r/AndroidGaming • u/xLionhartx • May 21 '18
Attention Android Developers
For the love of God. Add. Controller. Support.
Jesus Christ... Nobody loves playing all games on touch buttons. We do it because we HAVE to not because we want to. Thank you.
45
u/that_90s_guy OP3/GS7/MotoZP/Nex6P/Note5/LgG4/Nexus6/MotoXP/Note4/M8/MotoX2 May 21 '18 edited May 21 '18
Nobody loves playing all games on touch buttons.
Even as a controller fan, I have to recognize that sadly, no, quite a lot of people don't care if they play games with or without touch buttons.
In fact, I think the biggest reason for which mobile gaming thrives is because people just enjoy the ability to play something quick while on the guy without hauling something bulky like a controller. Heck, I even had a 3DS which was almost as portable as my phone, and even then I preferred gaming on my phone since not always did I carry my 3DS due to not wanting to carry yet another device in my pocket.
TLDR; Too few people user controllers to actually add controller support. And the pay-off is usually only there for major AAA titles that benefit big time from controller support like FPS (ShadowGun, Modern Combat, etc)
8
u/A_Filthy_Mind May 21 '18
I know i fall in that boat, as does the dozen or so friends that play mobile games. I can't think of any of them that have a controller for their mobile, i think most wouldnt even use one if it was given to them.
Typically, we play mobile because we are out, or shitting. If we're going to have special equipment and such, we'll just get a pc game going.
1
0
May 21 '18
[deleted]
12
u/123111223 May 21 '18
Am mass. Can speak for myself. I don't care for controller support.
The majority of the masses are into gaming on the go. That's why simple and easy to play games become famous. Clash of clans, candy crush, that bubble shooter game, and more. The other guy is right. The percentage of people who use controllers on mobile are likely rather small, in fact, I've seen one in person just twice. The rest of us don't care that intensely for it.
4
u/MrPlumkitten May 21 '18
Even if a game has controller support, I try to get used to touch controls cos Im not comfortable with carrying a controller everywhere I go.
-10
u/xLionhartx May 21 '18
I'm obviously not saying that games like clash of clans need controller support lmao. - _- common sense please
9
u/IveGotABluePandaIdea May 21 '18
Did you have a bad day? Do you wanna talk? Pm me if you need someone.
27
u/that_90s_guy OP3/GS7/MotoZP/Nex6P/Note5/LgG4/Nexus6/MotoXP/Note4/M8/MotoX2 May 21 '18 edited May 21 '18
Yep, who am I to judge right? It's not like in all my years of daily commute (and even taking my own Moga Pro controller), I've only seen like 1 or 2 people use bluetooth controllers out in the wild. Heck, I work in the tech industry. Where you would expect to find more gamers, or at least people who know about gadgets, and even here some people are still surprised bluetooth controllers that work with Android exist.
Oh, and it's strange that you don't find the irony of the statement you just wrote. Both you and me are just 2 people, the masses have already spoken, and that's why so few games have controller support.
0
May 21 '18
[deleted]
14
u/that_90s_guy OP3/GS7/MotoZP/Nex6P/Note5/LgG4/Nexus6/MotoXP/Note4/M8/MotoX2 May 21 '18
Who's bitching? Heck, if anyone's butthurt, it might be you by the tone of your comment. Dude, I'm on the same side. Like you, I really, REALLY wish more games had controller support. World of Tanks is easilly one of my favorite games and it's dying due to lack of controller support.
However, as much as I want controller support, I'm no fanboy and I recognize why developers aren't adding it. If anything, I'm just not a fan of people thinking we as a community have an opinion that represents the majority of users.
0
May 21 '18
[deleted]
7
u/MrPlumkitten May 21 '18
You start the thread with "Nobody loves playing all games on touch buttons" and talk about logic.
First speak for yourself and don't forget that this one thread is not going to change any developer's mind. AAA publishers are trying hard to optimise touch controls and thats not gonna change any time soon.
1
u/runbktrop May 21 '18
You got controller support money?
-7
u/xLionhartx May 21 '18
Yeah I do. I'll buy the game if it has it and if it doesn't I just won't. Same with everyone else who wants controller support.
20
u/friendofthedevil5679 May 21 '18
Controller support is good for games like GTA, PUBG, action rpgs, platformers etc.; touch is awesome for puzzle games, strategy games and turn-based rpgs tho.
