r/AnimeReviews • u/hallzy102 • Jan 11 '26
Discuss! Megumi Fushiguro - being a decently well written character doesn't make you not a bum
Hey y’all. I wanted to talk about the online narratives surrounding Megumi Fushiguro. Specifically the idea that “Megumi is a representation of depression and fans treat him like society treats depression." Before anything else: this is not an attack on people with depression or mental illness. These are real, serious issues that are still massively misunderstood and under-treated. This is about a fictional character and the discourse surrounding him (Spoilers ahead).
Any JJK fan that’s been online enough has seen the memes and online discussions with that special flair to them that has been lovingly dubbed: Lobotomy Kaisen. One aspect of Lobotomy Kaisen that has permeated anime online culture more broadly is Fraud Watch.
There have been many Fraud Watch victims across anime spaces, Fraudkuna, Mahoraga’s little baby boy, “the half one” Gojo, Yuta, and The Five Elder Frauds pictured above^, compliments of One Piece’s own brainrot spectacular known as Agenda Piece. One thing that’s clear throughout all the fun, brain dead takes and the ever so rare good point - no one is safe from fraud watch (except for Aoi Todo of course). You can be top in your verse and still get slandered. So if Sukuna, Gojo and Kaido, aren't safe, what hope does a mid to lower tier have?
Enter the Perennial Fraud Watch Champion: Potential Man himself, Megumi Fushiguro. And I’ll be real with you - if you think Megumi’s a fraud I’m not even gonna argue. He is potential man.
Let’s take a quick look at the record. Megumi fails to secure Sukuna’s finger, resulting in Yuji becoming Sukuna’s vessel. He gets his ass beat by one-finger Sukuna who doesn’t even have a heart. His body gets stolen by Sukuna, Sukuna uses it to kill his sister and throughout the series he regularly struggles with low-to-mid tier opponents. I’m not saying all these are all directly his fault or that he should have been able to alter the outcomes but, the results are the results.
What’s a little ironic is that Megumi fans defending him with “ifs” and “whens” are doing the same thing the potential memes mock - focusing on unrealized outcomes rather than what actually happened, which mirrors how depression often gets misunderstood.
It’s these same fans pushing Megumi as a representation of depression angle, that tend be the ones defending him from Fraud Watch. And, honestly I mostly agree with that read. It’s not the most complex depiction ever, but it’s effective and pretty well written.
Where I think things go wrong is that people start conflating two different conversations.
Fraud Watch is about power scaling, performance, and aura.
Megumi’s depression narrative is about theme and storytelling.
Those aren’t the same thing.
In fact, Megumi being a fraud does not undermine the depression narrative - it is the depression narrative. Megumi underperforms, gets labeled potential man, and never quite lives up to the expectations placed on him - which mirrors how depression can manifest as stagnation, hesitation, and unrealized ability. The pressure + underperformance creates a feedback loop that keeps him stuck.
His fight against the finger bearer at the end of season one spells this out pretty clearly. He doesn’t succeed because he perfects himself - he succeeds because he stops waiting for perfection and acts.
That’s why the two readings actually complement each other. Fans are right that Megumi gets treated the way society treats depression. But when those same fans insist he would’ve done better “if only” or “eventually,” they’re kind of doing the same thing - piling expectations onto someone for outcomes that already happened.
So when people say “Megumi’s a fraud” and others say “fans treat Megumi like society treats depression,” both sides are touching on something real. Trying to crown one as the correct reading misses the point - and honestly misses what makes Megumi’s character work at all.
I’m curious what people think! .
Does the depression narrative land for you, in Megumi or JJK more broadly?
Is Megumi forever an irredeemable fraud?
What about his character resonates with you or completely falls flat?