r/AndroidQuestions • u/Optimal-Analyst-8507 • Feb 13 '25
Consensus on Android System Safety Core?
Been doing a bit of research into this after noticing it on my new phone.
Seemingly installed itself across most of the Android market without the knowledge of owners. Seems that the premise of the application is to blur images which are received on the device which may contain nudity, and also cross verify contacts?
Whilst it seems to be there for safety and privacy, installing without user knowledge and then seemingly scanning all photos received to the device, seems to be anti-privacy to me...?
11
u/senojon Feb 15 '25
Wow. Just got the s25+ a week ago, new to android as well. Had no idea about this. Uninstalled this now, thank you
8
u/Chemical-Material-69 Feb 19 '25
I've had the S24 Ultra for a year, been on Android since the day it came out.
This will drive me straight to Apple and I *HATE* iPhones.
9
u/silversketch06 Feb 26 '25
Apple pretty much has the same thing Apple’s Enhanced Visual Search
0
4
u/SiteRelEnby Feb 21 '25
This made me decide my next main phone will be running GrapheneOS. Switching to iphone is just replacing one problem with another.
1
2
2
1
u/Olaf2k4 Jul 18 '25
I'm starting to miss my non google Huawei... Not in China so the CCP can spy on me all it wants ...
1
1
u/Avantstrangel Oct 17 '26
Go grapheneOS
1
u/MartyBarracuda 4d ago
Not an option for the 3 billion people running Samsung, OnePlus, Xiaomi, and other non-Pixel Android brand phones.
2
u/Meerkat212 Feb 16 '25
Weird. I just got my new s25 last week, and this app isn't on it.
6
u/Pr3ttyhazeleyes Feb 19 '25
It won't let you search for it on Google play Search in Google https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.safetycore
6
u/Meerkat212 Feb 20 '25
Hey!!! It was there! I just removed it! That's a bunch of crap! Thanks for pointing that out!!! How can I find a comprehensive list of apps and everything installed on my phone?
3
u/CalebHawn Mar 14 '25
Yeah, it has no GUI to open, so won't be in your app list, so gotta find it either on Google Play or your Settings > Apps.
2
u/SiteRelEnby Feb 21 '25
Varies by phone but usually some permutation of settings > apps > show system apps
1
1
u/JP-5838 Aug 25 '25
I can not find it on Play Store either. It just pops up in a notification and I ignore it every time
1
u/aerobar642 Feb 16 '25
Yeah I've had my Pixel 7a for a year but just did a security update and I don't have the app either. Hopefully it stays away from me.
1
1
u/Basic-Anybody-7820 Feb 20 '25
Go to your apps screen on the phone itself, what all you have installed, then search it in the bar. It won't come up but it'll let you search on Google then. Click on it (it initially said "install" for me in the results) and it'll show the blue bar across that now says -un-install . I reported it also
5
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 13 '25
Whilst it seems to be there for safety and privacy, installing without user knowledge and then seemingly scanning all photos received to the device, seems to be anti-privacy to me...?
Optional feature you have to opt-in for, unless you're under 18, in which case you can opt-out.
Also, no data about the images is sent to Google:
1
u/Dudefoxlive Feb 13 '25
How do i opt out?
1
1
u/CalebHawn Mar 14 '25
Doesn't seem like you can. Gotta manually uninstall from all your Android devices after it rolls out to them. So far, seems like it stays uninstalled after that; doesn't reinstall.
2
u/toadjones79 Feb 15 '25
That doesn't stop them from sending metadata, like how often you send or receive nudes, back to the mainframe. In theory, this could be expanded to give them a huge marketing profile on you. Are you liberal or conservative, who will you vote for if at all. Will you be likely to commit a crime, or are you a pedophile (re: not a pedophile but AI flags you as one by mistake and you end up on a list).
4
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 15 '25
That doesn't stop them from sending metadata
You may not have finished reading the two sentences I quoted.
Let me quote a smaller portion for you:
They can't know how often you "send nudes" if they don't know if an image was a nude or not.
