r/AmIFreeToGo • u/[deleted] • Jun 26 '13
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/tripsy67 • Jul 07 '13
Cop claims to smell marijuana in car then taser driver for asserting rights
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/OFFascist • Sep 16 '19
Police harass Infowars reporter at Democrat debate
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/davidverner • Nov 12 '15
Detroit Cops Keep Arresting Armed Citizens
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/odb281 • May 04 '20
California Police STAND DOWN After Marine Vet Challenges Their Integrity
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/Ana___Beaverhausen • Sep 05 '26
Unpopular opinion: Why I can no longer support Sean Paul Reyes / Long Island Audit
I already know this probably won’t be a popular opinion in this community, but I’ve been thinking about this for a while and I finally reached the point where I can’t ignore the things that have been bothering me.
For some context, I have watched Long Island Audit basically from the beginning. I am a huge supporter of government transparency, accountability and the First Amendment auditing community in general. That hasn’t changed.
One of the things that originally made me like Sean so much was that he seemed different from a lot of people doing this type of content. He seemed genuinely passionate about making a difference. He wasn’t just walking into buildings trying to get someone to lose their temper for a viral video. He was generally respectful, professional and friendly, while still standing his ground and knowing his rights.
Most importantly, he always seemed to emphasize transparency and honesty. Those are things he has repeatedly presented as being important to him.
And I think that is part of why some of the things I’ve noticed bother me as much as they do.
As his channel got bigger, I started noticing a change during some of his livestreams. I have a hard time even explaining it because there isn’t one specific statement I can point to and say, “There. That’s when it happened.”
It was just a subtle change in demeanor. A little more arrogance. A little more ego. Just an overall feeling I started getting from him.
His actual audits were still generally respectful and professional, so for a long time I dismissed it. Maybe I was reading him wrong. Maybe I was interpreting something that wasn’t there.
But as the channel continued growing, that feeling got stronger.
Then something happened that gave me a very different perspective because the auditing community suddenly crossed over into my real life.
About a year or so ago, J-Town Press audited the government agency where I work. I work in child protective services. Obviously, I’m not going to identify the agency or location, but I think what I do is relevant because constitutional rights are incredibly important in my profession. We deal directly with parents, enter homes under certain circumstances, interview children, work alongside law enforcement and make decisions that can seriously affect families.
The audit itself really wasn’t a big deal and went fairly well.
Behind the scenes, however, employees were basically losing their minds.
A lot of people had absolutely no idea why someone was filming, what their rights were, what the auditor’s rights were, or what government employees could and could not demand from a member of the public.
Afterward, I spoke with our director. To their credit, they were actually very receptive to learning from what happened instead of just getting angry about it.
That made me think of Sean.
Sean doesn’t just occasionally mention that he has done First Amendment training. He actively promotes it. On his YouTube channel and website, he talks about conducting trainings and seminars with police departments, district attorneys’ offices and other agencies around the country, and he specifically invites agencies that are interested in working with him to reach out by email.
So this wasn’t me randomly tracking down a content creator and asking him for a favor. This was literally the kind of opportunity he publicly tells agencies to contact him about.
Our director asked me to reach out.
So I emailed Sean at the contact information he provides. I explained that I had followed and supported his work, told him what had happened at our agency, and explained that our leadership was genuinely interested in potentially having him come provide First Amendment training.
And just to be clear, nobody expected him to do it for free. He would have been compensated for his time and travel.
I never received a response.
Nothing.
Now, is Sean obligated to come train my agency? Of course not.
Is he obligated to accept every training request he receives? Absolutely not.
What bothered me is that Sean regularly asks his audience to support the mission—not just financially, but by watching, subscribing, sharing his videos, engaging with his content, buying merchandise, donating and helping grow the platform. And one of the things he repeatedly talks about is using education and training to “bridge the gap” between government officials and the public.
That is exactly what this opportunity was.
A government agency had just experienced a First Amendment audit, realized that many of its employees did not understand the rights involved, and instead of becoming defensive, the leadership was actually willing to learn. They were interested in bringing someone in to educate staff so that if something like this happened again, employees would better understand both their responsibilities and the rights of the public.
Isn’t that the goal?
Isn’t that what “bridging the gap” is supposed to look like?
Again, he was under absolutely no obligation to accept the training. My issue isn’t that he didn’t come. But when you publicly advertise this type of work, specifically invite agencies to reach out, and continually talk about wanting to educate government officials and bridge that gap, I think a legitimate inquiry deserves at least an acknowledgment.
