r/Antitheism • u/[deleted] • Oct 31 '14
Does antitheism mean anything?
I’ve been noticing some really questionable statements being thrown around by antitheists lately, so I thought I would collect a few here for discussion purposes. Please bear in mind this isn’t an attack on atheism, or a defense of theism, I just want to put these out there to see if someone can help me understand what I am missing, or maybe even discourage people from recycling dud arguments in future. I am no theologian, and I am happy to be corrected if something I said here is wrong.
Ok, here is an example of the kind of thinking I am referring to - it’s a thread from this sub.
‘Four questions that Christians can't answer without their brains exploding. They won't even try. Pathetic.’
Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Is he able, but not willing? 3)Is he both able and willing?
Is he neither able nor willing?
I know I have picked a pretty cringeworthy example - I do this because it’s a good example of what I am talking about, not because I think it’s representative of antitheism. It’s not hard to find something to object to here, starting with the fact that theologists have been asking that very question for centuries. I think the main issue is that the OP is trying to use theological ideas as a weapon without really understanding what they mean, which is a good example of the problems I have been noticing.
Basically, the less sophisticated arguments against religion often involve quoting scripture. This seems like a logical thing to do, but it ignores the fact that theology (as opposed to religion in general) is not comprehensible to the layman. It is a massively broad discipline, and it is a discipline in the same sense that any of the sciences are. This is a really major difference between religion and theology; theology can no more be understood by a layman than engineering or psychology. Like other intellectual disciplines, theology requires years of dedicated study to get to grips with. Without this, your reading of any religious text is largely worthless for anything but informing your own, personal beliefs. For example, the post above seems to imply that the existence of evil precludes the existence of God, and an inability to answer the question implies a lack of intelligence or insight. The point of this kind of question is that it does not, and cannot, have one answer. I’d argue that the question has more to do with interrogating interpretations of scripture than with the nature/existence of God. In fact, the question itself presupposes the existence of God, so it doesn’t even make any sense in an atheist context.
This is my main issue with commentators like Dawkins and Sam Harris: although they’re both presumably outstanding in their fields, neither of them are in the field of theology. Dawkins is especially good at making broad statements in areas that he’s not really qualified in. Which brings me to the next questionable statement.
Theology is a pseudo-science
This is a big one. I’d argue it’s not true though; theology isn’t pseudo-science or science, it’s theology, and it has its own rules. Theology will always look bad when you present it in a scientific context, but that’s just because it has no place there. Many prominent thinkers seem to be of the view that science has replaced religion and theology, but this seems about as accurate as saying that fiction has replaced poetry. They deal in different ideas, and in different ways. Of course I am not talking here about religious lobby groups and young-earthers, but that’s because I don’t see them as being very representative of religion in general. There will always be idiots, and sadly these idiots are lumped in with everyone else who believes in God. Until we start listening to people who actually have some grounding in the interpretation of religious texts, we will be stuck with hearing the ham-fisted, overly-literal interpretations of the wingnuts, and the shit-flinging will continue.
And onto the next one:
Religion makes good people do bad things
This is a popular statement, though there seems to be little evidence that it’s true. I honestly doubt any credible psychologist would agree, but it’s a convenient one liner. Tests such as the Milgram and Stanford Prison experiments told a very different story; basically good people will do bad things for any number of reasons, regardless of religion.
Religion is the main source of suffering on earth.
I could do the whole “Stalin/Pol Pot/Mao/Sri Lanka” thing but Christ, everyone has heard that. The majority of genocides in the last century were committed by secular forces, often against religious groups, and secular-on-religious violence is far more common than either inter-religious violence or religious-on-secular violence. I am not discounting the suffering caused to many by religion, but statistically it really is just a drop in the bucket these days.
Religion is in decline
Seems plausible, but it’s bullshit. Religion is growing, in both relative and concrete terms.
Atheism implies intelligence/intelligence implies atheism
A lot of people seem to think that their atheism implies that they’re more logical, stable and humane than religious people. This is so ridiculous it doesn’t need refuting.
I have often heard these statements used to justify someone’s intolerance of religion. Since most of them don’t hold much water, this leaves me wondering about the role of antitheism. If antitheists are unable to refute theology by applying their own systems of thought to it, then what exactly does antitheism stand in opposition to? The most common answer I get seems to be that people are disgusted by religion’s lack of regard for human rights, but again, the examples often seem to be more related to systematic social problems (female circumcision/stoning, etc etc) than they are to religious thought in a broad sense.
Again, I am not using these examples to attack antitheism, but I think it’s worth discussing exactly why anyone should oppose free practice of religion. Antitheism as it stands seems far too liable to drift into outright bigotry.
Anyway, sorry for the wall of text. I’d be interested to hear some views on this. Also, I would love to get some recommendations of authors and thinkers who have actually engaged with theology in earnest, rather than dismissing it outright.
Cheers.
7
u/ssianky Oct 31 '14
Actually there is no good response to the Epicurean dilemma. The best response I heard is - everything what God does is good. That's a nonsense.
1
-1
Oct 31 '14 edited Oct 31 '14
Actually there is no good response to the Epicurean dilemma.
Yeah, that's what I said. My point is that people are too quick to make judgements from a modern, secular point of view, without taking into account the complexities of theoligical thinking.
EDIT: Could you explain what you mean by it being a nonsense?
10
u/ssianky Oct 31 '14
How an absence of a good response makes "theological thinking" complex? For me it is more like dishonest thinking.
2
u/bouchard Nov 01 '14
the complexities of theoligical thinking.
It's been a long time since I've been able to use this video as a response to something.
Could you explain what you mean by it being a nonsense?
Because it's just handwaving.
19
u/AntithesisVI Oct 31 '14
Antitheism is about growing up as a species. Do you still believe in the tooth fairy? or Santa Claus? A disturbingly large percentage of the American population believe Jesus is gonna come back to fix all our problems, or destroy the world, and there's no point in worrying about climate change, or world hunger, or anything else.