3
u/toadjones79 Feb 15 '25
It can be expanded later. They do this now so they can insert lines like this while everyone freaks out about it being installed. Then, later they expand how it gathers information about pictures being sent, including things like vacation data and product involvement, and sell that to advertisers.
4
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 16 '25
It can be expanded later.
Literally anything can be expanded later. They could insert code that listens to you pooping.
You either trust them to do what they say, or you don't.
You also either trust security researchers' ability to catch Google lying, or you don't.
If you don't, don't buy a smartphone. Buy a flip phone.
0
u/toadjones79 Feb 16 '25
Or, just a simple thought, you try your best to thread this needle and reduce exposure where you can. Seems like a weird hill to die on here. I'm just saying that you might want to delete this one for the reasons stated, which aren't that far fetched. What's the harm here? By Google's own statements it will shockingly allow a minor to gain access to my phone password and send or receive nudes using my phone, instead of the many much easier ways they would do that. I feel ok with uninstalling that one and you're kinda a weirdo for making an issue about my statements here.
3
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 16 '25
Because we're likely having a conversation about something that will not be removable on future devices, and Google may reinstall this on your device every once and a while. The only reason it's uninstallable on your device currently is because they can't remotely add things to your system partition, which is how apps are made uninstallable.
Which is why I stated that if you truly care about this, you honestly believe that Google would be dumb enough to make public statements about not looking at nudes and then look at nudes, and honestly believe that Google desperately wants to look at your nudes, you should avoid a smartphone. Because if they are who you believe them to be, they can look at your nudes literally any time they want to.
This isn't me trying to "die on a hill" or defend anything. This is literally me telling you that if you're worried about this, you have way more to be worried about, and what the solution is.
Personally, I'm still waiting on them installing it on my device. I'm a bit confused as to how/why a bunch of people are complaining that they had it installed remotely on theirs, and yet mine has yet to get it. (I know I can get it manually, I just want to see it actually happen remotely. I don't care if it's on my device or not.)
-1
u/rathlord Feb 16 '25
lol @ you going straight from straw manning this person’s argument to trying to gaslight people about the credibility of it being silent installed when it’s been heavily reported on already.
If you don’t know, it doesn’t show up in your apps if you search for it. That doesn’t mean you don’t have it.
Fuck’s sake what a tool.
2
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 16 '25
to trying to gaslight people about the credibility of it being silent installed when it’s been heavily reported on already.
Are you replying to the wrong comment?
I entirely believe it's being installed remotely because Google said they'd be installing it. 🤦🏻♂️
How in the world did you somehow reach the conclusion that I thought it wasn't being installed?
Are you trolling?
If you don’t know, it doesn’t show up in your apps if you search for it.
It does, if you ask it to show all apps installed. That's how people can see it's present. Otherwise no one would know it was there.
I also can go and try to install it, and Google says it's not installed on my device, and offers to install it for me. Which is another way of confirming.
1
u/Altruistic_Tank_9636 Apr 14 '25
How can they claim to not know if you're getting nudes if the whole purpose of it is to keep you from seeing nudes? That's the most moronic comment I've ever seen a company make.
1
u/Moleculor 8 Apr 14 '25
It's the same way that a spell checking software in a word processor can work disconnected from the internet.
The computer does all the work locally to identify what's going on. Only the computer knows if you misspell a word, it isn't reporting that data to anyone.
1
1
Feb 28 '25
Since when is opt in considered secretly installing this TJ every android world wide without any notice and having to delete it? It's an opt out.
2
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 28 '25
Because the thing being installed performs many tasks that are non-optional.
Much like how every other thing that Google has installed on your phone remotely over the past decade has often had non-optional parts to it.
The image scanning feature is optional.
1
u/InquisitorWarth Jun 06 '25
Also, no data about the images is sent to Google:
Or so they claim. Honestly with the kind of hot water Google's in right now and their willingness to flash their ass in the face of the feds (see the recent case vs Epic Games for an example), I wouldn't trust them.
Also there's the fact that they're installing this even on custom ROMs which qualifies as unlawful access of a computer device at that point.
1
u/NozeDive Sep 23 '26
"Optional feature you have to opt-in for, unless you're under 18, in which case you can opt-out."