A simple, “Thanks for reaching out, unfortunately I can’t accommodate this,” would have been completely fine.
Instead, there was nothing.
And I think that was the first time I really started questioning whether some of the things Sean talks about as part of the “mission” were as important to him in practice as they sounded when he talked about them on camera.
Still, I made excuses for it.
He’s busy. He gets tons of emails. Maybe he somehow never saw it.
Fine.
Then came the Brian Fahey/private-road trespassing case.
I supported Sean through that situation too. This was the case involving the “Private Road – No Turnaround” sign and the dispute over the trespassing charge.
Sean raised money for his legal defense. Later, we learned that he ultimately represented himself at trial.
Sean has explained that attorneys were still involved behind the scenes advising him, and I have no reason to say that isn’t true.
But again, something about it bothered me.
If you are raising money from your supporters specifically because of legal expenses, and then you ultimately represent yourself, I think being extremely clear with those supporters about exactly what their donations are funding matters.
Maybe attorneys were being paid substantial amounts behind the scenes. Maybe every dollar was legitimately used for legal expenses.
My issue is the transparency.
For somebody whose entire platform is built around demanding transparency from other people, I think the standard should be especially high when you are asking your own audience for money.
Again, though, I let it go.
And then we got to the recent YouTube demonetization situation.
First, I want to make something very clear because I know people will misunderstand this post otherwise:
I think what YouTube has done to First Amendment auditing channels is wrong.
Whatever anyone thinks about individual auditors, removing monetization from large portions of an entire category of lawful content is deeply concerning. Long Island Audit was one of the major channels affected, followed by numerous others.
Now many auditors are moving content to Patreon.
I understand why.
These people make content for a living. They travel, buy equipment, spend countless hours filming and editing, and they have bills just like everyone else. I have absolutely no problem with somebody being paid for their work.
But there is an obvious problem.
If 20, 30 or more creators all move their content behind separate Patreon subscriptions, the average viewer simply cannot financially support all of them.
People are struggling right now.
That is why a lot of viewers have been asking a perfectly reasonable question:
Why not Rumble?
Rumble allows viewers to watch without paying a monthly subscription while still giving creators an opportunity to monetize their content.
That doesn’t mean creators can’t also have Patreon for people who want bonus content, early access, livestreams or simply want to financially support them.
It just gives everybody else somewhere to continue watching.
Sean recently posted about the situation, and I left a comment basically making that argument.
I was a longtime supporter raising what I thought was a legitimate and respectful point about Rumble and the financial reality of expecting viewers to subscribe to dozens of individual Patreons.
Sean deleted my comment.
And strangely enough, that was probably the moment that bothered me more than everything else.
Because think about the irony.
This is somebody whose entire platform is built around transparency, accountability and the right to express yourself—
Yet when a supporter respectfully questioned something he was doing, rather than answer it, disagree with it, or simply leave it alone, the comment disappeared.
That says something to me.
Especially because some genuinely nasty comments were allowed to remain while a respectful criticism apparently wasn’t.
It made me wonder whether I had asked a question he simply didn’t want to answer.
And then, out of curiosity, I went to look at his Patreon tiers.
There are normal options: $5, $10, $25, etc. Nothing unusual about that.
Then they keep going.
Including tiers of $500 and $1,000 per month.
I’m sorry, but that was the moment where I just thought: What are we doing here?
One thousand dollars.
A month.
I understand that Patreon tiers can sometimes basically function as voluntary support levels. Maybe nobody is literally expected to pay $1,000 just to watch a video. If someone has the money and voluntarily wants to support a creator at that level, that’s their business.
But even offering a $1,000-a-month tier feels unbelievably out of touch to me.
And taken together with everything else, it changed the way I look at him.
Maybe none of these individual things would have been enough by themselves.
An unanswered email? Fine.
Questions about how legal-defense donations were communicated? Okay.
Deleting one critical comment? Whatever.
Having extremely expensive Patreon tiers? His choice.
But taken together, they form a pattern that I personally can no longer overlook.
And this isn’t coming from someone who only watched his videos for free.
My family is also a member of Attorney Shield, which is connected to Sean and his work. We signed up because I genuinely believed in what he was doing and was willing to financially support something associated with him.
I’ll be canceling that membership.
I don’t say that as some kind of threat or attempt to hurt his business. One canceled membership obviously isn’t going to make or break anything. I mention it because I think it shows where I’m at. I supported Sean beyond clicking “subscribe” on YouTube. I was willing to put my own money behind something he was involved with.
I’m no longer comfortable doing that.
The biggest issue for me is the contradiction.
