With the latest update, Ancestry is telling me that I am 13% Belgian, which is basically equivalent to a great-grandparent. There is simply no way that this is true.
Both my grandfathers were of Catholic Irish stock, and for one of them I have genealogies going back many generations; one of my grandmothers was an Ulster Protestant, which explains some of the Scottish heritage, and the other grandmother was an American WASP, and I can track almost all of her ancestors back to the boat they came to the USA from England.
Yes, there are a few gaps here and there in my genealogy, but even if every missing branch was filled by a secret Belgian, it could not be enough to add up to 13%.
On top of that, not a single one of my DNA connections on Ancestry - or any of the other sites, MyHeritage, 23andMe, Gedmatch, FTDNA - is Belgian. You would think that if I really had a Belgian great-grandparent, or the equivalent, some of their relatives might have signed up to one of the DNA sites. Incidentally, none of the other DNA sites thinks that I have any Belgian ancestry at all.
And that, I think, is the clue to the answer. I suspect that Ancestry has not done many DNA samples for people living in Belgium. But I know for sure that one of the few is my own DNA. So I guess that my own residence in Belgium is contaminating the statistics for everyone; when Ancestry looks for where people with DNA like mine are living now, Belgium comes up because I happen to live here.
I don’t put much faith in the ancestral origin results from any of the DNA sites. For what it’s worth, 23andMe is the only one that tells me the same as my genealogical research does, that all my ancestors are from Ireland, Scotland and England, in that order. But Ancestry’s DNA results are the wackiest by far. And it’s clearly not just me, as evidenced by the large number of people posting “MY RESULTS WTAF” to this sub. It’s not secrets in your ancestry, folks, it’s flaws in Ancestry.
It’s a shame, because I really appreciate the research tools for genealogy and for research on DNA relatives that Ancestry provides. They are far better than any other site in that regard. But the DNA origins stuff is so misleading that it is practically a scam.