r/anxietypilled • u/Possible-Display-891 • Apr 29 '26
Fictional Story My Little Sister Keeps Eating Batteries (Part 2)
After dozens of trips to the hospital, it was clear they were sick of us.
In a rather condescending manner they told Caroline to return when there was a real problem. Until then she'd be better with a child psychologist.
It definitely got under her skin.
Before we even left the parking lot, her and dad started arguing outside the car.
Me and Lucy-Lou sat inside, pretending not to hear. I couldn't tell if Caroline was boiling over with rage or on the verge of tears. Maybe both.
Lucy-Lou just sat there. Not moving.
“Lucy, why do you keep lying?”
“I'm not. I did eat them.”
I don't know why, but I believed her. So, I asked a simple question.
“Why?”
Turning to me, she beamed a big smile.
“They keep me warm!”
I could still hear Caroline breaking down outside the car. Rather than continue to scream, she opted to break down in tears. I couldn't gauge dad's reaction.
Lucy-Lou just stared ahead, waiting to get going.
I didn't know what to do with myself. So, I just pulled Lucy close to me and hugged her tight.
I don't think she understood what was happening, but she embraced me. As we held each other, I couldn't help but notice her skin on mine.
It was cold. Cold as the day she died.
The pattern continued. Locking batteries away helped but we couldn't hide everything.
Guilt consumed me. Witnessing the fracturing of my once cheerful family was tearing me apart inside.
I could've prevented this.
This was my fault. Lucy-Lou was hurt because of me. I caused all of this. But I didn't know how to fix it.
Caroline didn't have the energy to resent me anymore. That just made me feel worse.
Sometimes I debated falling on my knees and begging for forgiveness. I knew it was something she'd never give me, but it felt wrong watching her hatred turn to apathy.
I'd rather she hate me. Then I'd know she still felt something.
If I could just figure out what was wrong, I could fix all of this.
Maybe if I could find where Lucy-Lou was putting all the batteries that would help.
No matter where I looked I could never find them. If I asked Lucy, she'd just give the usual answer.
I could see dad had the same idea. On a few occasions I found him digging up the garden. When I'd ask what he was up to, he'd claim he was tidying things up a bit.
Creating holes across your garden doesn't tend to have a ‘tidy’ look.
I knew what he was doing though. I'd see him watch Lucy-Lou's movements when she went out on the grass. Every spot she'd stop to take in the scenery, he'd tear a part the next day.
Eventually he gave up. From the beginning of his searches, I think he knew he'd never find anything.
The more hope he lost, the less he checked in on Lucy. Knowing she'd never give an honest answer made it pointless asking in the first place.
She used to tell dad everything.
It came to a head one night when I heard screeching outside my window.
Once again, Lucy-Lou had somehow managed to make it to the car. Even after we hid the keys.
Caroline found her first, and had decided to try to drag her out.
It should've been easy. Lucy was small and could only move the upper half of her body, but she was putting up a hell of a fight.
I watched as she pushed against Caroline's face, digging her nails into her skin, trying to escape her tight grasp. It was like watching an animal thrashing about.
Dad also heard the commotion, I could hear him scrambling out of his bedroom. With how fast he was moving, I'm surprised he didn't take a short cut and jump out the window.
I followed.
Caroline and Lucy were shouting so loud I could hear what they were saying before we even reached the front door.
“Come back inside!” Caroline kept repeating as Lucy just said no again and again and again.
“Inside! Now!” The demand sounded final this time.
Caroline had run out of patience a long time ago.
When we threw open the door to run outside, I could see Lucy lean in to whisper something in Caroline's ear.
I could see the moment Caroline's heart dropped. White as a sheet, for a moment she just stopped.
Until rage consumed her.
“Who are you?!?! Where is my daughter?! Tell me where she is!”
Violently she shook Lucy, ignoring my dad as he begged her to stop. Lucy's cries were dry but chilling.
It sounded like a survival instinct more than an emotion. I've heard prey animals call for their parents in similar ways before they were about to be torn apart.
Dad barely managed to pull Caroline away, leaving Lucy to fall to the dirt. Caroline just kept demanding answers as dad held her back.
Never once had I seen her blow up like that.
I didn't have time to question it. My focus remained on Lucy. I took her in my arms and carried her inside as fast as my feet could manage.
I ran to the bathroom and locked the door behind us. As the adrenaline wore off and my breathing became heavier, I slid my back down the door.
I cradled Lucy, refusing to let her go despite her looking unfazed.
In what must've been an attempt to calm me down, she patted my head.
