

This is a false dilemma where the atheist assumes morals are inherently separate from God in any way to begin with. God does not decide what the standard of good is based on arbitrary decisions made on a whim, nor does He decide it based upon some standard higher or separate from Himself.

He is the standard itself. He is the very standard we look to because He Himself is love. He is generosity. He is self-sacrifice. He is virtue. God is goodness itself. Many will conflate goodness, the word, as being an adjective when applied to God when it is, in fact, a noun rather. God is good by nature, not by what He does. His goodness is necessary, not contingent on anything above or below Him. The buck has to stop somewhere and it stops with Him because He Himself is necessary. Whether someone believes God to be a specific God or not does not change this fact. Finding out, then, which religion, philosophy, belief system (or even lack thereof), has the right God comes after recognizing this and after measuring each god against this undeniable truth, not before. Thus, God's morality is independent of our religious beliefs, and we can all now fully agree that morality simply cannot be objective separately from the existence of a God. Therefore, the first premise is true:

"If God does not exist, objective moral values and duties do not exist."

Now let's consider the second premise:

"Objective moral values and duties do exist."

If atheism is true, there is no ultimate standard (because God is the standard itself), so there can be no moral obligations or duties. Who or what lays such duties upon us?

No one.

In order for the atheist to maintain his position, he will propose that the second premise is false by saying something along the lines of:

"Humans, while accidents of nature, are highly evolved animals. We developed morality for self-preservation because we realized that working together gets us farther than a mere survival of the fittest mentality."

This sounds nice and dandy at first. However, animals have no moral obligations. When a cat kills a mouse, it hasn't done anything morally wrong. The cat's just being a cat. If God doesn't exist, we should view human behavior in the same way. After all, we are still just animals. Albeit, “highly evolved” ones (according to the atheist). No action can be considered morally/objectively right or morally/objectively wrong then. That would mean that what Hitler did was not only fine but should also be encouraged as, in a materialistic worldview, a survival of the fittest attitude would be maximally efficient. For he believed that Jews were deserving of death for being weak and inferior to the “Arian race.” If morality was based on societal consensus and/or a survival of the fittest mentality (which is naturally inherent to a materialistic worldview) the Nazis were technically right and we should all follow suit.

But the problem for the atheist is that good and bad, right and wrong, do exist. Just as our sense experience convinces us that the physical world is objectively real, our moral experience convinces us that moral values are objectively real. Every time you say "Hey! That's not fair! That's wrong! That's an injustice!" You affirm your belief in the existence of objective morals. We're all well aware that child-abuse, racial discrimination, and terrorism are wrong, for everybody, always. Is this just a personal preference or opinion based on societal consensus, culture, rulers, time and the passage thereof? No.

"The man who says it is morally acceptable to rape little children is just as mistaken as the man who says 2+2=5."-Micheal Ruse, Atheist, Philospher of Science, teacher at Florida State University

Some atheists will have the intellectual honesty to admit the first premise of the moral argument is true. The same can't be said, however, for most atheists whenever it comes time for them to confront the second premise or even confront themselves. My friends, you can't have your cake and eat it too. Considering all this, the second premise has proven itself to also be true:

"Objective moral values and duties do exist."

Because both premises are true, it logically follows that the third premise is also true:

"Therefore, God exists."

Morals are like facts that belong under truth. Truth is not malleable. 2+2 always equals 4 no matter where you are, just like murder is always wrong no matter where you are. This kind of worldview where you think society, or people, decide upon right and wrong and that morals or truth somehow change with time got us men like Stalin (who was an atheist, mind you). It's disgusting and I will not stand for it. In fact, I'm going to give an example of just how fallible this worldview is.

In the Bible, we see for ourselves the effect of twisting and manipulating the truth and morality. We see this when the Jews, (Jesus’ very own people), persecute Him, falsely accuse Him of crimes He didn’t commit, and send him to be judged by a ruling Roman prefect. This prefect was Pilate:

“Pilate therefore said unto him, Art thou a king then? Jesus answered, Thou sayest that I am a king. To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth. Every one that is of the truth heareth my voice. Pilate saith unto him, What is truth? And when he had said this, he went out again unto the Jews, and saith unto them, I find in him no fault at all.”-John 18:37-38

We all know what eventually happens here. Pilate caves in to the angry mob, convicts Jesus of treason, and declared Jesus thought himself King of the Jews. All this despite Pilate himself knowing that these were erroneous and falsely made up charges raised against Jesus. However, Pilate is just another in a long history of men who believe morality and truth can mean whatever you want it to mean. After all, if a group of people get together, believe hard enough on a lie, and pressure others into believing said lie, who’s to say it isn’t true? “What is truth?”

