r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/WildAutonomy • 3d ago
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/Ronahi_int • 3d ago
The Resistance International Press Conference - For November 20, Youth Strike
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/Delicious-Rope-1128 • 3d ago
🔥 11N - HUELGA GENERAL
After the General Strike of November 11th lawmakers voted 35-34 on Thursday to ban evictions for financially and socially vulnerable tenants with no alternative housing until 2030. The measure also includes two-year lease extensions and caps on rent hikes and bans on "vulture funds" buying property until 2028.
Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez called a snap election after congress rejected emergency housing measures he’d proposed in October, in response to the growing protest movement demanding housing affordability. The decrees were reintroduced this week with minor changes.
The conservative People Party, which leads in the polls ahead of the Nov. 29 vote, has vowed to repeal the reforms if it takes power.
Who said that organizing the people from the botton and fight for our rights has no difference?!
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/Hefty_Rich6269 • 3d ago
As an Iranian Anarcho-Syndicalist: Some Thoughts, Experiences, and Views on Recent Events, and My Displeasure, Unease, and Fears Concerning Certain Strange Currents
Foreword: This is a rather long article, but I sincerely ask everyone to read it in its entirety. I would also very much like to hear your thoughts.
I am of Iranian descent. I am an anarchist. These are not merely labels or a matter of identity politics. My principles have always revolved around the finest contributions to humanity left behind by anarchist thinkers. I take pride in these principles, and I am willing to struggle for them. My homeland lies in the vast northeastern reaches of Iran. Yet living against such a background has never brought me a single moment of happiness. I have witnessed far too many tragedies, far too much bloodshed, far too much violence, far too many instances in which Allah, the Prophet, patriarchy, and the nation have been invoked to solidify barbaric orders into absolute and permanent domination. I will set out my thoughts below, perhaps somewhat ramblingly. I will try my utmost to use the most objective language possible, to appeal both to reason and to emotion. Nevertheless, I know perfectly well that some people will inevitably describe me as "Islamophobic," "right-wing," or "anti-progressive." I want to make this clear to everyone in advance. This article consists of thoughts that have emerged from years of research, years of reflection, and years of reading. I hope everyone understands that.
In my homeland, people are enduring the most severe religious oppression, the bloodiest repression, and the most ruthless theocratic rule, whose horrors have, in certain respects, now surpassed even those of the Taliban. Recently, the son of the tyrant Khamenei has once again mobilized the entire country, establishing so-called "Camps for Sacrifice for the Nation." Through religious fanaticism, he urges people to surrender their precious lives for fraudulent, fictitious, and disgraceful abstractions: Allah, clerical authority, the Twelve Imams, and the despicable ruling class embodied by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. As I write these words, I cannot help but feel an overwhelming grief and indignation. My compatriots—those who took to the streets at the beginning of January this year to protest against the unbearable cost of living and the Revolutionary Guards' plundering of the people—at least 36,500 of them have forever sacrificed their precious lives for the people and for the future of us all. And yet they have been forgotten by the Western media and the left, as though they were not people who mattered.
Some of those hypocritical, or perhaps merely naive and even foolish, progressive leftists who march shoulder to shoulder with Islamists—including, as one interview revealed, quite a number of Muslims who support the implementation of Sharia law in Western societies—seem to focus their attention solely on Palestine. It seems to be Palestine, always and forever Palestine. What problem lies beneath this? I believe it reflects a profound imbalance in whose suffering receives attention. Because the United States and Israel bombed Iran, they immediately think: America and Israel—oh no, two imperialist and colonialist regimes! Surely that contradicts our ridiculous principles of progressivism and pluralism! And so the task of demonstrating against Iran's theocratic regime has been left almost entirely to the decrepit last remnants of the Pahlavi dynasty: the Iranian monarchists. This reminds me of 1979. That year, communist leftists likewise stood shoulder to shoulder with Islamists in Iran and helped overthrow the Pahlavi regime. But what happened afterward? Khomeini repressed and massacred those very leftists who had helped pave the way for his rise to power and had, objectively speaking, supported him. And from this emerged a new ruling class: the Revolutionary Guards. This ruling class came to control the economy, the military, grassroots society, and political administration from top to bottom. It penetrated every stratum and every corner of Iranian society, and began committing atrocities on an unprecedented scale, atrocities dozens of times worse than those of the Pahlavi era.