I stared at her as she just smiled back at me.
“Don't worry Sammy, I'm ok!”
I knew she couldn't be. How could she be?
She hadn't been ok for a while now. Why was she acting so weird? I know the accident was going to cause problems but I just didn't get it.
And why wouldn't she just tell me what was wrong?
I expected her smile to fade, but she just sat there. I could've just continued to sit like that until it was safe to leave, but curiosity tempted me.
“Lucy… what did you say to your mom?”
Her expression remained the same, not even a twitch in reaction to my question.
Still looking me in the eye, she answered, “I asked her if she was going to kill me like she killed our siblings.”
“What? What siblings?”
Still not even a wrinkle of movement on her face.
“We never got to meet them.”
At first, I didn't understand what she could be implying. That's when I remembered something from before Lucy was born.
Dad and Caroline had been married for a number of years before they had Lucy. I thought nothing of it at the time, but in retrospect it was strange they waited so long to have a kid of their own.
Except now it dawned on me.
Before Caroline was pregnant with Lucy, my parents were somber. I remember Caroline had to go to the hospital a lot and I never knew why.
There was one time Caroline locked herself in the bathroom and told me to go get dad. I remember crying because she shouted at me unexpectedly.
After they left for another hospital trip.
Caroline started praying a lot in those years. It all meant nothing to me as a child, but now…
Was Lucy not their first attempt?
Lucy sat there, waiting for my next question.
“How… How did you know that?”
Nothing. Still nothing. Just that same damn smile and piercing blue eyes in the dark.
Before I could ask anything else, there was a gentle knock on the door.
Dad assured me it was safe to come out. Caroline left to go cool off at our grandpa's house.
I opened the door, expecting him to be all over Lucy-Lou. But he only briefly asked if she was alright, as if it were only out of obligation.
After we brought her back to her bed, he seemed more concerned about me. Asking if I was ok, or if anything happened, or if I was rattled by the situation.
I answered honestly, that I was fine but a bit freaked out. But I'd manage.
He offered to sleep on the armchair in my bedroom, something he'd do when I was little and had a nightmare.
I tried my best to insist I was fine, and that Lucy probably needed his company more than I did.
When he didn't respond, a realization hit me.
He didn't agree with Caroline, did he?
“Dad?-”
“Goodnight Sam.”
He left without another word.
The days grew longer after that incident. The sense of dread in the house kept growing.
Caroline avoided Lucy. Dad tried his best to interact with her, but I could tell it was forced.
I couldn't understand what was happening. Only I seemed to care about my little sister, only I seemed to be giving her the time of day.
The way our roles had switched left me uneasy.
Over time, Lucy's skin began to grow pale, with an almost blue tint. Still she'd complain about the cold no matter how many heaters and blankets I brought her.
I could swear her eyes were brighter. They'd reflect in the night like a cat's, her unkempt hair making her look even more feral.
Items continued to disappear. The nightly car routine also restarted.
I didn't want to leave her alone, so I returned to sleeping there with her. My dad didn't stop us but he tried his best to sway me otherwise.
Then one day the car engine stopped working. Dad had to phone in late to work when we discovered the battery was gone.
Before we could get it replaced, Caroline found her car wouldn't start the next day either.
Soon the fuse box went, along with the oil tank being drained.
Then the birds.
Dead birds. Everywhere. In the garden, her room, the kitchen. All drained of their life source like everything else.
Blood.
The culprit was willing to give herself up as always.
I begged Lucy to tell me what was wrong. I burst into tears on multiple occasions, she could tell me anything I'd assure her again and again.
She'd always say nothing was wrong. She's just cold.
Another night came where I found her bed empty. So, I ventured outside to join her.
Yet, the cars were empty too.
I bolted back inside, frantic to figure out where she went.
Instead, I found my parents sitting in the kitchen.
Dad was leaning against the counter top, while Caroline sat beside it, her hand rubbing her forehead.
“Where's Lucy?!”
“Gone. She left.” Caroline kept her head down, refusing to face me.
“Gone?! Gone where?! Her wheelchair is still here!”
Neither of them answered, as if I should be able to guess myself. I could feel myself getting agitated.
“She couldn't have crawled away!”
“I doubt she crawled.”
Caroline was the only one to answer, but dad never disagreed.
“W-we have to go after he-”
“A priest is coming by tomorrow.”
A mixture of confusion and disgust washed over me.
“A priest? She's sick, she needs help, not a priest!"
Caroline chuckled a little, “Of course you wouldn't understand. That's not her.”
