Hoppe gave a speech where he endorsed Holocaust Denial, seemed to imply the existence of some kind of international Jewish conspiracy, and peddled of bunch of bullshit history.
I think Hoppe is a deeply unserious thinker, but you don't have to agree with me about that to see how what he presents as "the libertarian version" is not only wrong on the facts but is not really libertarian at all. It's contrarian but it has nothing to do with libertarianism.
Just read what he said in a recent speech at his own think tank based in Turkey, and the fact that Hoppe lives in Turkey is relevant, as you will see. I highly recommend you read the whole transcript because man it is a lot of bullshit, and I'm having to pick just the worst of the bullshit.
So what about the second world war? Again the history that we learned in Germany was of course that the Germans started that damn thing too. In fact it was by no means the case.
Hitler was a great friend of Great Britain and the Anglo-Saxon world…He had no interest in conducting war against England or the United States. What he did want was to regain some of originally German territory that had been occupied by Poland, which was created after World War I…So Germany had some fights there with Poland. The Poles were very intransigent, encouraged by the British and the French, that if anything ever happened to the Poles that would be a reason for war of them against Germany.
When Germany invaded Poland in agreement with Russia—which invaded Poland a couple weeks later—Britain declared war on Germany…So there was no war declaration of Germany against any of the western powers. To the contrary, the western powers declared war against Germany…
Germany was forced to conduct a war in the west…Germany wanted peace—it sought to secure peace in the west—because its ambition, Hitler’s intention, was directed toward the east. He wanted to have nothing to do with the west. They were considered even friends.
Now how did this world war end? Again, the British managed to get the Americans entangled in this war too, just as they had done during the first war, and it was again of course the Americans who ultimately decided the outcome of the war.
If I submitted this as an essay answer for an AP History course in high school, I'd get flunked. It's a bunch of crap, but how can anyone take this seriously? Hoppe provides basically no evidence to back up his claims, scanty reasoning to back up his claims, and some of his claims are so vague, I don't even know if they are falsifiable. And this guy is supposed to be some deep thinker who is the greatest living libertarian intellectual?
Let's start with his claim that "Germany" did not start World War II. But wait a minute.
What is "Germany"? Let me remind you, Hoppe is not only an anarcho-capitalist, but he claims the mantle of Murray Rothbard and makes himself out to be (or is cracked up to be) the living heir apparent, the St. Peter to Murray Rothbard the Christ. So what did Rothbard say?
Rothbard wrote in The Anatomy of the State:
….one of the basic doctrines of the State was to identify itself with the territory it governed. Since most men tend to love their homeland, the identification of that land and its people with the State was a means of making natural patriotism work to the State’s advantage. If “Ruritania” was being attacked by “Waldavia” the first task of the State and its intellectuals was to convince the people of Ruritania that the attack was really upon them, and not simply upon the ruling caste. In this way, a war between rulers was converted into a war between peoples, with each people coming to the defence of its rulers in the erroneous belief that the rulers were defending them.
Hoppe is committing the very error Rothbard warned against!
So, like I said, the version of history being presented by Hoppe isn't libertarian. He's speaking about collectives as if they are real; he is conflating groups of people with the state that rules over them. So, when he says "Germany" you should read "the Nazi state."
But then, Hoppe seems to go out of his way to not mention the Nazis. He only mentions "the National Socialists" by name twice, basically to say "it's the fault of democracy that the National Socialists took power," with no mention of what "National Socialism" is or what Hitler believed or how "National Socialism" led to the both the war and the Holocaust. Because: the Nazis were socialists. And the zero-sum thinking of socialism logically leads to totalitarianism and genocide. A "revisionist" historian should be pointing out how Hitler was a socialist and yet Hoppe has almost nothing to say about Hitler or his socialism. So Hoppe is not only not doing libertarianism, he isn't doing "revisionist" history either! He is regurgitating a narrative that was set in stone in the 1960s by Neo-Nazis like David Leslie Hoggan.
And this narrative is crap.
Hoppe says that it's "by no means the case" that World War II was started by "the Germans."
Okay. So who did start WW2? Hoppe never says. Maybe nobody started World War II? After all, the "mainstream narrative" presented about World War 2 has "huge holes in the story" so, maybe World War 2 never happened at all? It's all one big hoax?