Who, then, was responsible for this? What brought about such an outcome? Was it merely the work of a handful of conspirators? Was it simply an accident of history? I do not believe so. Although I do not, like Marxists, believe that history possesses some inherent necessity or predetermined direction of development, that does not mean I believe everything happens without causes. Rational analysis can help us understand the roots of events, the reasons behind them, and the conditions that brought them into existence. And so I shall begin my analysis.
What exactly is Islam? What exactly are Muslims? Why on earth should Islam enjoy any special immunity? What is the behavioral logic behind a Muslim voluntarily and rigorously observing religious commandments? These questions have often occupied my thoughts. They can be extremely complicated, yet they can also be extraordinarily simple. But the question that troubles me most is this: If someone voluntarily follows religious commandments, and then requires their children and descendants to follow those same commandments, is this a principle of voluntariness, or a principle of domination? Once we clearly examine the relations of power and the logic of discipline behind these practices, things gradually become much clearer.
We can dispense with a detailed enumeration of the historical actions of Islam and its supposedly greatest Prophet, because these materials are publicly available and can be consulted by anyone: conquest, massacres, the oppression of women, slavery, child marriage, the oppression of children, and patriarchy. Or Muhammad's own private conduct, such as the account, widely transmitted in Sunni hadith, of his marriage to a wife who was six years old. These materials are not secrets deliberately concealed from the public. Anyone willing to examine them seriously can gain access to them. I have no desire to argue over these facts. Much of this is recorded in the original Quranic and hadith texts as either divinely revealed or divinely permitted. In essence, I see little difference between the two. But what I want to explain, briefly, is not merely this. Although what I intend to discuss cannot be separated from these matters, I want to offer an analysis that is more fundamental, more genealogical, more piercing, and ultimately more useful. These questions are directly connected to the lives of nearly two billion Muslims. They are directly connected to the relations of power that constitute their existence. For what I truly wish to discuss is a question more fundamental than the historical acts themselves: How were these acts endowed with sacred legitimacy? How did these authorities survive the passage of centuries, continually participating in the shaping of successive generations of Muslims—their thoughts, bodies, desires, and moral judgments—through scriptural interpretation, religious jurisprudence, family education, social customs, and state institutions?
I am not satisfied with merely condemning the cruelty of their Prophet and his successors. Nor am I satisfied with demonstrating that their morality conflicts with modern ethics—even though, from the standpoint of moral universalism, the rights of women and children in the overwhelming majority of Muslim regions are indeed suppressed and controlled by their prevailing moral orders. What is it that allows a moral order produced under particular historical circumstances to demand obedience from living human beings fourteen centuries later? I believe the root of the problem lies precisely in the process of absolutizing historical authority and sanctifying human-made norms. And the ultimate justification for this authority invariably returns to the same place: the will of Allah, and a sacred revelation proclaimed to be final, perfect, and absolutely infallible. But this gives rise to a contradiction that cannot easily be evaded. If someone firmly believes that the Quran is Allah's final, perfect, and absolutely infallible revelation, and that Allah is omniscient and perfectly good, while simultaneously acknowledging that the scripture did indeed grant normative permission to institutions such as slavery, sexual slavery, and child marriage, then how can that person declare, without any qualification whatsoever, that these institutions are absolutely evil in every age and under every conceivable circumstance?