“What the hell are you saying?! Who else would it be?! Have you both gone mad?!”
“Sam, she's changed.” Dad finally chimed in.
“She almost died! Of course she changed! What?! Did you think she'd come back all fixed as good as new?!”
Instead of responding, dad emptied a cardboard box onto the counter that had been sitting beside him.
Dozens and dozens of items, all broken or missing batteries. It was as if there was a graveyard of electronics spread across the marble top.
“This isn't normal, Sam. She… my little girl would never act like that. At night sometimes she just… I find her staring at me from the foot of my bed… Smiling.” I could see the whites of my father's eyes as he spoke, like he was recounting the horrors of war.
“She needs help, but she-”
“We've tried professionals. We've switched her therapist so many times but… I don't know what happened to the real Lucy but that's not her.”
I could see his eyes go glossy as he teared up.
Caroline was more apathetic as she spoke, “I don't know what that thing is but it took my daughter. If it never returns, so be it.”
“Y-you're both crazy. She's out there alone right now! She needs our help! And you are just abandoning-”
“You don't get to lecture me about my kid when you left her to die in the first place!”
Caroline smacked the counter so hard I could hear her knuckles crack.
It was an anger I always knew was there. Simmering. What hurt more, was when my own father didn't come to my defence.
Or Lucy's.
I stood there like an idiot. Not knowing what to say, with no defence for myself.
“...You're right. It's my fault. Which is why I won't leave her alone again.”
I pivoted to run out the door before either of them could stop me. I could hear dad shouting for me to stop but I blocked him out and just focused on making it out.
Once outside, I ran barefoot, ignoring the pains of the stones beneath my feet.
I kept running and running, not realising my dad's begging had already faded out behind me.
I couldn't be sure where Lucy went. I had a good hunch though.
I wouldn't leave her. Something was wrong, I knew that. I didn't know if it was psychological, or physical or something else. All I knew was she needed my help.
That's all I needed to know.
By the time I made it to the junkyard, my feet were bleeding. When I passed the scene of the incident that started this all, it didn't even process in my mind.
I was too focused on my destination.
I called out for Lucy-Lou. I tried my best to tempt her out, praying she was there to hear my requests.
I searched everywhere I could. No car went unchecked. No scrap metal unturned.
Every time I found nothing, a little of me died inside.
If she wasn't here, I wouldn't have had any other ideas. It would mean I lost her for good this time.
I couldn't.
Losing her would mean I failed. That I never made up for my mistakes. I don't think I could bear that.
Yet my desires meant nothing. If she was gone, she was gone.
I was ready to give into despair when I heard metal clacking from behind.
I whipped around, desperate to find the source.
When I looked up, I saw her silhouetted on top of one of the piles of metallic husks.
The only feature I could make out were her eyes, almost turquoise and dilated. They were focused on me, shining on top of the opaque shadows surrounding them.
The way she was postured looked unnatural, almost on all fours as she crouched over, the innards of one cars still clutched in her now spindly hands.
I told myself it must be a trick of the light.
Her once delicate hands were more adjacent to claws. Each knuckle bone pierced through the skin.
It was like looking at a malnourished child. As if she were only skin and bone with hollow insides.
Her spine was wrong, her shirt partly ripped to reveal it poking out of her skin, as if tempting to claw its way out.
The details were obscured in the darkness. The stillness somehow made it harder to tell if my mind was betraying me.
Yet it felt like I was looking death in the eyes.
I swallowed. I could not let fear get in the way.
“Lucy-Lou… can we please go home?”
As if on queue, one by one she clambered down each vehicle.
The way she moved as unnatural, as if each step was calculated yet sporadic at the same time. I could hear her spine pop with each movement.
I was scared of what I'd see once she was lit by the moonlight.
But when she was finally visible again, she just looked like my Lucy-Lou.
Face smothered in oil, she wiped it as it dripped down her chin. The smile she always wore had disappeared, replaced by a cold stare.
“You want me to come home?”
I just nodded.
I waited for her to ask more. Those questions never came so I persevered.
“Please Lucy, let me help you…”
Lucy-Lou took in the junkyard around her, spinning to survey her surroundings.
Once finished, she gave a gentle smile.
“Ok, Sammy.”
I felt a wave of relief. I held out my hand for her to take. At first she didn't seem to understand, then took it on her own.
The whole way home we walked in silence. I wasn't sure what to say, hoping she'd begin the conversation first.
By the time we returned home, dad and Caroline were already in their room. I'm sure dad was comforted knowing I had returned, he just wouldn't want to see what with.
