r/AnimalIntelligence • u/TombStoneFaro • Feb 11 '19
This may not be "scientific" enough for this subreddit but: dog/cat language use -- your own impressions?
There is without a doubt evidence that dogs can associate words with objects. Almost every cat I have known seems to understand English to a certain extent -- a cat of my neighbors used to come by and go for walks around my apartment complex and once when we were approached by a toddler who wanted to pet him, he looked up at me and only after I said, "It's okay" did the cat rub against the baby. We have also seen videos of cats and dogs solving surprising problems.
What is a bigger question is, can dogs or cats use language? When a husky says, "I love you" which is shown in many videos, I sort of doubt that the dog understands that this is a sentence made up of individual words. But I have also seen a husky use the word "no" in a context where it is plainly disagreeing with a request, repeating the word with more insistence as the owner continues to make the request.
So some language abilities exist in many dogs and cats. Is it possible that the Einstein of cats/dogs exists who can actually speak English? There is at least one story of a cat named Whitey who could speak pretty extensively and while no recording exists, I am not going to rule it out -- one extremely bright cat who could simply do more of what we have ample evidence for in many cats.
So what has been your personal experience? The same cat who liked to go on walks did the following: When I heard him meowing and tried to locate the source, he actually thrust his paw into the Venetian blind behind which he was sitting so I could see him. This is sophisticated behavior that cats are not supposed to be capable of -- it shows a theory of mind, knowing what I did not know and furthermore realizing what he could do to show himself to me. (He was in so many other ways clearly a very bright cat although he did not speak -- on the other hand, he was only six months old and I do not know what became of him when he got older.)