Additionally, theism in general is forced upon young children during their most impressionable years. It teaches them concepts, like unwavering, unquestioning obedience to an unseen master. It teaches belief without reason or evidence. When concepts like these are ingrained into your brain as good, later in life they will easily be applied to other aspects of your life. Imagine what a society full of citizens incapable of critical thought, who blindly believed every single word that comes from an official source, would be like...
Imagine how easily manipulated those people would be by other influences as well...
Theism is a lie. The question we should be asking is why we allow such a fraud to perpetuate throughout the human consciousness. Given that there's no evidence to support it, and the burden of proof lies with the claimant, there is no excuse for allowing people to twist their children's minds with it. It's abuse. If theism didn't exist, and someone suggested it just today, everyone would think it was a crazy person. If that person went on to do things that are done today in the name of religion, they would be locked up and the key would be thrown away. If they're lucky.
5
u/exploderator Nov 01 '14
If you look closely, the religion here is just mystic camouflage on a system of human authority. You can substitute "authoritarianism" in your above statement, everywhere you say "theism", and it makes more sense. We are fighting authoritarianism here, and shouldn't give religion that much credibility, and should blame it for what it actually is.
1
Nov 01 '14
Thankyou, that's way more concise than anything I said. I'm not denying that awful things have been done in the name of religion, but I think that much of the time these things were done for secular reasons. Nobody is going to have a holy war if the winner doesn't get filthy rich from it, right?
2
u/exploderator Nov 01 '14
Thank you, but I admit I am of divided mind on this point. I think I also wouldn't say things were done for secular reasons per se, and prefer saying things often reflect ugly human instincts. What I'm thinking here is more like this: religion is a mostly a set of traditions and cultural habits, mostly clustered around established social authority hierarchies. It's not actually coherent in the way people think it is, and it's not fully to blame for human nature that is the real root cause of both religion, and many other ugly things. So to say religion was fully to blame is often putting excess value on religion. Religion was partly to blame for many things, a partial causative factor, that people were organized to act on whatever shit they were up to.
6
u/exploderator Oct 31 '14
Wall of text? Sorry? No you're not sorry, and thank you for having more than a 30s attention span, which is why NOT to hang out over in some place like r/atheism. You wanted some thoughts, here are some responses from an ignostic, in no particular order:
basically good people will do bad things for any number of reasons, regardless of religion.
Basically good people will do bad things for any number of reasons, INCLUDING religion. The Milgram and Stanford prison experiments showed that misuse / abuse of authority is the biggest danger here, and religion is deeply, perhaps primarily concerned with authority (ultimately human) on every front, and thereby ripe for causing trouble. Religion is a common reason good people do bad things, of course not the only one. The most common mechanism is that a good person will do (obey) something they are told by a religious authority figure (in their eyes), which is a bad thing, that they would not have done, or perhaps even would not have thought to do, unless some claim of authority was made. This also includes people obeying religiously justified but bogus or inappropriate authority, such as women obeying their husbands and beating children, because their religion says they must obey the husband, even though they feel (likely contrary to their religion) that beating the children is wrong.
Basically, the less sophisticated arguments against religion often involve quoting scripture.
I think the strategy has some appeal, as a basic attempt to point out that the scripture is nonsensical on the face of it, which is honestly a prudent thing to note about books that claim to be "holy" and speak for some all powerful "god". Especially when talking to people who claim those same books as their life's inspiration. Unless you want to go back to a time where mere peons are not allowed to read the books, then these books can, will and should be debated, peon to peon, as often as they are read or mentioned. With luck, better argument will eventually obtain, as we peons continue our long rise from ignorance.
This seems like a logical thing to do, but it ignores the fact that theology (as opposed to religion in general) is not comprehensible to the layman.
And many reasonable people argue, very conclusively in my view, that scripture, theological writings, and those theologians who perpetuate and apologize for it all, are utterly full of shit, nonsense, and that the whole works is about fiction and mythology, and only tangentially has any connection to reality. You get a lot of historical and cultural content, and some ongoing philosophical work (often with painfully superstition / faith tainted logic), but ultimately what you have is a many-millenia long circle jerk composed of countless unsupported "because I say so" assertions. Where science appreciators criticize this, is because we want some bloody evidence, and all theology can do is point back to an endless echo chamber of "because I say so", which includes the "holy" books. Don't be surprised when we gladly agree that theology is not comprehensible, by any standards acceptable to anyone but theologians. It can be completely obvious from the outside looking in that you have to drink the Kool-Aid to take any of it seriously, and it was probably pounded into most people's heads while they were still young and soft. I'm not forgetting that there are numerous people who have studied theology and don't believe in the religion, but they seldom have anything terribly supportive to say about what they discover, and they are typically not popular with the apologetic majority, likely because their work is often quite penetrating in an unflattering way.
Finally, as a layman with respect to most science, I nonetheless enjoy full and open access to science, in a way that makes perfect sense at almost every stage of involvement, and with full and open opportunity to see with my own eyes the truth of the matters I'm studying. And to the degree I have any doubt, there is an abundance of direct demonstrated evidence, which is not significantly in dispute by anyone other than by scientists who simply wish to make sure there is no error creeping in. When a Christian theologian will usually claim that the literature proves Jesus is God and Islam is false, and an Islamic theologian will claim {stuff} is the perfect final true word of God and Christianity is superseded, and a Jewish theologian will scoff at both of them as upstarts, WELL, forgive me for granting the points they ALL make, about each and every one of those religions being untrue.
Religion is the main source of suffering on earth.
Yeah, that one is badly over stated. It gives way too much credit to religion. I think of religion as a social phenomenon amongst an advanced species of primate, heavily influenced by a complex mixture of culture and history, but primarily driven by the complex biological social-psychological facts of our species. To say that religion is driving, is to ignore that our underlying animal nature is the original author here. Our species is authoritarian, patriarchal, territorial, aggressive, jealous and greedy, for right or wrong, and religion expresses that along with everything else we do. We are right to recognize that we are not well served by these tendencies, and do something about them, because they harm us. To the extent that such problematic traits become institutionalized, we must strive to reform the institutions, and argue the points, but blaming the institution for the impulse is often misleading.
too long, continued in reply to this post...