“Lucy, want to sleep in my room tonight?”
With a look of glee, she nodded.
I gathered her blankets and pushed her mattress into my room. To the best of my abilities, I threw together a blanket fort in the corner.
That night I couldn't bring myself to join her though.
I offered her my own bed but she said she liked the mattress better.
I tried my best to give her a smile before saying good night. With how quickly that smile faltered, I'm sure she knew it was forced.
I then set a torch beside her, batteries still inside.
She looked at me surprised.
“Lucy, I'm here if you need me. Remember that.”
I expected her usual facade, but instead she laid down to sleep.
I crawled into my own bed, not even bothering to pull my blanket up. I just laid on my back, staring at my ceiling.
I could feel a sharp pain shoot through my foot. My injuries from running had caught up to me. I couldn't ignore the pain but I had no will to go find a solution.
I don't know how a priest could fix Lucy-Lou. Maybe my parents were right, while she may have appeared to be herself once visible, I knew what I saw.
I knew she was still in there though. They thought Lucy was gone, but they hadn't seen those glimpses of her I did.
How she'd hold me in the back of the car. How she'd tell me stories about her friends at school. How she'd light up when doodling.
I knew she was in there.
I looked down at my feet, expecting to see the blood smearing across my bedsheets.
Instead, I saw Lucy's eyes peering over the bed frame.
It was as if they were staring into my soul. Unmoving, unblinking.
That unbroken focus as she stared at me sent a chill up my spine. It was like watching a predator sizing up its prey, debating if it should swallow it whole or take its time.
I could feel my heart in my throat. I didn't know what to say.
Then I noticed the blood on my bedsheets was all over her hands.
“What are you doing?”
I could still only see her eyes.
“It's warm.”
We remained at a standstill. I could feel my heart beating faster. My mind raced with all the ideas Caroline and dad had put into my head.
I took a deep breath, relaxing as I remembered who I was looking at.
“Sleep well, Lucy-Lou.”
The stand off ended as I turned to my side. Despite my moment of courage, I didn't unwind until I heard her walk back to her mattress.
“Night Sammmy, love you.”
It was the first time she ever said those words to me. Despite the situation, I couldn't contain my smile.
“Love you too, Luc.”
I don't know how, but I managed to fall asleep.
Adrenaline and fear had still been pumping through my veins all the way until I closed my eyes and drifted off.
Somehow I knew, even if dad and Caroline were right, Lucy wouldn't hurt me. Even if that wasn't the real Lucy, I could tell a piece of her was still in there.
Why else would she remind me she loved me?
That night remained unpeaceful as I awoke again.
I heard some slight muffled sounds, followed by something smashing.
I was still half asleep, so it took a while before I realised what I heard.
What caught my attention was my dad's agonising scream.
I shot up in my bed. To my horror, Lucy-Lou wasn't on her mattress.
No. No, no. She wouldn't. She wouldn't, she wouldn't.
I kept repeating it to myself as I dashed down the hallway. I slipped on the carpet, struggling to stay up right, going too fast and almost missing their bedroom door.
My hand hovered over the door handle. Dread took over me, as I trembled in place.
I resolved myself to continue, swinging open the door.
I just stood there. Watching the same scene play out before me all over again.
No one wants to see a corpse. Especially the mangled one of some you know. Someone you love.
Especially when it's your fault.
And this time you knew, whatever being you had been bargaining with, just enjoyed toying with you.
The once cream bedroom was now painted red. Detailed patterns on the wall were now smothered in a crimson pulp making them unrecognisable. The family portrait dad kept by his bedside drawer was in pieces on the ground.
Caroline's head was twisted up to the ceiling, so far back her neck snapped. A slash was across it, exposing her trachea.
Her eyes were shut over, suggesting a peaceful slumber before her life was cut short.
Unlike dad, whose jaw was ripped open. The bottom row of teeth so far down it was only attached by some fleshy strings.
Worse than this fate, was the expression imprinted into his face. The look of terror as he sat upright in his bed, the tears still streaming down his cheeks.
And who stood a top of him other than Lucy-Lou.
Or whatever remained of her.
Her skin was an icey-blue. With her back now facing me, I could see the details of her veins pulsating down her spine. The once broken legs now bent the opposite way they were supposed too.
I could see her draw her long finger nails across dad's neck, piercing the skin as a long spiralling tongue unravelled to lick up every drop of blood.
It was then I saw those once beautiful eyes shining back at me.
Her attention locked on me.
No… No, no, no. I was meant to help. No, not again. I can't lose them. I can't lose her again. I made a promise.