Confronted with this question, one must make at least one of several choices. Either acknowledge that these institutions were not absolutely wrong in every historical period; or reinterpret the relevant scriptural passages and deny that they were ever genuinely granted sacred permission; or reconsider the meaning of a "perfect revelation"; or begin questioning the supposedly infallible divine origin of the scripture itself. Beyond these possibilities, the two judgments simply cannot coexist: that these permissions genuinely came from an absolutely righteous God, and that the practices permitted were absolutely evil under every conceivable circumstance. Those who call themselves moderate or progressive Muslims can, of course, oppose these institutions. To some extent, I do not deny the sincerity of their opposition. But I must ask those who insist upon all the premises above: How exactly do they explain this contradiction? If they merely borrow modern secular ethics to reject these institutions, while refusing to reexamine the scriptural authority that endowed them with legitimacy, then to what extent has their progress actually reached the roots of the problem?
Yet all this is merely a criticism arising from within the religion's own logic. If we temporarily set aside the question of theological consistency and turn instead to actual individuals, bodies, and relations of power, the situation becomes even more disturbing. Why must a person's birth, sex, marriage, sexual behavior, and even thoughts be subjected to the judgment of an order proclaimed sacred? Why must women occupy unequal positions under Sharia law in matters of testimony, inheritance, divorce, and guardianship? According to opinion polls, apart from the five Central Asian states and Turkey, Muslims in the overwhelming majority of Muslim-majority countries support the application of Sharia law. Why must a child who has not yet developed the capacity for independent judgment already be assigned a religious identity by their family and community—an identity they cannot easily reject? Is this really voluntary freedom? Is defending such practices in the name of pluralism and religious liberty genuinely a defense of freedom? To what extent is a choice truly voluntary merely because someone declares it to be so?
After all, sincere willingness and disciplinary conditioning are not mutually exclusive. A person can sincerely believe that they are making a free choice, while never having been permitted to see that other choices exist. A person can passionately defend the discipline imposed upon them, while never having been allowed to question the origins of that discipline. This is precisely power in its most sophisticated and enduring form. It no longer needs to hold a knife aloft at every moment. It only needs to forge that knife into everyday morality, into the warmth of family affection, into the sense of belonging offered by the community, until those subjected to domination begin wearing their own chains as necklaces.
In my homeland, this discipline begins in the cradle. Before a girl can even speak, she is already taught: "When you grow up, you must wear the hijab, because Allah commands it." Before a boy can distinguish right from wrong, he is already indoctrinated with the belief that "your sister, your mother, and your future wife are worth only half as much as you when giving testimony." When they grow older, they may say, "This is my faith. I follow it voluntarily." But I must question this. When an entire family, an entire neighborhood, an entire mosque, and the entire machinery of the state repeat the same narrative day after day; when questioning itself is defined as sin, as betrayal of Allah; when leaving means social death or even physical death—look up for yourselves the consequences of leaving Islam in most Islamic countries—how much genuine freedom of choice remains in such "voluntariness"? Discipline does not always manifest itself as coercion. More often, it manifests itself as something "natural." And to describe historically produced, human-made norms, bearing the marks of violence, as "natural" and "sacred and unchangeable" is precisely domination's most successful disguise.
And once this so-called "voluntariness" enters the political sphere, the consequences become even more terrifying. Might those religious masses who sincerely believe that Sharia law ought to govern society not also sincerely support a regime that deprives women of their freedom, punishes apostates, and suppresses dissenters? They may even use their ballots to bring political forces advocating religious rule into power. Shouldn't Hamas's victory in the 2006 Palestinian legislative elections serve as a warning? Religious rule can indeed enjoy the sincere support of certain sections of society. But this is precisely the problem. Even if ten million people sincerely believe in the Quran, that does not give them the right to dominate another person's body, conscience, or life. The piety of the majority is no proof of freedom. Nor can a ballot transform slavery into justice. A person may voluntarily submit to their own faith, but they have no right to demand that others submit to that same faith. If so-called religious freedom ultimately means that a religious majority has the right to deprive a minority of the freedom not to believe, not to obey, and to leave the religion, then that freedom has long since become merely another name for domination.