5
u/exploderator Oct 31 '14
intolerance of religion
If you want to whine about shitty politics, then please do justify the last several thousand years of nearly universal murderous intolerance against atheism, that continues even as current law in some places.
Since most of them don't hold much water, this leaves me wondering about the role of antitheism.
So you want to condemn all antitheists because there are some lame ducks quacking? Interesting, and back to shitty politics, I hear a lot of religious whining when the same broad brush style is applied to them. It would be wiser if we were careful about realizing that the label is not the person, and there are no conclusive groups here, so "antitheists" is no more all encompassing than "Christians", which overly-general group is still actively burning witches, but you don't hear me blaming you personally for it.
If antitheists are unable to refute theology by applying their own systems of thought to it
That is simply untrue. You're ignoring the very well developed and broadly held naturalism, which most science appreciators, including your typical atheists and antitheists, posit is a completely self sufficient and godless explanatory framework for reality, and which is honestly only growing in totality and completeness as we apply the scientific process and learn more. When I say godless, I am not trying to prove a negative, perhaps something exists. I'm saying that none of the multitudinous variations of "god", a word used by people, have ever been demonstrated in nature, and are utterly irrelevant, indeed nonsensical, in light of what IS demonstrable. As an ignostic, I would say the word "god" is abused to the point of meaninglessness, and unless you are indoctrinated in some particular religious group that supplies an "official" meaning, the word is incoherent at this point in history.
Sorry, but I grew up in an atheist family, walking through nature and learning science and logic and philosophy, and the world seems quite wholly natural to me, including we human apes with our minds full of complex fantasies. From my perspective, theology never even began to justify itself, there's nothing for me to refute. All that's been presented to me is an endless parade of "because I say so", evidence free claims by people. Furthermore, these claims frequently conflict, are usually nonsensical, and often are transparent superstition, myth or bigotry. I see little reason to even begin to investigate or entertain them in earnest, I've better life investments to make, and I have never been sympathetic to any authority (human of course) who would bully me in spite of the lack of compelling evidence. If you think your "god" wants my attention, then by everything I've heard, I'm sure it's perfectly able to find me. I don't need some shitstorm of apology that takes years of study to appreciate, to refute that in spite his "omnipresence", "omnipotence", and compassion, that he is also unwilling, or sent his only son 2000 years ago. What an obvious pile of nonsense. I suppose I'll be damned to hell for my insolence, or is that the official doctrine of your church these days?
Look, in your post, you on one hand tell me I ought to refute theology, and on the other, tell me "it's theology, and it has its own rules", and "theology can no more be understood by a layman than engineering or psychology. Like other intellectual disciplines, theology requires years of dedicated study to get to grips with". So sorry, that really just means it's not my job to refute theology. My most important conclusion is that religion is almost exclusively concerned with our species complex instincts for social authority, and the 99% reason religious even worry about a "creator" is because they demand I obey him, to which I say fuck off. My rules say you must explain life in terms of animal behavior and natural science, because the very best facts we have plainly demonstrate that we are animals living on a planet, behaving as animals do. I don't see theology refuting that, and if they wanted to, at least they would have very sensible rules to play by.
But I must end with the final, and brutally obvious elephant in the room here. All this time, you use words like "religion" and "theology", you disingenuously, indeed dishonestly omit being specific. But it's easy enough to know that you mean, very specifically, but at the same time actually quite vaguely, Christianity and Christian theology, and I say vaguely because it's unspecified which subspecies you actually accept amongst many, even though you do attempt to eliminate what you say (and I agree) are the worse fanatics and idiots. I infer we should assume you don't mean the very dedicated theologians who promote stoning homosexuals and apostates to death (Islam has a bunch of them), or the theologians who say the only route to enlightenment is through meditation (common with Buddhists and Hindus), nor probably even the Catholic theologians who will tell you in all seriousness about saints, exorcism, the trinity, and the evils of contraception. But why not? Do you propose some monopoly on theology they aren't party to? I can't buy any of it, and from what you say, the only way I could purportedly tell would be to invest decades of my life to it. I'm still not buying, and you would have to make one hell of a case for me to even begin to consider it.
1
Nov 01 '14
Thanks, another excellent reply.
I'm on my phone, so I can't really address much of what you said, a lot of really great points though.
I should point out that I am not religious in the slightest, I was just interested in getting a debate started. My post is mostly me playing devil's advocate, so to speak, in the hopes of getting some people to expand on these kinds of statements, which you clearly did, so thanks again.
then please do justify the last several thousand years of nearly universal murderous intolerance against atheism
Not my place to do so, but when I say 'intolerance', I was referring more to the bigotry I've noticed becoming more prevalent, often against Muslims (I live in Australia). IMO this kind of intolerance is a massive burden for more level-headed atheists, in the same way that religious wingnuts are a burden for much of the religious community. What you're talking about is way out of my depth.
1
u/exploderator Nov 01 '14
LOL, devil's advocate. You had me fooled with your stated acceptance of theology, which while it is a big deal (so are churches, so is Rome), I can not quite credit it for actually being anything much more than an extended aspect of the same religious infrastructure, with unreliable objectivity regarding religion.
As for atheist bigotry against religion, I'm not sure what to think. Part of me is willing to grant that especially with Islam, there are some intractable conflicts with Enlightenment philosophy, and that is going to leave us having to choose sides in a very real war of ideas, and hoping Islam evolves very rapidly or dies out. I'm just hard pressed how to ratify some of the cultural / religious facts of Islam with Western culture. And I gladly admit I think they're dead wrong on a bunch issues, factually objectively wrong, in a way I can't relativise away.
But OTOH, religions are not monolithic, and are not defined only by "holy" books or doctrine, they are dynamic things made up by the people as they go along, and different groups of people often make up far less bad versions of their religion than others, and no one is officially right or wrong for doing it differently. Accusing them of cherry picking their doctrines to ignore the ugly bits is exactly equivalent to blaming someone for making up a story wrong. It doesn't matter, it's a made up story, and they are free to make it up how ever they like, and I just hope it's nice instead of violent. I wish they would spend less time in fantasy land, and maybe we can make their story converge more with reality as time passes, just as the stories of Western scientific thought have been converging with natural reality as time passes.