It seems that in the two years since this post, that has changed because i didn't opt in, I'm 42, and this thing is on my phone anyway
1
0
u/dhjwushsussuqhsuq Feb 17 '25
well, no, I didn't opt in and it installed itself. it was very much not an optional feature that you have to opt into lmao.
1
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 17 '25
It being installed only means it's installed. It performs several tasks unrelated to images.
The image thing is the one that's opt-in.
1
u/dhjwushsussuqhsuq Feb 17 '25
that makes sense but I just don't trust it. why not ask me if I wanted it?
2
u/Moleculor 8 Feb 18 '25
They didn't ask you if you wanted the dozens of upgrades they've made to Google Play Services over the last several years, either.
You basically agree when you have Google stuff on your phone.
You just never noticed them, because they don't involve nude images, and so there's no story about them.
1
u/dhjwushsussuqhsuq Feb 18 '25
that could all be true and the fact that you needed to explain it to me, that Ive been conditioned to assume that google just said sod it to my privacy and installed the photo scanner anyway, is the problem. even now, with all that you've said making sense, I don't really believe that google isn't scanning my photos.
1
1
u/Aerroon Mar 14 '25
They didn't ask because people wouldn't agree, so they snuck this garbage in there.
You're implying that if people don't want apps suddenly installed on their phones the scan their messages and images then they should never update their device. Do you really think that would be a better future?
1
u/Moleculor 8 Mar 14 '25
They didn't ask because people wouldn't agree, so they snuck this garbage in there.
If it operates as described, there's nothing harmful about this software, just like the dozens of other updates you've silently received without your knowledge that you haven't objected to.
You're implying that if people don't want apps suddenly installed on their phones the scan their messages and images then they should never update their device.
No I'm not.
I'm outright stating it.
Google-run Android devices, and Apple-run iPhones, are going to self-update with whatever new-fangled thing they want to put on to your device.
Do you really think that would be a better future?
If you don't want it, use an OS that isn't going to do that.
1
u/Aerroon Mar 14 '25
If you don't want it, use an OS that isn't going to do that.
That's literally not an option. Governments don't support those other OSes. Banks don't support them.
I guess you're right though. Updating = bad.
1
Feb 17 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/Middle_Efficiency471 Feb 19 '25
We really need someone to decompile it and blow it out. Other than that, it's speculation and Google's PR.
Regardless, apps that scan your photos is beyond frightening. Imagine the control they would have. The government having access.
"We're looking for things that are bad, swear!" kind of sounds familiar...
3
u/brainmydamage Feb 19 '25
I work for a Google competitor and use this phone for work, and Google decides it can just scan all my images without asking?
Majorly sus.
8
3
u/Fragrant-Chance-7834 Feb 25 '25
Immediately uninstalling, may be sending an email. This isn't okay
2
2
1
1
u/TopAnswer2546 Feb 16 '25
It's not on my android, and when I checked on play store it didn't even come up in the search. Has this just not been sent out in the UK yet?
4
u/TopAnswer2546 Feb 16 '25
Just found it. If you had the same problem as me, Google the app and it should come up with the link to the store press it and you can delete it from there
2
u/dixiehellcat Feb 16 '25
bless you! I had searched on my phone & didn't see it, went into the play store & didn't even see it there, so I thought I was okay; but I just saw your post, so I went that route too just to be certain, and sure enough, there it sat going 'uninstall' at me. /rage
1
u/Double_Banana_781 Feb 18 '25
>UK
>Having playstore installedYou are special aren't you?
0
1
u/ProfessionalGoatFuck Mar 01 '25
Recently updated my phone after 5 months, Nord N20 5G and noticed this shit silently installed itself on my phone. Talk about a breach in privacy.
1
1
1
u/CalebHawn Mar 14 '25
Only reason I learned of this was because I have Xiaomi phones. I always thought it was annoying when the "Xiaomi security scan" would popup and scan every time I installed an app. Now, I'm thankful when it randomly popped up for Android System SafetyCore and Android System Key Verifier, which I then uninstalled.
1
1
u/Ollirick Mar 26 '25
Also regarding this app, my phone's internet protection (Webroot) claimed the app had malware on mine and my mom's phone. So I uninstalled it for protection.
