r/Antipsychiatry • • Feb 17 '21

Most "mental illnesses" are actually just trauma responses

1.7k Upvotes

I work in a mental health facility as a tech and I see it all the time. Patients diagnosed with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder or borderline personality disorder and medicated, but when I look in their charts I see most of them have a history of abuse, and it's not being addressed anywhere in their treatment.

Complex PTSD can manifest itself in many ways and can look like psychosis or mania. Also it has all the same symptoms as BPD, almost all patients with BPD have a trauma history.

Also trauma can be many things, the interpersonal trauma that causes ptsd symptoms don't have to be extreme. Especially as a child. If you felt like your parents weren't there for you because they were too busy, that's emotional neglect and it's super common and can have lasting effects on a developing brain.

I just feel like instead of assuming it's a chemical imbalance and going straight to medication, trauma should be addressed. I see people who spend their entire lives in and out of hospitals and it makes me sad.


r/Antipsychiatry • • Jul 31 '22

Therapy is becoming a replacement for friendship and community.

1.7k Upvotes

Our society is so individualistic and isolated that people are struggling to connect with each other. There's no community spaces left, and so a lot of people rely on the internet to form relationships. We are really lonely, and it seems like with each generation this loneliness gets worse. As great as online friendships are, you need to have an irl support system, and a lot of people just don't have that.

I keep seeing screenshots of tweets where people describe what their therapist tells them. The advice these therapists give aren't particularly mindblowing. They don't have some cosmic answer to all your problems. The same advice could have been give by your boy Kyle behind a 7/11 at 3 in the morning.

Venting to your friends has become somewhat of a social taboo. We don't want to trigger anyone-- fair. But it's preventing us from actually alleviating the loneliness. Instead, people tell you to go get a therapist and spend upwards of a hundred dollars a session just to be able to talk to someone.

I do think therapy could be beneficial to some people, but it's being overly recommended as a band-aid solution to the rampant loneliness and and isolation people feel.


r/Antipsychiatry • • Dec 06 '20

Kaczynski on antidepressants

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • May 05 '21

Your son has ADHD bro...

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Nov 22 '20

Truth

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Apr 05 '21

lol

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Feb 15 '21

A more accurate version of the meme.

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Jun 27 '20

Expand the mental health system?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Mar 06 '21

Self-care is bs.

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Aug 08 '21

Psychiatry has absolutely dehumanized language

1.0k Upvotes

Everywhere I look, human emotion and nature is reduced to psychiatric labels.

Here is a recent experience, although this happens everywhere, and I do it myself.

“I don’t drink coffee, except in the winter as it is a mild antidepressant for my seasonal affective disorder (seasonal depression).”

WhT would this sentence have sounded like 20 years ago? Maybe “I don’t drink coffee, but I’ve found that it helps bring some happiness into cold winter days.” And I imagine just reframing it like that they would possible reflect more on the seasons and add a sentence or two.

Psychiatric diagnoses make language sterile and cold and short.

Instead of “I’ve always felt different, I seem to operate at a different wave than most of society” or any mix on that sentiment, almost every comment I see now is “I don’t fit it because I am probably autistic (not diagnosed yet).”

Even undiagnosed people feel the need to explain human emotion through a psychiatric lense!

When you ARE diagnosed, it’s taken to extremes.

Yesterday, I felt extremely peaceful. And I was thinking how lucky I am to be right here. It was colder outside and I was gardening, I had just found a frog den and was watering my garden.

I stopped and realized “this is the first time I’ve allowed myself to feel good without pathologizing it.”

When I was diagnosed BPII—events above were not allowed. Extreme feelings of peace and contentment, I was trained, are warning signs of hypomania. I could not have even the most basic human experience without labeling it under a medical lens.

And now I am seeing this is extending beyond even diagnosis. Or used as an excuse when someone feels guilty they did something. “I only drink coffee because of SAD.” It’s creating a population that cannot experience the full breadth of human emotion, and when they do, it’s contained in a sterile label that reduces us to dependence and subservience.


r/Antipsychiatry • • May 28 '20

Relatable?