Is that bigotry on my behalf? I don't know.
3
u/kmdr Nov 01 '14
theology requires years of dedicated study to get to grips with. Without this, your reading of any religious text is largely worthless for anything but informing your own, personal beliefs.
So, a simple farmer, who hadn't the money to these "years of dedicated studies" can't worthily read the Bible? A less-than-average smart person can't worthily read the Bible?
You know how a guy once called those "less-than-average smart persons"? He called them "the poor of spirit".
Need I me remind you who this guy was? And what he said about them?
Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
He doesn't say "blessed the super-smart and rich who can afford years of theological studies".
For Christ's sake, does he say: you are just a fisherman, your "reading of any religious text is largely worthless." ?
Are you fucking serious? in /r/anthiteism, posting this "Holier and wiser than thou" bullshit?
Let's keep going:
Atheism implies intelligence/intelligence implies atheism
This is so ridiculous it doesn’t need refuting.
Meh. Is this the deepest you can go on that topic?
You are putting yourself at the same level of people that say "humanity is condemned because of the interaction between a naked women and a talking snake? This is so ridiculous it doesn’t need refuting."
Except that a talking snake is actually ridiculous, while scores of researches have measured a negative correlation between IQ and religiosity.
A good sum-up of several studies is in "Average intelligence predicts atheism rates across 137 nations", by Lynn et al. (full-text here)
It's an important point, you can't just dismiss it like this.
I've heard better argumentations from an almost 80-years old Catholic Priest. What he said was basically along these lines:
"Sure, there are smarter and less smart people. And the church is accepting them all. Science, on the other hand, can be EXTREMELY difficult and less welcoming for the less gifted. So, it's just normal that the less gifted are more attracted to the church, and that the average IQ is lower. There's nothing bad in being less smart, about half of the people have an IQ below the average. Does this make them less valuable as persons?"
Now THAT is a religious guy I respect. A lesson of humility and true Christian spirit.
On your side, instead I get dismissive criticism and mumbo-jumbo about how "theology can no more be understood by a layman than engineering or psychology."
You know what? A true religious person will always have my respect. A theologian, on the other hand, makes me immediately doubt of his intentions, especially when he uses his theology to talk low to simpler but perhaps more authentically religious people, or to non-religious people who use "less sophisticated arguments".
Aren't you ashamed of your pseudo-intellectual superiority?
Even in my atheist eyes, all your "sophisticated arguments" are worth far LESS than a sincere and simple prayer from a "poor in spirit".
What do you think your "lord" would think of you?
You are the living negation of the good parts that one can find in religiosity.
0
Nov 01 '14
I wasn't talking about a religious person, I was talking about a theologian. This doesn't really have anything to do with a simple farmer.
Bear in mind that what I actually wrote was "worthless for anything but informing your own, personal beliefs." In the case of a religious person, that's exactly what religion does.
You referred to the difference yourself:
A true religious person will always have my respect. A theologian, on the other hand, makes me immediately doubt of his intentions.
...
What do you think your "lord" would think of you?
You are the living negation of the good parts that one can find in religiosity.
I'm not even remotely religious.
2
u/kmdr Nov 01 '14
I'm not even remotely religious.
Why this fixation about theology, then?
Or you were just speaking out of your ass ?
Like other intellectual disciplines, theology requires years of dedicated study to get to grips with. Without this, your reading of any religious text is largely worthless for anything but informing your own, personal beliefs.
Ok, then I see. You know shit about what theology is.
1
Nov 01 '14
Why this fixation about theology, then?
As I said, I brought it up for discussion. Try adding something to the conversation.
2
u/kmdr Nov 02 '14
Sorry, I don't buy this.
I think you are a religious trying to troll.
Only a religious person would say:
Like other intellectual disciplines, theology requires years of dedicated study to get to grips with. Without this, your reading of any religious text is largely worthless for anything but informing your own, personal beliefs.
This is pure bullshit. Religious texts, for a non-believer, aren't just read to "inform your beliefs". They can be read to entertain, to criticise, as an historical text, as a literary text, etc.
The fact that you can't even fathom other uses than "belief-related" ones makes me feel you are lieing when you proclaim yourself a non-believer.
Only a religious person would speak about " intolerance of religion".
I call bullshit
5
u/Xechorizo Oct 31 '14 edited Oct 31 '14
I think you make some very good points. I hold myself foremost as an ignostic, or theological noncognitivist, meaning that without something objective for us to define "god" as, the term itself is meaningless. This is why I laugh at the term "theology". Epistemology meets etymology here. How can an impossible subject have a field of knowledge around it?
Anyhow, I'd have to contest two of the points you contest:
Religion makes good people do bad things
This isn't to say that it takes religion to do evil. However, when a majority of the population is voting and making secular decisions with bullshit supernatural premises, it leads to a stunting of our species in human rights, education, cooperation, and honesty.
Religion is the main source of suffering on earth.
Given the magnitude of the above evils, this is why I'm an antitheist. Belief in god to me is the worst atrocity and greatest shame to ever plague humanity. It promotes scapegoating, war, segregation, and any other petty attribute a believer projects onto their anthropomorphized maniacal monstrosity of a deity.
Clearly I'm biased on the topic, but these two points addressed by your post hadn't dissuaded me of the opinions I hold above.
I only have an author who addressed god scientifically, which as you stated above seems a little backwards. Nonetheless I enjoyed GOD: The Failed Hypothesis by the late Victor Stenger.
3
u/exploderator Nov 01 '14
Hail fellow ignostic, I have a thought concerning religion as the main source of suffering:
I think that is badly over stated. It gives way too much credit to religion. I think of religion as a social phenomenon amongst an advanced species of primate, heavily influenced by a complex mixture of culture and history, but primarily driven by the complex biological social-psychological facts of our species. To say that religion is driving, is to ignore that our underlying animal nature is the original author here. Our species is authoritarian, patriarchal, territorial, aggressive, vindictive, judgmental, punishment obsessed, jealous and greedy, for right or wrong, and religion expresses all those things along with everything other thing we do. We are right to recognize that we are not well served by these tendencies, and do something about them, because they harm us. To the extent that such problematic traits become institutionalized, by religions, governments, corporations, etc., we must strive to reform the institutions, and argue the points, but blaming the institution for the human impulses is often misleading.