You cannot constantly preach transparency while becoming less transparent with the people funding you.
You cannot talk endlessly about respecting people’s ability to speak and criticize government, but then be unable to tolerate polite criticism from your own supporters.
And you cannot build a community largely through ordinary working people donating $5, $10 and $20 at a time and then become so disconnected from those same people that $500 and $1,000 monthly Patreon tiers seem reasonable.
Maybe Sean hasn’t changed at all.
Maybe I have.
I watched Sean from the beginning because I thought he represented the best parts of that movement: professionalism, education, transparency and accountability.
Somewhere along the way, I stopped feeling like those principles were being applied equally when the transparency and accountability were directed back at him.
And after years of supporting him, financially supporting things connected to him, and repeatedly giving him the benefit of the doubt, deleting a respectful comment from a longtime supporter was finally enough for me to say:
I’m done.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/TheBigBadDuke • Jun 14 '13
Miami Police officer choking kid at music festival
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/DefendCharterRights • Sep 22 '22
Understanding Utah's criminal trespass laws
Moderators, please note: "spreyes" has blocked me, so I'm unable to comment in any threads he has originated. Therefore, Reddit's software prevents me from adding the following information to spreyes' recent post.
As one can expect, another Long Island Audit video means he's published more misinformation about rights and laws. And this LIA video, like too many of his others, contains dangerously bad misinformation.
LIA habitually flings crap against the wall to see what sticks. LIA's explanation of Utah's trespass laws was flat-out wrong: "Um, yeah, criminal trespassing in Utah, it's private property, not, speaks of private, this is not private property."
Ironically, the title of LIA's video includes the phrase: "Ignorant Of The Law And Our Rights!"
If LIA is going to "educate" others about laws, then he really should educate himself first. If LIA had spent three minutes researching Utah trespass statutes, then he likely would have found Utah Code Section 76-6-206, subsection (2)(b)(i):
A person is guilty of criminal trespass if,...knowing the person's...entry or presence is unlawful, the person enters or remains on...property to which notice against entering is given by...personal communication to the person by the owner or someone with apparent authority to act for the owner...
The only reference to "private property" in Section 76-6-206 is what "remains unlawfully" means as it relates to unmanned aircraft.
LIA told the police officer: "But, um, that they seem to be, uh, a little bit confused on the law." In reality, it was LIA who seemed very confused about Utah's criminal trespass statutes.
Later, LIA told the police officer: "I'm not breaking any laws."
When someone with apparent authority tells you, "wait outside please" and you refuse to immediately leave the building, then you normally are breaking Utah's criminal trespass law. If it's a public building, then that person usually also must have a reason that rationally serves a legitimate state interest.
The same applies when that person tells you, "you need to get out of the lobby."
The same applies when another person with apparent authority tells you, "please leave."
The same applies when that person tells you, "like I said, we've asked you nicely to leave."
I said "normally" because Utah's statute requires would-be trespassers to know their presence is unlawful. And Long Island Audit is so ignorant about laws he might be able to make a plausible case that he didn't know his activity was unlawful. He might actually have believed criminal trespass in Utah only applied to private property. Sometimes, ignorance of the law is an excuse. Long Island Audit isn't the sharpest spine on the pufferfish when it comes to legal matters.
On the other hand, LIA has been arrested for trespass so often that it's hard to believe he hasn't learned at least a little about trespass laws. This is especially true in this instance because one of the government officials explained to LIA that LIA can be trespassed from public buildings.
So, maybe LIA simply feels a sense of entitlement to not obey laws that apply to the rest of us. He even claimed: "I don't have to listen to anyone."
For a more general explanation of when people can be trespassed from public buildings, see this post.
Once again, Long Island Audit has published dangerously bad misinformation. Gullible viewers (including fellow auditors) could believe it, stand up for their "rights," get arrested, get convicted, pay a hefty fine, spend time in jail, and live with the burden of a criminal conviction for the rest of their lives.
What kind of constitutional auditor wants more warrantless arrests? What kind of constitutional auditor prevents free speech by blocking sub users? What kind of constitutional auditor allows themselves to be co-opted by the people they're supposed to be auditing? What kind of constitutional auditor constantly publishes bad misinformation?
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/davidverner • Sep 21 '20
Update about Lucas Gerhard case. He made an obvious joke on social media and is being criminally charged for it.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/WheatonLaw • Feb 07 '24
LIA Lawsuit Not Looking Good
So yesterday, the defendants in Long Island Audit's lawsuit (New York City) filed a motion to dismiss with prejudice LIA's lawsuit. In support of this motion, they basically drop the hammer by citing all the well established principles of the 1st Amendment's interaction with public forum doctrine.