Islam's control over grassroots society is far more rigorous, comprehensive, and deeply ingrained than many people are willing to acknowledge. It is not merely a matter of attending worship once a week. It penetrates every detail of eating, clothing, sleeping, speaking, marriage, inheritance, legal testimony, education, relations between neighbors, and even the burial of the dead. The mosque is not merely a place of prayer. It is a center of surveillance, mobilization, and moral judgment. The family is not merely a unit of affection. It is the first frontline of the most terrifying patriarchy, enforcing the gender hierarchy of Sharia. Religious schools do not merely impart knowledge. From childhood onward, they cultivate fear of "apostasy," "blasphemy," and "disobedience." In many places, this control is even more pervasive than that exercised by the Catholic Church in old Spain. Catholicism at least possessed a relative distinction between "this world and the next," between "render unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and unto God what is God's." The Apostle Paul discussed Gentiles who did not possess the Mosaic Law, pointing out that they could nevertheless do by nature what the law required, that the requirements of the law were written upon their hearts, and that their consciences also bore witness. Medieval Latin Catholicism established natural law as an important higher normative foundation of canon law. By contrast, Sharia in Islam—whose direct origins lie in the revelations Muhammad claimed to have received from Allah and in the judicial precedents of his religious and political rule in Medina—directly claims authority over every sphere of public and private life in this world. The morality police can intervene in your bodily existence because of a single strand of exposed hair, a joke, or a prayer not performed on time. Neighbors can report you for failing to fast. Your family can deprive you of your inheritance, or even your life, because you refuse an arranged marriage or child marriage, or because you remove your hijab. This grassroots control is not occasional. It is everyday, comprehensive, and sanctified.
It is precisely because of this that I think of the CNT-FAI militias during the Spanish Civil War. When the revolution erupted in 1936, the anarchist workers of Catalonia and Aragon did not politely maintain "respect for diversity" toward the Catholic Church's control over grassroots society. They burned churches, tore down crosses, expelled and even executed members of the clergy who were deeply entangled with the old order. This was not simply a matter of anti-religious fanaticism. It was because they clearly understood that the Catholic Church, through education, confession, charity, moral judgment, and its alliances with landlords and the state, had solidified the thoughts, desires, and obedience of entire generations into permanent domination. Without breaking this grassroots control, land reform, workers' self-management, and women's liberation would forever remain empty words. Through their actions, they demonstrated that when a religious institution has transformed itself into a machine for dominating people's everyday lives, the oppressed have the right—and indeed the necessity—to destroy its material and ideological foundations of domination. As Durruti said: "We are not in the least afraid of ruins. We are going to inherit the earth; there is not the slightest doubt about that." "The only church that brings light is a burning church."
Why, then, may Catholicism be treated in this way, but not Islam? Why is the destruction of the former's grassroots control regarded by many anarchists and left-wing historians as a necessary revolutionary cleansing, while the same structures in the latter are met with demands for "cultural sensitivity" and warnings against "Islamophobia"? If the principle of opposing domination is consistent, it should not suddenly cease to apply merely because the name of the religion changes. In many societies, Islam's control over bodies, gender, thought, and the socialization of children is, in both intensity and scope, far greater than that of the Catholic Church in Spain at the time. It likewise sanctifies historical norms, marked by violence, as eternal. It likewise binds families, communities, religious authorities, and the machinery of the state into an impenetrable web. Refusing to acknowledge this, or daring to attack only "Western" religions while granting immunity to "non-Western" religions, is not internationalism. It is a new and hypocritical hierarchy, a new form of Western-centrism. In practice, it protects a system of domination simply because that domination wears the cloak of an "oppressed culture."