I'm not trying to let religion completely off the hook here, in some ways you could almost define religion as a phenomenon of many of our bad impulses institutionalized in groups, and that view has more substance than any of their absurd so-called metaphysical claims. EG, I think the primary reason they care that there's "a creator" is because they then demand we obey Him. There's our authoritarian and patriarchal instincts, topped off with an impulse to eagerly obey perceived authority, all wrapped up and sold as something deep, which it's not. Physics, geology, biology, astronomy... these are genuinely deep, and anyone who doubts it is welcome to explain the math to the rest of us. Religion is selling human instincts back to us, mislabeled and scrambled by historical myths, fantasies, and ignorance of nature. We need to carefully ask what ill impulses we might be prone to, before thinking religion was actually bright enough to synthesize such evil.
3
u/Xechorizo Nov 02 '14
Religion is selling human instincts back to us
Lovely! I absolutely agree and respect your view. It is very much an authoritarian form of terrorism, and it does what we do worst well (best, in my eyes). Thank you for your reply :)
1
u/exploderator Nov 02 '14
It is my pleasure to discuss these matters with the rare person who appreciates them. But I would shy away from the word "terrorism", even though you're right to use it, because it's badly tainted with the most awful politics these days, to the point of becoming incoherent just like "god".
Cheers :)
0
Oct 31 '14
I'll be honest, a lot of that went over my head.
How can an impossible subject have a field of knowledge around it?
This is a good point. I should have worded what I said differently. I don't think knowledge is really relevant, which is what I mean when I say it is incompatible with science: empirical knowledge is kind of useless in its structure. Theology doesn't have to be an exact science, or even a science, for it to be valid. From what I understand, religious texts are more useful as historical documents, as well as being really important for understanding a lot of western literature and philosophy. I think there is a problem when many of the people who actually have a good knowledge of the history of these texts are dismissed as delusional. Their knowledge is just as valid and useful as a historian's or a writer's in terms of understanding the human race, whether they believe in God or not.
3
u/bouchard Nov 01 '14
From what I understand, religious texts are more useful as historical documents,
False, religious texts are useless as historical documents. The vast majority of the people described in the bible never existed, likewise the vast majority of the described events never happened. They do make good cultural documents, however.
I think there is a problem when many of the people who actually have a good knowledge of the history of these texts are dismissed as delusional.
It's not the people who have knowledge of the texts who labeled as delusional: it's the people who think the invisible sky magician described by the book is real who are labeled as delusional (because they're suffering from a delusion).
Their knowledge is just as valid and useful as a historian's or a writer's in terms of understanding the human race, whether they believe in God or not.
Useful to a writer? Maybe; it depends on the writer's topic. Useful to a historian? Absolutely not.
2
u/kmdr Nov 01 '14
Theology is a pseudo-science
This is a big one. I’d argue it’s not true though; theology isn’t pseudo-science or science, it’s theology, and it has its own rules.
Unless you are playing with words, when someone says "Theology is a pseudo-science" I guess he/she means "Theology isn't science", as in "real science"
So, If I understand correctly, your response to me saying "Theology isn't science" would be "It isn't supposed to be"
While a legitimate answer, this can also be said about Yoga, numerology, and things like that.
The "I don't care if it isn't science" is fully legitimate but of course won't earn you great favour/respect/audience in people who DO care about science
0
Nov 01 '14
So, If I understand correctly, your response to me saying "Theology isn't science" would be "It isn't supposed to be"
I would definitely say that. I realise not everyone will agree with that. Theology just isn't useful to science, and, as many here have pointed out, science isn't useful to theology. They both have their relative merits, but they deal in different currencies.
While a legitimate answer, this can also be said about Yoga, numerology, and things like that.
This is also true. While yoga isn't a science, it is still useful in it's own way, and so has merit in that sense. Numerology is less obviously useful, but no-one would seriously consider it in a scientific context these days, so it seems like a harmless oddity.
None of these things will stand up in a scientific context, but at the same time none of them really need to, since they're inherently unscientific.
5
u/ssracer Oct 31 '14
Tl;dr: None of you are experts in the field of voodoo so stop calling us idiots until you are.
3
u/funkengruven88 Oct 31 '14
Thank you. There's walls of text everywhere debating huge ideas and arguments but this is all OP is really saying.
1
Nov 01 '14
I wasn't saying anything, I made it pretty clear that I was just putting this up for discussion. I phrased it the way I did in the hope that it would start some interesting conversation, rather than knee-jerk snark.
5
u/RaggedClaws Nov 01 '14
Religion makes good people do bad things
That's like summarizing Occam's Razor as "the simplest answer is the correct one". The sentiment, as captured by the Steven Weinberg quotation, is "With or without (religion) you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion.
Religion is the main source of suffering on earth.
Religion is not the source; it is the catalyst. It is the warrant for violence and inhumanity. Also, it is very often the incitement.
4
u/sleepyj910 Oct 31 '14 edited Oct 31 '14
For me anti-theism represents the idea that religious thought, and all forms of delusional behavior wherein evidence is not valued, create a system where we base on moral judgement on faith, and not evidence.
The idea that you could have some or any knowledge from faith is very dangerous. The idea that you have an opinion that you think came from the Creator of All Things is very dangerous.
The enemy of morality is delusion, and religion represents the greatest force of delusion, because it promotes the ignorance as part of it's own survival methods. Overall, when we teach others that what you want to be true is more important than what is true, people are more likely to suffer.
Bigotry is right out, I'm attacking an idea, not a person or people. I don't want to hurt theists. I don't oppose the practice of religion, I oppose the idea of religion. The same way I don't oppose the practice of rooting for the Yankees, but I oppose the idea of rooting for the Yankees.
It's true that religion isn't the only factor in delusion, but it's the most systematic. Nationalistic dogma is equally delusional, but at least Hitler and Stalin never claimed to be Gods that were by definition perfect.