I'll skip over the 1st Amendment arguments because it's already well established that policies that restrict the 1st Amendment in government buildings are in fact constitutional. The memo lists many examples of courts finding this very thing.
LIA's biggest strength in this lawsuit was New York's Right to Record Act. It seemingly gave citizens unlimited access to record police ANYWHERE they were working. The Act listed no exceptions to this right. It did not limit it in any way. This starts falling apart, though, once you start diving into the already well established precedents regarding public forum doctrine.
Some highlights from the memo:
Nothing in ... the [Right to Record Act] purported to displace the NYPD’s common law privileges as proprietor. While the Acts guarantee a substantive right to record the police and enumerate conduct based exceptions to this right ... their text says nothing about where such recordings are permitted. Given the Acts’ silence on this point, they cannot be read to impliedly supersede the NYPD’s proprietary authority to require visitors at its precincts to observe its rules. In other words, the City does not propose an unwritten “exception” to the Acts, but rather use of settled canons of construction to identify their intended boundaries.
Boom. Unless a judge wants to erase NUMEROUS previous court rulings establishing that, yes, governments can set policies for their buildings by which to trespass people, LIA ain't winning this lawsuit based on the Right to Record Act.
It cannot be that the statutory right to record is unrestricted as to location. A contrary reading would lead to the sort of “absurd application[s]” that courts construing New York legislation must avoid... For example, if the [Right to Record Act] did not import the government’s traditional prerogative as a proprietor, there would be no textual basis to bar courtroom spectators from bringing their cellphones into State courthouses and recording court security officers.
This is logically sound. Judges would essentially lose control over their own court rooms with respect to who can enter and record or not.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/TheBigBadDuke • Dec 29 '13
Police Officers are Dangerous Thugs Never Open Your Door to the Police
youtube.comr/AmIFreeToGo • u/BigBossHeadKrumpa • Feb 23 '22
Shout out to the shit mods over at r/bad_cop_no_donut
Specifically, id like to call out u/FreedomsTorch for being an all around cockswaddle, and his hussybussy u/AnnArchist for tacitly approving of their conduct by refusing to address it. Check my post history on that sub for more details.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/odb281 • Apr 19 '17
First Amendment Test Brings Out The Gestapo
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/odb281 • Nov 07 '19
Bodycam from Daytona Beach City Hall, THIS ONE WILL MAKE YOU MAD!!!!
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/davidverner • Jun 08 '14
Tom Zebra aka Daniel Saulmon has a drone and is using it on police checkpoints. First DUI checkpoint.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/kikaider007 • May 15 '14
"Are you a lawyer?" A response I just thought up.
If a cop asks if you are a lawyer just say "why do you need a lawyer, you make it sound like I know the law better than you."
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/[deleted] • Mar 19 '13
Man detained and beat by mall cops in Calgary, Alberta.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/Dont_Ban_Me_Ok • Aug 18 '21
Just did my first amendment audit, and can't believe what happened. Within 5 minutes, the police were called. All i did is record a public parking lot with my phone.
3 people came and harassed me
Edit: Video
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/DefendCharterRights • Apr 15 '22
Guilt, innocence, and avoiding conviction. Some auditors are publishing dangerously bad information.
If police have probable cause to believe you might have committed a crime, then they can arrest you without violating the Fourth Amendment. But police arresting you doesn't mean you're guilty of a crime.
On the flip side, police NOT arresting you doesn't mean you're INNOCENT of a crime. If police arrest you and a prosecutor declines to press charges, then that still doesn't mean you're innocent. Prosecutors often have more important crimes on which to focus their limited resources.
If prosecutors charge you with a crime and later drop the charge (or a judge dismisses the case before trial), then guess what. Your innocence or guilt still remains an open question. For example, you might have committed the crime, but the arresting officer might have been outside his jurisdiction.
Even if you're tried and a judge or jury finds you not guilty, then they haven't declared you to be innocent...just not guilty. The judge/jury might believe you were guilty, but they just didn't believe it "beyond a reasonable doubt."
In a recent video, Long Island Audit stated:
We are, we are here at the United States Post Office, here in Waterbury, the scene of the crime. Not my crime; that was dismissed. I'm speaking of the Waterbury Police Department's crime of unlawful arrest and stealing my property from me for 11 months.
As I noted, a judge dismissing your case doesn't mean you didn't commit the crime. Nor does it mean the police unlawfully arrested you or stole your property. But LIA isn't the sharpest letter opener in the post office when it comes to matters of law.