I'm meant to fix things this time.
The way she moved was particular, her head tilting as if to decipher my reaction. Once off the bed, she began her approach.
So focused on her, I lost my footing and fell backwards. Landing on the ground and shuffling back in a panic.
“L-Lucy please…”
I debated running, but I was shaking so much. And where would I run to? Even if she didn't catch me, she was all I had left.
I have to fix this. I have to fix this.
I could see her hands crack and turn, the proportions morphing back into something more human.
Yet despite the mutation reverting back, I knew her intent was the same.
“Luc… i-it's me Sammy… please…”
Not sure what else to do, I searched through my pockets.
I kept it on at all times as a reminder, making sure even my pajamas had pockets so it never left my side.
I tried my best to unfold the paper and present it despite my hands shivering with every fearful breath.
The only thing I had I left to try. The only chance I had of survival.
The drawing she made of us.
“L-look! It's us, see?!”
Pausing, she tilted her head.
“It's me, and dad, and, your mom! Pl-please Lucy I-I don't know what's happening to you but please… ”
She continued to just stare at me, not moving.
“I promised I'd be better this time. I'm not abandoning you! I don't why you… W-we can fix this please…”
The grotesque form she had taken, cracked and convulsed until it was back in its original state. That of the little girl I loved so dearly.
All except, those luminous all seeing eyes.
“...you.” She croaked out.
I couldn't understand the expression she was making. It consisted of a scrunched nose and an intense stare. The eyebrows curled and pushed the folds of the skin together. The entire time the eyes remained glued to me despite attempting to calculate something.
It took a few steps towards me. I had nowhere behind me to retreat to.
I just waited for my fate, still trying to understand that bizarre expression.
Then it stopped at my feet.
“You still think I am her?”
I felt my heart shatter as a feeling of disgust creeped up inside. Rage, devastation and detachment came alongside it.
I now understood that expression.
Pity.
I sat frozen in fear, even as it came closer.
“I guess, you wouldn't know the difference, would you? If you never knew her.”
It leaned down in front of me. Its bones creaked as it crouched. With a gentle touch, it took my chin and raised it to face it.
Looking straight into my eyes, I could see myself reflect in its pupils.
“If only, you had kept an eye on her…”
Its nails slid under my eyelids, digging into my eyeball. Careful, it dislodged it from its place. I could feel the strain of my socket as it pulled against its force.
I could feel the pain but I did not process it.
The further it was pulled out the more my other eye could see it detach from the remaining read threads.
Until it snapped.
It then took the eye and swallowed it whole. Before leaving without another word.
And I just sat there, staring at what remained of our family.
I stayed in that state until the next morning when the priest found me. I hadn't moved all night.
I never spoke again after that. This is the only way I can communicate now. Fractured ramblings in texts as an attempt to write my scattered thoughts.
I think the police were suspicious of me at first, but after the state they found me in and the details the priest already knew about Lucy-Lou they dropped me as a suspect.
I went to live with my grandparents. There was nowhere else for me to go, but even after all these years I can tell they don't know what to do with me.
Lucy-Lou was never found, or whatever that thing was. The police only resolved to find a body not a person, presuming she met the same fate as my parents.
They'd never see a little girl as a serious culprit.
They just presumed my parents asked the wrong people to help us out with the demon conspiracy theories. The story was they became convinced their traumatized daughter was possessed by a demon and started asking around those too willing to help out.
And with me now a recent mute I couldn't defend their legacy.
That is until now. Not that anyone will believe this anyway.
I'm not sure what to believe myself. It's clear to me now that my judgments were always wrong.
Why did that thing keep me alive? Why do I not get to join my family? Why must I live with the guilt?
What decided to give me the false hope I could ever get a second chance with Lucy-Lou?
Or maybe it thought it was being merciful somehow.
What keeps me up at night, is what happened to the real Lucy-Lou? Did she get to pass on peacefully? Is she still in there somewhere trapped?
Is she suffering in that things place, in whatever hell hole it came from?
Even after all this time, I still have that picture in my pocket. The drawing it handed to me in the hospital is in my hand as we speak.
I know it is wrong. I know it means nothing. But no matter how I try, I can't let it go.
I would've kept the real Lucy-Lou's drawings, but I always threw them in the trash.
Maybe that's why that thing kept me alive. The cruelty that fueled it was mirrored in me.
Whatever happened, it is my fault. And even if my family could hear my hollow apologies they'd mean nothing now.
All I can do is mourn a sister I never knew.