Post image
981 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Jan 08 '21

Stockholm Syndrome was invented by a psychiatrist to discredit a woman who criticized him after he almost got her killed

931 Upvotes

23-year-old Kristin Enmark was taken hostage in a Stockholm bank in 1973 by Jan Olsson. Jan demanded that his friend Clark be brought to him and so he was. The art and science of hostage negotiation didn't exist back them, so the authorities treated the criminals with hostility and aggression - what modern hostage negotiators would call "escalating" and is known today to be a terrible idea. Kristin was way ahead of her time and handled the situation by talking to them peacefully and establishing a rapport.

She managed to negotiate several concessions from Jan - to let one hostage out of an enclosed space because she was claustrophobic, to let them call their friends and families. Meanwhile, the police parked themselves with guns pointed at the group, so that the hostages themselves would likely be shot if the police had fired their guns.

The psychiatrist Nils Bejerot was in charge, and he entered the building to make aggressive demands, which only made Jan more agitated. Clark told the hostages that no matter what happens, he will not let anybody hurt them. Kristin says it was difficult to know what to believe, but as the police were being reckless with her life and Jan was out of control, this was the one person who showed any concern for her safety.

Jan agreed to let her make a call to the prime minister himself. She explained that she had negotiated with Jan, and that he was willing to let the hostages go peacefully if Jan and Clark were permitted to leave.

You can hear the recording of this phone call online and if you understand Swedish, it's incredible. The prime minister is the one who sounds like an irrational, cornered animal - panicking and lashing out. While this 23-year-old is the one calmly explaining that she has the situation under control and knows the solution. The prime minister refused to give the kidnappers any concessions and told her:

You are going to have to be content to die at your post.

The police ended up gassing the building, an extremely reckless escalation, but luckily it worked. As Kristin says, it's a miracle it didn't get them killed. The police beat Clark up and then paraded Jan and Clark down the street to roaring applause, showing off their victory. This made Kristin furious as they had so recklessly endangered her life and Clark was the only person who had shown concern for her safety.

Kristin gave interviews after the incident where she was highly critical of Nils the psychiatrist and the terrible way he handled the situation. Nils, who had never even spoken personally to Kristin, claimed that her criticism was because she was "in love" with her kidnappers and invented the Stockholm Syndrome diagnosis to explain it.

Kristin did go to a therapist after the experience, and the therapist began their very first session by asking if she had sex with the kidnapper (she did not). She left in anger.


r/Antipsychiatry • • Jul 04 '20

trust no therapist

Thumbnail
imgur.com
891 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Dec 02 '20

like God intended

Post image
885 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Apr 23 '22

Working in admin at a community mental health center, I can say confidently: y'all are right

882 Upvotes

I was on the other side as a "crazy" person, learned to hide it. Now I'm in admin for a place that, in theory, provides mental healthcare, physical healthcare, employment support, housing support, etc. This is what I learned:

  • they can and do lie

  • Therapists do not want non billable interactions with clients.

  • sometimes crisis workers don't consider someone to be in crisis (even if that person is asking for crisis support..) and will make them wait a while hoping they'll eventually leave

  • ^ if you are an "annoying" client (aka someone who dares using their therapist as actual support), therapists will tell me to delay finding space for them. Or they will call out sick the day that person is supposed to come in, over and over again, until that person gives up and asks for a new counselor

  • The staff is friendly with the police. There's no hesitation to call 911 despite the fact that we're literally in a building full of mental health professionals who should be able to talk people down

  • Staff members have literally refused to help people with paperwork because a client smelled strongly of urine. Paperwork that would allow him to access showers and laundry..

  • I hear gossiping a lot. Your stories of pain and paranoia are turned into funny anecdotes. They say that this is blowing off steam in a difficult profession but the lack of compassion is astounding. You only get compassion if you're a "good" client

  • if you have ever freaked out, screamed, had a bad day, there's almost always a big red message stuck on your chart flagging you as a danger and that I in reception should be wary about letting you in. usually something dumb like "hx of unprovoked violence" but they don't include that the violence was directed at a lamp, not a person.