“The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good.”-Psalm 14:1

"Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter! Woe unto them that are wise in their own eyes, and prudent in their own sight!"-Isaiah 5:20-21

“For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves: Which shew the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the mean while accusing or else excusing one another;”-Romans 2:14-15

Man is a poor judge of good and evil. The moral argument is the one that did it for me as a former atheist, then agnostic, and now theist.

It's not that people don't know God exists. We actually, (and quite inherently), do. We just squash the belief of Him in order to get away with whatever we want. An atheist who says “I just don't see any evidence for God" is the equivalent of someone going up to Stonehenge in person and saying “Yeah, I think that just naturally formed on its own over a couple million years.” Even a child knows someone put it there. The same could be said for children obviously recognizing it was God that put everything here. It's intuitive.

“At that time Jesus answered and said, I thank thee, O Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because thou hast hid these things from the wise and prudent, and hast revealed them unto babes.”-Matthew 11:25

We all know God exists; we just suppress this truth by choking it with the vain wisdom of men.

Considering everything I've just mentioned, this notion given by atheists that the burden of proof somehow strictly lies on theists (instead of simply both parties) is just flat out erroneous. You would not only have to disprove that God exists, but disprove any possibility that God exists. Both are propositions that are simply too heavy for the atheist to bare. Especially since both have already been refuted, as I have firmly established. This is why most atheists nowadays avoid calling themselves “atheist” but "agnostic atheist," rather, because they know that God either undeniably exists, or that God doesn't exist solely based on probability and/or chance.

Now, this may not prove God is the Christian God. But it certainly proves God exists. There is very good reason to believe God is the God of the Bible. However, that's for the (hopefully now turned theist) unbeliever to find out for him or herself once they search out God for themselves. Once they really and truly do, (if they're honestly seeking the truth), they'll inevitably come to find out that Jesus really is who He says He is. Atheists will presuppose that you need empirical evidence to prove God's existence, but you can't go searching for God if you don't even know what kind of God you're looking for. That's just ludicrous. Even if you don't come to the conclusion that Christianity is true, you don't have to be a Christian to simply be a theist.

Before I finish, I must discuss the difference between faith and belief because there is a big difference between the two. For example, belief is the acknowledgment of the existence of something or someone. Faith is belief plus trust. I believe we can know God exists undeniably. Everyone can know, in fact. However, that doesn't necessarily bring someone to a relationship with God. But it certainly helps if we know that there definitely is a God and that you can know Him if you decide to get to know Him.

Likewise, there's many Christians who believe in God. Do they know Him though? Do they have a relationship with Him? Many do not. Faith (I.E. trust) in God comes in receiving the gospel. The gospel is not simply proving or believing that God exists, (that's just what gets your foot in the door). The gospel is 1. realizing why we need a saviour, 2. repentance, and 3. faith (trust) in Jesus and that you are saved by grace through faith and faith in Him alone. I wasn't giving the gospel here. I was just proving something that everyone can know intuitively: God exists. The gospel, instead, is what initiates the relationship. It usually doesn't prove God exists unless you play the apologetics game first. That's why I implore non-believers and false converts alike to search for God after knowing definitively that He exists, so that that they may inevitably come to faith in the truth that is the gospel, and know who God really is. To my lukewarm Christian readers, you can believe that Jesus is God all you want. But if you don't know Him, His promise of salvation does nothing for you (Matthew 7:21-23). We aren't owed anything, and that includes our salvation. Jesus died for your sake so that you may even get to have a relationship with Him. So please, if you have not yet gotten right with God, please do so as soon as you can. God bless.

"And ye shall seek me, and find me, when ye shall search for me with all your heart."-Jeremiah 29:13


r/Apologetics • • Sep 03 '19

Why would someone want god to be involved in their life?

16 Upvotes

Hi all, me again :)

So I was thinking today, why do people want god in their life?

I would personally rather live by by own efforts. I would rather own up to my accomplishments and failures than have anything either way handed to me. Having a god interfere with my life feels almost dirty, like getting rich off someone else’s money, or letting someone else go to jail in my place. If I mess up, I want to be responsible for making things right, and sharing that with my loved ones to give them the opportunity to do better.

Some of you guys are more philosophically inclined, so feel free to ask any philosophically important questions in the comments that might get me thinking otherwise. And for those not as philosophically inclined, also feel free to ask any hard questions you might have difficulty handling without a god.

Thanks guys! You guys have been great in the past, and I look forward to your responses. If you want some motivation to participate, this can get juices flowing for you to teach Sunday school kids or something :)


r/Apologetics • • Jun 06 '24

Hitchen’s Razor applied to atheism / naturalism

15 Upvotes

Hitchens' Razor states that "what can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence." When we turn this principle on naturalism (and atheism by association), we find that it is a worldview that is often asserted without sufficient evidence, and thus can be dismissed on the same grounds.

Naturalism, at its core, is the philosophical belief that the natural world is all that exists - that there are no supernatural or transcendent realities beyond the physical universe. But what evidence does the naturalist provide for this sweeping metaphysical claim? How do they prove that there is nothing beyond the natural order?