I see certain Western progressive leftists raising the banners of "bodily autonomy," "gender equality," and "children's rights," while maintaining an astonishing silence about the structural subordination of women and children under Sharia law. Some even actively defend it. They say, "This is culture. We must respect diversity." But when diversity becomes a shield for relations of domination, it ceases to be an instrument of emancipation. It becomes a new prison. When the Taliban, in the name of Allah and Sharia, deprive millions of Afghan women of the right to education, employment, and a free life, tolerate child marriage and forced marriage, and reduce the bodies and destinies of countless girls to appendages of patriarchy and religious commandments; when Iran's theocratic rulers and Revolutionary Guards, in the name of defending the Islamic Revolution and sacred order, open fire upon people demanding bread, freedom, and dignity, causing the deaths of tens of thousands in the bloody repression of January 2026; when decades of Islamist state-building and Arab nationalist rule in Sudan intertwine, giving rise to the Janjaweed and their successors, the Rapid Support Forces, subjecting non-Arab communities in Darfur to repeated massacres, rape, forced displacement, and ethnic cleansing, while hundreds of thousands of lives are destroyed by war, persecution, and famine; I cannot help but ask: What, exactly, are these people's lives worth? Those girls robbed of their childhoods, their education, and their bodily autonomy; those young people shot dead in the streets by a theocratic state; those Sudanese civilians massacred and driven from their homes because of their non-Arab ethnic identity—what kind of political narrative must they fit into before they can finally be regarded as human beings worthy of genuine concern? Those progressives who endlessly proclaim themselves "anti-colonialist" and "anti-imperialist" so often choose to turn their eyes elsewhere. They can safely wave a flag in the safest possible places, in the safety of Western countries, while turning a blind eye to another group of people who are bleeding to death. This selective morality, in my eyes, is not progress. It is not an act of courage. It is shameful. It is another form of betrayal—a betrayal of all those who are genuinely oppressed.
The ghost of 1979 still haunts us. Those leftists who once stood shoulder to shoulder with Islamists to overthrow the Pahlavi dynasty were ultimately swallowed by Khomeini's nooses and prisons. From the very beginning, the Revolutionary Guards were never "guardians of the people." They were a newly emerging ruling class, forged through religious fanaticism into a machinery of domination more comprehensive, more deeply entrenched, and more brutal than the old monarchy. Today, their establishment of "Camps for Sacrifice for the Nation," and their exhortations to die for Allah, for the Twelve Imams, and for clerical authority, are nothing more than a continuation of the same logic: using fictitious abstractions to devour real human lives. My compatriots took to the streets at the beginning of this year not for some grand narrative, but simply because bread and freedom were being taken away from them. Yet the deaths of more than 36,000 people were swiftly forgotten by far too many, as though those bodies were not sufficiently "correct," as though they failed to conform to some ideological hierarchy of internationalist priorities.
I am not a remnant of the Pahlavi dynasty, nor am I a supporter of any monarchy. I am an anarchist. I believe in the power of workers organizing themselves, in cooperatives, in trade unions, in federations built from below, and in the continuous dismantling of every power structure that attempts to solidify itself into permanent domination. Whether that power wears the robes of a king or the robes of Allah, it is the same enemy to me. The will of Allah, the authority of the Prophet, the interpretive authority of the ulama, and the guns of the Revolutionary Guards together constitute an immense web, fixing human beings into predetermined positions from birth until death. To break this web, we cannot simply replace one interpreter with another who is supposedly more "progressive." Nor can we place our hopes in the bombardment of some external empire—although I would still rejoice at Israel's elimination of Khamenei. Instead, the oppressed masses themselves must come to recognize that no revelation is so perfect that it cannot be questioned, and no order is so sacred that it cannot be overthrown. Just as the anarchist militias of Spain once acted against the grassroots strongholds of the Catholic Church, we possess the same right to question, dismantle, and destroy the material foundations of domination belonging to any institution that seeks to imprison human beings permanently within a theocratic hierarchy.
What troubles me is not merely the present situation in Iran. What troubles me is a strange and increasingly widespread current. It marches under the banners of anti-racism, anti-colonialism, and multiculturalism, yet in practice it continually provides cover for religious patriarchy, theocratic rule, and forces hostile to individual freedom. It hastily brands any structural criticism of Islam as "hatred" or "right-wing," while turning a blind eye to the domination actually taking place within Muslim communities, particularly the domination inflicted upon women and children. This current deeply unsettles me, because it is manufacturing a new kind of immunity. Certain relations of power, simply because they present themselves in the name of the "oppressed," are permitted to escape analysis, dismantling, and resistance. Genuine anarchism cannot accept such immunity. Genuine opposition to domination must apply equally to all. If the Catholic Church's grassroots control could be shattered through revolution, then Islam's grassroots control should likewise enjoy no sacred and inviolable privilege.