  • if you admit to ANY drug/alcohol use, you are not trying hard enough to 'get better'

There's more but I got really depressed writing this list. I guess my point is these people are not always on your side and it's ok to fight them to get your needs met. Also, please don't scream at the receptionists, we have very little power here :(

edit: thank you to everyone who got vulnerable and shared their feelings, it means a lot. And I appreciate everyone who made me really confront being enmeshed in this system. It is hypocritical to help run the day to day ops of a place fueled by misery and then be critical of it without acknowledging my own role in its functioning


r/Antipsychiatry • • Jun 15 '21

Right?!

Post image
844 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Mar 16 '22

have you realized that the response to profound conversation is usually "have you considered therapy?"

830 Upvotes

if we try and talk to people, have profound conversations about life, death, loss. If we share dark thoughts, if we dare to speak more than the usual "career, school, job, money" then the conversation is suddenly too serious for unprofessional humans to speak to each other and they say "therapy would help" ; but I DONT WANT HELP, I just want to discuss life!!!!! to talk shit?? to consider the after life and the end of society as we know it. to maybe idk be realistic about the situation and stop pretending for a second

but its always like. "Oh, that's a very dark sentiment. Have you considered therapy?"

its like we need to stop having these thoughts. but WHY? because these kinds of thoughts are dangerous, they are what would bring a revolution

anyway I'm tired

HaVe yOu cONSidErEd TheRaPy ToDaY??? be careful if you have any bad thoughts!!! take your medication and smile!! if you think society is bad is because your brain is chemically imbalanced :):):):):) lots of love


r/Antipsychiatry • • Jan 11 '22

Bad ending

Post image
829 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Jun 20 '22

Why do mental health professionals act like our depression and anxiety have no rational basis?

789 Upvotes

If I live with abusive family members, work in a stressful minimum wage job where people treat me like shit, and my only alternative is to become homeless and get beaten, robbed and raped in the streets, I think it's a very rational reason for my depression and anxiety, and the way to cure it is to put me in safe environment. Mental health professionals act like I'm already in a safe environment and I have nothing to worry about. Hence, they prescribe medication which doesn't really relieve my stress because it's my life that sucks, not my brain.


r/Antipsychiatry • • Jul 02 '20

bloop

Post image
777 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Apr 26 '21

"Remember: These are the only two options and you should never question authority."

Post image
755 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Feb 16 '21

Everything is made up

Post image
750 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Oct 17 '20

Haha, the inherently abusive power dynamic of psychiatry is so funny and relatable!

Post image
742 Upvotes

r/Antipsychiatry • • Dec 17 '22

Stop fucking telling people to go to the fucking psych ward. Quit it.

735 Upvotes

The psych ward; Does. Not. Fucking. Help. I don’t give a solid fuck if it “SAveD YOuR LiFE” or “It was such a pleasant experience I got help :D” like shut the fuck up. I’m tired of people making posts asking if they should commit themselves and the people in the comments are always like “ABSOLUTELY! My experience was great, so yours will be too!” Like no.

Psych wards are such a gamble, and the honest truth is, if they don’t traumatize and hurt you, it’ll just waste your time and bore you.

How the ever loving fuck is having these psychopaths lock you up against your will and forcibly drug you supposed to help? Like okay, it’ll physically prevent you from committing suicide. For a week. Then you get discharged. What then? What fucking then? Stop giving poor innocent people high expectations and hopes that they‘ll get better once they go. No. You won’t get better. Fuck psych wards. I hate them so much they’ve traumatized me and ruined my fucking life.

Legit I bet those people who say the psych ward helped them probably never got sedated or restrained. Once you get sedated and restrained and pin down and thrown on the floor you’ll view the whole operation in a whole different light. You’ll see the truth;

Psych wards aren’t MEANT to help you, or keep you safe. They’re meant to keep you from “bothering” society. They’re for exhausted parents who can’t deal with what THEY caused, they can’t deal with how traumatized their kid is after they abused them. Shipping the kids off is just so they can have a vacation. And fuck that noise.

How the fuck pro psychiatry people don’t see it? No. Fucking. Clue. I hate psych wards. I hate it all. It’s sick to harm hurt people even futher, under the guise of protecting them.

It’s the most sinister phrase; “It’s for, your own, protection.”


r/Antipsychiatry • • Oct 20 '21

Suicidal people need more from society than a link to a hotline.

Post image
729 Upvotes