If auditors wish to remain ignorant of the law and risk possible future arrests, then that's up to them. They're free to repeatedly trespass, for example, until an officer with proper jurisdiction decides to arrest them, a prosecutor decides to charge and prosecute them, and a judge or jury renders a verdict about the auditor's guilt (not innocence!).
What I find extremely troubling, however, is when auditors who should know better continue to publish dangerously bad information. A gullible viewer could listen to this kind of nonsense, actually believe it, and decide to stand up for their rights when confronted by a law enforcement officer. They could be arrested, convicted, fined and/or incarcerated, and bear the burden of a criminal conviction for the rest of their lives. To make things even worse, other auditors might further disseminate this dangerously bad information.
Example One. You're video recording inside a post office, and a customer expresses concern that your zoom lens might be recording the code they're entering into a credit card reader. An authorized post office employee tells you to stop recording, but you refuse. Even if you're gathering footage for news purposes, you're very likely violating 39 Code of Federal Regulations Section 232.1(i) and could be arrested, convicted, fined, and imprisoned for up to 30 days.
Example Two. You're video recording inside a post office, and a customer tell a postal clerk that they don't want you recording their conversation with the clerk. The clerk tells you that you're impeding or disturbing the general public in transacting business or obtaining services, but you continue recording. You're very likely violating 39 CFR § 232.1(e).
Example Three. You're video recording inside a post office, and the postmaster fears your zoom lens might be recording addresses of senders and recipients. The postmaster tells you to stop recording, but you refuse. The postmaster tells you to leave the building, but you refuse. You're very likely violating the state's criminal trespass law.
Citing a two-justice (out of nine) opinion in the U.S. Supreme Court's Bates v Little Rock, LIA mistakenly believed First Amendment rights are absolute. But, "[i]t is a long-settled principle that governmental actions are subject to a lower level of First Amendment scrutiny when the governmental function operating...[is] not the power to regulate or license, as lawmaker,...but, rather, as proprietor, to manage [its] internal operation[s].": United States v Kokinda. Furthermore, "regulation of speech activity where the Government has not dedicated its property to First Amendment activity is examined only for reasonableness.": Kokinda.
As long as they're acting in a content-neutral manner in furtherance of legitimate government purposes, authorized agents of post offices can order auditors to stop photographing/recording, to stop impeding/disturbing customers, and to leave postal property.
LIA published dangerously bad information when he asserted "we're not doing anything wrong" and "you cannot trespass in public" and "you can't turn a constitutionally protected activity into an annoyance".
Sadly, this is just one of many examples when LIA has published dangerously bad information. It's not even the first time he's done so after being arrested. In 2021, LIA knew he'd gotten too close to a deputy conducting a traffic stop and would've been found guilty of hindrance in court. So, he accepted a deal, agreed to 10 hours of community service, apologized to the deputy who'd arrested LIA, and dropped his complaint against that deputy (which allowed the sheriff to drop his investigation of that deputy). LIA knew he'd messed up. LIA admitted in his apology letter to the arresting deputy that LIA's actions were misguided. Yet LIA told viewers he hadn't broken the law and wasn't guilty of any crimes.
A short while later, auditor American Amy was arrested in very similar circumstances.
In his recent video, LIA claimed "none of this would have happened if it wasn't for the fundamental lack of knowledge on the part of the postal employees...". Pot, meet kettle. LIA needs to educate himself about basic rights and laws before he tries to educate others. Otherwise, his videos could result in disastrous consequences for some of his viewers.
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/stinkfinger11 • Dec 20 '14
POLICE FIGHT PROTESTERS ON FREMONT STREET
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/velocibadgery • Jan 04 '22
LOL just got banned from /r/bad_cop_no_donut
There was a post about a 13 year old kid who ran from the cops and tragically crashed and died. The kid was doing wheelies and blowing through red lights and stop signs. I was banned for saying he should have pulled over when the cops stopped him. LOL
Edit: So just as a PSA, don't be a voice of reason in that sub, you will be banned. They obviously only want a cop hating echo chamber.
Here you can see my two comments that got me banned: https://camas.github.io/reddit-search/#{%22author%22:%22velocibadgery%22,%22subreddit%22:%22Bad_cop_no_donut%22,%22resultSize%22:100,%22query%22:%22Kid%22}
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/Daisy_Destruction • Dec 26 '21
This is Brutal; Tempe Cop Gets Owned
r/AmIFreeToGo • u/HurricaneSandyHook • May 25 '14