I write these words not to incite hatred, but because I have personally witnessed far too many lives shattered beneath this sacred order. I do not want to see another generation bound by the same chains, only to be taught that those chains represent their "free choice." If freedom means that a person can genuinely question, genuinely leave, and genuinely rearrange their own life and body without the threat of social death, then in far too many places we remain terribly distant from that freedom. And the first step toward closing that distance is to stop sanctifying domination, and to stop treating the accidents of history as eternal necessities.
I hope that one day, from the Atlas Mountains along the Atlantic coast to the ancient plains of Mesopotamia; from the boundless deserts of the Arabian Peninsula to the snow-covered peaks of the Iranian Plateau and the Hindu Kush; from the banks of the Nile to the Indus Valley, and onward to the distant shores of the Bay of Bengal and the Malay Archipelago, this vast Islamic world will finally free itself from the rule of monarchs, clerical authority, and Islam itself. May freedom and federations of workers built from below replace theocracy and despotism. May women be liberated from patriarchy and religious commandments. May children no longer be born burdened with a faith they are forbidden to disobey. May every human being finally be free to determine their own destiny. Perhaps these lands must still endure a long and terrible night. Perhaps countless more people will perish before the dawn finally arrives. But I am still willing to believe. I am still willing to believe that when that day finally comes, the faces of all those who can at last decide their own lives for themselves will be filled with smiles of genuine, heartfelt happiness.
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/Ronahi_int • 4d ago
Europe YOUTH STRIKE ON THE 20N!
As student and youth organizations from across Europe, we are calling for a day of joint strikes and mobilisations under the slogan: The constant escalation of wars, rearmament and imperialist oppression, alongside climate breakdown, is shaping the world we are growing up in and denying us, as young people, the possibility of a dignified future.
We fight for education free from military interests. We fight to abolish both voluntary and mandatory military service. We fight for public investment in schools, healthcare, housing and climate justice instead of weapons and war. We fight for a rapid and just transition beyond fossil fuels, led by the workers, where no one is left behind; for international solidarity instead of imperial domination, and the right of every people to determine their own future free from occupation and colonialism.
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/littleemmagoldman • 5d ago
The Ban on Choking and DDLG Is Worse Than You Think.
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/batsdontwearhats • 6d ago
Fuck Capitalism How to create space for disabled comrades
I saw a post on Reddit about how you can’t be communist while excluding disabled people. I wanted to add onto that as a disabled ancom activist. Creating spaces for disabled activists that are accessible is mandatory to this movement if you truly want to include us. I know that in many areas (including my own) that’s not possible right now. However, it can’t be optional going forward. All of us have to do better with inclusivity.
I’m from a rural area of northern New Hampshire. I tried for years to hold a job, but ultimately I came to a heartbreaking realization: that I can’t work cuz of my disabilities. I can’t drive either. Genuine leftists are very rare around here, it’s mostly maga and libs. The only space that I really have at this moment to be an activist is online, where there’s more people like me that I can organize with if only virtually.
What we need is comrades willing to offer transportation to protests or anywhere where movement is happening. We want to be a part of it too, many of us just can’t get there.
We need people to educate themselves on the disability rights movement, we have never been complacent or silent. People just refuse to listen to us- which is yet another barrier. Not having our voices taken seriously.
We may need help communicating with others depending on what type of disability we have.
Most of all, we need our voices to be uplifted just like any other minority’s should be. We’re directly harmed by a capitalist system- with cuts to Medicaid and food stamps and other lifesaving services. Remember, many of us can’t work and the government limits how much money we are allowed to have in our bank accounts. We’re not supposed to have expensive assets either (people have gotten kicked off of SSDI for their baseball card collections). It needs to be talked about more, because we are starving and dying.
