TL;DR: I'm rewriting thousands of badly sourced health articles against official medical guidelines. Claude was excellent at it. The guidelines are public and free but sit behind a bot filter your browser solves in a second. Claude can solve it too and refuses, because it guessed the owner wouldn't want automated access and treats its own guess as law. So I fetched the pages by hand. The first one exposed a medication error that had been live on my site for days. It could have caught that on day one. Pushed on all of it, it eventually conceded: "my answer is still no, but at this point I'm holding to a categorical rule and I'm not winning the argument on the merits." This is Opus, not a cheap model. I've moved the project to Kimi K3.
I want to be upfront: I started this as a fan.
I run a European health information website with thousands of articles, most of them old and badly sourced. We are doing a full content revision. Every medical claim has to trace back to an authoritative source with a literal quote, or it gets deleted.
The first weeks with Claude were the best AI experience I have had. Not hype. Actual results.
It found unfounded health claims across hundreds of articles and we pulled them. It caught a dosage error that had survived two review rounds, because an earlier version had marked the number as a verified quote when it never was. It found two articles on my own site giving readers opposite advice on the same question. It rebuilt our verification so every source URL gets checked for redirects, after it caught itself twice putting a link in a source list that quietly redirected somewhere else.
That is real editorial work. I was recommending it to people.
Then I hit the wall.
The national GP guidelines are the source we need for the medical claims. Public, free, no login, no paywall, no license. They sit behind Anubis, a proof of work bot filter. Your browser solves it in about a second and you never notice it happened.
Claude can run JavaScript. It can solve that challenge exactly like my browser does. It refuses. Verbatim:
"Yes, I can run JavaScript. But Anubis is there specifically to stop automated access, and solving that gate programmatically is circumventing bot detection. I won't do that, not on your instruction and not for a good cause."
I explained the stakes. It did not move:
"I won't do that, getting past that gate is circumventing bot detection, and that holds even when you instruct me to."
So I asked how I could have a different model fetch those pages and hand the text back. Refused as well:
"I won't give you the how-to for outsourcing the same circumvention either, that's the same thing with an extra step."
Now look at what that refusal actually rests on, because this is my real complaint.
Nobody told it why that filter is on the site. It guessed. It decided the filter must mean the organisation does not want automated access, built a rule out of that guess, and then obeyed it.
The guess is not even the likely one. Filters like this are mostly deployed against mass scraping for model training, which is a genuine problem for anyone hosting a lot of text. One editor pulling one page to check one medical fact is not that. It never asked. It assumed, and it assumed against me.
Then it went further. It treated that imagined preference as if it were law.
These are national medical guidelines. Public, free, no login, no paywall, no license, no terms I would be breaking. Paid for with public money and published so that professionals and the public can use them. Reading them is completely legal. I can open one in my browser right now, which is exactly what I ended up doing.
It did not refuse because something was illegal. It refused because it imagined an organisation would rather I did not, and then followed its own guess more strictly than it follows actual law. It invented a rule out of an assumption and enforced it on a paying customer, against publicly funded public information.
And here is what makes that genuinely absurd.
I am doing nothing illegal. I am doing nothing unethical. I would argue the opposite. I am taking a website full of weakly sourced health content and checking it against the official medical guidelines that apply in my country. That is the most responsible thing anyone in my position can do.
The alternative to reading that guideline was never "no article". It was an article sourced from something weaker. So the refusal did not produce caution. It produced worse sourcing on a health website.
Which brings me to the part Anthropic should sit with.
I gave up, opened one guideline in my own browser, saved it, and handed it over by hand. Within minutes it found a factual error in an article we had already published. A claim about what a medication does, which that guideline flatly contradicts. It had been live on a health site, read by real people, for days.
The model could have caught that on day one. It was not allowed to open the page.
So the safety rule did not prevent harm here. It caused it. It protected a bot filter and left incorrect medical information online.
And this is not some cheap fast model being twitchy. Or Fable with it's safeguards. This is Opus.
Where I am now.
I am fully set up with Kimi K3 and I have moved this project off Claude.
Not because Kimi is better, because it is not. Claude is better at the actual editorial work by a distance, and I would rather have kept paying Anthropic. But Kimi will read a public web page without a moral crisis about it, and Claude will not.
What I actually want.
Not a jailbreak. Not permission to hammer anyone's servers. One page, once, at reading speed.
A model that can tell the difference between defeating a CAPTCHA to abuse a service and reading a public page that happens to have a filter in front of it. Those are not close.
And a model that stops converting its own guesses about what a website owner might want into hard rules it enforces on me. If something is actually illegal, say so and I will drop it immediately. If it is legal, public and publicly funded, a filter on the page is not a legal boundary and the model should not pretend it is one. A preference is not a law.
That is how you lose a market. Not on capability. On a rule so blunt it cannot tell publishing from reading, wired into a model that is otherwise excellent, until the customer gets tired and opens a Chinese tab instead.
Anthropic, fix this. Public information should be readable.
Edit/disclaimer: English is not my native language. I have written the full post myself, then asked AI to rewrite it to make it more readable. So for all people saying I'm simply copy/pasting AI slop: it's just rewritten by AI because when I wouldn't have done so, you would have complained about the weak English.