Hello there,
Following the most recent developments, this is my attempt at structuring my own thoughts and share my concerns. Maybe it helps other community members to understand why many of us are upset. Maybe even AnkiHub can benefit from hearing why so many are disappointed in how things have been handled the past few days, instead of only hearing that they are disappointed.
First of all, I know that there are many opposing opinions floating around, so I'd appreciate if you read and try to understand my arguments before dismissing my overall stance on the matter. This particularly applies to those individuals who seem to try to discredit people like me by calling us "haters", "insane", "tinfoil hats", "paranoid freak" (all original quotes btw) or whatever else they come up with instead of actually taking part in a civilized discussion. I guess some of these users will probably not even read this far and have already called me names by now, but so be it.
In my opinion, what we're about to experience sooner or later is the following: Initially, small inconvenient changes get implemented. Some of them might even get temporarily reverted to pretend good will (such as attempting to take control over this sub) and to test the community's will for resistance. At first, these incremental changes might not be annoying enough by themselves to make a significant amount of users stop using Anki. At some point later, however, more and more features will get paywalled to justify past investments and cover current costs. Anki will change from a community-centered project to a consumer product and will be a shadow of its former self. This isn't a question of whether that's ever going to happen, but rather of how soon. Just to be clear, this isn't inherently "good" or "bad/evil" by itself, it's just how profit-oriented companies have to operate to keep their business running. Enterprises have to be profitable to survive and consequently cannot work like a donation-based non-profit project. I understand that some people wish AnkiHub would work more like a non-profit, but projecting this hope onto the actual profit-oriented company is just denying reality.
Why am I still so critical (some will certainly call it "pessimistic")? My argument stands on: 1. how I interpret AnkiHub's recent activities, and 2. my impressions of the current AnkiHub website. I'll first summarize AnkiHub's recent actions:
AnkiHub claimed to not have plans for any changes, yet they already tried to take control over this independent community-run sub. Additionally, they tried to portray their reversal on the matter as a wise decision on their part, when it was rather just a desperate way to minimize the potential damage to their reputation and the trust among the community.
The phrasing of AnkiHub's message to the mod team wasn't a gentle "suggestion" or "request", it was a shamelessly entitled demand, combined with the ever so generous offer to at least let the current mods remain in their role (as of now).
AnkiHub emphasizes that they want to build trust among and work with the community. Instead of trust-building actions on their part, however, all they do is ask for us to give them a "chance" along the lines of "it'll be alright, trust me bro". This one-sided demand for unquestioned trust is obviously counter to the points above.
The extreme mismatch between your communication and your actions is demeaning and an insult to everyone's intelligence. People are sick and tired of always hearing the same empty corporate PR lingo and if you seriously want us to believe your good intentions, then you'd better narrow the gap of what you're saying and what you're actually doing. If I wanted to give you the benefit of doubt that you're asking of us, then I'd describe such behavior at best as blatantly contradicting and uninformed. At worst, and if I didn't want to give you the benefit of doubt, then my words would probably violate this sub's rule #2. Assuming that you're a bunch of reasonably smart business people, I'm pretty convinced your true intentions are much closer to the latter than the former. It's entirely up to you to prove me wrong.
My second point rests on my assumption that AnkiHub's current state serves as a blueprint for Anki's future as a whole. To be transparent, this is speculation on my part and I'm not (and never was) an active user of AnkiHub, but just an outside observer. If I misunderstand anything that I criticize below, please let me know and I'll gladly strike through those passages (I won't entirely delete them though to live up to my own accountability). The general monetization of essential features I've found is deeply disturbing. Right on AnkiHub's main page I see that "Build-your-own deck" is promoted as a paid-only feature, how great - not! Also, "Optimize your review sessions [...] Learn more in less time with our Premium plan" sounds a lot to me as if they're trying to pass off general SRS and/or custom study options as an exclusive feature. Maybe I'm misunderstanding something here, but is SRS another basic and free feature of Anki they're deliberately paywalling? Last but not least, I'm generally concerned about the unregulated use of AI, especially in products where I question its practical use beyond serving as a buzzword to potential investors. AnkiHub's ToS only refer to OpenAI's ToS instead of clearly explaining what happens with the user's data and particularly their cards. I understand that's probably a convenient way to handle things for them, but it doesn't seem very trustworty to me. I'm somewhat reverting to my point made further above regarding the necessity of a company to generate profit. Overall, I cannot get rid of my impression, that AnkiHub's costs might've grown way past maintaining its original niche market of medical students. The development of rather specialized features, that go far beyond what the majority of users actually need, probably cost a disproportionate amount by comparison to their benefits. Now, instead of admitting to yourselves that you reached the market's limits and downsizing your endeavors to a feasible operation size, you try incorporate the entire Anki market and thereby keep the cash flow going.
PS: Before people tell me that it's sooo easy to set up my own Anki environment, please take a step back and consider what that really means for people outside of our relatively tech-savvy Reddit bubble. I've been using Anki for years exactly because of its ease of use straight out of the box. I'd also say I'm an above average technically skilled person, but I'd still prefer to use a software that just works without having to regularly tweak things. Less versed people - and let's be honest, that's probably the clear majority of users - won't bother having to deal with that or with having to distinguish and choose from a multitude of similarly named applications. People were already confused by the countless copycat apps for their phones and those weren't even actually using Anki. Tell me how that won't be an issue if the original base of Anki gets fragmented into several more or less competing services. Yikes.
PPS: I know this second excursus might sound very naive and idealistic, but to me personally, knowledge should be as free as possible. In its current state, Anki is probably the most powerful tool to consciously decide what parts of the world's knowledge I want to remember. As such, any restrictions to this free and open approach feels to me like an attack on learning itself, which is in my opinion the basis of becoming a more educated and more complete person. I'm worried if essential Anki features such as addons, custom study options, full control over my data, multi-platform use, SRS and many more (@AnkiHub: this list is NOT exhaustive, but a starting point) risk getting restricted or fully monetized. And no, offering "scholarships" to waive the costs is not the same as keeping it free. The arbitrary financial barriers to learn are still upheld.