1
u/pretend7979 May 22 '18
Agreed mostly, I'd rather have controller support for something fast like Tetris, or racing games even. I don't really like turning my phone, and I hate on screen controls. Some games it just makes sense to use touch though...
1
14
u/Mischala May 21 '18
I echo your sentiment. But judging from your other comments, your debate skills leave a lot to be desired.
Am a developer (not much of a game dev, but I have dabbled). Adding controller support isin't a one line fix.
It adds significant development and testing time to add an entirely different way to interact with a game.
And the payoff is minimal, as usage stats show that not many Android games use controllers.
It you want more support, speak with your wallet.
Keep using your controller, keep buying games that support controllers.
If devs start to see a significant uptick in controller usage, they will see that it's in their best interest to support controllers.
1
u/pretend7979 May 22 '18
Good points, I think one of the challenges is that a lot of controller supported games don't advertise it well, or support it very well. They're difficult to find too... There's no filter on Google play for it, an if you search for "controller support" you just get a list of controller apps. How can I support theses games if I don't know what games I should be supporting.
2
u/apeinej May 21 '18
What's your reference for saying "nobody loves playing all games on touch buttons". Do you have a research for that, or got it out of your mind? There are several games it sucks badly, but mostly on bad implementation. Free placing movement stick and larger buttons are really good. Maybe if dev worked that way (or make it an option), touch control would be better.
2
u/iatrik Dev [Tap Healer - Healing Touch] 🧙 May 21 '18
Smartphones are touch devices, which allow you to create your own input layouts. When a game tries to recreate the controller experience using on-screen buttons, then I agree. Those games should implement some kind of controller support.
All other games shouldn't be "punished" by actually making well designed games for its targeted platform. For this reason, my game will never see Controller Support.
3
u/russellinho May 21 '18
Why would you even play a mobile game if you have to plug a controller in? Why not just play a PC or console game instead? Unless you're talking about a specific game
4
2
u/origamiboy2 May 21 '18
Nvidia really needs to release that gamepad mapping thing they had on the Nvidia shield portable that could bind a controller button to a touch input
2
u/naive-dragon All the emulators May 21 '18
Everyone here would love to have that.
Unfortunately, the majority of mobile gamers just don't give a shit.
1
u/RageGoria May 21 '18
Yeah, lots of games don't have controller support, i have a DS3 controller and i managed to connect it to my phone, but there's only a handful of game with controller support, usually i'd use sixasis controller's touch emulation if the game doesn't have a controller support.
Quite understandable tho, since most mobile gamers don't really care about controllers and most games can be played just fine without one, and a controller would usually obstruct portability, but really, a controller support would always be a welcome addition.
1
May 21 '18
Second this and also mentioning if a certain game has offline capabilities. I swear I'll pay a lot just to play Gear Club in offline. Stormborne got an offline mode update, why can't others do too?
-1
0
u/Fellhuhn Troll Patrol | Hnefatafl | ... May 21 '18
I will add it to my current game (currently open beta) once the UI has been finalized. Sad thing is that Unity doesn't have a good controller support for Android and the UI isn't really made for it. It requires quite some rework.
0
-5
May 21 '18
Another PUBG fanboy.
1
1
u/BiigLord Vodafone Smart V8 May 21 '18
Fun fact: you can't actually play PUBGM with a controller. Tencent won't allow it. You'd gain a significant advantage over the other players if you could use one.
0
4
u/LordofSyn May 21 '18
I have a moga pocket pro. I love it, but the reason I do not use it more often is that there is not enough controller support. I love Terraria on my phone. I have even tried third party mapping software and cannot get it to work. I am a tech head though and even other IT and gamers I know were not aware they made BT controllers for phones and tablets.
I agree with OP, and I do also agree that the vast majority of phone gamers prefer the practicality of touch controls at any time they can play (especially while on the go), it has to be something that is advertised more.
I honestly thought they missed out on a prime opportunity to really market BT controllers like the Moga line when the head mounted VR kits started rolling out a few years ago. Seemed like a match made in heaven to me.
The only game I had no issue using my controller with was San Andreas. But if only <1% of my mobile gaming library supports a controller, then you will understand why I have not used it in a while.