The answer, upon scrutiny, is that naturalism is often accepted as a default position without proper evidential support. It is assumed, rather than argued for, as the starting point for many atheists and skeptics. But this assumption is not metaphysically neutral; it is a substantive philosophical stance that requires justification.

When pressed, naturalists often appeal to the success of science in explaining physical phenomena as evidence for their worldview. But this is a non sequitur. The effectiveness of scientific methods in studying the natural world does not prove that the natural world is all that exists. It is entirely consistent with theism to acknowledge the validity of scientific inquiry while also affirming the reality of a transcendent God.

Moreover, as the argument from intelligibility powerfully demonstrates, the very success of science in uncovering the rational structure of the universe is itself evidence against naturalism. The profound intelligibility of the cosmos, its mathematical elegance and fine-tuning for discovery, is more naturally explained by a theistic worldview that grounds the rational order of nature in a divine mind.

Naturalism, in contrast, struggles to account for this intelligibility. It is forced to accept it as an inexplicable brute fact, or resort to ad hoc explanations like the multiverse hypothesis which themselves lack empirical support. Naturalism provides no satisfying explanation for why the universe is comprehensible to rational minds in the first place.

So when Hitchens' Razor is applied to naturalism, it becomes clear that it is a worldview that is often asserted without adequate evidence. The naturalist makes a bold metaphysical claim - that there is no supernatural reality - but fails to provide a convincing proof for this claim. They assume naturalism as a default position, but offer no justification for this assumption.

Indeed, when pressed on the inadequacy of their naturalistic explanations for the intelligibility and fine-tuning of the universe, atheists often retreat to a position of skeptical agnosticism (i.e., the Skeptic’s Shield). They'll say things like "we just don't know" or "it's a mystery" or "science hasn't figured it out yet".

But this is nothing more than a thinly veiled argument from ignorance. It's an attempt to evade the force of the teleological argument by appealing to our current lack of knowledge or understanding. In effect, the atheist is saying "I can't explain the apparent design and purpose in the cosmos, therefore no one can, therefore we should suspend judgment".

Theism, on the other hand, is not merely asserted, but argued for on the basis of the observable evidence of the universe's intelligibility. The theist follows the evidence where it leads, inferring a divine mind as the best explanation for the rational structure of the cosmos. This inference is not a bare assertion, but a philosophically rigorous argument grounded in the empirical features of the universe.

Thus, Hitchens' Razor, when applied evenhandedly, actually undermines naturalism and supports the theistic argument from intelligibility. It exposes naturalism as a metaphysical assumption often accepted without proof, while highlighting the evidential basis of the theistic worldview.

This is not to definitively settle the debate or rule out all forms of naturalism. But it does shift the burden of proof onto the naturalist to provide a compelling evidential case for their position. They cannot simply assert naturalism as a default and dismiss theistic arguments; they must justify their worldview in the face of the universe's profound intelligibility.

In the end, an honest application of Hitchens' Razor suggests that it is naturalism, not theism, that is the brittle, question-begging worldview that can be dismissed without evidence. Theism, grounded in the rational structure of the cosmos, emerges as an empirically anchored and philosophically robust explanation that demands serious consideration from any sincere truth-seeker.


r/Apologetics • • Apr 04 '20

Greetings it is I...one of the Atheist lurkers. Lurking in the shadows...With 2 genuine questions.

15 Upvotes

Hiya! :)

Lol, I was watching a WLC interview, (why do people call’em Bill btw?) and he was saying that he doesn’t think most atheists are not academically formidable. But I’ve never heard him express a list of reasons, perhaps an example laying out a debate he had with an atheist and expressing what he believes the “un-academic” part of what the atheist/nonbeliever might’ve said and then demonstrate what he thinks an academic would’ve said instead.

I am willing to assume (as is likely the case) that he just has a personal list of whats really relevant to him regarding Theology based on his own presumptions or pre-suppositions; and as a result considers much of anything not relating to those “unacademic” or “unintellectual”. And that most atheists don’t consider those arguments to be worth the time and so don’t even humor those complex but perhaps silly concepts or arguments and as a result the two groups wind up talking largely past each other.

But since Ive never really seen him do so, I was wondering if you guys knew why he doesn’t consider most atheists very intellectual. Has he offered any list of reasons? Or a podcast going through an argument layout and a good contrasting academic argument in his view.

Sorry if that last bit comes off a bit repetitive, but just wanted to be clear.

2nd question is just curious.

Why doesn’t big man Yahweh punish sinners and non believers and etc with his own hands? Y’know to hell with hell, time for Papa Yah to handle this mess face-to-face? Always found it strange when my grandmother first introduced Hell to me. Seemed evasive and just odd.

Thanks in any case!