On the other hand, look at the Scientologists sad worship of every thing L. Ron Hubbard ever said as they try to live their lives based on the idea that he was perfection. The danger of the superstition is that is allows us to accept ideas without second thought. Hubbard says all psychiatrists are evil? Then it must be true for now and always.
So for me the thought is this...humanity has better options than religion, and my belief is that as we let go of religion and all superstitions, we will be better prepared to make moral decisions based on what's in front of us, and not what some ancient book or dead person said.
Any system that derives values from static infallibility is immoral, because are morals need to change as the world changes. Many believers do ignore the tenants of their religion, but they still give the book to their children, who are more susceptible to falling backwards into tribal morality than if they had been raised to be skeptical of anything that claimed to have 'the answer'
1
u/PositivelyClueless Nov 01 '14
I see it as:
Atheist: Does not believe in any gods.
Antitheist: An atheist who believes that the belief in gods is generally harmful to the human race.
Example one (four questions) is probably sarcasm, using not - as you say - "theological ideas" but rather common youtube titles by religious drones.
Second example (theology as a science). It's strange of you to remove theology from the challenge "is it a science?", as the problem is that theology presents itself as scientific and rational.
Third example (religion makes good people do bad stuff), that is a misleadingly abbreviated quote.
4 Religion is the main source of suffering on earth
Probably wrong, although much suffering today has its roots in almost forgotten religious motivation. But all that is needed for antitheism is the belief that the world would be better off without the belief in gods - it doesn't have to be the main source for sufering.
5 Religion is (not) in decline
Would like to see a citation on your statement
6 Atheism implies intelligence/intelligence implies atheism
I'm sure there are douchebag atheist who think that. But I thought you are arguing against antitheism?
This is so ridiculous it doesn’t need refuting.
Eh. That's not how a logical argument works. You could say: "Being irrational and delusional about one thing (aka believing in a god) does not automatically mean that the person is stupid and exhibiting those logical flaws applies when other subjects are at hand." There. Refuted. The atheist would then quote one of the studies showing that atheism generally scales with education, but that's not strictly the same as intelligence.
1
Nov 01 '14
Thanks!
that is a misleadingly abbreviated quote.
I wasn't referring to that quote, just an example of something I'd heard.
It's strange of you to remove theology from the challenge "is it a science?", as the problem is that theology presents itself as scientific and rational.
This may be true in some cases, but none that I've heard of. If theology did present itself as a science, then I'd completely agree that it's nonsense. I see it as being closer to literature or philosophy.
But all that is needed for anti theism is the belief that the world would be better off without the belief in gods - it doesn't have to be the main source for sufering.
That makes sense.
Would like to see a citation on your statement
Don't have access to this at the moment, but it was from a talk by Miroslav Volf. It showed that Christianity and Islam, among others, are actually on the increase again.
1
u/im_not_afraid Nov 01 '14
Religion makes good people do bad things
This is a popular statement, though there seems to be little evidence that it’s true. I honestly doubt any credible psychologist would agree, but it’s a convenient one liner. Tests such as the Milgram and Stanford Prison experiments told a very different story; basically good people will do bad things for any number of reasons, regardless of religion.
You don't understand, the point isn't that religion is the only reason why people do bad things. It's ironic that something people think is a source for morality can also be a source of evil.
You want evidence? Watch the news and watch what people do while motivated by religion. There is a reason why terrorism is defined based on whether or not the person is motivated by ideology. Religion is a type of ideology. You sound like a evolution-denying creationist.
0
Nov 01 '14
You sound like a evolution-denying creationist.
I'm agnostic, if you must know. Feel free to leave your pitchfork at the door and actually take part in the conversation though.
3
u/bouchard Nov 01 '14
I love when theists say the kind bullshit that only theists say and then try to make it look like they're "thinking from a point of balance" by insisting that they're atheists.
1
u/im_not_afraid Nov 01 '14
I said you sound like.
Being agnostic doesn't save one from making poor arguments.
4
u/mDust Oct 31 '14
Ok, here is an example of the kind of thinking I am referring to - it’s a thread from this sub.
It's a mixed community, like any other.
Basically, the less sophisticated arguments against religion often involve quoting scripture. This seems like a logical thing to do, but it ignores the fact that theology (as opposed to religion in general) is not comprehensible to the layman.
I'm not sure if you're implying that sophisticated arguments are somehow "better" or more correct than less sophisticated arguments, but this is false if so. Highly complex arguments can and have been defeated by very simple arguments. Reading a religious text doesn't require any higher education. Theology deals with context and history more so than answering "what was the writer trying to convey and why?" That's an impossible question to answer with certainty using armchair-reasoning.
and [theology] is a discipline in the same sense that any of the sciences are.
Be careful with your wording here. It's a discipline, yes, but like various other social studies, not like biology or physics. It's as soft as soft-science can get. Theology has been around for nearly as long as organized religion. [wiki link] It historically was the equivalent of modern college. I'm of the opinion that brilliant thinkers flocked to these institutions and, realizing it was a waste of time, left to invent philosophy and critical thinking ~2,500 years ago. Please thank them if you haven't done so already.
the post above seems to imply that the existence of evil precludes the existence of God, and an inability to answer the question implies a lack of intelligence or insight.
It's not meant to directly challenge the intelligence/insight of the religious party. Barring cognitive dissonance, there is NO logical answer one could give to satisfy the question without conflicting with the Christian definition of god. It's a cliched trap.
Without this, your reading of any religious text is largely worthless for anything but informing your own, personal beliefs.
You really believe there is deeper meaning in that text, don't you? Learning about the context and history at the time the passages were written is fun and all, but it doesn't largely change the meaning of said passages. If you disagree, then please provide some examples where the meaning is substantially changed by hidden context.
Dawkins is especially good at making broad statements in areas that he’s not really qualified in.
Please list some examples.
There will always be idiots, and sadly these idiots are lumped in with everyone else
who believes in God.