1
u/SumoSamurottorSSPBCC Mar 27 '25
They say it's for "safety." If that's truly the case why do you have to go into your settings to find the app to begin with? Why was it secretly installed across thousands of devices? Ah yes safety to blur graphic images, which if you're a normal person you'd just you probably used Google to find anyway if you were horny.
Unless you go out of your way to turn it off Google automatically has safety search ON to begin with. Plus Google tracks everything you do regardless, why the fuck do they need an extra app to do it with?
I honestly wouldn't be surprised if they're using it for AI which has caused enough problems by itself thanks to psychotic entrepreneurs saying "but what if, & what about the future?🥺"
1
1
u/tomo100brt Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
I unistall it from Sony XPERIA 1 VI to see if battery is going to be better. But no Android System Safety Core on Honor 200 Pro. Strange. I tought every Android phone has Android System Safety Core installed. At least every phone with Android 15. But that is very good for me. No battry problems on Honor 200 Pro.
1
Jun 15 '25
It kept auto installing. They really want you to use it... I found a magisk module that put an end to that typical Google behavior 😂
1
1
u/Moonlight1st Aug 08 '25
I never installed it seems fishy but now messages it sending me notifications to download it like every time I send or receive a message it gives me a notification to download it
1
u/Icypop02 Oct 23 '25
Yeah I keep getting the same notification, I came here looking for a way to disable the notification 😭
1
u/smallbaconfry Aug 12 '25
If imaged are processed locally on the device with supposedly no data leaving to external servers why did it just reach out just now over my network?Samsung safetycore caught on glasswire
1
u/Adamaxx Nov 13 '25 edited Nov 13 '25
I noticed my phone seemed to be acting weird so I looked & this app had reinstalled itself at some point (after removing it months ago), Mobile data & Battery background activity ON.
My other phone (same model) does not have data service but use often & the app is not installed on it noting its being installed per the phone data plan & not wifi.
1
u/AyeYoTay May 12 '26
This app was actually installed my phone like I did it, but I didn't. So now I'm weirded out that an app can just be installed on my phone without me saying "Yes" or "No" to it.. I don't like that!
1
u/IndividualStreet6997 Jun 17 '26
It keeps getting installed, how do i stop that shit from getting auto downloaded and installed?!,
1
1
u/N1ck_Nasty Sep 05 '26
"installing without user knowledge and then seemingly scanning all photos received to the device, seems to be anti-privacy to me" welcome to google... Honestly, it's best to download a custom android os that doesnt depend on Google services to run.
1
u/NotMeUsee Sep 05 '26
It's for csam. Last thing I want is some robot to make that decision and send the cops to my house over nothing. I uninstalled it. To keep it off your phone turn off auto updates in play store because it will come back
9
u/Motor-Design-4932 Feb 13 '25
Garbage, why i need to spend my ram on useless nude censor in app where i got 0 images for 10 years
1
u/matthew65536 Apr 22 '25
I am wholeheartedly against it. This is MY device, and I should get to decide what I put on it. if I want to look at porn, I will.
0
Mar 05 '25
[deleted]
1
u/ZaCloud Mar 14 '25
"Woke agenda"? You mean the people who want equality & individual rights? Censorship of people's private property & adult material is what the opposite side wants, pal.
Look up how Project 2025 wants to make pornography illegal, including sending nude pics to anyone except your legally licensed/married spouse, & look into the people who put it together & what side of the political aisle they're on. Lots of them are in office right now working on a lot of the stuff in that document, if not nationally, then at their state-level.
(And between what this app does, & Google Maps renaming the Gulf of Mexico into Gulf of America without any official approval by international agencies, it seems like Google's trying to get on the current administration's good side so they can get rewarded like a good little lapdog.)
The "woke" people are the ones who've been fighting against this kind of stuff, against both corporations & government, because banning/criminalizing stuff related to sex work has the worst impact on women & LGBTI+ people.
32
u/Arnas_Z Moto Edge+ 2023 | Moto Edge 2024 Feb 13 '25
Consensus? Directly into the trash bin. Useless garbage that auto installs on your phone. Delete it.