Hoppe doesn't make it clear, but I think that he believes it's "the case" that "Germany" (really: the Nazi state) is not responsible for WW2 because "Germany" did not declare war on Britain, but Britain's govt declared war on Germany, and thus "Germany" was "forced" to fight a war in the West.
That's the only way I can make sense of Hoppe bringing up this little factoid about the lack of a reciprocal war declaration from Hitler against Britain, as if somehow because Hitler didn't declare war therefore Hitler is absolved of starting the war.
But notice the double standard. Hoppe says "Germany" was "forced" to fight a war in the West because of the British declaration of war on Germany, but Hoppe does not say this about America.
Hitler declared war on America even though America had not declared war on Nazi Germany.
Congress declared war against Japan on December 8, 1941. They did not declare war on Germany. Three full days elapsed, and there was no American declaration of war against Germany, and then Hitler declared war against the United States on December 11.
So if we applied to the American government the same standards Hoppe applies to Nazi Germany, then "America was forced to fight a war in Europe" because Hitler declared war on America even though America had not declared war on Germany. But does Hoppe say? That the British "entangled" America in a war. But couldn't we just as well say Hitler entangled America in a war by declaring war on America.
The fact that Hoppe goes out of his way to point out how Hitler did not declare war on Britain, but never mentions how Hitler declared war on America, should tell us a lot.
So far then, let me remind you: Hoppe isn't living up to Murray Rothbard's principles, he's not making an evidence-based argument, and now he's deliberately ignoring historical facts so that he can apply a double standard. Go ahead and try to defend that, you Hoppe fanboys. I welcome the challenge.
But then if "the Germans" didn't start the war....who did? Hoppe never tells us. What even is his argument? He never backs up his claim with either reasoning or evidence to actually falsify the premise that the Germans started the war. What? Is he gonna argue, well, ackshually, the Germans didn't start the war because Hitler was Austrian or something?
This guy is an intellectual lightweight, or perhaps a midwit who was mentally one-shotted by anti-Semitic propaganda intended to fool illiterate Russian peasants.
Let's go back to this point that Hoppe lives in Turkey, a country which does not criminalize Holocaust denial (which, to be clear, is a good thing, but then the fact that the Turkish government criminalizes or censors speech pointing out how the Ottoman Empire committed a genocide against the Armenians would suggest that the Turkish government is hardly some champion of the principle of the right to free speech).
Here is I think the most damning thing Hoppe said:
...if you look at what Israel—with Americans assistance—is doing in the Gaza Strip, is doing in Lebanon and doing in Iran, of which we all have documentation—we can see it, there are videos of that, the cruelty that is unrivaled. Nothing like that happened in World War I. Nothing like that happened in World War II. Look at Gaza completely flattened. And that is all explained to us as self-defense. And of course the Europeans, dumb as they are, having been made even dumber by the dumb Americans, they believe in this sort of thing. They compare what happens to Gaza with the so-called Holocaust.
I bolded that section to call out how I think Hoppe is a bitter America-hating loser. Read his speech and it reeks of a German nationalist who is upset America came along and ruined the chances of a 20th Century dominated by a German-dominated Europe and/or world. What else Hoppe said:
As far as the Holocaust is concerned, if you deny the teeniest detail in the official narrative of the Holocaust in Germany, you will be jailed.
Again: Hoppe lives in Turkey, where denying the Holocaust isn't a crime. And, likewise, denying the Holocaust is not a crime in the US. So what's Hoppe's point? That the German government is evil? No, it's to make himself out as some kind of a persecuted victim because he dares question the Holocaust. No, Doktor Hoppe, you're not a victim of anything, you're just an idiot. As your own words attest to!
So what's the point Despite the fact that nobody, even among those people who are called Holocaust deniers, has ever denied that cruel, evil, ugly things happened during that period. [Let me interject: cruel things like what exactly????]
But if you study these things a little bit more closely—again I learned that all from Rothbard too—there are huge holes in the story. There are lots of lies mixed into certain things that are undoubtedly true. There were never forensic investigations done in these places. The so-called Nuremberg trial was—even by high ranking American politicians like Taft, who was a presidential candidate—considered to be kangaroo courts. If you compare the evidence that had large holes with the evidence that we have about the cruelty that is done in Gaza, you must say: how can anybody not blame people who support this sort of thing.
Hoppe is not only denying the Holocaust, he is saying he got his Holocaust Denialism from Rothbard. I'm fucking done with this guy, he's a fucking loser.