FTFY
I could do the whole “Stalin/Pol Pot/Mao/Sri Lanka” thing but Christ, everyone has heard that. The majority of genocides in the last century were committed by secular forces, often against religious groups, and secular-on-religious violence is far more common than either inter-religious violence or religious-on-secular violence. I am not discounting the suffering caused to many by religion, but statistically it really is just a drop in the bucket these days.
You definitely need to cite some sources here.
Committed by secular forces or committed for secular reasons? There is a big difference here. Any reason other than religious could be considered a secular attack, which is completely unfair. A group of people killing another group of people because they wanted the land doesn't mean that's a point on the board for secular violence. It has to be a secular group attacking a group for religious reasons to keep it relevant to the discussion.
Religion is in decline
Seems plausible, but it’s bullshit. Religion is growing, in both relative and concrete terms.
Source?
A lot of people seem to think that their atheism implies that they’re more logical, stable and humane than religious people.
A lot of people are dumb. A lot of people associate themselves with a group for the wrong reasons. This isn't the group's fault. I would argue that people who are logical, stable and humane tend to shrug off religion, but being an atheist doesn't make someone any of those things. A square is a rectangle, but a rectangle is not a square.
This is so ridiculous it doesn’t need refuting.
That can be said of religion and theology too.
I have often heard these statements used to justify someone’s intolerance of religion. Since most of them don’t hold much water, this leaves me wondering about the role of antitheism.
There are as many reasons to justify the intolerance of religion as there are antitheists. You've picked all the low-hanging fruit you could find. I personally find it repugnant because its wool pulled over the eyes of the religious, usually at birth, without their consent. It's used to cow people into a specific mindset, to control them. It teaches ridiculous lies to comfort its followers, making alternatives sound dangerous or unappealing. It's a tax-free big business. It has the potential to spawn extremist-believers. I'm not convinced cults and religions are different in any way other than popularity...drink the blood and eat the flesh of your prophet in your basement and you're a nut, do the same in a Catholic church and you're an upstanding citizen on your way to an everlasting afterlife of bliss. And finally, there is nothing a religious group can do that a secular group cannot. Religion may have been useful in our lawless, nomadic history, but it has no use in modern society. I have no ill-will toward most religious people, as it isn't their fault they are religious; generally they weren't asked if they wanted to be a part of their religion. I won't just accept the indoctrination of innocent people as tolerable practice. If the person wants to continue with their belief system, then fine. I see them as a lost cause, but not as a terrible person who is beneath me.
Also, antitheism isn't an organized movement. We don't hold recurring meetings and force our beliefs on others with threats of damnation or unfavorable reincarnation. We don't offer everlasting rewards to trick the simple-minded into our way of thinking. It's an alternative belief system based around critical thinking and skepticism. That's it.
I would love to get some recommendations of authors and thinkers who have actually engaged with theology in earnest, rather than dismissing it outright.
There probably aren't too many. You might as well ask for a science or philosophy author that takes any other superstition seriously enough to write about it.
4
2
u/Armandeus Nov 01 '14 edited Nov 01 '14
I think a key part of antitheism is rejecting the very value of theology.
You yourself said the problem of evil is not relevant for atheists. "In fact, the question itself presupposes the existence of God, so it doesn’t even make any sense in an atheist context." But how could theology be useful to us when it also presupposes such things?
The problem of evil is "used as a weapon" because it is a case of finding errors in religious logic by seeing where their premises actually lead. But if we do not play that game, and instead simply say, "get back to me when you have empirical evidence for your god-beliefs" then we can also throw out the theological baby with the bathwater.
But if we study theology in the depth you are recommending before arguing with religionists, aren't we playing the game that you said "doesn't even make sense in an atheist context?"
Then again, how can we not "dismiss it outright" if we are opposed to religion and do not believe in any religious claims?
I think we don't need theology because it is nonsense invented to make nonsense seem less nonsensical.
The only time theology is ever relevant is when seen as literature: what motivated someone, or what is the background for a mythological story. Then it is interesting as other fiction is. It might serve as background for understanding what some philosophers claim, but not in as far as accepting any theological premises at all.
Otherwise it is 100% meaningless drivel as a "social science" -- apologetics and mind-gymnastics to force broken idea systems to make sense somehow. That is the only reason it becomes complex.
2
u/bouchard Nov 01 '14
It's not bigotry to point out that an idea isn't only false but is also dangerous and harmful to society.
1
u/Riktenkay Oct 31 '14
I believe the agreed definition is that it means being opposed to religion, as such I consider myself one. But just from looking at the word, you'd think it just meant someone that dislikes gods.
1
u/ScottBerry2 Nov 06 '14
Religion makes good people do bad things
My aunt is an excellent person generally, but discriminates against gay people.
basically good people will do bad things for any number of reasons, regardless of religion.
Ummm...yes. And?
If someone says "People who kill other people are thrown in prison," it's reasonable to point out that they are thrown in prison for other reasons. It's not reasonable to imply that there aren't people who are thrown in prison for killing others.
9
Oct 31 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/exploderator Nov 01 '14
Skepticism isn't much compatible with authority, which is what religion is mostly peddling, and blind obedience to which is what pushed people past their own better judgment and compassion in all those cases. You also don't question your own beliefs when your are explicitly told not to, because the doubt is dangerous and sinful, and obey that awful command.
25
u/SpockStoleMyPants Oct 31 '14 edited Oct 31 '14
As a historian I can't begin to say how wrong this line of thinking is. There is a continued regurgitation of outdated anti-communist propaganda in western nations regarding the effects of so-called "communist" perpetrated genocides. Whenever the holocaust or Hitler are mentioned in a thread there is always the inevitable post of "well Stalin was way worse than." It's just garbage. The Nazis, who were highly motivated by Christian theology and who many historians such as Kershaw, Stein and Spotts consider was a religion unto itself, remain by far the most effective perpetrators of genocide in the 20th century. Labelling tragic famines that took place due to poor bureaucracy is nowhere in the same league as the calculated, intentional extermination of religious/ethnic minorities. Western nations have propagandized this definition for their own benefit, and were forced to significantly rework their analysis following the fall of the Soviet system in 1990 when better first hand information was released that dramatically shrunk the previous statistical estimates. Yet, somehow, those outdated books are still taught. A particular favourite of fervent anti-communists is to regurgitate the highly biased work of Robert Conquest which has been discredited by many moderate historians. (See EDIT #3 for more details)
The Rwandan genocide, which was highly religiously motivated, was also an intentional extermination. Argument can be made that the 2,000,000 vietnamese deaths during the Vietnam war at the hands of the predominantly Christian american military was entwined with religiosity. A great deal of anti-red American propaganda was centred around the theistic debate of fighting against the godless communist threat. Hell, "in God we trust" was plastered on the currency by Eisenhower in an attempt to draw a religious line in the sand between the U.S. And USSR.