That’s how you help disabled comrades. I hope I broke it down well enough, I’m autistic and struggle to choose my words sometimes because I don’t know how it will come across. Let me know your thoughts. Please keep us in mind going forward
Edit: we’re basically not allowed to get married either cuz our healthcare can get taken away. They see it as a spouses assets becoming yours. Better hope your spouse has health insurance…
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/petrosmisirlis • 8d ago
Bash The Fash! Antifascist patrol in northern Athens keeps fascists hidden in their holes
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/Zonfixx • 9d ago
Asia The Left is going to make your life better no matter what
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/burtzev • 9d ago
North America November 7 & 8: Boston Anarchist Book Fair
bostonanarchistbookfair.orgr/Anarchy4Everyone • u/Nnthytk • 10d ago
Join the movement!
I invite you to participate in the #IDoNotConsent movement (check out Aaron abke video for more understanding)
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/online_fuki • 10d ago
LGBTQ PRIDE I'm an anarchist communist who believes in a monarchy. Let me elaborate.
I've been thinking about anarchism and something that I think gets overlooked in a lot of discussions about political organization: opposition to hierarchy doesn't necessarily mean opposition to every form of leadership, coordination, or tradition.
Anarchists regularly discuss voluntary associations, delegated responsibilities, community leadership, and local self-governance. We recognize that societies need ways to coordinate themselves and preserve a degree of continuity across generations.
So why is monarchy automatically excluded from this discussion?
I think there's a distinction worth making between the existence of a permanent institution of leadership and the existence of an oppressive state apparatus.
A monarch doesn't necessarily need to represent a separate ruling class or administer every aspect of society. The Crown could instead serve as a permanent institution of communal identity, political continuity, and coordination.
This is the basis of what I've been calling Anarcho-Communist Monarchism.
Under this arrangement, communities would retain substantial autonomy over their own affairs. Workplaces could be organized through cooperatives, independent associations, family enterprises, and voluntary agreements between individuals.
I don't think we necessarily need to impose one universal economic arrangement on every community, either. Local production, independent craftsmanship, private possession, and voluntary exchange can all have a place in a decentralized society.
Markets themselves aren't inherently synonymous with centralized capitalism. People should be able to trade the products of their labour, establish independent enterprises, and enter into mutually beneficial agreements without requiring permission from a bureaucratic authority.
The monarchy would exist alongside these arrangements rather than replacing them.
I also don't think the monarchy necessarily needs to be purely ceremonial. I would support an active Crown with genuine royal prerogatives. The King could issue decrees, appoint representatives, and intervene in matters concerning the wider realm.
I don't see why this must automatically translate into conventional state government.
In fact, hereditary succession has some advantages worth considering. It provides institutional continuity across generations and prevents the Crown from becoming another arena for electoral competition and factional politics.
There's also something to be said for preserving historical and cultural institutions rather than assuming that revolutionary politics requires their complete destruction.
I would also argue that the protection of individual possession and voluntary economic association is important to preventing communities from becoming overly dependent on centralized administration. A decentralized society should allow people considerable freedom in how they organize their livelihoods.
The point isn't to restore feudalism or create a conventional constitutional monarchy.
It's to reconsider whether anarchist principles necessarily require the abolition of monarchy, private enterprise, or traditional institutions.
I would argue that they don't.
A society can be organized around voluntary cooperation, local autonomy, independent production, and mutual responsibility while retaining a permanent hereditary Crown.
I understand that this will probably be controversial, but I think the relationship between anarchism, leadership, economics, and monarchy deserves more consideration than it usually receives.
The people shall govern their communities, the individual shall enjoy the fruits of their labour, and the Crown shall remain.
Long live the revolution. Long live the King.
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/BlakeRoberts327 • 12d ago
Auth-Right Cringe Stop saying capitalism is human nature, because it's not
r/Anarchy4Everyone • u/DrewGlowYoung • 14d ago