All too often the term genocide is bandied about to raise the reaction of tragic failed policies that had no direct intention to eliminate ethnic/religious groups. If we go back even further to the 15-19th centuries and look at the mass genocides committed by the Spanish, British, and Americans against the indigenous peoples of North and South America, it's hard to argue that religion didn't play a large part in the "extermination of savagery." (Even my home nation of Canada, which has been so well regarded internationally, has genocide on its hands with regards to the treatment of indigenous peoples in religious state run residential schools. It is becoming more appropriately labelled a calculated and intentional cultural genocide. And, unlike the U.S. And even Mexico, we have no separation of church and state - hell, our head of state is he head of the Anglican Church as well. [EDIT This is a moot point, however as ironically there are statistically higher levels of religiosity in Mexico and the US then there is in Canada - as of the most recent census', the non-religious in Canada was at 23.9%, the U.S. at 19.6% and Mexico, who historically had the strictest laws on separation of church and state, is only at 2.49% - This number is debatable as many atheists are counted as Catholics for some inexplicable reason in Mexican surveys])
All in all I think it's far more important to look outside the example of the 20th century, which is shaky in itself, to the vast swaths of history where religion played a dominant role in society to see examples of far more devastating and calculated genocides perpetrated in the name of religion.
With regards to general violence, why is the overwhelming majority of the United States prison population theistic?
It's true that atheists can commit atrocities, by all means, and there is a lot of validity in the argument similar to the one used by 2nd amendment advocates in the U.S.: "guns don't kill people, people kill people." However, historical statistics still side with the religious as the dominant perpetrators of large scale intentional atrocities. Religion is a weapon which makes it easier and more justifiable for its followers to commit heinous acts. TripperDay's comment sums up this idea up more eloquently than mine as does this blog post by Sam Harris.
EDIT: I wanted to add 2 more historical points. Firstly, remember that the Cambodian Genocide was ended by "godless communist" Vietnamese intervention, not by predominantly religious Christian Nations. The U.S. did little more than issue a verbal denouncement in 1978. Furthermore, when the Soviets were present in Afghanistan, education and equal rights for women flourished. It was the U.S. that funded the conservatively religious Mujahideen which gave way to the Taliban, all with the underlying guise of supporting religious freedom from godless atheists. Secondly, although communism as a pure ideology derived from Marx and even Lenin advocates atheism, that was far from reality in the majority functional communist nations (which were communist in name only.) Religion, although officially banned in Russia, still thrived as long as it kept its head down and was quiet about it. You can liken it to how marijuana is illegal in most places, yet that doesn't stop people from having a puff or ten. How else do you think that the Russian Orthodox Church made such a tremendous resurgence after 1990, especially under the devoutly Christian Putin? It never went away. Same in Cuba, which is still predominantly Catholic.
EDIT #2 A fantastic book on the subject of how religion has historically influenced American foreign policy and domestic politics is "Sword of the Spirit, Shield of Faith" by Andrew Preston
EDIT #3 Ok, I promise this is the last edit! When people incite the term genocide in reference to the USSR, they are most often referring to what has been dubbed the "Holomodor" in 1930's Ukraine. I'll begin by stating that there has never been accurate numbers of those who perished due to either famine allegedly caused by or direct incursion by the Soviet authorities. The numbers vary from 1.8 to 12 million. That's a pretty big difference! The reason for this edit, is that I was trying to find my source for the following, but couldn't find it...
I read an article once that described the effect the Orthodox church had in the Soviet Union and its satellite states from 1917 to 1945. Western Propaganda has really twisted the narrative into how the "USSR persecuted the church" in that they formed a cohesive coalition of resistance towards the Bolshevik Revolution and the implementation of Agrarian Collectivization. What this is leaving out is which perspective is right, and obviously, depending on the reader's political inclinations this is debatable. Those who are die hard capitalists agree with the aforementioned Western propaganda, but Marxist historians see this narrative as missing some important points.
The Orthodox church had an immense influence on rural peasant farmers during the Tsarist Era and the Church was one of the most effective tools of oppression employed by the Tsar. When the Communists came in and demanded that farmers collectivize, the Church gave orders to resist - even to the point of sabotaging crop yields. Many peasants were so devout to the church that if their priest told them not to seed or cultivate (or whatever) on a certain day, they would not - even if it meant destroying a crop. Farmers were extremely superstitious. In this respect, the argument can be made from an anti-theist/ Marxist perspective that the Church leaders were manipulating farmers into rebellion against the Communists for their own selfish reasons. If their farmers collectivized, they would lose their power over them. This rebellion, incited for selfish reasons by the Orthodox elite, bolstered by superstition was a key player in the tragic famines that took so many lives. The west says it was the failed policies of collectivization that caused the famines, Some Marxist historians argue that, along with the failed bureaucracy and implementation of collectivization by the Soviets, it was also the resistance ordered by the church that never gave collectivization a chance to succeed - so how could it be ultimately solely responsible?
To put it very crudely, those who believe the resistance against Communism that occurred because they were fighting for "freedom" are absolutely correct - but it was not the freedom that they believed. It was the freedom of individuals to exploit the masses. This is the continued perversion of the term "freedom" which people continue to fight for in Capitalist countries. For the Trekkies out there, it's the debate between "the needs of the many outweighs the needs of the few or the one" (Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan), or "the needs of the one outweighs the needs of the many" (Star Trek 3: The Search for Spock).